2018596 (Refugee)

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

2018596 (Refugee) [2024] AATA 2698 (30 April 2024)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

REPRESENTATIVE:  Mr Harry Huang (MARN: 9579277)

CASE NUMBER:  2018596

COUNTRY OF REFERENCE:                   China

MEMBER:Christine Cody

DATE:30 April 2024

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal remits the matter for reconsideration with the following directions:

(i)that the second named applicant satisfies s 36(2)(a) of the Migration Act; and

(ii)that the first named applicant satisfies s 36(2)(b)(i) of the Migration Act, on the basis of membership of the same family unit as the second named applicant.

Statement made on 30 April 2024 at 9:03pm

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection on 11 November 2016 to refuse to grant the applicants protection visas under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act). The applicants were represented by the same agent before the Department, and in relation to the review.

  2. The applicants, a mother (the applicant) and child, who claim to be citizens of China, applied for the visas on 12 January 2016. It was claimed that the applicant was a Christian. [Mr A], born in [Year], married the applicant on [Date]. He is the father of the child. He lodged his own protection visa application separate to the applicant and child; his application, made on different grounds, was refused.

  3. After an interview with the applicant the delegate refused to grant the visas on the basis that the applicant’s claims to be a Christian and to have experienced harm in China were not credible and were not true.

  4. The applicants lodged an application for review to the Tribunal. The “first Tribunal” affirmed the decision under review in a decision dated 16 January 2020 (AAT case number 1620513). The Federal Circuit Court of Australia (FCCA) set aside the first Tribunal’s decision on 12 January 2021 for the reason that:

    The MICMSMA concedes that the decision of the Tribunal dated 16 January 2020 (AAT case number 1620513) is affected by jurisdictional error. Specifically, the Tribunal failed to give proper, genuine and realistic consideration to corroborative evidence in the witnesses' statements as its reasons at [40] do not grapple in any meaningful way with why the witnesses would—essentially untruthfully—claim that the applicant had started attending the church in 2013, attended nearly every week since, been baptised in 2014, and was a genuine Christian: see BZD17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 94. It was a matter for the Tribunal to accept, or to reject, the witnesses’ evidence, but it was not permitted to reject that evidence out of hand, even if it held significant doubts about the applicant’s credibility. This error was material to the outcome of the review as, had the Tribunal given proper consideration to the witnesses’ evidence, it may have accepted that the applicant started attending church in 2013 and may have accepted she had been baptised.

  5. The matter is now before the (current) Tribunal pursuant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 2018596 (Refugee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 2698
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Circuit Court considered the case of a mother and her child seeking protection visas. The dispute arose after the original application for protection visas was refused by the Department. The applicant mother claimed to fear persecution in China due to her conversion to Christianity and her involvement in church activities, including proselytising. She also alleged she was reported to the authorities by her boyfriend after his arrest. The court was required to determine whether the applicant and her child met the criteria for a protection visa, specifically whether they had a well-founded fear of persecution or faced a real chance of significant harm upon return to China.

The court's reasoning focused on the credibility of the applicant's claims and the consistency of her evidence. It noted significant delays in her application for a protection visa, her history of being an unlawful non-citizen in Australia, and a lack of substantial official or documentary evidence to support her assertions. The court found that her explanations for these issues were often vague and inconsistent. Furthermore, the court considered that her religious activities, including taking her child to church, may have been undertaken primarily to secure a protection visa rather than stemming from genuine religious conviction or fear. The court also examined country information regarding the treatment of Christians in China, acknowledging a small but real possibility of persecution in all areas of the country.

Ultimately, the Tribunal found that the applicant was not a witness of truth and had not established that she was a refugee or entitled to complementary protection. However, when considering the specific circumstances of the child, particularly in light of the country information, the Tribunal concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration. This reconsideration was to include the mother's application as a member of her child's family unit.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, a citizen of China, arrived in Australia in March 2008 on a TU-571 Student visa, which expired in March 2011. Despite ceasing her studies in 2009, she remained in Australia unlawfully until 19 January 2016, when she was granted a bridging visa associated with her application for a protection visa. In January 2016, she applied for a protection visa for herself and her child, who was born in Australia. The applicant claims to have converted to Christianity in March 2013, following encouragement from her neighbour, and to have attended Church 1 in Sydney regularly since then. She asserts that she and her child face persecution in China due to her Christian faith and activities, including sending Bibles and Christian materials to her parents and friends in China. The applicant met her husband in December 2013 at Church 1, and they began a relationship in 2015. Her husband's separate application for a protection visa, lodged in October 2013, was refused on different grounds, with no mention of religion. The Tribunal found the applicant's claims vague, inconsistent, and lacking in specific detail. Her testimony included contradictions regarding her contact with her family in China and her reasons for not returning home. She did not provide evidence to substantiate her claims of Christian activities or proselytising in China and Australia. The Tribunal was unconvinced by the applicant's explanations for the significant delay in applying for a protection visa and found that her activities, including church attendance and encouraging her child's involvement in Christianity, were undertaken for the purpose of obtaining a protection visa. Despite these findings, the Tribunal concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration in light of the child's particular circumstances and the country information.

The matter came before the Tribunal as an appeal against the decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, who had refused the applicant's application for a protection visa. The applicant, a Chinese national, had arrived in Australia in March 2008 on a student visa and subsequently overstayed after her visa expired in March 2011. She applied for a protection visa in January 2016, following the birth of her child and her marriage to an Australian citizen. The delegate found that the applicant had engaged in activities, including attending church and proselytising her Christian faith, to obtain a protection visa and concluded that she was not a refugee or entitled to complementary protection. The matter was remitted to the delegate for reconsideration on the basis that the applicant was a member of her child's same family unit. The Tribunal's decision highlighted the applicant's vague and inconsistent claims, delays in applying for protection, and lack of documentary evidence to support her assertions. The Tribunal's reasons for remittal focused on the child's circumstances and the country information regarding the small but real possibility of persecution in China for religious activities.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant provides a statutory declaration dated 3 January 2020 in response which included:The information in relation to my studying in Australia which I gave atdepartmental interview on 20 September 2016 is correct. I would like to repeat itonce again that I stopped my studying because I learned my friend wassentenced to imprisonment and I lost my mind and terminated my study as aresult.According to the departmental interview the departmental database was basedon the information obtained from school. Further according to the interview thedepartment will get that information if a student did not attend the school or if the student’s attendance was unsatisfactory.[In] July 2019 I left for China on a school holiday. Before that I attended theschool regularly and my attendance was satisfactory. Although I also went to schoolafter I returned to Australia [in] August 2009 my attendance was obviouslyunsatisfactory because I was on and off as I said at the departmental interview.My unsatisfactory attendance, I think was the reason why the school gave theinformation to the Department my stop studying in July 2009.The information in relation to my husband which I gave at the Tribunal’shearing on 20 December 2019 is correct. I would like to repeat it once again that Imet my husband at church in 2013 and that he was also a member of [Church 1].When my husband lodged his protection visa applicant (PV application) in October2013 he did not officially become a Christian, because he had not yet beenbaptised by then. To the best of my knowledge my husband’s protection visaapplication (PV application) was mainly based on the reasons that his father hadborrowed money from others for gambling and that his family was hounded bydebt collectors. I think that all of these were the reasons why my husband did notclaim that he was a Christian in his PV application.My husband was baptised on 26 January 2014. It was on the same day with meas well as other new believers, but my relationship with my husband did not startuntil 2015.When my husband attended a hearing before the Refugee Review Tribunal inMay 2015 it clearly indicated the tribunal that he was a Christian and he then tookthe oath on Bible. I believe that the Tribunal must have kept a record on it.Evidence at current Tribunal hearing The applicant provided further documents to the Tribunal through her agent including photos and statements as follows:· The third letter of Support from [Ms D] dated 12 November 2023 · Letter of [J] dated 10 November 2023· Second letter of support from [Mr I], director, dated 15 November 2023 · Letter of Support from [K] and [L] (translated copy) dated 13 November 2023 The letters indicate that they believe the applicant is genuine and she shares her knowledge and she has brought her child along to church and her son is involved in the church. The photos indicate that she has continued to attend church activities including online and has brought her son along. Other documents are referred to below.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant sent further documents to the Department by way of a letter from the agent dated 19 September 2016, the day before the interview, as follows:· Photographs of the applicant and her husband apparently at a Baptism; · Supporting statement from [Ms D] dated 17 September 2016 with translation. She states she is a member of [Church 1]. She knew the applicant from January 2014, during baptism training sessions. After her baptism the applicant has been attending Church Sunday services and Saturday night Bible study frequently. The applicant has advised her that she uses religion in bringing up her child and she encourages others. · Supporting translated statement from [Mr E] dated 11 September 2016. He and his wife [Ms F] were the neighbours of the applicant, his wife promoted the Gospel to the applicant, they took her to church in March 2013 and since then they attended Church meetings together. The applicant actively participates, was baptised, she helps do the cleaning and keep the church tidy. Interview with the delegate and the Delegates decision record On 20 September 2016 the applicant attended an interview with the delegate. She made no claims on behalf of her son, stating that he was just a dependent. Some of the contents of that interview are contained in the delegate’s decision record which have been set out below for ease of refence (other evidence not recorded in the decision record is also referred to in this decision record where relevant):· The Applicant was asked how she practised her religion in Australia; she replied that she read the Bible and prayed to God. She said that she liked attending gatherings and communicating with the Brother and Sisters. She said that she liked to serve the church. She said that she is a Protestant and she attended the church every Saturday night, Sunday and any main gatherings at the church.· The Applicant was asked if she was a Christian when she was in China. She replied in the negative, consequently the Applicant was asked why she became a Christian in March 2013, given she has been living in Australia since March 2008. To this the Applicant replied that it was because when she came here she did not know what she was doing. She proceeded to say that at the end of 2012 her neighbour started preaching gospel to her. The delegate considered that significant elements of her testimony were vague, generalised and lacking in specific detail, that she was not a satisfactory witness, and she delayed in applying for protection. The concerns included: The Applicant indicated at the interview that her parents and her younger brother were living in China. At the interview, the Applicant was asked about her last contact with her family, to this she stated that she spoke to her mother last week Thursday (15/09/2016). However, later at the interview she contradicted this information when she stated that her mother only communicated with her every fifth day of the month. She also stated that her mother would ring her because she dare not ring her parents because the Chinese government would eavesdrop on their conversation. The Applicant also mentioned at the interview that her parents were unemployed, despite her claim that she communicated with her mother every fifth day for the month; she claimed not to know how they were able to survive and support her brother in China without an income. In her Protection visa application, the Applicant had mentioned that her husband [Mr A] was refused a protection on 28/05/2014 by the Department. The Applicant said that her husband worked in a [workplace] for three to four days a week. She mentioned that she met her husband in December 2014 at a church and began a relationship with him in 2015. Later at the interview, she changed this statement to say that she first met her husband in December 2013 and began living together in 2015. The Applicant was asked at the interview why she did not approach the Department to regularise her visa status when her Student visa ceased in 2011. The Applicant replied that she did not know, she was confused, weak at the time and felt lost. The Applicant was asked why she did not return to her country when she stopped her studies in Australia in 2009. The Applicant replied that she dare not go home because she will be arrested by the Chinese authorities. The delegate considered that was able to live and probably work in Australia for a substantial period of time. Furthermore, despite her claim that she did not want to return to her country in 2009 because she was afraid that she would be arrested by the Chinese authorities, the Applicant made no attempt to apply for any other visas to regularise visa status and/or lodge a Protection visa sooner if she had a genuine fear of persecution in her country. It is indicative to note that the Applicant had declared at the interview that she knew about the protection visa since she arrived in Australia. The Applicant was asked why she was seeking protection in Australia, to this she replied thatshe was afraid to go back because the Chinese government had identified her as a dangerous person and a threat to the security. She said that she would have no freedom if she returns to her country. Consequently, the Applicant was asked why she was considered as a dangerous person by the Chinese authorities, the Applicant replied that it was because she preached to the Chinese people therefore she was identified as a dangerous person. However, when the delegate asked her how she preached, her evidence was very basic (I tell them to believe in God). ·The Applicant was asked why she sent the Bible and Christian materials if she knew that they were banned by the Chinese authorities, to this she said that she wanted them to know more about Christianity. Consequently, it was put to the Applicant that there was no information to suggest to the Chinese authorities that she was the one who had sent the materials to her friend, to this the Applicant replied that [Mr C] had reported her to the police. When questioned further on this matter, she said that he was arrested by the police. At the interview, the Applicant was asked how she knew the absolute details about [Mr C]’s situation, i.e. his activities, arrest etc. in China. The Applicant replied that the police had told her mother about [Mr C]. Consequently the Applicant was asked why the police would tell her mother all the personal details about [Mr C]. The Applicant responded that the Chinese police went to her place and asked her to surrender herself. I find it farfetched and unreasonable that a police officer would divulge every activities of [Mr C] to the Applicant’s mother which would have been considered as confidential.·There were other discrepancies and inconsistencies in the Applicant’s responses for instance she claimed that an arrest warrant was issued against her. When asked for evidence, i.e. arrest warrant, the Applicant indicated that her mother had sent it to her and it was on its way. However to-date no evidence has been received from the Applicant or her representative in regard to this matter. It is also indicative to note that the Applicant later at the interview changed her testimony and indicated that the police showed the arrest warrant to her mother and then took it away. However I find this assertion is in contradictory to her earlier verbal testimony which suggested that her mother had posted the arrest warrant to her.·Even though the Applicant claimed that she attended church in Sydney, she has not provided any supporting letters from the pastors or elders of her claimed church in Australia. The Applicant has provided two support letters. However this alone is insufficient to confirm the Applicant’s attendance to [Church 1]. Further to this, the Applicant claimed to have been baptised at this church, however she provided no evidence to substantiate this claim.·In my assessment of the Applicant’s claim in regard to her proselytising of her Christian faith to her parents and friends in China, I find it implausible that the Applicant who had claimed tohave been a Christian since March 2013 and had claimed to have attended [Church 1] on a regular basis was unable to provide any significantinformation about her Christian faith to the people she claimed to have preached in China. It isindicative to note that the Applicant was given several opportunities to explain about how shewas able to evangelise her faith to the people in China. Based on the Applicant’s testimony Iam not convinced that she had proselytised to her family or her friend and his wife in China. I am of the opinion that a person who wished to proselytise would have a certain degree ofknowledge about the religion and some crucial information about Jesus Christ, his miracles etc. In considering the Applicant’s activity in proselytising of the Christian faith in China and inAustralia, I find her responses at the interview did not indicate to me that she possessed acertain degree of knowledge that I would expect of a person who has the intention toproselytise and convert people in China and Australia. Though I accept that the Applicant hadprovided some information about Christianity at the interview, however I am of the opinion that it was prepared for the purpose of this interview.·At the interview, the Applicant indicated that she knew about the Protection visa (PV) application since she came to Australia. She said that she did not even think about applying did not lodge a Protection visa application when her Student visa ceased. She said that after 2009she was like a dead person; she did not have any thoughts. However I do not accept thisexplanation. I am of the opinion that this story was created in an attempt to justify the delay inthe lodgement of a PV application. Despite being aware of the existence of the Protection visain 2008 and having fears of returning to her country since 2009, she only lodged the PVapplication nearly seven years later. The Applicant claimed at the interview that she had a valid Student visa at the time, even if I was to accept the Applicant’s assertion, however it isindicative to note that her Student visa ceased in March 2011 and the Applicant continued todelay the lodgement of a PV application for nearly five years and continue to live in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen.·The evidence suggests that if the Applicant was considered to be of any concern when departing China to return to Australia, it is unlikely that she would have been able to exit China and travel overseas. There is no objective evidence to indicate that the Applicant holds a profile that would attract adverse attention from the authorities if she were to return to China. Rather, the evidence is to the contrary.·I am of the opinion that her reason in lodging a PV application was for the purpose of seeking a migration pathway so she can stay permanently in Australia

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal has found that the applicant is not a witness of truth. She has engaged in activities including attending church and religious activities, and encouraged her child’s involvement in Christianity, for the purpose of obtaining protection visas. The Tribunal has not accepted that she is a refugee or entitled to complementary protection. However, when considering the child’s particular circumstances in the context of the country information, the Tribunal has concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration (with the mother’s application on the basis that she is a member of her child’s same family unit). The Tribunal’s reasons are set out below. The applicant’s migration history[1][1] Source: the delegate’s decision record provided to the tribunal by the applicant, passport and application form The applicant’s passport was issued [in] 2007. She arrived in Australia [in] March 2008 on a TU-571 Student visa. This visa was granted on 29 February 2008 and expired on 02 June 2008. A subsequent TU 571 Student visa was granted on 02 June 2008 and ceased on 21 March 2011. (On her own evidence) the applicant ceased studying sometime in 2009 yet remained in Australia, and when her student visa ceased, she remained unlawfully present for 4 years and 10 months, until 19 January 2016 when she was granted a bridging visa in association with her application for a protection visa.Departmental file[2][2] There is no non-disclosure certificate on file The applicant lodged the protection visa application forms and accompanying documents: statements dated 12 January 2016, certified copy of marriage certificate between the applicant and her husband showing that they were married on [Date] by a marriage celebrant, the birth certificate for the child born [Date], now aged [Age] years, and stamped pages of her passport. Application form for applicant signed 12 January 2016 The applicant makes the following claims in her form:· She was born in Fuqing, Fujian, China in [year] and she resided there until she came to Australia aged [Age] years. Her religion is Christian and her ethnicity is Han. · She attended school in China, withdrawing from her high school in March 2008 when she came to Australia. She departed China on [Date 1] March 2008 and arrived in Australia legally on [Date 2] March 2008 as the holder of a student visa. · She speaks, reads and writes in Chinese only [the lack of reference to any English was inconsistent with her claim that in Australia she attended an English and high school course at [Provider] (from March 2008 to December 2009)]. · She undertook odd jobs in Australia between June 2008 to July 2015. From July 2015 she was unemployed.· Since her first arrival, she returned to China, departing Australia [in] July 2009 and returning [in] August 2009. · She is in contact by telephone with her parents and brother in China. Application form for child The child’s parents are the applicant and her husband who are Chinese citizens. The child’s ethnicity is Chinese Han and his religion is Christian.