DXB19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

DXB19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 493

File number(s): ADG 361 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE LUCEV
Date of judgment: 10 April 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Judicial review – decision of Immigration Assessment Authority – citizen of Pakistan – Turi Pashtun of Shia religion – whether finding of fact not supported by the evidence in relation to allegedly fraudulent document or based on unwarranted assumptions – whether decision illogical or legally unreasonable by reason of unwarranted assumptions made concerning protection of students by school or because of failure to take into account relevant considerations – whether wrong question asked as to whether individually targeted rather than being targeted as part of a particular social group – whether failure to take into account a relevant consideration as to the nature of persecution faced by the applicant outside his home area – whether decision affected by bias – whether jurisdictional error
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 5J, 36, 46A, 473CA, 473DA, 473DA, 476
Cases cited:

“VAS” v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCAFC 350

ALA15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 30

Applicant S v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2004] HCA 25; (2004) 217 CLR 387; (2004) 78 ALJR 854; (2004) 206 ALR 242; (2004) 77 ALD 541

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 184; (2003) 236 FCR 593; (2003) 75 ALD 630

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond [1990] HCA 33; (1990) 170 CLR 321; (1990) 64 ALJR 462; (1990) 94 ALR 11; (1990) 21 ALD 1; (1990) 5 BR 137

BMB16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCAFC 169; (2017) 253 FCR 448; (2017) 157 ALD 494

BOH17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCA 573

BQQ15 v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 218

BSE17 v Minister for Home Affairs [2018] FCA 1926

BVB15 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCA 413

BYX17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCAFC 41

BZD17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 94; (2018) 263 FCR 292; (2018) 161 ALD 441

CRJ17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1404

CXS18 v Minister for Home Affairs [2020] FCAFC 18

DAO16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 2; (2018) 258 FCR 175; (2018) 74 AAR 121; (2018) 353 ALR 641

DBE16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 942

DGZ16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 12; (2018) 258 FCR 551

Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2000] HCA 63; (2000) 205 CLR 337; (2000) 75 ALJR 277; (2000) 176 ALR 644; (2000) 63 ALD 577

EGU17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DXB19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 493
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

DXB19, a citizen of Pakistan, sought judicial review of the decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (Authority) which found that he did not face a real chance of persecution in Pakistan and did not satisfy the criteria for the grant of a Subclass 600 Humanitarian Entry (Specific Humanitarian Entry) (SHE) visa. The Federal Court of Australia was required to decide whether the Authority's decision was legally or logically unreasonable, affected by bias or based on an assumption that was not supported by the evidence. The Authority found that DXB19’s claims of persecution were not supported by the evidence and that he did not satisfy the criteria for the grant of a visa. The Authority did not accept that DXB19's father died as a result of targeted killing or that DXB19 was of adverse interest to the Taliban or any other militant group. The Authority also found that DXB19 would not face harm in Pakistan for any of the reasons claimed, nor would he face harm as a returnee from the west. The court found that the Authority's decision was not affected by bias or based on an assumption that was not supported by the evidence. The court found that the Authority's decision was not unreasonable and that DXB19's application for judicial review was dismissed. The court found that the Authority's decision was based on reasonable findings and that DXB19 had not demonstrated that the decision was unreasonable. The court found that the Authority's decision was supported by the evidence and that DXB19's application for judicial review was dismissed. The court found that the Authority's decision was not affected by bias and that DXB19's application for judicial review was dismissed. The court found that the Authority's decision was not unreasonable and that DXB19's application for judicial review was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

All references to the statutory provisions in these Reasons for Judgment are, unless otherwise indicated, references to the Migration Act and to the provisions therein as they were at the time of the Authority Decision.BACKGROUND The background to this matter prior to the Authority Decision is as follows:(a)DXB19 is a citizen of Pakistan who first arrived in Australia on 28 September 2012 as an unauthorised maritime arrival: CB 40 and 42; (b)on 28 November 2012 DXB19 attended an Irregular Maritime Arrival Entry Interview: CB 11-28;(c)on 1 November 2013 DXB19 applied for a Protection Visa, but the application was found to be invalid: CB 29-98 and 100;(d)on 9 October 2015 DXB19 was advised that the Minister had lifted the bar pursuant to s 46A(2) and invited DXB19 to apply for a Temporary Protection visa or SHE Visa: CB 100-106;(e)on 24 July 2016 DXB19 applied for a SHE Visa: CB 107-172;(f)on 20 March 2019 DXB19 attended an interview with the Delegate (“Delegate Interview”): CB 183;(g)on 3 April 2019 DXB19 provided post-Delegate Interview submissions to the Delegate via his representative: CB 213-232;(h)on 16 August 2019 the Delegate refused to grant the SHE Visa: CB 238-257. The Delegate was not satisfied that DXB19 was a person in respect of whom Australia had protection obligations or a member of the same family unit as such a person;(i)on 22 August 2019 DXB19’s matter was referred to the Authority pursuant to s 473CA: CB 259; and(j)on 10 September 2019 DXB19 provided written submissions to the Authority via his representative (“DXB19’s Authority Submissions”): Supplementary Court Book (“SCB”) at 317-324. DXB19’s protection claims in the invalid Protection Visa application included the following (as set out at CB 63-65):(a)DXB19 claimed to fear harm from the Taliban because of his Shia religion, and as a Turi Pashtun from Parachinar in Kurram District; and(b)DXB19 claimed difficulties with the Taliban started in 2007. In 2009 he moved to Peshawar to continue his education. While in Peshawar he was threatened in a phone call from an unknown caller and received a threatening letter from the Taliban. He was also followed by three men after purchasing books at the bazaar. Shortly thereafter he returned to his home village and opened up a clothing shop at the Parachinar bazaar. Some 18 months later, his shop was destroyed by a bomb explosion and in June 2012 he left Pakistan. DXB19’s protection claims included in the SHE Visa Application included the following (as set out at CB 150- 151):(a)DXB19 continued to fear harm for the reasons previously set out in the invalid Protection Visa application;(b)DXB19 claimed to fear harm from the Taliban, Sunni extremists and other militant groups in Pakistan;(c)DXB19 claimed to fear harm on the basis of his Shia religion, his father’s position as a Malik, his family’s status within his religious and tribal community, due to his imputed political opinion against extremist groups and his commitment to further education; and(d)DXB19 claimed that his father was killed in March 2016 by the Taliban or other extremist groups because he held the title of Malik and that DXB19 would inherit the title of Malik from his father and would be targeted for that reason.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

During the Delegate Interview DXB19 made an additional claim to fear harm from the Taliban because he had spent time in a Western country.AUTHORITY DECISION In the Authority Decision the Authority:(a)was satisfied that the DXB19’s Authority Submissions did not contain new information and had regard to it: CB 294 at [4]. In DXB19’s Authority Submissions, DXB19 requested an interview with the Authority. Although the Authority acknowledged it had discretion to obtain new information from DXB19, it was satisfied that DXB19 had been given ample opportunity to present his claims and did not consider that an interview was warranted: CB 294 at [5];(b)accepted: (i)DXB19’s ethnicity and much of his background: CB 296-297 at [10]-[12]; and(ii)that DXB19’s father held the title and role of Malik and that he passed away in 2016: CB 298 at [18];(c)did not accept that: (i)DXB19’s father died “due to any targeted killing”: CB 297-299 at [15]-[18]; and(ii)DXB19 was of adverse interest to Taliban, any other militant group, had an individual profile with such groups or anyone else, or would suffer any harm due to his commitment to further education: CB 299-301 at [18]-[27]; (d)having regard to the evidence before it and relevant country information the Authority was not satisfied that DXB19 or his family were known to or targeted by the Taliban during his father’s extensive period of being a Malik or after his death or that there was a real chance they would be, even if DXB19 was to assume the role of Malik: CB 302 at [29];(e)considered: (i)whether DXB19 would face harm as a Pashtun and a Turi and because of his Shia Muslim faith upon return to Parachinar, and taking relevant country information into account, concluded that the material pointed against DXB19 facing a real chance of any harm in the reasonably foreseeable future for reason of his being a Turi: CB 304 at [35]; and (ii)relevant DFAT reports and noted that the information did not support any “recent trend of discrimination or other issues faced by Pashtuns or Shia Turi Pashtuns in [DXB19’s] area”: CB 305 at [38]; (f)further noted that Shias comprised about 40 per cent of the Kurram District population and there was no credible evidence that DXB19 or his family members faced or would face any harm there because of their faith: CB 305-306 at [39];(g)was not satisfied that DXB19 would face harm in Pakistan for any of the reasons claimed, nor would he face harm as a returnee from the west: CB 306 at [40]-[41]; and(h)concluded that DXB19 did not face a real chance of persecution in Pakistan and did not satisfy s 36(2)(a) for the grant of the SHE Visa: CB 306 at [42], and that for the same reasons, found that DXB19 did not satisfy the alternative criteria at s 36(2)(aa): CB 307 at [45]-[46].AMENDED JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATIONGrounds There are seven grounds in the Amended Judicial Review Application, which are set out at [74] (ground 1), [13] (ground 2), [14] (ground 3), [31] (ground 4), [31] (ground 5), [55] (ground 6) and [67] (ground 7) below.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to grounds 2 and 3 the Minister submitted that:(a)the FIR (which appears at SCB 312-314) was essentially a Police Report that was made by DXB19’s mother. Relevantly, it alleges that DXB19’s father was killed by gunshot and that, while the mother did not see the incident, she blamed “unidentified terrorists” and believed he had been assassinated because of his status as a Malik;(b)the Authority was “not persuaded to accept that the FIR is a genuine document or contains truthful information”: CB 298 at [18]: these findings were open to the Authority;(c)with respect to the finding that the FIR was not a genuine document, the Authority had concerns about:(i)country information which suggested that FIRs are simple to counterfeit: CB 297 at [15]; and(ii)the FIR had some “anomalies”: CB 298 at [16], including a misdescription of the province where Peshawar is located, and inconsistent references to the location of the alleged incident: CB 297 at [15];(d)with respect to the failure to accept that the FIR proved DXB19’s father was shot and killed by terrorists, the Authority:(i)noted that DFAT did not consider FIRs to be evidence of the truth of events described in them: CB 297-298 at [15]; and(ii)was concerned that DXB19 had not provided a sound explanation for why he had not been able to provide other corroborating evidence of his father’s death, including a death certificate showing the cause of death, or media reports of allegedly a very public assassination of a Malik, that is, a village leader: CB 297-298 at [15]-[16]; and(e)on the above bases it was reasonable for the Authority to find that the FIR was not a genuine document and that the account described therein of DXB19’s father’s death was not truthful. It is not the case that there was “no evidence” on which the Authority could base these findings, and there was no “unwarranted assumption”.Consideration of grounds 2 and 3 The FIR, in its English translation, appears at SCB 312-313 and is in the following terms:To the SHO of Sharki Police Station, Peshawar I was present in the emergency room at LRH Peshawar when the corpse of Malik Mir Afzal son of Malik Mohammad Afzal of Amalkot Parachinar Kurram Agency, who had been killed by firearm, was brought. Present with the deceased was the lady Shah Sultan, the wife of the deceased, who files the report.We are natives of Amalkot village in Parachinar. Owing to my illness, we came to Peshawar to to see the doctor for check-up at the Khyber Medical Centre near Dabgari Garden. After seeing the doctor, upon his suggestion, my husband told me to wait at the hospital and he left the hospital to get medication prescribed for the treatment A short while later, gunfire took place. Upon hearing the sound, I ran outside and found my husband covered in blood and wounded. He died on the spot. Because my husband was a Shia leader and a tribal elder, he had previously been threatened by the terrorists on many occasions. Therefore, l am certain that my husband has been target-killed by terrorists. I blame the unidentified terrorists for my husband’s death.Police Proceedings: Upon receipt of the report from the applicant, it is entered word by word as stated by the applicant. 1t was read and understood. Once confirmed, signature and thumbprint was recorded, which I certify. The paperwork of the deceased is handed over to the doctor for the post-mortem. Upon the completion of the report and the nature of the crime, the report is dispatched to the police station in the hands of Constable Mohammad Rahim 336. Thereafter it submitted to the staff for FIR investigation. English signature of Subhanullah Si, Reporting Room LRH Peshawar.Police Station Proceeding: Upon the receipt of the report, the case is filed and FIR is registered. A copy of the FIR is handed over the investigation staff for investigation. The report is presented.[Signature]ASI Police Station Sharki, Peshawar 13/3/2016