Street v State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Street v State of Western Australia [2024] FCA 1368  

File number(s): WAD 237 of 2020
Judgment of: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 29 October 2024
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application for court approval of settlement under s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – claim by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander workers in respect of wages earned but not paid between 1936 and 1972 – relevant principles in relation to settlement approval – key terms of proposed settlement – whether the settlement amount is fair and reasonable – whether proposed deductions are fair and reasonable – consideration of objections to the settlement – deductions from legal costs and funding commission necessary – common fund order made – settlement approved
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 33V, 33ZB, 33ZF

Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) s 9

Federal Court Rules2011 (Cth) Div 9.2, r 26.12

Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW) s 174

Limitation Act 1935 (WA) ss 38, 47

Native Administration Act 1905-1936 (WA)

Native Welfare Act 1905-1954 (WA)

Native Welfare Act 1963 (WA)

Slave Trade Act 1843 (Imp)

Cases cited:

Allen & Anor v G8 Education Ltd (No 4) [2024] VSC 487

Augusta Pool 1 UK Ltd v Williamson [2023] NSWCA 93; 111 NSWLR 378

Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon [1991] NSWCA 19; 22 NSWLR 1

Blairgowrie Trading Ltd v Allco Finance Group Ltd (Recs & Mgrs Apptd) (In Liq) (No 3) [2017] FCA 330; 343 ALR 476

BMW Australia Ltd v Brewster [2019] HCA 45; 269 CLR 574

Bolitho v Banksia Securities Ltd (No 18) (remitter) [2021] VSC 666; 69 VR 28

Bradshaw v BSA Limited (No 2) [2022] FCA 1440

Caason Investments Pty Limited v Cao (No 2) [2018] FCA 527

Camilleri v The Trust Company (Nominees) Ltd [2015] FCA 1468

Carkeek v Aubrey F Crawley & Co [2024] NSWSC 86

Carnie v Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd [1995] HCA 9; 182 CLR 398

Chocolate Factory Apartments v Westpoint Finance [2005] NSWSC 784

Collard v State of Western Australia (No 4) [2013] WASC 455; 47 WAR 1

Court v Spotless Group Holdings Ltd [2020] FCA 1730

Darwalla Milling Co Ltd v F Hoffman-La Roche (No 2) [2006] FCA 1388; 236 ALR 322

Downie v Spiral Foods Pty Ltd [2015] VSC 190

Dyczynski v Gibson [2020] FCAFC 120; 280 FCR 583

Earglow Pty Ltd v Newcrest Mining Limited [2016] FCA 1433

Elliott-Carde v McDonald’s Australia Ltd [2023] FCAFC 162; 301 FCR 1

Endeavour River Pty Ltd v MG Responsible Entity Ltd [2019] FCA 1719

Galactic Seven Eleven Litigation Holdings LLC v Davaria [2024] FCAFC 54; 302 FCR 493

Ghee v BT Funds Management Ltd [2023] FCA 1553

Greentree v Jaguar Land Rover Australia Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 1209

HFPS Pty Ltd (Trustee) v Tamaya Resources Ltd (In Liq) (No 3) [2017] FCA 650

In re General Motors Corp Pick-Up Truck Fuel Tank Products Liability Litigation, 55 F.3d…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Street v State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 1368
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Street v State of Western Australia, the Federal Court was tasked with approving a settlement between Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander workers and the State of Western Australia. The dispute centered around unpaid wages earned between 1936 and 1972 by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander workers who were subject to discriminatory legislation and practices during that period. The proposed settlement sought approval under section 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), encompassing various legal and procedural issues, including the fairness and reasonableness of the settlement amount and the proposed deductions from legal costs and funding commission.

The court was required to determine whether the settlement amount was fair and reasonable, taking into account the historical context and the nature of the claims. Additionally, the court had to assess the fairness of proposed deductions from legal costs and funding commission, as well as consider any objections raised by the parties involved. The decision involved a detailed analysis of the evidence provided by the applicants and the State, as well as the submissions from the parties and the intervener, Shine.

After careful consideration of the evidence and submissions, the court concluded that the proposed settlement was fair and reasonable. The settlement was structured to ensure that after the funding commission was reimbursed, the remaining amount would be distributed among the class members, with priority given to the applicant's actual costs. The court also found that the deductions from legal costs and funding commission were necessary and appropriate. The settlement was structured such that the quantum of the settlement fund amount depended on the number of participating class members, with a preliminary estimate suggesting there would be around 8,750 eligible claimants. Based on this estimate, the settlement sum was determined to be $159.775 million, comprising the settlement fund amount and the agreed costs component.

In summary, the court approved the settlement, acknowledging the historical injustices and the importance of compensating the affected workers. The court emphasized that the proceeding was not about compensating for the cruel treatment endured by the Aboriginal people but rather about rectifying the financial injustice of unpaid wages. The settlement was deemed a fair and reasonable resolution of the claims, and the court's approval was granted accordingly.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I now turn to consider the proposed settlement in detail. I thank the parties for their detailed submissions, upon which I have directly drawn at various points.2. THE EVIDENCE The applicant relied upon affidavits of:(a)Ms Vicki Antzoulatos, a solicitor employed by Shine with the conduct of the proceeding for the applicant, filed 8 October 2024 (First Antzoulatos Affidavit), 22 October 2024 (Second Antzoulatos Affidavit), 25 October 2024 (Third Antzoulatos Affidavit), 28 October 2024 (Fourth Antzoulatos Affidavit), 29 October 2024 (Fifth Antzoulatos Affidavit) and 29 October 2024 (Sixth Antzoulatos Affidavit); and(b)Ms Sarah Thomson, a solicitor employed by Shine, filed 13 November 2024. The applicant filed written submissions dated 8 October 2024, supplementary submissions dated 25 October 2024, and further written submissions on 7 November 2024. The State relied upon affidavits of Mr Daniel Gorman, a solicitor employed in the State Solicitor’s Office with the conduct of the proceeding for the State, filed 14 June 2024 (First Gorman Affidavit), 22 October 2024 (Second Gorman Affidavit) and 25 October 2024 (Third Gorman Affidavit). The State filed written submissions dated 22 October 2024, and further written submissions dated 27 October 2024. The Funder relied upon affidavits of Mr Stephen Conrad, an executive officer of the Funder, filed 10 October 2024 (First Conrad Affidavit) and 24 October 2024 (Second Conrad Affidavit), and the First Antzoulatos Affidavit. The Funder filed written submissions dated 10 October 2024, submissions in reply dated 24 October 2024, and further submissions on 1 November 2024. Shine was given leave to intervene. It filed written submissions dated 22 October 2024.3. THE CLASS The class members to whom this proceeding relates are persons who:(a)are Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander persons who lived in Western Australia during all or part of the period from 11 December 1936 to 9 June 1972; (b)during all or part of the claim period were a “native” as defined by:(i)s 2 of the Native Administration Act 1905-1936 (WA) (as amended from time to time in the claim period) (the 1936 Act), including by the Native Welfare Act 1905-1954 (WA) (the 1954 Act); and/or (ii)s 4 of the Native Welfare Act 1963 (WA) (as amended) (the 1963 Act); and(c)during all or part of the claim period worked in Western Australia at a time when they were a “Controlled Native” or had their property controlled under the 1936 Act, the 1954 Act or the 1963 Act (collectively, the Control Acts), all persons meeting sub-paragraphs (a) to (c) being a Working Controlled Aboriginal, and if a Working Controlled Aboriginal has died (Deceased Working Controlled Aboriginal), then any legal personal representative or beneficiary of the estate of the Deceased Working Controlled Aboriginal who has the capacity to claim on behalf of that estate. Any person who has a right (equitable or otherwise) in respect of the administration of, or property forming part of, the estate of the Deceased Working Controlled Aboriginal is also a class member. 3.1 The Class Member Registration Process

Decision

Reasons for decision

Taking all of this into account, in my view it is “just” that the priority of payment as between the Funder and Shine be such that after the Funder has been reimbursed its Project Costs, Shine receive what is left of the ACC in part payment of the Applicant’s Actual Costs, and thereafter as provided in the SDS, from each tranche, Shine be paid the Applicant’s Actual Costs and any Transitional Allowance in an equal amount to that which the Funder is paid its funding commission, and at the same times, until the Applicant’s Actual Costs are paid in full. The amount due to Shine for the Applicant’s Actual Costs is substantially less than the amount due to the Funder for its commission, so Shine will be paid out before the Funder is paid out. CONCLUSION The Court has provided the parties with draft orders to reflect these reasons. The parties should confer and provide any suggested changes, but reflecting these reasons, within 7 days.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The proposed settlement is structured such that the quantum of the Settlement Fund Amount depends upon the number of participating class members (defined as “Original Eligible Claimants”):(a)an Original Eligible Claimant (OEC) is:(i)a class member who registered during the Court-ordered class member registration process (Registration Process);(ii)who is alive, or if deceased there exists at least one “Descendant Eligible Claimant” who is eligible for a payment under the SDS; and(iii)who the Court-appointed Administrator of the SDS is independently reasonably satisfied meets the criteria for eligibility under the Scheme on the basis of credible and cogent evidence (with minimum evidence as specified), including as to identification as an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander, having a date of birth before 9 June 1962, provision of a statement that the person was employed by at least one nominated workplace in Western Australia which existed at the relevant time and were paid no or nominal wages during the claim period, and the provision of information allowing payment of an entitlement under the Scheme to be made;(b)a Descendant Eligible Claimant (DEC) is:(i)a class member who is the living spouse or child of a deceased OEC who registered during the Registration Process; and(ii)who the Administrator is reasonably satisfied meets the criteria for eligibility under the SDS. Orders were made on 14 and 20 November 2023 providing for class members to be given notice of the proposed settlement, and for the conduct of a substantial physical outreach program to Aboriginal communities throughout Western Australia, including in remote locations, so that class members were informed of the requirement to register if they wished to be eligible for a payment under the SDS, and to assist them to register. The Registration Process was reasonably effective. Although the number of OECs is presently unknown, and the final decision as to eligibility rests with the Administrator under the SDS, the solicitors for the parties have engaged in a process to preliminarily assess the registrations received to date. The parties agree that there are likely to be circa 8,000 to 9,500 OECs once all eligible registrations have been determined by the Administrator (including all late registrations). In my view it is appropriate to assess the fairness of the proposed settlement by reference to the middle of that range, being 8,750 OECs. On the assumption that there are 8,750 OECs, the Settlement Sum will be $159.775 million, comprising the following payments:(a)the Settlement Fund Amount of $144.375 million (representing 8,750 OECs multiplied by $16,500 per OEC), to be paid by the State in tranches as the Administrator accepts the eligibility of OECs; and(b)the Agreed Costs Component (ACC) of $15.4 million, to be paid by the State upon expiry of the time for appeal from the settlement approval orders. It is important to understand that the proceeding does not relate to the discriminatory and cruel way Aboriginal people were often treated during this appalling period of our history; it is concerned with the fact that many were not paid either properly or at all for their work. In the course of the proceeding the Court heard evidence from many Aboriginal people who were taken away from their families at a young age, placed into an institution run by the State or a church, where they were then required to work for no pay. Many of the children suffered inestimable grief and trauma by being forcibly removed from their families, and many were cruelly treated within the institutions and discriminated against. Many suffered lifelong psychological scars as a result. As is often the case with people, some managed to rise through the discrimination and trauma they were forced to endure and went on to have reasonably happy and productive lives. Others, through no fault of their own, were brought down by the way they were treated and their lives were blighted by it. The stories that I heard will stay with me forever, and I am deeply sorry that First Nations people were so disgracefully treated. The proposed settlement does not attempt to compensate Aboriginal people for the shameful way they were treated.