FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
McDonald v Commonwealth of Australia [2025] FCA 380
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read McDonald v Commonwealth of Australia and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] FCA 380
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court's reasoning centred on evaluating the fairness of the settlement sum, the reasonableness of proposed deductions for legal costs and funding commissions, and the necessity of the outreach program to effectively notify potential claimants. The court emphasised the importance of ensuring that the settlement was both fair and reasonable for the affected group members and that the outreach program adhered to best practice principles. The court approved the settlement, noting the shameful historical context of the alleged exploitation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander workers. The court also directed the parties to address any potential miscalculations in the settlement figures and to propose a joint solution.
The final orders included approval of the settlement sum of up to $180 million, reimbursement payments to certain individuals, and a cap on the funder's commission. The court also authorised interim payments to living eligible claimants and set out a process for determining future legal costs. Additionally, the court fixed the registration date for claimants and outlined the steps for the outreach program, including dissemination through various communication channels and languages. The court further directed the parties to address any miscalculations in the settlement figures and to propose a joint solution, with mediation as a fallback option.
Orders
Orders of the court
Ms Harris’ report
1. Pursuant to r 28.67(1)(b) read with r 1.40 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), Ms Harris is to provide an explanation by way of a further report on the matters raised in these reasons concerning possible miscalculations in her report dated 28 November 2024.
2. The further report is to be provided to the Court, the parties and interveners on or before 4pm on 5 May 2025.
3. On or before 15 May 2025, and having conferred, the parties and Shine Lawyers are to file a joint proposal for the Court’s consideration addressing the issues identified by the Court and Ms Harris’ explanation in her further report.
4. In the event that the parties and Shine Lawyers are unable to agree on a joint proposal, the issue will be referred to mediation before National Judicial Registrar Colbran, such mediation to be completed before 21 May 2025.
Proposed orders
5. The parties and interveners are to confer in relation to the proposed orders provided to them by the Court by email on 17 April 2025.
6. By 4pm on 26 May 2025 the parties and interveners are to notify the Court of any changes to the proposed orders that are consistent with the Court’s reasons for judgment, but which in their view are necessary or appropriate.
7. The notification is to be by way of a single submission filed on behalf of the parties and the interveners, together with a set of proposed amended orders.
Suppression orders
8. By 4pm on 6 May 2025, the parties and/or interveners are to file and serve any application or applications, together with any supporting evidence, for any orders to be made pursuant to s 37AF of the Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth), to replace the interim suppression orders.
9. If the parties and/or interveners propose to apply for any replacement suppression orders, the Court will list the application(s) for hearing, and will take such steps as it considers appropriate to ensure adequate public notification of any such application(s).
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Deed provides that the Registration Date is the day after the expiration of six months after the date of settlement approval or such later date as approved by the Court. By orders made on 16 September 2024, the Registration Date was fixed by the Court, by consent, as 31 August 2025. In other words, group members must have registered by 31 August 2025, subject to any extension or exceptions granted by the Court. Ms Antzoulatos is the solicitor on the record for the applicant. She provided several affidavits for the purposes of the settlement approval process. Her evidence is that she expects, based on her experiences in Street, for “the bulk” of registrations to occur after the settlement approval hearings and when the outreach program to a range of communities in the Northern Territory is conducted. In the Deed and Scheme is the term “Registration Process”, which includes the outreach program but goes beyond it. The term includes the obligations of the applicant, through Shine, for obtaining and processing registration forms (including those gathered earlier in the proceeding), processes for maintaining a register of potential eligible claimants, providing information on potential eligible claimants to the Commonwealth and requiring registration forms to be received by Shine before the Registration Date (with some limited exceptions set out in cl 14 of the Scheme). The Scheme requires the applicant, by Shine, to use reasonable endeavours during the registration process up to the Registration Date to seek registrations. In their submissions to the Court the parties used a number of terms including “outreach program” and “registration process”, which are the terms I have used in these reasons. I describe the outreach program in more detail at [42]–[43] below. Ms Antzoulatos explains that registrants will generally fall into one of two categories:(a)Living persons who worked in the Claim Period. These persons will also (1) generally be making claims in respect of their parents, because most Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people who themselves worked in [the] Northern Territory between 1933 and 1971 will also have had parents who also worked during that time; and (2) sometimes be making claims in respect of a deceased spouse who worked in the Claim Period. They will therefore be registering at least three claims (some of which are likely to be shared).(b)Children of persons who worked in the Claim Period but who did not themselves work in the Claim Period. Because , she deposes, most Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people alive during the Claim Period worked (or are assumed to have worked), their children will generally be registering two claims (but these will be shared between all children). Ms Antzoulatos’ evidence is that the settlement notice approved by the Court by orders made on 16 September 2024 and information regarding the registration and outreach program and pre-approval program will be disseminated by:(a)email, post and text message communication to group members who had previously registered with Shine Lawyers to advise of the pre-approval and outreach sessions;(b)written communications with stakeholder organisations and telephone communication with each Land Council, Peak Organisation and Local Government listed in Annexure F of the 16 September 2024 orders;(c)posting the settlement notices on Shine’s website;(d)publication of the advertisement approved by the Court in the Centralian Today, the Katherine Times, the Sunday Territorian, the NT News, the NT News Realestate and the Australian Financial Review;(e)publishing the settlement notice on Facebook, Instagram, Tik Tok and LinkedIn; and(f)radio announcements interpreted into five languages – Arrernte, Warlpiri, Kriol, Yolngu Matha and Tiwi.