Williams v Minister for the Environment and Heritage

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Williams v Minister for the Environment and Heritage [2003] FCA 535

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Decision of Minister refusing application for interim protection declaration under Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act – Application related to area of proposed mining lease being part of a lakeshore – Material indicating significance     of the lake itself and also of archaeological relics in the subject land – Decision concentrated attention on the wider area rather than the proposed mining area – Whether Minister failed to take into account a relevant consideration – Whether decision was unreasonable – Minister’s decision set aside – Whether Court should make an interim order restricting on-site work pending reconsideration by Minister.

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act 1984 ss 3, 9, 11, 22

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 ss 5, 13, 16

NEVILLE WILLIAMS v MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT AND HERITAGE, BARRICK AUSTRALIA LIMITED
N 192 of 2003

WILCOX J
30 MAY 2003
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 192 of 2003

BETWEEN:

NEVILLE WILLIAMS
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR THE ENVIRONMENT AND HERITAGE
FIRST RESPONDENT

BARRICK AUSTRALIA LIMITED
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

WILCOX J

DATE OF ORDER:

30 MAY 2003

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.It be declared that the decision of the first respondent, the Minister for the Environment and Heritage (“the Minister”), dated 9 December 2002 to refuse to make a declaration pursuant to s 9 of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act 1984 is invalid.

2.        The said decision be set aside.

3.The application of the applicant, Neville Williams, for a declaration pursuant to the said section be remitted to the Minister for consideration and determination according to law.

4.The Minister pay any costs hitherto reasonably incurred by the applicant or the second respondent, Barrick Australia Limited, in connection with the proceeding.

5.The Minister complete his determination of the remitted application, and notify his decision thereon to the other parties to this proceeding, by not later than Friday, 13 June 2003.

6.        The parties have liberty to apply on two days’ notice.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 192 of 2003

BETWEEN:

NEVILLE WILLIAMS
APPLICANT

AND:

MINISTER FOR THE ENVIRONMENT AND HERITAGE
FIRST RESPONDENT

BARRICK AUSTRALIA LIMITED
SECOND RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

WILCOX J

DATE:

30 MAY 2003

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

WILCOX J:

  1. This application is made under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (“the ADJR Act”) seeking review of a decision of the Minister for the Environment and Heritage (“the Minister”). The Minister (the first respondent to the application) decided not to make a declaration under s 9 of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act 1984 (“the Act”) in relation to land at Lake Cowal in central New South Wales (“the specified area”).

    The legislation

  2. Section 9 of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Williams v Minister for the Environment and Heritage and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 535
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Williams v Minister for the Environment and Heritage involved a dispute between Neville Williams, a member of the Wiradjuri People and Chairman of the Mooka Traditional Owners Council, and the Minister for the Environment and Heritage. Williams sought an interim protection declaration under the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act 1984 concerning a specified area near Lake Cowal, which was proposed for a mining lease by Barrick Australia Limited. The application was based on the significance of the lake and archaeological relics found within the area. The Minister's decision to refuse the application was challenged on the grounds that it was unreasonable and failed to take into account relevant considerations.

The primary legal issue was whether the Minister failed to consider relevant factors in making his decision, specifically whether he overlooked the significant evidence provided by Williams and the two archaeologists regarding the importance of the specified area and the archaeological relics. Another issue was whether the Court should grant an interim order to restrict on-site work while the Minister reconsidered the application. The court had to determine if the Minister's decision was invalid due to an error in evaluating the evidence and if the Minister had concentrated his attention on the wrong area.

The court found that the Minister's decision was invalid as it did not properly evaluate the evidence, particularly the archaeological evidence which predominantly related to the specified area. The Minister's concentration on the broader Lake Cowal area rather than the specific proposed mining area was a material consideration he failed to take into account. As a result, the court set aside the Minister's decision and remitted the application back to him for reconsideration according to law. The Minister was also ordered to complete his determination of the remitted application and notify the parties of his decision by a specified date.

The final orders of the court were to declare the Minister's decision invalid and set it aside, remit the application back to the Minister for reconsideration, and direct the Minister to complete his determination by a specified date. The Minister was also ordered to pay the costs of the proceeding. The parties were granted liberty to apply for further orders on two days' notice.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. It be declared that the decision of the first respondent, the Minister for the Environment and Heritage (“the Minister”), dated 9 December 2002 to refuse to make a declaration pursuant to s 9 of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act 1984 is invalid.

2. The said decision be set aside.

3. The application of the applicant, Neville Williams, for a declaration pursuant to the said section be remitted to the Minister for consideration and determination according to law.

4. The Minister pay any costs hitherto reasonably incurred by the applicant or the second respondent, Barrick Australia Limited, in connection with the proceeding.

5. The Minister complete his determination of the remitted application, and notify his decision thereon to the other parties to this proceeding, by not later than Friday, 13 June 2003.

6. The parties have liberty to apply on two days’ notice.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 22 makes it an offence to contravene a provision of a declaration under s 9.Background The applicant, Neville Williams, is an Aboriginal. He is a member of the Wiradjuri People and Chairman of the Mooka Traditional Owners Council, an incorporated association that purports to represent the interests of Wiradjuri People resident near Lake Cowal. The Mooka Council claims these people are the traditional owners of the specified area. The Wiradjuri Council of Elders, which purports to represent the interests of all Wiradjuri People, does not accept the Mooka Council’s claim. On 17 October 2003, Mr Williams applied to the Minister to make a declaration under s 9 of the Act in relation to the specified area. There was a proposal for the specified area to be the subject of a mining lease, to be granted by the State of New South Wales to Homestake Australia Ltd, now Barrick Australia Limited, the second respondent. I will use the word “Barrick” to refer to this company, whatever its name at the relevant time. I understand the mining lease has now been granted. The specified area was identified on a map attached to the Minister’s decision. It extends from the West Wyalong-Burcher Railway on the west to an easterly boundary that lies within the waters of Lake Cowal, when it is full. Judging by the map, approximately one-sixth of the total lake shore lies within the specified area. Mr Williams supported his application by affidavits and statements, made by himself, other Aboriginal people and two archaeologists, Mr David Johnston and Dr Francis Wilfred Shawcross, and by documents concerning applications by Barrick to the New South Wales National Parks and Wildlife Service (“NPWS”) for permission to remove and destroy aboriginal artefacts found within the specified area. The affidavits detail the nature and location of numerous artefacts found in and near the specified area. The two archaeologists expressed the view that these were all Aboriginal artefacts, and that many of them were significant pointers to past Aboriginal use of the land. The Minister invited Barrick to respond to Mr Williams’ application. Barrick did so. It included in its submission reports from three archaeologists, Dr Colin Pardoe, Dr Johan Kamminga and Dr Frederick Allen, and also an anthropological report written by Emeritus Professor Richard Wright. These reports disputed the rarity and significance of many of the artefacts identified by Dr Shawcross and Mr Johnston but, for the most part, they did not dispute their Aboriginal origin. Mr Williams’ application was assessed by an officer in the Minister’s Department, Dr Barry Reville. He submitted a Minute to the Minister dated 4 December 2002 in which he discussed the issues and evidence. He did not make a substantive recommendation but he indicated the procedure the Minister ought to take if he decided to make, or alternatively decided not to make, a declaration under s 9 of the Act. On 9 December 2002 the Minister noted on the Minute his decision not to make a declaration.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

WILCOX J
Notwithstanding the difference between the language used by Lord Diplock and that of Sheppard J, it is not enough, either in the United Kingdom or Australia, that the judge disagrees with the decision under review. In Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; ex parte Eshetu [1999] HCA 21; 197 CLR 611 at para 137, Gummow J said:“… where the criterion of which the authority is required to be satisfied turns upon factual matters upon which reasonable minds could reasonably differ, it will be very difficult to show that no reasonable decision‑maker could have arrived at the decision in question. It may be otherwise if the evidence which establishes or denies, or, with other matters, goes to establish or to deny, that the necessary criterion has been met was all one way.”Conclusions In para 17 above, I set out the critical part (paras 24 and 25) of the Minister’s statement of reasons. As mentioned, Mr Oshlack criticised the opening and closing sentences of para 24. He asserted it was incorrect for the Minister to say, first, that “[m]ost of the evidence relating to significance in Mr William’s application did not relate to the specified area, but rather the broader Lake Cowal area” and, second, that it was not clear whether the assertions of significance related to the specified area. The first sentence in para 24 might puzzle anyone who had read the evidence put by Mr Williams before the Minister. That evidence fell into two categories. First, there was evidence about the significance of Lake Cowal, considered as a whole. This involved the Dreaming story of the Rainbow Snake, the reputed massacre (the exact location of which is apparently unknown) and the significance of the lake as a traditional ceremonial site and source of food. It was certainly correct for the Minister to regard this evidence as relating to “the broader Lake Cowal area”, but it seems also to have related to the specified area, as part of the whole. The second category of evidence, which was preponderant in terms of volume, was archaeological evidence. Overwhelmingly, the identified archaeological sites and artefacts were within the specified area. The probable reason for this is that the proposal for a mining lease had caused this area to be subjected to particular scrutiny. Whatever the reason, there is no doubt that, in terms of volume, the bulk of Mr Williams’ material (and Barrick’s response to it) concerns the specified area, rather than the broader Lake Cowal area. Notwithstanding my reaction to the first sentence of para 24, I am not able to find it a source of invalidity. The sentence expresses a judgment by the Minister about the evidence. It was for the Minister to determine the facts relevant to his decision. That task necessarily required him to evaluate the evidence, including by making qualitative judgments about it. If I were to substitute my view for that of the Minister, in relation to that matter, I would commit the error that Spigelman CJ warned against in Bruce v Cole.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: WILCOX J

Full text does not contain this section.