BZD17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BZD17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 94

Appeal from: BZD17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCCA 3186
File number: NSD 3 of 2018
Judges: PERRAM, PERRY AND O’CALLAGHAN JJ
Date of judgment: 25 June 2018
Catchwords:

MIGRATION – where the Federal Circuit Court refused application for judicial review of Administrative Appeals Tribunal decision affirming delegate’s decision not to grant the appellant a protection visa – where appellant claimed to fear harm by reason of his sexuality – where Tribunal found in effect that the appellant’s credibility had been so weakened that “the well has been poisoned beyond redemption” and no weight can be given to corroborating evidence - consideration of principles governing judicial review of adverse credibility findings - whether Tribunal failed to give a proper, genuine consideration to evidence of critical witness – whether Tribunal made adverse credibility findings lacking any logical or probative basis – appeal allowed – matter remitted to the Tribunal differently constituted for determination according to law

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where primary judge failed to give sufficient reasons and constructively failed to exercise jurisdiction by failing to consider fundamental aspects of the appellant’s case – whether the matter should be remitted to the Federal Circuit Court to determine the application for judicial review – consideration of the need to guard again erosion of the appellate structure  – where compelling factors against remitting the matter to the Federal Circuit Court

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Cases cited:

AAM15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 804; (2015) 231 FCR 452

ARG15v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 174; (2016) 250 FCR 109

AXL16 v Minister for Border Protection [2018] FCA 208

Belmorgan Property Development Pty Ltd v GPT Re Ltd [2007] NSWCA 171 (2007) 153 LGERA 450

DAO16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 2; (2018) 353 ALR 641

Islam v Cash [2015] FCA 815; (2015) 148 ALD 132

Lafu v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCAFC 140; (2009) 112 ALD 1

Morris v R (1987) 163 CLR 454

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZUXN [2016] FCA 516

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS [2010] HCA 48; (2010) 243 CLR 164

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS [2010] HCA 16; (2010) 240 CLR 611

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZNSP [2010] FCAFC 50; (2010) 184 FCR 485

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Anthonypillai [2001] FCA 274; (2001) 106 FCR 426

MZYPW v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCAFC 99; (2012) 289 ALR 541

Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Applicant S20/2002 [2003] HCA 30; (2003) 77 ALJR 1165

Smith Kline & French Laboratories (Aust) Ltd v Commonwealth (1991) 173 CLR 194

SZDGC v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCA 1638; (2008) 105 ALD 25

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BZD17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCAFC 94
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of BZD17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the appellant, who claimed to fear persecution in Cameroon due to his sexuality, challenged the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) affirming the delegate's refusal to grant him a protection visa. The Federal Circuit Court (FCC) had dismissed the appellant's application for judicial review, but the appellant appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court. The primary issues for the Full Court were whether the AAT adequately considered the evidence of a critical witness, whether the AAT's adverse credibility findings were logically and probatively sound, and whether the FCC had failed to provide sufficient reasons and constructively exercised its jurisdiction.

The Full Court held that the appeal should be allowed on the grounds that the AAT failed to properly consider the evidence of a critical witness, leading to legally unreasonable adverse credibility findings. The Court found that the AAT did not sufficiently engage with the evidence of Mr C, who supported the appellant's claims of being in a homosexual relationship in Cameroon. The Full Court also considered that the FCC had failed to provide adequate reasons and did not genuinely exercise its jurisdiction by not considering fundamental aspects of the appellant’s case. Despite these failings, the Full Court deemed it appropriate to address the substantive issues on appeal, as compelling factors existed against remitting the matter back to the FCC.

Consequently, the Full Court set aside the FCC's orders and remitted the appellant's application for review to the AAT, differently constituted, for a fresh determination according to law. Additionally, the Court ordered that the respondent pay the appellant's costs of the proceeding and the appeal, as agreed or taxed. The Full Court's decision underscores the importance of ensuring that tribunals properly consider all relevant evidence and provide adequate reasoning in their decisions, particularly in cases involving credibility assessments and judicial review.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The appellant is to file and serve an amended notice of appeal within 7 days.

3. Orders 2 and 3 of the orders made by the Federal Circuit Court on 15 December 2017 are set aside and in place of those orders, order that:

(a) the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 28 April 2017 is set aside;

(b) the appellant’s application for review is remitted to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, differently constituted, to be heard and determined according to law; and

(c) the first respondent is to pay the appellant’s costs of the proceeding, as agreed or taxed.

4. The first respondent is to pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal, as agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, the appeal must be allowed. First, in the circumstances of this case we consider that it is appropriate for this Court on appeal to consider the substantive grounds relating to the Tribunal’s decision, despite the failure by the FCC to provide adequate reasons and consider substantive aspects of the appellant’s case. Secondly, the Tribunal failed to discharge its jurisdiction by giving a proper, genuine consideration to the evidence and its decision is legally unreasonable. 2. BACKGROUND2.1 The appellant’s claims We note that, in summarising the appellant’s claims, we have been mindful of the need to avoid details by reference to which his identity might inadvertently be disclosed. For this reason, his claims are summarised at a general level only. The appellant claimed to fear persecution or significant harm if returned to Cameroon by reason of his homosexuality. He claimed to have had his first homosexual relationship at 18 years of age in Cameroon with a man who we will call Mr B, and that this relationship lasted for six years. However, he claimed that he was threatened and abandoned by his family because of the relationship, and then forced by them to marry. Despite this, he continued to meet Mr B. Eventually his wife found out about his continuing relationship with Mr B. Shortly thereafter the appellant and Mr B were attacked by a large group of people and beaten so badly that Mr B died from his injuries. The appellant said that he was then arrested on the ground that he was homosexual and he was taken to the police station despite being badly injured. An association promoting human rights was informed of his arrest and negotiated his removal to a hospital. The appellant said that he was unconscious on arrival. The appellant alleged that he spent two weeks in intensive care with a police officer posted to keep watch on him. He said that he began to recover and that a nurse who he knew previously then helped him to escape. He claimed that he went to the house of a gay European friend who helped him to gather the documents necessary for his business visa application to Australia. As earlier mentioned, the appellant applied shortly after his arrival in Australia for a protection visa. Since arriving in Australia, he claimed to have engaged in gay relationships, gone to sex venues, and belonged to Grindr, a gay dating app. He also said that, while he had had no long-term relationships in Australia, he was looking for a long-term partner. 2.2 The evidence relied upon by the appellant The appellant appeared before the Tribunal on 9 February 2017, 16 February 2017 and 19 April 2017 to give evidence and make submissions. His registered migration agent also attended the hearings which were conducted with the assistance of an interpreter in the French and English languages. In support of his claims, the appellant provided a large body of documentary material and relied on the evidence of a number of witnesses. These included Mr C who gave a statutory declaration in support of the appellant’s claims and appeared before the Tribunal (Tribunal decision at [73]-[75]). Mr C said that he met the appellant and his then partner, Mr B, in Cameroon on a project for a human rights group, and that the appellant and Mr B were definitely a gay couple. The appellant and Mr C claimed to have met again by coincidence at the 2017 Mardi Gras in Sydney at which the appellant had been a volunteer. In addition, the appellant relied, among other witnesses, upon the evidence of Ms Goulding, a social worker at the Western Sydney Sexual Health Centre; and Mr Hill, a counsellor with 50 years’ experience working with gay, lesbian, and transgender individuals in a number of different capacities. Both Ms Goulding and Mr Hill had given extensive counselling to the appellant and expressed their professional opinions that the appellant was unquestionably a gay man. 2.3 The Tribunal’s reasons for decision

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As earlier mentioned, the appellant applied shortly after his arrival in Australia for a protection visa. Since arriving in Australia, he claimed to have engaged in gay relationships, gone to sex venues, and belonged to Grindr, a gay dating app. He also said that, while he had had no long-term relationships in Australia, he was looking for a long-term partner. 2.2 The evidence relied upon by the appellant The appellant appeared before the Tribunal on 9 February 2017, 16 February 2017 and 19 April 2017 to give evidence and make submissions. His registered migration agent also attended the hearings which were conducted with the assistance of an interpreter in the French and English languages. In support of his claims, the appellant provided a large body of documentary material and relied on the evidence of a number of witnesses. These included Mr C who gave a statutory declaration in support of the appellant’s claims and appeared before the Tribunal (Tribunal decision at [73]-[75]). Mr C said that he met the appellant and his then partner, Mr B, in Cameroon on a project for a human rights group, and that the appellant and Mr B were definitely a gay couple. The appellant and Mr C claimed to have met again by coincidence at the 2017 Mardi Gras in Sydney at which the appellant had been a volunteer. In addition, the appellant relied, among other witnesses, upon the evidence of Ms Goulding, a social worker at the Western Sydney Sexual Health Centre; and Mr Hill, a counsellor with 50 years’ experience working with gay, lesbian, and transgender individuals in a number of different capacities. Both Ms Goulding and Mr Hill had given extensive counselling to the appellant and expressed their professional opinions that the appellant was unquestionably a gay man. 2.3 The Tribunal’s reasons for decision The Tribunal comprehensively rejected the appellant’s claims. Its reasons may relevantly be summarised as follows. First, at the commencement of its reasons considering the appellant’s claims to fear harm by reason of his sexuality, the Tribunal found that:87. Whilst the Tribunal appreciates that there can be no single test to determine whether a person is gay or not, and the applicant has submitted a range of reports and witnesses to state that he is unequivocally gay, the Tribunal is required to look at the totality of his evidence. This reveals the applicant to have consistently fabricated claims and to have been deliberate in his actions in order to present himself to a range of people as gay. Such is his lack of credibility that I am satisfied that the applicant is not homosexual, and there is no real chance he will face serious harm on return to Cameroon as a result of being perceived to be so. Secondly, the Tribunal considered the appellant’s credibility by reference to perceived inconsistencies in his evidence, delay in raising certain claims, lack of documentary evidence to support certain claims, the perceived implausibility of certain claims, and difficulties in proving the authenticity of threatening emails said to have been received by the appellant after he arrived in Australia. The Tribunal in the course of this part of its reasons comprehensively disbelieved each aspect of the appellant’s claims including as to alleged early homosexual encounters, his long-term relationship with Mr B, the assault on the appellant and Mr B and its alleged sequelae, the appellant’s account of why he arranged to travel to Australia rather than to France, and the appellant’s claim that his business was broken into and his house ransacked (Tribunal reasons at [87]-[113]).

Decision

Reasons for decision

In support of his claims, the appellant provided a large body of documentary material and relied on the evidence of a number of witnesses. These included Mr C who gave a statutory declaration in support of the appellant’s claims and appeared before the Tribunal (Tribunal decision at [73]-[75]). Mr C said that he met the appellant and his then partner, Mr B, in Cameroon on a project for a human rights group, and that the appellant and Mr B were definitely a gay couple. The appellant and Mr C claimed to have met again by coincidence at the 2017 Mardi Gras in Sydney at which the appellant had been a volunteer. In addition, the appellant relied, among other witnesses, upon the evidence of Ms Goulding, a social worker at the Western Sydney Sexual Health Centre; and Mr Hill, a counsellor with 50 years’ experience working with gay, lesbian, and transgender individuals in a number of different capacities. Both Ms Goulding and Mr Hill had given extensive counselling to the appellant and expressed their professional opinions that the appellant was unquestionably a gay man. 2.3 The Tribunal’s reasons for decision The Tribunal comprehensively rejected the appellant’s claims. Its reasons may relevantly be summarised as follows. First, at the commencement of its reasons considering the appellant’s claims to fear harm by reason of his sexuality, the Tribunal found that:87. Whilst the Tribunal appreciates that there can be no single test to determine whether a person is gay or not, and the applicant has submitted a range of reports and witnesses to state that he is unequivocally gay, the Tribunal is required to look at the totality of his evidence. This reveals the applicant to have consistently fabricated claims and to have been deliberate in his actions in order to present himself to a range of people as gay. Such is his lack of credibility that I am satisfied that the applicant is not homosexual, and there is no real chance he will face serious harm on return to Cameroon as a result of being perceived to be so. Secondly, the Tribunal considered the appellant’s credibility by reference to perceived inconsistencies in his evidence, delay in raising certain claims, lack of documentary evidence to support certain claims, the perceived implausibility of certain claims, and difficulties in proving the authenticity of threatening emails said to have been received by the appellant after he arrived in Australia. The Tribunal in the course of this part of its reasons comprehensively disbelieved each aspect of the appellant’s claims including as to alleged early homosexual encounters, his long-term relationship with Mr B, the assault on the appellant and Mr B and its alleged sequelae, the appellant’s account of why he arranged to travel to Australia rather than to France, and the appellant’s claim that his business was broken into and his house ransacked (Tribunal reasons at [87]-[113]). Thirdly, the Tribunal referred to the requirement in s 91R(3) (since repealed) of the Act requiring it to disregard conduct in Australia in determining whether an applicant has a well-founded fear of persecution, if the Tribunal found that the conduct was carried out for the sole purpose of strengthening a refugee claim. In this regard, the Tribunal found that:114. … I do not believe that the applicant has either genuinely explored any homosexual behaviour or sought to live a genuinely homosexual lifestyle in Australia.115. While the Tribunal understands that it is difficult to ascribe a test to determine one’s homosexuality, the Tribunal is also required to look at the totality of the applicant’s behaviour to determine the genuineness of his actions. He has been deliberate in his actions in trying to enter Australia and in constructing a fabricated history of trauma and homosexual behaviour in Cameroon, and I am satisfied that he has continued that deliberate construction of a fabricated profile once in Australia.