BNY19 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

BNY19 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 367

File number(s): SYG 929 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE SKAROS
Date of judgment: 17 March 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Judicial Review – Protection Visa – Bangladesh – Political persecution – Sexual assault – Relocation - Unreasonableness - Unwarranted assumption – Consideration of corroborative evidence – Failure to consider a claim – Application dismissed with costs   
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 ss 36, 65, 412, 424AA
Cases cited:

ASB17 v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 38; (2019) 268 FCR 271

AVQ15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 133

BEL16 v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 1678

BFH16v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2020] FCAFC 54; (2020) 274 FCR 532

BJI18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 266

BKTS v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCA 729

BOH17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship & Multicultural Affairs[2023] FCA 573

BZD17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 94; (2018) 263 FCR 292

Carrascalao v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2017) 252 FCR 352; [2017] FCAFC 107

DKY22 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCA 1166

FPA18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FedCFamC2G 770

Htun v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 1802

Minister for Home Affairs v Omar (2019) [2019] FCAFC 188; (2019) 272 FCR 589

Minister for Immigration & Border Protection v Sabharwal[2018] FCAFC 160

Minister for Immigration & Border Protection v Stretton [2016] FCAFC 11; (2016) 237 FCR 1

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS [2010] HCA 16; (2010) 240 CLR 611

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZNPG [2010] FCAFC 51

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZNSP [2010] FCAFC 50; (2010) 184 FCR 485

Minister for Immigration v Eshetu [1999] HCA 21

NAHI v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 10

Plaintiff M1-2021 v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] HCA 17

Randhawa v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs [1994] FCA 1253

Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Applicant S20/2002 [2003] HCA 30; (2003) 198 ALR 59

SZATV v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] HCA 40; (2007) 233 CLR 18

SZHYH v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection (No 3) [2019] FCA 589; 194 ALR 676

SZNYF v Minister of Immigration and Citizenship [2010] FCA 839
WAIJ v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 74

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 185
Date of hearing: 13 February 2025
Place: Parramatta
Solicitor for the Applicants: Mr Jones, Michael Jones Solicitor
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Mr Dennis, Mills Oakley
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Submitting appearance, save as to costs

ORDERS

SYG 929 of 2019

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

BNY19

First…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BNY19 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 367
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, citizens of Bangladesh and married couple, sought judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Review Tribunal affirming a decision of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs to refuse their applications for Protection (Class XA) (Subclass 866) visas. The applicants argued that they had suffered political persecution in Bangladesh, including threats, assaults, and sexual assault of the second applicant, and therefore were owed protection obligations by Australia. The key legal issues were whether the Tribunal had erred in finding that there were no false cases against the first applicant in Bangladesh, whether it had failed to properly consider the evidence of sexual assault of the second applicant, and whether it had made any other jurisdictional errors. The Court found that the Tribunal's reasons for concluding that there were no false cases against the first applicant in Bangladesh were reasonably open to it, and that there was no jurisdictional error in this respect. However, the Court found that the Tribunal had failed to properly consider the evidence of sexual assault of the second applicant and had made an unwarranted assumption about the availability of relocation within Bangladesh. The Court found that these errors were sufficient to vitiate the Tribunal's decision and remit the matter to the Tribunal for reconsideration. The application for judicial review was therefore allowed and the matter was remitted to the Tribunal for reconsideration in light of the Court's reasons.

Background

Background to the litigation

By application filed on 12 March 2019, and amended on 16 January 2025, the applicants seek judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal[1] (the Tribunal) dated 21 March 2019. The Tribunal affirmed a decision of a delegate (the delegate) of the first respondent (the Minister) in refusing to grant the applicants Protection (Class XA) (Subclass 866) visas (the visas) under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act). [1] The Court notes that the Administrative Appeals Tribunal has been superseded by the Administrative Review Tribunal. Item 10, Part 2 of Schedule 16 to the Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No. 1) Act 2024 provides that for any proceedings that were pending in any court or tribunal immediately before the transition time and to which the Administrative Appeals Tribunal was a party, the Administrative Review Tribunal is, after the transition time, substituted for the Tribunal as a party to the proceedings. Therefore, in these Reasons, reference to the Tribunal is a reference to the Administrative Review Tribunal.BACKGROUND The first and second applicants are, respectively, husband and wife. They are citizens of Bangladesh. They married in 2010. They have previously travelled to Malaysia in 2011, to India in 2012 and to the United Kingdom in 2013. The applicants travelled to Australia on 7 February 2014 on visitor visas and applied for the visas on 3 March 2014. In a statement provided with the visa application, the first applicant made the following claims for protection:·The first applicant was actively involved with the Bangladesh National Party (BNP) during and after his studies including in 2008 during the election campaign in which the BNP lost and the Awami League (AL) won.·In 2006 the first applicant formed a construction company with others, Steelex Development (Steelex). In 2007 Steelex received its first development contract and halfway through construction ‘we’ faced serious problems with ‘a group of Awami activists.’ These activists assaulted and stopped Steelex’s workers and demanded a ransom once construction was completed otherwise they wouldn’t allow construction to continue. The activists were followers and supports of Mr Kamal, a prominent AL leader and member of parliament. Steelex did not pay the ransom and had to abandon the construction project for six months. When construction recommenced in mid-2008 the activists appeared again, demanded a larger ransom, attacked workers and engineers and stopped the project again. Construction was again suspended and abandoned.·During and after the 2008 election the first applicant became a ‘target of attack and assault by those Awami activists.’·In April 2010, Steelex entered into a contract for another project which was ultimately successful and the Company and investors made a substantial profit. ·In October 2010, the first applicant married his wife, Mrs Khan, the second applicant. In 2011 the pair visited Malaysia as tourists. On return from Malaysia, the first applicant started ‘to face serious political consequences from the Awami activists’ due to the upcoming election because the first applicant was a BNP activist. The first applicant was attacked and insulted. Steelex was again obstructed by the AL activists and construction projects were halted. ·In 2012 the first applicant joined his wife’s maternal uncle in incorporating a new garment manufacturing business which soon became profitable. In 2012, the applicants visited India and in 2013 they visited the UK. In 2012 the first applicant was selected as the general secretary of a wing of the BNP. Upon returning to Bangladesh in March 2013, there were clashes between supporters of the AL, the BNP and the Jamate Islami parties including killings and arrests. The first applicant was ‘badly targeted because of [his] political activities for BNP’.·In 2014, the first applicant’s garment business received a large order however due to a strike and unrest the business could not complete the order in time. The first applicant had a dispute with the buyer, he ‘went wild’ on the first applicant and cancelled the order. The buyer left a phone number and when the first applicant called this number it was Mr Kamal ‘himself on the phone abusing and threatening my life would be at risk’ because of the failed order and his BNP profile. The first applicant discovered that Mr Kamal was ‘behind that order’ and was disappointed and angry. Later, the first applicant discovered Mr Kamal filed a case against him for ‘holding illegal arms and explosives which was completely a false and fabricated allegation’ with the intention to make the first applicant suffer because he was a BNP activist.·Due to the threats from Mr Kamal and given his party, the AL, were still in power, the first applicant took time off work and ‘remained cautiously’ with relatives and in-laws to avoid ‘unpleasant incidence and assaults’ but his hiding ‘did not help much in that respect.’·Mr Kamal and his associates filed another case against the first applicant because he was associated with the BNP.·On 27 November 2014, the second applicant was returning from shopping when a mini-bus stopped her and the men inside dragged her into the bus, brought her to an unknown place, interrogated her as to the first applicant’s whereabouts and identified themselves as ‘fellows of’ Mr Kamal. She did not disclose the first applicant’s location so she was ‘randomly raped’ and had hot water thrown on her. Experiencing extreme pain and an ‘almost dying situation’ the men left her at a hospital and escaped. After three days the first applicant was informed that his wife was at the hospital. After being discharged an unknown person handed a warning letter to the applicants’ gate keeper which stated that if they file a case or report to the news media in relation to the incident they would ‘have to pay a high price.’ Being afraid of this threat, they did not file any case or make any report.·Since the rape of his wife, the first applicant has been having nightmares, couldn’t concentrate on his business. The first applicant lost his pride, lost interest in his business and lost his lifestyle. The applicants decided to escape out of Bangladesh to ‘avoid such incidents once for all.’

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 21 March 2019, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the delegate not to grant the applicants the visas.THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The dispositive issue in the review was whether the applicants were persons in respect of whom Australia had protection obligations under s 36 of the Act. The Tribunal identified the criteria for a protection visa; that the applicants must either satisfy the ‘refugee’ criterion or meet the ‘complementary protection’ grounds for protection. The relevant definition of ‘refugee’ and the provisions relevant to the complementary protection grounds under the Act were also set out. The Tribunal identified that it must have regard to Ministerial Direction No. 56 made under s 499 of the Act, and that it must take into account the policy guidelines titled PAM3 Refugee and Humanitarian - Complementary Protection Guidelines, and PAM3 Refugee and Humanitarian - Refugee Law Guidelines and any relevant country information assessments. Prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT report). The Tribunal noted that the Department’s file contained a s 438(1)(a) public interest non-disclosure certificate which was said to be in respect of ‘internal working documents and business affairs.’ The Tribunal considered the certificate invalid as no reason had been provided about why disclosure of the information would be contrary to public interest. In any event, the Tribunal informed the applicants of the certificate and noted that the information covered by the certificate was not relevant to its decision. The Tribunal then summarised the claims and evidence before it, being those contained in the statement accompanying the visa application and outlined the documents before it in support of the claim. This included a police complaint from 2013, a document relating to the BNP, a letter from a hospital stating that the second applicant was admitted to the hospital from 28 November 2013 to 30 November 2013, that she had been raped and had hot water burns caused by unknown persons, and a health report dated 1 July 2016 from a nurse at the ‘Asylums Seekers Centre’ stating that the second applicant was seen at the centre twice in 2014 and that she recorded being tortured and sexually assaulted in November 2013 in Bangladesh and that she had a comprehensive assessment but did not wish to seek counselling as she found talking about the assault traumatic. The Tribunal briefly summarised the delegate’s decision and noted that it had received information on 12 November 2016, being a typed statement from an unknown person which stated that the second applicant’s burns were a result of ‘an accident with a kettle’ and that the applicants came to Australia using passports containing false names. The Tribunal then summarised the submissions made and documents provided to the Tribunal. On 1 February 2019 various documents were provided to the Tribunal including birth certificates, various letters, court documents and order sheets, a memorandum, a letter to police, and a charge sheet.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Minister further contended that the Tribunal was not required to uncritically accept the applicant’s claims: Randhawa v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 52 FCR 437 at 451; [1994] FCA 1253. Consideration of ground one It is well established that illogicality, irrationality or legal unreasonableness in the reasons for an administrative decision may establish jurisdictional error, as may a failure to give proper, genuine or realistic consideration to a significant matter: Minister for Immigration & Border Protection v Sabharwal[2018] FCAFC 160 at [45]. However, a decision will not involve jurisdictional error if a reasonable decision-maker could reach that decision or finding on the same material: Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS [2010] HCA 16 (SZMDS) at [130]–[132] and [135] per Crennan and Bell JJ and at [78] per Heydon J. The question is ‘whether a decision-maker could reasonably come to the conclusion’ reached. If the conclusion is one upon which reasonable minds can differ, it will not be legally illogical, irrational or unreasonable: Minister for Immigration & Border Protection v Stretton [2016] FCAFC 11 at [21]. A party relying upon an unwarranted assumption to establish jurisdictional error will need to establish that the assumption was not one which a reasonable decision maker could make. Another way of asking this question is to ask whether the decision has an evident and intelligible basis: BOH17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship & Multicultural Affairs[2023] FCA 573 at [8]. The threshold for finding illogicality, irrationality or unreasonableness is a high one and is not a finding to be made lightly: BKTS v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCA 729 at [45] – [46]. The question to be determined is whether the Tribunal’s reasons for concluding that there were no false cases against the first applicant in Bangladesh were reasonably open to it (or whether they lacked a rational foundation, or an evident or intelligible justification). The first reason given by the Tribunal is that the applicants were able to legally depart Bangladesh using travel documents in their own name in circumstances where an MP had initiated false cases against the first applicant and had instructed police to maintain a ‘rigorous search’ for him. The applicants contended that there was no evidence to support the Tribunal’s description that the police were searching (rigorously or otherwise) for the first applicant and that the Tribunal had made an unwarranted assumption about the power, influence and conduct of the MP. As acknowledged by the Minister, the Tribunal’s description of the search being ‘rigorous’ could have been differently expressed. However, the Court is not satisfied that there was no basis (or evidence) for the Tribunal to say that the police were searching for (or pursuing) him. The Minister referred to the following extracts from the transcript:At T1, 13.37-46: Interpreter (first applicant): And then in 2013, November 6, there was a false case brought into my name that I have – (not-transcribable) - in the when BNP was and I did some destruction of BNP office. This was all false and when he lost the case against me and that day police came to my house and there’s no record of that day when someone lodged a case against you saying the police visit in your house? We don’t have this type of record but it has happened in, like, this and I asked my friend, I may involve my friend to get the information and got the information that this is [Mr Kamal], [Mr Kamal] behind this, [Mr Kamal] is there, and the police people they are Mr Kamal’s – under Mr Kamal’s influence. They did this. At T1, 13.48-49: Interpreter (first applicant): The police came to my house and looking for me, and asking about my whereabouts and I started living in hiding.At T1, 15.2-3: Interpreter (first applicant): There was a further case brought against me, false cases, police was looking for and I was in hiding. At T1, 16.10-13: Interpreter (first applicant): I wasn’t sure. I was not 100% sure at that time my warrant was there under my name or not. Same police, group of 10 people, 10 police people make. Those same people are looking for me, same police.At T1, 22.19-23 Tribunal: What were you doing in those two months? Interpreter (first applicant): I was in hiding, and I was trying to contact her. I was trying to see her in the house, but I was in hiding. Everything I did, I am not to expose myself, and that is – that is the time I need to stay beside her the most, but I couldn’t. I couldn’t even comfort her properly.