Court v Spotless Group Holdings Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

Federal Court of Australia

Court v Spotless Group Holdings Limited [2020] FCA 1730

File number: VID 561 of 2017
Judgment of: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 9 September 2020
Date of publication of reasons: 30 November 2020
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application for Court approval of settlement under s 33V(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – whether the proposed settlement is fair and reasonable – where Costs Referee appointed – whether Court has power to order payment of a litigation funding commission as a percentage of gross settlement sum – whether the funding rate is fair and reasonable – application for a reimbursement payment to the applicant – settlement approved with reductions in the quantum of the funders’ disbursements
Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) ss 12DA, 12GF; ss 18, 236 of the Australian Consumer Law, being Schedule 2

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 674, 1041I, 1317HA

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 22, 23, 33V, 33Z, 33ZB, 33ZF, 37AG(1), 173, 177

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) ss 173, 177, 179, 183

Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (Vic) s 172(1) of the Legal Profession Uniform Law, being Schedule 1

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 2.43(1), 28.67

Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Richards [2013] FCAFC 89

Blairgowrie Trading Ltd v Allco Finance Group Ltd (Recs & Mgrs Apptd) (In Liq) (No 3) [2017] FCA 330; (2017) 343 ALR 476

BMW Australia Ltd v Brewster [2019] HCA 45; (2019) 374 ALR 627

Brewster v BMW Australia Ltd [2020] NSWCA 272

Caason Investments Pty Ltd v Cao (No 2) [2018] FCA 527

Camilleri v The Trust Company (Nominees) Ltd [2015] FCA 1468

Campbell’s Cash & Carry Pty Ltd v Fostif Pty Ltd [2006] HCA 41; (2006) 229 CLR 386

Cantor v Audi Australia Pty Ltd (No 5) [2020] FCA 637

Clarke v Sandhurst Trustees Limited(No 2) [2018] FCA 511

Clime Capital Limited v UGL Pty Limited [2020] FCA 66

Darwalla Milling Co Pty Ltd v F Hoffman-La Roche Ltd (No 2) [2006] FCA 1388; (2006) 236 ALR 322

Davaria Pty Ltd v 7-Eleven Stores Pty Ltd [2020] FCAFC 183

Earglow Pty Ltd v Newcrest Mining Limited [2016] FCA 1433

Fisher (as trustee for the Tramik Super Fund Trust) v Vocus Group Ltd (No 2) [2020] FCA 579

Fostif Pty Ltd v Campbells Cash & Carry Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 83; (2005) 63 NSWLR 203

Haselhurst v Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd t/as Toyota Australia [2020] NSWCA 66

Inabu Pty Ltd as trustee for the Alidas Superannuation Fund v CIMIC Group Limited [2020] FCA 510

Kelly v Willmott Forests Ltd (in liquidation) (No 4) [2016] FCA 323; (2016) 335 ALR 439

Kuterba v Sirtex Medical Limited (No 3) [2019] FCA 1374

Lenthall v Westpac Banking Corporation (No 2) [2020] FCA 423; (2020) 144 ACSR 573

Matthews v AusNet Electricity Services Pty Ltd & Ors [2014] VSC 663

McKay Super Solutions Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Court v Spotless Group Holdings Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1730
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Court v Spotless Group Holdings Limited, the Federal Court was called upon to approve a settlement reached between the parties in a representative proceeding. The settlement in question was proposed to resolve a class action brought by Mrs Court against Spotless Group Holdings Limited, with the assistance of litigation funders. The legal issues before the court included the appropriateness of the involvement of the funders in the settlement negotiations, the fairness and reasonableness of the settlement considering that only registered group members would share in the compensation, the court's power to order a payment to the funders, and whether such a payment, if ordered, would be fair and reasonable.

The court found that the proposed settlement was fair and reasonable, taking into account the diligent efforts of Mrs Court as the representative applicant, who had gone beyond the scope of her required responsibilities. The court granted a reimbursement payment of $25,000 to Mrs Court, considering her extensive involvement in the case. Furthermore, the court approved the settlement administration costs, subject to a reduction to reflect the likelihood of minimal review applications from group members. With regard to the litigation funding commission, the court acknowledged the funders' significant involvement in the case from the outset and their substantial financial contribution. The court found that the funders were entitled to a percentage of the settlement sum net of approved legal costs, which was deemed fair and reasonable.

The court made orders approving the settlement terms and the distribution scheme, authorizing the applicant to enter into the settlement, and appointing Slater and Gordon Ltd as the Administrator. The court also approved various costs and disbursements, including the applicant's legal costs and disbursements, the funders' remuneration, and the administration project costs. Additionally, the court addressed the confidentiality of certain documents and the treatment of late registrants in the settlement. Finally, the court granted liberty to the applicant to re-list the proceeding for final orders after the completion of the settlement distribution.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to sections 33V and 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (the Act), settlement of the proceeding upon the terms set out in the Deed of Settlement and the Settlement Distribution Scheme (and any annexures therein) filed by the Applicant (together, the Settlement) be approved.

2. Pursuant to sections 33V and 33ZF of the Act, the Applicant is authorised nunc pro tunc for and on behalf of Group Members to enter into and give effect to the Settlement and the transactions contemplated for and on behalf of Group Members.

3. Pursuant to section 33ZB of the Act, the persons affected and bound by the Settlement are the Applicant, the Respondent and Group Members.

4. Pursuant to sections 33V and 33ZF of the Act, Slater and Gordon Ltd be appointed nunc pro tunc from 18 June 2020 as Administrator of the Settlement Distribution Scheme and is to act in accordance with the Court approved Settlement Distribution Scheme.

5. Pursuant to sections 33V(2), 22 and/or 23 of the Act and the Funding Terms approved by the Court on 8 May 2019:

(a) “Legal Costs and Disbursements”, being legal costs and disbursements of the Applicant on a solicitor and own client basis, including those incurred in connection with the proceeding on her own behalf and on behalf of all Group Members in the proceeding, be approved in the amount $7,856,318;

(b) “Project Costs”, further to the proportion of the Applicant’s Legal Costs and Disbursements paid by the Funders, are approved in the amount of $340,345;

(c) “Funders’ Remuneration”, be approved in the amount $19,500,324, being 22.5% of the settlement sum (net of costs);

(d) the “Applicant’s Reimbursement Payment”, being the Applicant’s reasonable claim for compensation for the time and/or expenses incurred in the interests of prosecuting on behalf of Group Members as a whole be approved in the amount $25,000; and

(e) the “Administration Project Costs”, being costs and disbursements incurred by the Applicant in connection with the administration of the Settlement Distribution Scheme be approved in the amount $211,165, without prejudice to the right of the Administrator to make application to the Court for approval of further “Administration Project Costs”.

6. Pursuant to rule 28.67 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (the Rules):

(a) the report of Catherine May Dealehr dated 21 August 2020; and

(b) the supplementary report of Catherine May Dealehr dated 26 August 2020;

be adopted as varied to allow an uplift of 15% on Slater and Gordon’s conditionally incurred professional fees.

7. Pursuant to section 33ZF of the Act or otherwise, upon the coming into effect of orders 1, 2, 4 and 5 above, each of the undertakings given by:

(a) the Applicant;

(b) Slater and Gordon;

(c) Investor Claim Partner Pty Ltd;

(d) ICP Capital Pty Ltd;

(e) Therium Australia Limited; and

(f) Therium Litigation Finance AF IC,

to each other and to the Court to comply with their obligations under the Funding Terms attached as Annexure A to the orders of the Honourable Justice Murphy made 8 May 2019 be discharged.

8. Pursuant to rule 2.43(1) of the Rules, all amounts paid into Court by or on behalf of the Applicant as security for the Respondent’s costs of the proceeding, and any interest accrued on those amounts, be repaid to the solicitors for the Applicant.

Confidentiality

9. Until further order, pursuant to section 37AG(1)(a) of the Act, on the ground that the order is necessary to prevent prejudice in the proper administration of justice:

(a) the confidential annexures MGC-21 and MGC-33 to the affidavit of Mathew Glen Chuk dated 28 August 2020;

(b) the unredacted confidential annexures MGC-34 and MGC-35 to the affidavit of Mathew Glen Chuk dated 28 August 2020;

(c) the unredacted affidavit of John Walker dated 28 August 2020, and its annexures (Walker Affidavit);

(d) the unredacted affidavit of Neil Andrew Purslow dated 28 August 2020, and its annexures (Purslow Affidavit); and

(e) the passages set out in Annexure A to these orders, being redactions to mask commercially sensitive information in the Walker Affidavit and Purslow Affidavit,

be:

(i) confidential and not be published or made available to any person;

(ii) marked or designated as confidential; and

(iii) held on the Court file in accordance with (i) and (ii) hereof until further order of the Court.

10. The Funders will file forthwith versions of the Walker Affidavit and the Purslow Affidavit in which the passages set out in Annexure A and Annexure B to these orders have been redacted.

11. Pursuant to section 37AG(1)(a) of the Act, on the ground that the order is necessary to prevent prejudice in the proper administration of justice:

(a) the confidential annexures MGC-32, MGC-36, MGC-37 and MGC-39 to the affidavit of Mathew Glen Chuk dated 28 August 2020;

(b) the report of Catherine May Dealehr dated 21 August 2020; and

(c) the supplementary report of Catherine May Dealehr dated 26 August 2020; and

(d) the passages set out in Annexure B to these orders, being redactions to mask information which is sensitive if the litigation is to continue, in the Walker Affidavit and Purslow Affidavit,

be, until the expiry of the appeal period in respect of these Orders or determination of any appeal if filed, or further order:

(i) confidential and not be published or made available to any person;

(ii) marked or designated as confidential;

(iii) held on the Court file in accordance with (i) and (ii) hereof.

12. Upon the expiry of the appeal period in respect of these Orders or determination of any appeal if filed, the Funders will forthwith file versions of the Walker Affidavit and the Purslow Affidavit in which the passages set out in Annexure A to these orders have been redacted.

Late registrants

13. Pursuant to section 33ZF of the Act, the following Group Members are deemed to be Registered Group Members for the purposes of the Deed of Settlement and the Settlement Distribution Scheme and will be treated as if they complied with paragraph 8 of the orders made on 21 February 2020:

(a) L&J Stagoll ATF the Stagoll Super Fund A/C; and

(b) Deborah Jane Evans and James Robert Newton Morey in their capacity as executors of the estates of Daryl Garfield Ritchie, deceased.

Further listing

14. The Applicant has liberty to apply to re-list the proceeding as soon as practicable after completion of the distribution of the Settlement Sum (and must in any event do so no later than thirty days after such completion) so that final orders can be made, including orders that:

(a) the proceeding be dismissed on the basis that the dismissal is a defence and absolute bar to any claim (either directly or indirectly) or proceeding by the Applicant or any Group Member in respect of, or relating to, the subject matter of the proceeding, without prejudice to:

(i) the right of any party to the Deed of Settlement to make an application to enforce the Deed of Settlement in a new proceeding; or

(ii) the right of any Registered Group Member to make application to the Court in accordance with the terms of the Settlement Distribution Scheme; or

(iii) the right of the Administrator of the Settlement Distribution Scheme to refer any issues relating to the Settlement Distribution Scheme to the Court for direction or determination in accordance with the terms of the Settlement Distribution Scheme; and

(b) there be no order as to costs as between the Applicant and the Respondent.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ANNEXURE A

ANNEXURE B

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves an application for approval of a proposed settlement in a class action proceeding against Spotless Group Holdings Limited. The applicant, Mrs Court, initiated the proceeding on behalf of a group of shareholders, alleging breaches of statutory duty and misleading or deceptive conduct. The proceeding was funded by litigation funders, Therium Australia and Investor Claim Partners (collectively referred to as "the Funders"). The proposed settlement includes a Deed of Settlement and a Settlement Distribution Scheme. The key issues addressed in the case relate to the fairness and reasonableness of the proposed settlement, the appropriateness of the involvement of the Funders in the settlement negotiations, the fairness of the proposed litigation funding commission, and a reimbursement payment to the applicant.

The case was initially filed on 25 May 2017. Prior to the settlement approval application, the matter involved various procedural steps, including the filing of originating process, the appointment of a Costs Referee, and negotiations between the parties. The court granted leave to the Funders to be represented in the application for settlement approval. The settlement approval application was heard on 2 September 2020, and the court made orders approving the settlement on 9 September 2020.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I heard the settlement approval application on 2 September 2020. I was well-satisfied that the proposed settlement is fair and reasonable in the interests of group members to bound to it, including as between group members, and I made orders on 9 September 2020 to approve the settlement pursuant to s 33V of the FCA. Some questions arose in relation to:(a)whether it was appropriate for the Funders to have been as closely involved in the settlement negotiations as they were;(b)whether the settlement is fair and reasonable having regard to the fact that only Registered Group Members are permitted to share in the compensation achieved in the settlement but all group members are bound by the release and their rights will thereby be extinguished;(c)whether the Court has power under s 33V(2) of the FCA to order a payment to the Funders in return for the costs and risks they took on in funding the proceeding, so that all group members who benefit from the settlement pay the Funders the same pro rata share of the litigation funding expenses incurred to achieve the settlement; and (d)if the Court does have such power, whether the proposed funding commission is fair and reasonable.I now provide reasons for the orders made.THE EVIDENCE The parties rely upon the following material:(a)two affidavits with annexures of Mathew Glen Chuk, a practice group leader in the class actions practice of Slater & Gordon, the solicitors for the applicant, made 5 June 2020 and 28 August 2020. The relevant annexures include: (i)a confidential joint opinion of counsel dated 28 August 2020 provided by Peter Collinson QC and Melanie Szydzik, senior and junior counsel briefed for the applicant in the proceeding, in relation to the reasonableness of the proposed settlement (Counsel’s Opinion);(ii)a copy of the Slater & Gordon Conditional Legal Costs Agreement offered to group members as at 30 January 2017 (First CLCA);(iii)a copy of the litigation funding agreement offered to group members by Therium Australia as at 30 January 2017 (Initial Therium LFA);(iv)a copy of the Notice of Disclosure to the Federal Court made 12 October 2017 in relation to the Spotless Umbrella Co-Funding Agreement dated 20 July 2017 between the ICP Entities and Therium Australia, to which the applicant and Slater & Gordon are also parties (the Co-Funding Agreement), including a copy of:(A)the amended Slater & Gordon Conditional Costs Agreement (Second CLCA) relating to the co-funded proceeding; and(B)the amended litigation funding agreements offered by Therium Australia and the ICP Entities from approximately July 2017 (Amended Therium LFA and Amended ICP LFA), both of which include as a schedule the Terms of Engagement between Slater & Gordon and the Funders respectively (Terms of Engagement);(v)a copy of the executed Deed of Settlement dated 29 May 2020 (Settlement Deed);(vi)the proposed Settlement Distribution Scheme (SDS), including the confidential Loss Assessment Formula and confidential schedules relevant to the loss assessment formula;(vii)a copy of the after the event Adverse Costs Insurance Policy (ATE Policy) entered into by the Funders with AmTrust Europe (AmTrust) to insure against any adverse costs liability up to a confidential limit;(viii)copies of the invoices for the premiums in relation to the ATE Policy;(ix)copies of invoices from AmTrust for deeds of indemnity provided by AmTrust in favour of Spotless as security for costs in 2018 and 2019; and(x)a copy of the estimates of claim value modelling prepared by Slater and Gordon; (b)an affidavit with an annexure of Michael Edward Russell, a partner of Colin Biggers & Paisley Pty Ltd, the solicitors for the respondent, made 28 August 2020;(c)an affidavit with annexures of Neil Andrew Purslow, Chief Investment Officer of Therium, made 31 August 2020. The relevant annexures include:(xi)a copy of the Terms of Engagement between Slater & Gordon and Therium Australia entered into on or about 30 January 2017;(xii)a copy of the Initial Therium LFA offered by Therium Australia to potential claimants between January and May 2017;(xiii)a copy of the Assignment and Assumption Deed dated 17 April 2019 by which Therium Australia assigned all of its rights and obligations under the Initial Therium LFAs and the Amended Therium LFAs to Therium Litigation Finance AF IC (Assignment Deed); and(xiv)copies of the invoices for the premiums in relation to the ATE Policy;(d)an affidavit with annexures of John Walker, Chief Executive Officer of Investor Claim Partner Pty Ltd and Managing Director of ICP Capital Pty Ltd and ICP Funding Pty Ltd, made 31 August 2020. The relevant annexures include:(xv)a copy of the Co-Funding Agreement dated 20 July 2017;(xvi)a copy of the litigation funding agreement offered by ICP and ICP Capital to potential claimants in the initial book building process (Initial ICP LFA); and(xvii)copies of invoices paid by ICP Capital in respect of third party costs associated with the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Chuk deposed that that Mrs Court took the role of representative applicant very seriously and was conscientious and diligent in acting in that role, and that she went beyond the scope of what was required of her to discharge her responsibilities. She engaged in a variety of tasks almost all of which can properly be characterised as being for the benefit of group members including discussing the development of the case theory, reviewing documents for the filing of the proceeding, reviewing communications by Slater & Gordon concerning the proceeding, and providing instructions in relation to the two mediations. That work was for the benefit of group members overall. Having regard to that, Mr Chuk’s evidence about the quantum of reimbursement payments allowed in comparable securities class actions, and Professor Morabito’s empirical research in relation to the range of reimbursement payments that have been allowed (V Morabito, ‘An Evidence-Based Approach to Class Action Reform in Australia: Common Fund Orders, Funding Fees and Reimbursement Payments’, Monash University, January 2019), I consider a reimbursement payment of $25,000 to be fair and reasonable.CONCLUSION For these reasons I approved the proposed settlement pursuant to s 33V of the FCA .

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Taking into account that change, which will increase the approved applicant’s costs by about $105,000, I consider it appropriate to allow the deduction of $7,856,318 for the applicant’s costs and disbursements on a solicitor and own client basis.The proposed settlement administration costs The orders appointing the Costs Referee also required Ms Dealehr to report as to the reasonableness of the sum proposed for settlement administration costs. With one exception I considered it appropriate to adopt the Costs Referee’s report which said that $220,651 (inclusive of GST) was a reasonable and proportionate amount for settlement administration costs. I reduced the amount by $10,423 to reflect my view that it was unlikely that group members would seek review in relation to the distributions under the SDS as most had already been provided with a Notice of Estimated Distribution and had not done so. I approved settlement administration costs to $211,165 but gave liberty to apply to the Administrator in the event that such an amount was insufficient to meet the costs incurred. THE PROPOSED LITIGATION FUNDING COMMISSIONThe background By orders made on 18 June 2020, the Funders were granted leave to be represented in the application for settlement approval. They filed an interlocutory application dated 28 August 2020 seeking an order that they receive equitable remuneration for their provision of litigation funding, at the rate of 22.5% of the settlement sum net of approved legal costs. The Funders rely on the affidavits of Mr Purslow and Mr Walker which show that:(a)in early 2016 ICP commenced investigating a proceeding against Spotless in relation to the events giving rise to the present case and they subsequently sought legal, accounting and econometric advice regarding the merits of the claim, which investigation was largely complete by late 2016. Thereafter the ICP Entities entered into litigation funding agreements with a number of shareholders who had expressed interest in participating in a class action, and a retainer with a firm of solicitors, and had consulted with counsel in anticipation of litigation, but no proceeding was yet commenced; and(b)in August 2016 Therium Australia, along with Slater & Gordon, commenced their own investigation. Between January and May 2017, Therium Australia entered into engagement terms with Slater & Gordon and in conjunction with that firm undertook “book building” of clients, following which it unconditionally agreed to fund the claim against Spotless. Mrs Court, represented by Slater & Gordon and funded by Therium, then commenced the proceeding on 25 May 2017. The day after the applicant commenced the proceeding, Mr Walker contacted Slater & Gordon and Mr Purslow inviting discussion as to arrangements by which the Funders could jointly fund the proceeding. Ultimately, those negotiations culminated in the applicant, her solicitors and the Funders entering into the Co-Funding Agreement which provides for the Funders to fund the action and also that:(a)the applicant will consider extending the claim period to include an earlier period and include an equity swap claim contemplated in the ICP Entities’ proposed claim;(b)Slater & Gordon is to remain as solicitors on the record;(c)each of the Funders retain their respective contractual rights to recover, as commission from those group members who had signed a funding agreement with that funder prior to the execution of the Co-Funding Agreement, a proportion of their recovery sums; (d)the Funders are together required to enter into an after the event insurance policy to pay any adverse costs order that is made, which policy is to cover costs in an amount representing a substantial part of the budgeted costs. The Funders would each bear 50% of the costs of such a policy; and(e)the applicant is to apply for a common fund order, that would entitle the Funders to a proportion of any damages that would otherwise be paid to those group members who had not signed a funding agreement with either of the Funders.