BXO20 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2025] FedCFamC2G 1206
File number(s):
SYG 1063 of 2020
Judgment of:
JUDGE PAPADOPOULOS
Date of judgment:
1 August 2025
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Judicial Review – protection visa – credibility assessment – inconsistencies and implausibilities – unwarranted assumptions – legal unreasonableness – whether Tribunal had proper regard to circumstances affecting the applicant’s ability to recall traumatic events when giving evidence – whether Tribunal failed to understand and thereby mischaracterised the applicant’s evidence – whether Tribunal failed to explain significance of inconsistency when reaching an adverse credibility finding – whether Tribunal relied upon an unwarranted assumption – where Tribunal reached findings based on common knowledge – no error disclosed – application dismissed.
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)
BETWEEN:
BXO20
Applicant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent
ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
JUDGE PAPADOPOULOS
DATE OF ORDER:
1 AUGUST 2025
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The name of the first respondent be amended to ‘Minister for Immigration and Citizenship’.
2.The name of the second respondent be amended to ‘Administrative Review Tribunal’.
3.The application filed 5 May 2020, as amended,…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BXO20 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:
The applicant, a male national of Pakistan, sought judicial review of the Tribunal's decision not to grant him a protection visa. The Tribunal found the applicant not to be a credible witness and rejected his claim for protection. The applicant alleged that the Tribunal erred in various ways, including by failing to have proper regard to the impact of trauma on his ability to recall events and by making unwarranted assumptions about his credibility. The applicant argued that the Tribunal's approach was legally unreasonable and amounted to jurisdictional error.
The legal issues in the case centred on whether the Tribunal had properly assessed the applicant’s credibility, whether it had appropriately considered the impact of trauma on his ability to recall events, and whether it had made unwarranted assumptions in reaching its adverse credibility findings. The applicant submitted that the Tribunal’s reasoning was flawed and failed to properly account for the effects of trauma on memory and recollection, particularly in the context of traumatic events such as sexual assault and serious threats. The applicant contended that the Tribunal’s approach was legally unreasonable and that it had thereby committed jurisdictional error.
The court considered the arguments put forward by the applicant and reviewed the Tribunal’s decision. It examined whether the Tribunal had properly taken into account the nature of traumatic events and their impact on memory. The court found that the Tribunal had reasonably assessed the applicant’s credibility based on the inconsistencies and implausibilities in his evidence. It concluded that the Tribunal's reasoning was not legally unreasonable and that it had provided sufficient justification for its findings. The court held that the Tribunal had not made unwarranted assumptions and that its decision had an evident and intelligible basis.
The application for judicial review was dismissed, and the Tribunal’s decision was affirmed. The court found no error in the Tribunal's assessment of the applicant’s credibility or its reasoning process. It determined that the Tribunal had properly considered the evidence and the relevant legal principles in reaching its conclusions. The applicant's claims for a protection visa were therefore rejected.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
For the following reasons, the application is dismissed.BACKGROUND The background and procedural history of this matter was helpfully summarised in the Minister’s written submissions, which I primarily adopt. The applicant, a male national of Pakistan, first arrived in Australia on 12 May 2013 as the holder of a Subclass 573 Student (Temporary) (Class TU) Higher Education Sector visa (student visa) granted on 24 April 2013.[1][1] Court Book (CB) 214. On 24 December 2014, the applicant travelled to Pakistan.[2] On 22 January 2015, the applicant re-entered Australia.[3][2] CB 236.[3] CB 236.The protection visa application On 30 June 2015, the applicant applied for the protection visa on the basis that he fears returning to Pakistan because he is a Christian and he will be targeted on return by a particular Mullah, the police, the Taliban and others because he refused to convert to Islam and insulted the Mullah in front of everyone by not converting.[4][4] CB 272 at [2]. On 24 June 2016, a delegate of the Minister refused to grant the protection visa.[5][5] CB 210 to 227.The review application On 27 July 2016, the applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision.[6][6] CB 229. On 8 March 2020, the applicant provided the Tribunal with a written statement and various news articles and reports. The following summary provides detail of the narrative underpinning the applicant’s claim for protection:[7](a)Between February and December 2019, the Rangers, a Pakistani paramilitary law enforcement corps, conducted widespread raids in Karachi and arrested many supposed criminals including S and H.(b)S and H were the applicant’s classmates and the nephews of the applicant’s scripture teacher.(c)The applicant’s scripture teacher accused the applicant’s father of informing on S and H.(d)Following this, the applicant’s family faced threats, home searches, and arrests, with the applicant’s father and brother arrested then tortured during interrogation.(e)While S and H were imprisoned and the applicant’s father and brother were released, the applicant’s family continued to face harassment.(f)Based on statements from S and H, the Pakistani authorities believe the applicant was involved in drug and arms trafficking and the applicant fears the Rangers will arrest him upon return to Pakistan.[7] CB 245 to 254. On 16 March 2020, the applicant attended a hearing before the Tribunal.[8][8] CB 256. On 7 April 2020, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the delegate to not grant the applicant a protection visa.[9][9] CB 271.The Tribunal’s decision By way of its decision dated 7 April 2020, sent to the applicant by email under cover of a letter of 8 April 2020, the Tribunal:(a)identified the key issues to be considered were the applicant’s credibility, whether he had a well-founded fear of persecution, and whether he was owed complementary protection;[10](b)recorded, for the purposes of its consideration, the material before it which included country information submitted by the applicant;[11](c)recorded the applicant’s claims for protection in considerable detail, as iteratively presented to the Department and the Tribunal, along with the specific country information submitted by the applicant in support of claims relating to the Rangers’ arrests of drug and arms dealers around 2019;[12](d)recorded the applicant’s criticisms of the delegate’s decision;[13] and(e)recorded the applicant’s reiteration of his claims at hearing and the Tribunal’s raising of various credibility concerns at hearing, including by way of invoking the procedure in s 424AA of the Act.[14][10] CB 272, [7].[11] CB 272 to 275, [9].[12] CB 276 to 280, [12]-[32].[13] CB 280 to 281, [33]-[37].[14] CB 282, [38].
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
By way of nine particulars raised in support of the sole ground of review, the applicant alleges the Tribunal erred in ten distinct ways such that it ‘adopted a legally unreasonable process of reasoning in assessing [his] credibility and thereby committed jurisdictional error’. I now turn to address each of the ten errors alleged by the applicant.First alleged error – failure to have regard to impact of trauma when assessing inconsistent evidence in support of the serious assault and rape claims In relation to the error alleged by way of Particular 1a, the applicant submits that paragraph [52] of the Tribunal’s reasons disclose error in its treatment of inconsistencies in his evidence concerning the circumstances of his arrest by police prior to his detention, assault and rape. Paragraph [52] relevantly records the Tribunal’s identification of the inconsistency, the applicant’s explanation for the inconsistency, and the Tribunal’s reasons for rejecting that explanation (reproduced below without alteration):[32]Firstly, the Applicant provided inconsistent evidence as to whether he was arrested by the police on his way to church or on his way back from church. In his statement, he claims that while driving to church on 11 January 2015, [S] and [H] with the police stopped the car he was travelling in with his mother and brother and ordered them to get out of the car. He claims when he came out of the car he was arrested and taken to the police station, while his brother and mother were allowed to leave. However, in contrast at the Department interview and Tribunal hearing, he stated that he was stopped by the police and arrested after church. He said and confirmed at the Tribunal hearing that after church, the Applicant together with his mother and brother got in the car and drove for a couple of minutes when they were stopped by the police and taken to the police station. When the inconsistency was raised with him at the Tribunal hearing he said it was a mistake in his statement. The Tribunal does not accept his explanation that it was a mistake in his statement as it is of the view if he was stopped and taken by police as claimed he would be consistent as to this detail due to the significance of the event. It adds to the finding he is not a credible witness.(emphasis added)[32] CB 287, [52]. The applicant takes issue with the Tribunal’s reasoning process, alleging it was legally unreasonable to ‘assume’ he would be able to give consistent evidence when recounting ‘significant’ events such as serious assault and rape, and this is indicative of a failure to appreciate the likelihood of inconsistencies in the evidence of victims of sexual assault. Mr Jones argued at hearing that the fact that a particular incident, event or experience within the narrative presented by an applicant in support of their claim for protection might be regarded as significant, does not necessarily mean that its recitation must always be consistent. Mr Jones emphasised this is especially so where an individual has endured particularly traumatic experiences. In support of this submission, Mr Jones drew my attention to a range of propositions in Lehrmann v Network Ten Pty Limited (Trial Judgment) [2024] FCA 369 (Lehrmann), particularly paragraphs [116]–[117]:[116] The evidence was objected to by Mr Lehrmann on a number of grounds, which are now unnecessary to detail. Prior to ruling on the objections, I raised with the parties my preliminary view that even if the evidence was admissible, it would be, at best, of marginal utility in circumstances where: (a) this was a judge-alone trial; and (b) that subject to submissions to the contrary, I considered it would be appropriate to direct myself as to the impact of alleged counterintuitive conduct in a manner consistent with some foundational propositions referred to in the proposed evidence which, it seemed to me, simply reflected the accumulated experience of the common law (seen in standard directions) or in ordinary human experience.[117] Sensibly, both parties agreed, and it became unnecessary to deal with admissibility or discretionary exclusion issues, as the following became common ground as agreed facts pursuant to s 191 EA (Agreed Facts dated 18 December 2023 (agreed facts)):(1) trauma has a severe impact on memory by splintering and fragmenting memories; such that semantic or meaning elements become separated from emotion; and interfering with the timespan memories require to consolidate and become permanent;(2) due to the potential for cuing of emotional responses to fragmented memories, memory can change, be subject to reconsolidation effects, and even when these effects are not marked initially, memories may remain labile for some time (thus changes in what the person reports as their memory of an event can be expected);(3) lack of clarity and confused accounts can be expected until such time as the memory has consolidated;(4) inconsistencies in reporting following a traumatic event are often observed and explicable through underlying theories of trauma and memory function;(5) omissions can be understood as alterations in awareness due to high arousal at the time of the event that consolidate over time;(6) inconsistency is often observed in reliable reports of sexual assault and is not ipso facto a measure of deception;(7) in understanding the account of an alleged “survivor”, a person must consider how that account was elicited; this includes the skill and attitudes towards the person by the investigating officers; the time elapsed between the traumatic event and the formal interview; and the psychological/emotional state of the person being interviewed at the time of interview;(8) the first forensic interview is potentially a trigger for intrusive thoughts that can lead to fragmentation of memory and dissociation; patterns of behaviour such as high confidence and clarity in the account are not helpful in determining whether the account is accurate;(9) despite the belief that the emergence of inconsistencies across interviews is a sign of lying (people “can’t keep their story straight”), the literature on memory, impacts of trauma and the dynamic between interviewee and the interviewer must be considered; and(10) multiple interviews are typically necessary to construct a clear narrative of events; however, the consequence of these multiple interviews may be patterns of inconsistency or omissions especially early in the interview process (which need to be carefully evaluated but are not in and of themselves necessarily indicative of deception or accuracy).
Decision
Reasons for decision
On 7 April 2020, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the delegate to not grant the applicant a protection visa.[9][9] CB 271.The Tribunal’s decision By way of its decision dated 7 April 2020, sent to the applicant by email under cover of a letter of 8 April 2020, the Tribunal:(a)identified the key issues to be considered were the applicant’s credibility, whether he had a well-founded fear of persecution, and whether he was owed complementary protection;[10](b)recorded, for the purposes of its consideration, the material before it which included country information submitted by the applicant;[11](c)recorded the applicant’s claims for protection in considerable detail, as iteratively presented to the Department and the Tribunal, along with the specific country information submitted by the applicant in support of claims relating to the Rangers’ arrests of drug and arms dealers around 2019;[12](d)recorded the applicant’s criticisms of the delegate’s decision;[13] and(e)recorded the applicant’s reiteration of his claims at hearing and the Tribunal’s raising of various credibility concerns at hearing, including by way of invoking the procedure in s 424AA of the Act.[14][10] CB 272, [7].[11] CB 272 to 275, [9].[12] CB 276 to 280, [12]-[32].[13] CB 280 to 281, [33]-[37].[14] CB 282, [38]. Before detailing its assessment of the applicant’s credibility, the Tribunal adumbrated the basis of its ultimate rejection of the claim for protection by way of three key statements:(a)the applicant was not a credible witness as to either him or his family having faced the difficulties claimed or for fearing return to Pakistan for the reasons claimed;(b)the applicant’s testimony was inconsistent in relation to his claims;(c)the applicant had fabricated claims and concocted evidence to achieve an immigration outcome. By way of assessing the various claims raised, the Tribunal:(a)found the applicant provided inconsistent evidence in relation to the events leading to the applicant’s departure from Karachi to Islamabad in September 2012;[15](b)found to be implausible the applicant’s claim that radical Muslims attended his Catholic school in Karachi;[16](c)found the applicant provided inconsistent evidence in relation to the claimed events and experiences he and his family faced while he was in Islamabad between September 2012 and March 2013;[17](d)found the applicant’s delay in departure from Pakistan, such that he arrived in Australia on 12 May 2013 which was some 17 days after he was granted an Australian visa, undermined his claims in relation to the harm he suffered in Pakistan before his departure and his claimed fear of returning to Pakistan;[18](e)found the applicant provided inconsistent evidence in relation to the harassment faced by his family members between May 2013 and December 2014 while he was in Australia;[19](f)found the applicant’s return visit to Pakistan from Australia, between 24 December 2014 and 22 January 2015, undermined his claims of the harm he suffered in Pakistan and his claimed fear of returning to Pakistan;[20](g)found the applicant provided inconsistent evidence in relation to his detention and rape following his arrest by police in Pakistan on 11 January 2015;[21](h)found to be implausible the applicant’s claim that, on 11 January 2025, his sister posted photographs of him on his Facebook page celebrating his birthday with friends which was the day he was being detained by police in Pakistan;[22](i)found the applicant provided inconsistent evidence in relation to the harassment his family members faced after his departure from Pakistan in 2015;[23](j)found the applicant’s delay in applying for a protection visa in Australia on 29 June 2015 - being a period of over two years since first arriving in Australian and five months since he returned from Pakistan following his detention and rape - undermined his claim that he fears returning to Pakistan and that he departed Pakistan in fear in both May 2013 and January 2015.[24][15] CB 282 to 284, [41].[16] CB 284, [42].[17] CB 284 to 285, [43]-[44].[18] CB 285, [45]-[47].[19] CB 286, [48].[20] CB 286, [49]-[50].[21] CB 286 to 288,[51]-[55].[22] CB 284, [56].[23] CB 288, [57]-[60].[24] CB 288 to 289, [61]-[65].
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In BOH17 at [7]-[8], Perram J further exposed the jurisprudential basis upon which unwarranted assumptions give rise to error:7. On the current state of the authorities, it seems to me that the better view is that there is no freestanding ground of unwarranted assumptions. However, the making of unwarranted assumptions as part of a credit finding may be reviewed on rationality grounds (DAO16) or because the decision maker has failed duly to consider the question raised by the material (WAGO and BZD17). For myself, the former test is easier to apply in practicein the sense that it appears less conclusory. There are various extant formulations of this ground. The Full Court in Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Sabharwal[2018] FCAFC 160 at [45] described it this way:Illogicality, irrationality or legal unreasonableness in the reasons for an administrative decision may establish jurisdictional error, as may a failure to give proper, genuine or realistic consideration to a significant matter. An illogical or irrational administrative decision, or an illogical or irrational finding of fact or reasoning along the way to making the decision, may establish jurisdictional error if, for example, the decision or finding is not open on the evidence or if there is no logical connection between the evidence and the inferences or conclusions drawn. Making a finding on a fact or issue in the application by drawing an inference or a conclusion which lacks a logical connection with the evidence might also be described as failing to give proper, genuine and realistic consideration to the fact or issue. However, any such decision or finding will not involve jurisdictional error if a reasonable decision-maker could reach that decision or finding on the same material: SZMDS at [130]-[132] and [135] per Crennan and Bell JJ and at [78] per Heydon J. As Allsop CJ observed in Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Stretton[2016] FCAFC 11; (2016) 237 FCR 1 at [21] the question is “whether a decision-maker could reasonably come to the conclusion” reached. If the conclusion is one upon which reasonable minds can differ, it will not be legally illogical, irrational or unreasonable.(See also Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs v JSMJ[2023] FCAFC 77 at [39])8. Thus, a party relying upon an unwarranted assumption to establish jurisdictional error will need to establish that the assumption is not one which a reasonable decision maker could make. Another way of asking this question is to ask whether the decision has an evident and intelligible basis: Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZVFW [2018] HCA 30; 264 CLR 541at [10] per Kiefel CJ, [82] per Nettle and Gordon JJ, citing Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li [2013] HCA 18; 249 CLR 332 at [76] per Hayne, Kiefel and Bell JJ. In this case, therefore, this means that the question for decision is whether the Tribunal’s impugned credit findings were ones which could reasonably be arrived at or whether they lacked an evident and intelligible justification.CONSIDERATION