McDonald v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

McDonald v Commonwealth of Australia [2025] FCA 380  

File number: VID 312 of 2021
Judgment of: MORTIMER CJ
Date of judgment: 17 April 2025
Catchwords:

REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application for court approval of settlement under s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – claim for non-payment or under-payment of wages to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander workers in the Northern Territory between 1933 and 1971 – whether the settlement is fair and reasonable – whether proposed deductions are fair and reasonable – deductions for legal costs and funding commission – priority of payments – directions to the administrator – settlement approved

ABORIGINAL AND TORRES STRAIT ISLANDER PEOPLES – outreach program – remote communities – best practice principles for law firms operating outside the communities in which their clients are living – expertise and use of locally experienced cultural advisers, interpreters, community engagement staff or community development staff

Legislation:

Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth) s 46PO

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 23, 33V, 33ZC, 33ZF, 37P, 37AF, 37AH, 37AG, 37AI, 37AG, 54A

Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) s 9

Slavery Abolition Act 1833 (Imp) (3 & 4 Will IV c 73)

Administration and Probate Act 1969 (NT)

Cases cited:

Arthur (Litigation Representative) v Northern Territory of Australia (No 2) [2020] FCA 215

Asirifi-Otchere v Swann Insurance (Aust) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2020] FCA 1885; 385 ALR 625

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Richards [2013] FCAFC 89

Bellamy’s Australia Ltd v Basil [2019] FCAFC 147

Blairgowrie Trading Ltd v Allco Finance Group Ltd (Receivers & Managers Appointed) (In Liq) (No 3) [2017] FCA 330

Bolitho v Banksia Securities Ltd (No 18) [2021] VSC 666

Bradshaw v BSA Ltd (No 2) [2022] FCA 1440

Bushby (by his litigation representative Webling) v State of Victoria (Department of Education and Training) (No 2) [2023] FCA 340

Butler v Djerriwarrh Employment & Education Services Inc [2015] FCA 296

Caason Investments Pty Ltd v Cao (No 2) [2018] FCA 527

Camilleri v The Trust Company (Nominees) Ltd [2015] FCA 1468

Court v Spotless Group Holdings Limited [2020] FCA 1730

Darwalla Milling Co Pty Ltd v F Hoffman-La Roche Ltd (No 2) [2006] FCA 1388; (2006) 236 ALR 322

Eckardt v Sims Ltd [2022] FCA 1609

Elliott-Carde v McDonald's Australia Ltd [2023] FCAFC 162

Ellis v Commonwealth of Australia [2023] NSWSC 550; 411 ALR 578

Fordham v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2023] FCA 1106

Galactic Seven Eleven Litigation Holdings LLC v Davaria [2024] FCAFC 54

Ghee v BT Funds Management Ltd [2023] FCA 1553

Gill v Ethicon Sàrl (No 11) [2023] FCA 229

Iddles v Fonterra Aust Pty Ltd [2023] VSC 566

Ingram as trustee for the Ingram Superannuation Fund v Ardent Leisure Ltd (Settlement Approval) [2024] FCA 836

Jeffriess v Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd (No 2) [2023] FCA 911

Jenkings v Northern Territory of Australia (No 5) [2021] FCA 1585

Klemweb Nominees Pty Ltd (as trustee for the Klemweb Superannuation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McDonald v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 380
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In McDonald v Commonwealth of Australia, the Federal Court of Australia was called upon to approve a settlement of a representative proceeding concerning the non-payment or under-payment of wages to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander workers in the Northern Territory between 1933 and 1971. The case involved numerous legal issues, including whether the settlement was fair and reasonable, whether proposed deductions were justifiable, and the appropriate priority of payments. The court also had to consider the outreach program for notifying potential claimants, ensuring best practice principles were followed, including the use of culturally appropriate advisers and interpreters.

The court's reasoning centred on evaluating the fairness of the settlement sum, the reasonableness of proposed deductions for legal costs and funding commissions, and the necessity of the outreach program to effectively notify potential claimants. The court emphasised the importance of ensuring that the settlement was both fair and reasonable for the affected group members and that the outreach program adhered to best practice principles. The court approved the settlement, noting the shameful historical context of the alleged exploitation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander workers. The court also directed the parties to address any potential miscalculations in the settlement figures and to propose a joint solution.

The final orders included approval of the settlement sum of up to $180 million, reimbursement payments to certain individuals, and a cap on the funder's commission. The court also authorised interim payments to living eligible claimants and set out a process for determining future legal costs. Additionally, the court fixed the registration date for claimants and outlined the steps for the outreach program, including dissemination through various communication channels and languages. The court further directed the parties to address any miscalculations in the settlement figures and to propose a joint solution, with mediation as a fallback option.

Orders

Orders of the court

Ms Harris’ report

1. Pursuant to r 28.67(1)(b) read with r 1.40 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), Ms Harris is to provide an explanation by way of a further report on the matters raised in these reasons concerning possible miscalculations in her report dated 28 November 2024.

2. The further report is to be provided to the Court, the parties and interveners on or before 4pm on 5 May 2025.

3. On or before 15 May 2025, and having conferred, the parties and Shine Lawyers are to file a joint proposal for the Court’s consideration addressing the issues identified by the Court and Ms Harris’ explanation in her further report.

4. In the event that the parties and Shine Lawyers are unable to agree on a joint proposal, the issue will be referred to mediation before National Judicial Registrar Colbran, such mediation to be completed before 21 May 2025.

Proposed orders

5. The parties and interveners are to confer in relation to the proposed orders provided to them by the Court by email on 17 April 2025.

6. By 4pm on 26 May 2025 the parties and interveners are to notify the Court of any changes to the proposed orders that are consistent with the Court’s reasons for judgment, but which in their view are necessary or appropriate.

7. The notification is to be by way of a single submission filed on behalf of the parties and the interveners, together with a set of proposed amended orders.

Suppression orders

8. By 4pm on 6 May 2025, the parties and/or interveners are to file and serve any application or applications, together with any supporting evidence, for any orders to be made pursuant to s 37AF of the Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth), to replace the interim suppression orders.

9. If the parties and/or interveners propose to apply for any replacement suppression orders, the Court will list the application(s) for hearing, and will take such steps as it considers appropriate to ensure adequate public notification of any such application(s).

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Court provides a summary accompanying the publication of these reasons. The summary does not represent the Court’s reasoning, but is given as a way of making the Court’s reasoning more accessible.BACKGROUND In this section I set out a brief outline of the claim and the progress of the proceeding to the settlement that was reached, together with the process then adopted by the Court. These reasons do not contain many references to the significant evidence already filed in this proceeding, both from Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander workers and their families, and from a range of experts, and which the Court considers should be preserved in some way: see [598]–[600] below. The Commonwealth had access to all this material before it decided to agree to settle the proceeding. Because the matter has settled the Court is not making any findings of fact about what happened to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander workers during the claim period. However, on any view of the pleadings and the filed material the narrative of the claimed experiences of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in the Northern Territory casts a shameful shadow on the actions of government, government officials and other historic participants in the alleged exploitation of the labour of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. The Commonwealth properly recognised this in the statements its senior counsel made in open court during the first settlement approval hearing: see [588] below.A brief outline of the claim Ms McDonald was born in around 1938 and grew up at Lake Nash Station, which is located in the Northern Territory near the Queensland border, in the southern part of the Barkly Tablelands. She worked at Georgina Downs and then at Argadargada Stations as a domestic servant from around the age of 14. In summary, Ms McDonald says that she, and other Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander workers in the Northern Territory over the claim period were not paid properly for their labour, that labour often being performed in bad conditions. She claims that she, and other workers, were sometimes underpaid. She claims that she, and other workers, were sometimes only paid “keep” and no wages at all. She claims sometimes wages were not paid to the workers, but to government officials who were supposed to look after the wages and distribute them. She claims the government officials at the time, including people such as the Director of Native Affairs, did not look after the workers’ wages as they should have. Ms McDonald alleges that, at various times during the claim period, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander workers were subject to the Aboriginal Ordinance 1918-1933 (NT), the Welfare Ordinance 1953-1955 (NT) and the Wards Employment Ordinance 1953-1959 (NT). I will refer to these collectively as the Ordinances. Ms McDonald claims that the Ordinances authorised the Commonwealth to hold the money of some workers on trust for them in some cases and some workers did not get their money from those trusts.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Commonwealth contends that none of the causes of action can succeed. In its written submissions on the settlement approval application, the Commonwealth explained why this was so in considerable detail. Where necessary, I set out some of those explanations below.The taking of evidence by the Court in July 2023 A feature of this proceeding, as with Street and Pearson v State of Queensland (No 2) [2020] FCA 619 (QUD 714 of 2016), is that many of the people who worked on stations, missions or in other institutions and settlements during the claim period have passed away. Others are alive, but a number are in poor health and in any event almost all are of advanced age, especially taking into account the difference in life expectancy in Australia between Aboriginal people and non-Aboriginal people. The applicant sought, and the Court agreed, to the taking of evidence from a group of Aboriginal people ahead of the time when evidence would usually be taken. This is known as “preservation evidence”: evidence that the Court hears, where a witness might or might not be cross-examined by other legal representatives of other parties, and which is recorded and in that sense “preserved” for any future trial. The witnesses whose evidence was taken by the Court in this proceeding in July 2023, and preserved, were:(a)Ms McDonald;(b)J Stuart;(c)Alan Drover;(d)Veronica Dobson;(e)Bessie Parsons;(f)Lilly Stafford;(g)Daniel Forrester;(h)Kennedy Ricky;(i)Billy Grant;(j)Henry Bob;(k)Frank Holmes;(l)Peter Parlow;(m)Mary Allum;(n)Maisie Smith;(o)Brian Freddie;(p)Linda Turner;(q)J Anzac;(r)Susan Nurra;(s)Marie Allen;(t)Maybelle Terese Bourke;(u)C Nixon;(v)Sister Barbara Tippolay; and(w)Nora Sullivan. The witnesses worked at various stations, missions or in other institutions and settlements across a wide geographic area. Uncertainty attended the precise ages of many witnesses, but the majority were likely in their seventies or eighties. Since then, sadly, and on the information available to the Court, J Stuart, J Anzac and C Nixon have passed away. The preservation evidence was given before a different judge, Murphy J. At that time, Murphy J was the judge allocated to this proceeding. On 24 April 2024, the parties were informed that the proceeding had been reallocated to Mortimer CJ. While the reason for the re-allocation was not given at the time, the reason related to the statutory retirement of Murphy J in 2026, and the challenges that would have posed for the completion of a long and complex contested trial scheduled to run over 2025, and the finalisation of a judgment.The settlement approval application On 3 September 2024, and after intensive mediation efforts over a period of time, the parties conclusively agreed to resolve the proceeding and executed the Deed. By way of interlocutory application dated 5 September 2024, the applicant sought, amongst other things, approval of the form and contents of a notice to group members about the proposed settlement, including a pre-approval outreach program. On 16 September 2024, the Court made orders approving the notice to group members about the proposed settlement, as well as a range of additional orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As I reiterate in these reasons below, Ms Harris’ report was completed under considerable time pressure. The Court intends no criticism whatsoever of Ms Harris by reason of the clarifications sought in the preceding paragraphs. A SUMMARY OF THE COURT’S DECISIONS IN APPROVING THE SETTLEMENT In this section, I provide a summary of what the Court has approved for deductions relevant to Shine’s legal costs, the funder’s commission and other costs. I also provide a summary of my approach on priority of payments. In doing so I am using the defined terms used in the Deed, which I explain below. The figures below are based on the Court’s current calculations, without any conclusions as to the possible miscalculations referred to above, and subject to further submissions on the matters outlined in the orders accompanying these reasons.Overall approval The settlement sum of up to $180,000,000 has been approved. By orders of 14 November 2024, the Court did not approve a differentiation order of the kind set out in cl 1.1 of the Deed. Deductions relevant to group members By orders of 14 November 2024, the reimbursement payments totalling $165,000 were approved to those named in that order. By orders on 20 December 2024, Interim Payments of $10,000 to living eligible claimants were also authorised.Deductions relevant to the funder The funder’s commission of 20% of the net settlement sum will be capped at 8,750 eligible claimants. This is approved as a deduction from the settlement fund. That means the funder is approved to receive 20% of up to $157,500,000 being a commission cap of $31,500,000. The ATE premiums of $1,045,000 are approved as deductions from the settlement fund.Deductions relevant to Shine’s legal costs The Applicant’s Agreed Costs to 17 December 2024 are approved at $11,737,499.40 (GST inclusive). There is a direction to Shine to reimburse the funder in the amount of $9,738,386.63 within 7 days of receipt of the funds described at [92]. The Applicant’s Actual Costs to 17 December 2024 are approved as a deduction from the settlement fund in the amount of $1,872,829.10 (GST inclusive). The amount of $544,160.70 (GST inclusive) is approved as a deduction from the settlement fund on account of uplift. The total amount for the Applicant’s Actual Costs to 17 December 2024 inclusive of uplift is $2,416,989.80 (GST inclusive). The legal costs of the applicant from 18 December 2024 are to be assessed by Ms Harris in accordance with the proposed orders. Broadly, the proposed orders follow the process set out in the Deed. Ms Harris is to report on the costs she considers are recoverable on a solicitor/client basis and on a party/party basis. In respect of the party/party costs and whatever amount remains of the agreed sum of $15 million for the Applicant’s Agreed Costs, the applicant and Commonwealth are authorised to agree on those costs, and if agreed they can be paid without Court order. If agreement cannot be reached, the parties may approach the Court and the Court will make a determination of the amount payable. This will not occur until after the Registration Date.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Deed provides that the Registration Date is the day after the expiration of six months after the date of settlement approval or such later date as approved by the Court. By orders made on 16 September 2024, the Registration Date was fixed by the Court, by consent, as 31 August 2025. In other words, group members must have registered by 31 August 2025, subject to any extension or exceptions granted by the Court. Ms Antzoulatos is the solicitor on the record for the applicant. She provided several affidavits for the purposes of the settlement approval process. Her evidence is that she expects, based on her experiences in Street, for “the bulk” of registrations to occur after the settlement approval hearings and when the outreach program to a range of communities in the Northern Territory is conducted. In the Deed and Scheme is the term “Registration Process”, which includes the outreach program but goes beyond it. The term includes the obligations of the applicant, through Shine, for obtaining and processing registration forms (including those gathered earlier in the proceeding), processes for maintaining a register of potential eligible claimants, providing information on potential eligible claimants to the Commonwealth and requiring registration forms to be received by Shine before the Registration Date (with some limited exceptions set out in cl 14 of the Scheme). The Scheme requires the applicant, by Shine, to use reasonable endeavours during the registration process up to the Registration Date to seek registrations. In their submissions to the Court the parties used a number of terms including “outreach program” and “registration process”, which are the terms I have used in these reasons. I describe the outreach program in more detail at [42]–[43] below. Ms Antzoulatos explains that registrants will generally fall into one of two categories:(a)Living persons who worked in the Claim Period. These persons will also (1) generally be making claims in respect of their parents, because most Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people who themselves worked in [the] Northern Territory between 1933 and 1971 will also have had parents who also worked during that time; and (2) sometimes be making claims in respect of a deceased spouse who worked in the Claim Period. They will therefore be registering at least three claims (some of which are likely to be shared).(b)Children of persons who worked in the Claim Period but who did not themselves work in the Claim Period. Because , she deposes, most Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people alive during the Claim Period worked (or are assumed to have worked), their children will generally be registering two claims (but these will be shared between all children). Ms Antzoulatos’ evidence is that the settlement notice approved by the Court by orders made on 16 September 2024 and information regarding the registration and outreach program and pre-approval program will be disseminated by:(a)email, post and text message communication to group members who had previously registered with Shine Lawyers to advise of the pre-approval and outreach sessions;(b)written communications with stakeholder organisations and telephone communication with each Land Council, Peak Organisation and Local Government listed in Annexure F of the 16 September 2024 orders;(c)posting the settlement notices on Shine’s website;(d)publication of the advertisement approved by the Court in the Centralian Today, the Katherine Times, the Sunday Territorian, the NT News, the NT News Realestate and the Australian Financial Review;(e)publishing the settlement notice on Facebook, Instagram, Tik Tok and LinkedIn; and(f)radio announcements interpreted into five languages – Arrernte, Warlpiri, Kriol, Yolngu Matha and Tiwi.