Cantor v Audi Australia Pty Limited (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Cantor v Audi Australia Pty Limited (No 5) [2020] FCA 637

File numbers:

NSD 1307 of 2015

NSD 1308 of 2015

NSD 1459 of 2015

NSD 1472 of 2015

NSD 1473 of 2015

Judge:

FOSTER J

Date of Orders:

1 April 2020

Date of publication of Reasons:

13 May 2020

Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – representative proceedings – whether the Court should approve the settlement of five class actions brought under Pt IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) in which Australian purchasers of Volkswagen-branded, Audi-branded and Skoda-branded diesel-powered motor vehicles sued for (inter alia) compensation for loss and damage allegedly suffered by them as a consequence of the respondents (Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft and certain of its related corporations) installing illegal sophisticated two-mode software in the engines of such vehicles designed to circumvent Australian emissions standards in respect of NOx – whether, in addition, the Court should make a common fund order either at the instigation of the litigation funder of two of those class actions or at the instigation of the applicants in those two class actions – whether, in the event that the Court declines to make any common fund order, the Court should make a funding equalisation order in respect of percentage commission payments and project management fees which a small number of group members in the classes specified in two of those class actions agreed to make to that litigation funder 

Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law, ss 18, 29(1), 54(1) and 106(1)

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), ss 165, 166, 173 and 183

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 135

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), ss 17, 20(1A), 23, 33C, 33M, 33N, 33V, 33Z, 33ZB, 33ZF, 37AF and 37AG

Motor Vehicle Standards Act 1989 (Cth), ss 5, 7, 10A, 14 and 18

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 52, 53(a), 53(c), 65C(1) and 74D

Federal Court Rules 2011, r 9.05

Australian Design Rule 79—Emission Control for Light Vehicles

United Nations Economic Commission for Europe Regulation 83, Uniform Provisions Concerning the Approval of Vehicles with Regard to the Emission of Pollutants According to Engine Fuel Requirements

18 U.S.C. §371

18 U.S.C. §542

18 U.S.C. §1343

18 U.S.C. §1512(c)

42 U.S.C. §7413(c)(2)(A) 

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft [2019] FCA 2166

Andrews v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited [2019] FCA 2216

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Cascade Coal Pty Ltd (No 4) [2018] FCA 1243

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Richards [2013] FCAFC 89

Blairgowrie Trading Ltd v Allco Finance Group Ltd (In Liq) (2015) 325 ALR 539

Blairgowrie Trading Ltd v Allco Finance Group Ltd (Receivers and Managers Appointed (In Liq) (No 3) (2017) 343 ALR 476

BMW Australia Ltd v Brewster (2019) 366 ALR 171

BMW Australia Ltd v Brewster (2019) 374 ALR 627

Camilleri v The Trust Company (Nominees) Limited [2015] FCA 1468

Caason Investments Pty Ltd v International Litigation Partners…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cantor v Audi Australia Pty Limited (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 637
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cantor v Audi Australia Pty Limited (No 5) involved a consolidated proceeding brought by Australian purchasers of Volkswagen, Audi, and Skoda diesel-powered vehicles who sued Volkswagen and its related corporations for installing illegal software in the engines of the vehicles. The plaintiffs sought compensation for loss and damage allegedly suffered as a consequence of the software designed to circumvent Australian emissions standards in respect of nitrogen oxides (NOx). The proceeding sought representative proceedings under Pt IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The court was required to decide whether to approve the settlement of the proceeding, whether to make a common fund order, and whether, if it declined to make a common fund order, to make a funding equalisation order in respect of commission payments and fees which a small number of group members agreed to make to the litigation funder. The court approved the settlement, finding that the settlement was in the best interests of the group members. It found that the applicants had discharged the onus of establishing that the settlement was fair, reasonable, and in the best interests of the group members. The court found that the settlement terms were fair and reasonable and did not disadvantage any group member. The court also found that the settlement was in the best interests of the group members, as it provided a practical and efficient means of resolving the proceeding, avoiding the costs and risks of continued litigation. The court further found that a common fund order was not appropriate in the circumstances of this case. The court found that there was no evidence to support the applicants' contention that the litigation funder was responsible for the delay in reaching a settlement, and that the applicants had not discharged the onus of establishing that a common fund order was necessary to achieve justice in the circumstances. The court also found that a funding equalisation order was not necessary, as the applicants had not established that the commission payments and fees were unfair or unreasonable. The proceeding was dismissed with no order as to costs and with all previous costs orders vacated. The dismissal was without prejudice to the parties' or the Administrator's liberty to relist the matter for the purpose of seeking orders consequential to the Settlement Deed and/or the Settlement Scheme. The dismissal of the proceeding was to take effect upon completion of the administration of the settlement.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Confidential Material means the information and evidence in:

(a) Paragraphs 5 to 27 of the confidential affidavit of Julian Klaus Schimmel affirmed on 10 December 2019 and Annexure 2 to the Deed of Release and Settlement comprising Annexure JK-67 to the said affidavit;

(b) Annexure 2 to the Deed of Release and Settlement in Annexure JKS-68 to the confidential affidavit of Julian Klaus Schimmel affirmed on 20 March 2020;

(c) The Settlement Payment Methodology specified in Annexure JKS-69 to the confidential affidavit of Julian Klaus Schimmel affirmed on 20 March 2020;

(d) The expert report of Terence Michael Potter dated 20 March 2020 including all appendices;

(e) Confidential exhibit AGR-1 to the affidavit of Alexandra Gay Rose sworn on 24 March 2020 and filed herein;

(f) Paragraphs 3.1(2) and (3), 6.1 to 6.25 and Annexure A to the expert report of Abe Tomas dated 20 March 2020 and the letter of instruction from Maurice Blackburn Pty Ltd (Maurice Blackburn) to Mr Tomas; and

(g) The confidential affidavit of Gregory John Williams sworn on 25 March 2020.

2. Confidential Settlement Evidence means:

(a) The confidential affidavit of Julian Klaus Schimmel affirmed on 20 March 2020.

(b) The confidential opinion of the applicant’s Counsel dated 24 March 2020.

3. VW WO Data means the following information from the National Exchange of Vehicle and Driver Information System (NEVDIS) contained in the spreadsheet entitled SR1727_data.xlsx:

(a) Vehicle Information Number (VIN);

(b) Write-Off Status; and

(c) Write-Off Date.

4. Skoda WO Data means the following information from NEVDIS contained in the spreadsheet entitled SR1726_data.xlsx:

(a) Vehicle Information Number (VIN);

(b) Write-Off Status; and

(c) Write-Off Date.

5. Audi WO Data means the following information from NEVDIS contained in the spreadsheet entitled SR1965.xlsx:

(a) Vehicle Information Number (VIN);

(b) Write-Off Status; and

(c) Write-Off Date.

6. Pursuant to s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act), the settlement of this proceeding be approved upon the terms set out in:

(a) The Deed of Release and Settlement comprising Annexure JKS-68 to the confidential affidavit of Julian Klaus Schimmel affirmed on 20 March 2020 (Settlement Deed);

(b) The Settlement Scheme (version 2) comprising Annexure JKS-71 to the affidavit of Julian Klaus Schimmel affirmed on 20 March 2020 and filed herein (Settlement Scheme); and

(c) The Settlement Payment Methodology comprising Annexure JKS-69 to the confidential affidavit of Julian Klaus Schimmel affirmed on 20 March 2020.

7. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, the applicant be authorised, nunc pro tunc, to enter into and give effect to the Settlement Deed for and on behalf of all Group Members (being those persons who meet the definition of group members as set out in the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim filed herein on 18 September 2017 [which definition is set out in the Schedule to these Orders] and who did not opt out of this proceeding).

8. Pursuant to s 33ZB(a) of the Act, the persons affected and bound by the settlement are the parties to the Settlement Deed and Group Members.

9. Pursuant to s 33V(2) and s 33ZF of the Act:

(a) The payment to Steven Roe of AUD20,000 be approved as a Lead Applicant Reimbursement Payment (as defined in clause 1.1 of the Settlement Deed) and be paid by the respondents in accordance with clause 5.2 of the Settlement Deed.

(b) The Maurice Blackburn component of the Applicants’ Reasonable Costs (as defined in clause 1.1 of the Settlement Deed) be approved in the amount verified as reasonable in respect of the period up to and including 29 February 2020 in the report of Ian Ramsey-Stewart dated 20 March 2020 and filed herein and be paid by the respondents in accordance with clause 5.1 of the Settlement Deed.

10. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, Maurice Blackburn be appointed as the Administrator of the Settlement Scheme.

11. The proceeding be dismissed:

(a) With no order as to costs and with all previous costs orders vacated;

(b) Without prejudice to parties’ or the Administrator’s liberty to relist the matter for the purpose of seeking orders consequential to the Settlement Deed and/or the Settlement Scheme, and, to this end, pursuant to r 9.05 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 the Administrator be joined as a party to this proceeding for the limited purpose of exercising such liberty; and

(c) With the dismissal of the proceeding to take effect upon completion of the administration of the settlement.

12. Pursuant to s 37AF and s 37AG(1)(a) of the Act, until further order, on the ground that the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the Confidential Settlement Evidence:

(a) Be treated as confidential;

(b) To the extent that such material is held by the Court in paper form, be held with the Court file in envelopes marked “Not to be opened except by leave of the Court or a Judge” or destroyed;

(c) To the extent that such material is held by the Court in electronic form, be kept in a confidential section of the relevant Court file;

(d) Not be published, made available (whether electronically or otherwise) or disclosed to any person or entity except:

(i) The Court;

(ii) The applicant in this proceeding NSD1473 of 2015 and the applicants in proceedings NSD1459 of 2015 and NSD1472 of 2015 and their legal representatives; and

(iii) The legal representatives of the applicants in proceedings NSD1307 of 2015 and NSD1308 of 2015

such permitted disclosures to be on terms that none of those persons or entities disclose the Confidential Settlement Evidence or any part of it to any person or entity other than those listed in this Order.

13. Pursuant to s 37AF and s 37AG(1)(a) of the Act, on the ground that the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, up to and including 31 December 2021, the Confidential Material:

(a) Be treated as confidential;

(b) To the extent that it is held by the Court in paper form, be held with the Court file in envelopes marked “Not to be opened except by leave of the Court or a Judge” or destroyed;

(c) To the extent that such material is held by the Court in electronic form, be kept in a confidential section of the relevant Court file;

(d) Not be published, made available (whether electronically or otherwise) or disclosed to any other person than:

(i) The Court;

(ii) The applicant in this proceeding NSD1473 of 2015 and the applicants in proceedings NSD1459 of 2015 and NSD1472 of 2015 and their legal representatives;

(iii) The applicants and the legal representatives of the applicants in proceedings NSD1307 of 2015 and NSD1308 of 2015;

(iv) The respondents in proceedings NSD1459 of 2015, NSD1472 of 2015, NSD1473 of 2015, NSD1307 of 2015 and NSD1308 of 2015 and their legal representatives;

(v) Grosvenor Litigation Services Pty Ltd and its legal representatives; and

(vi) Nicholas Owens SC and Robert Yezerski in their capacity as independent contradictors appointed by the Court pursuant to Order 10 made on 12 December 2019.

14. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act:

(a) The claim registered by Mr Barry Holmes on 12 March 2020 be deemed to have been validly registered in accordance with clause 5.3 of the Settlement Scheme and Mr Holmes be permitted to participate in the Settlement Scheme; and

(b) Provided that a claim is registered by Mr Peter Shakes by 16 April 2020, his claim be deemed to have been validly registered in accordance with clause 5.3 of the Settlement Scheme and Mr Shakes be permitted to participate in the Settlement Scheme.

15. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, and notwithstanding Order 13 made on 12 December 2019, persons who have, after 10 March 2020 but on or before 26 March 2020, registered claims in accordance with the Settlement Scheme shall be deemed to have validly registered their claims in accordance with clause 5 of the Settlement Scheme and shall be permitted to participate in the Settlement Scheme.

16. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act:

(a) On or before 1 April 2020, Volkswagen Group Australia Pty Limited produce copies of the VW WO Data and Skoda WO Data to Maurice Blackburn;

(b) On or before 1 April 2020, Audi Australia Pty Limited produce copies of the Audi WO Data to Maurice Blackburn;

(c) Maurice Blackburn be permitted to use the VW WO Data, Skoda WO Data and Audi WO Data (together, the NEVDIS WO Data) for the limited purpose of verifying whether or not a group member held an interest in an affected vehicle in accordance with the Settlement Scheme and whether, and if so, when that vehicle was written off;

(d) Maurice Blackburn keep and store the NEVDIS WO Data in a manner that preserves its confidentiality; and

(e) Maurice Blackburn not disclose the NEVDIS WO Data to any person other than the following who have provided an undertaking to keep the NEVDIS WO Data confidential and not use it in a manner that is inconsistent with these Orders:

(i) Officers and employees of Maurice Blackburn who are involved in or responsible for the conduct of this proceeding;

(ii) Officers and employees of any third parties engaged to provide technical or project support services in relation to the settlement of this proceeding;

(iii) Counsel retained and appointed to perform the role of “Review Assessor” pursuant to clause 8 of the Settlement Scheme; and

(iv) Experts engaged by Maurice Blackburn to assist in carrying out any functions under the Settlement Scheme.

17. As soon as practicable after completion of the settlement administration, the Administrator provide a report to the Court as to the completion of the Settlement Scheme.

18. The claims for relief made by Richard Cantor, the applicant in proceeding NSD1307 of 2015, in the Interlocutory Application filed by him in this proceeding on 23 March 2020 be dismissed.

19. The claims for relief made by Josefina Tolentino, the applicant in proceeding NSD1308 of 2015, in the Interlocutory Application filed by her in this proceeding on 23 March 2020 be dismissed.

20. The parties have liberty to apply in the event that further orders are required:

(a) Should it become apparent that, for the reasons set out in paragraph 20 of the non-confidential affidavit of Julian Klaus Schimmel affirmed on 20 March 2020, certain group members were not notified of the proposed settlement prior to 10 March 2020, for the purpose of seeking such orders as may be appropriate to permit some or all of such persons to participate in the Settlement Scheme;

(b) Should it become apparent that amendments are needed to the Settlement Scheme for the reasons set out in paragraph 72 of the non-confidential affidavit of Julian Klaus Schimmel affirmed on 20 March 2020, for the purpose of seeking approval of such amendments; or

(c) Should any of the parties or Group Members consider that it is desirable to seek the assistance of the Court in relation to any matter concerning the Settlement Scheme.

AND THE COURT NOTES THAT:

21. In addition to information already provided and noting that the parties otherwise have sought non-publication orders in respect of the Confidential Material and the Confidential Settlement Evidence as set out proposed Orders 1, 12 and 13 of certain draft Orders submitted by Maurice Blackburn to the Court for its consideration at approximately 2.10 pm on 27 March 2020:

(a) Volkswagen AG will pay approximately AUD120 million as the total settlement amount to be made available to eligible group members.

(b) When the settlement has been finalised and all requisite payments thereunder have been made, the total of all amounts paid is unlikely to be significantly less than AUD120 million and may be more than AUD120 million.

(c) Individual settlement payments will be determined in accordance with the methodology developed by the applicant and approved by the Court.

(d) The precise amount of each individual payment must await the finalisation of the assessment of registrations by Maurice Blackburn as the Administrator (which is ongoing).

(e) The estimated average settlement payment for each participating vehicle is AUD2,800.

(f) Persons with an interest in different types of vehicles are eligible to receive different payment amounts, for example, as a result of the type and age of their vehicle. The range of per vehicle payments is approximately AUD1,589 to AUD6,554.

22. Exhibits AGR1 and AGR2 to the affidavit of Alexandra Gay Rose sworn on 24 March 2020 and filed herein, which are in the form of Excel files stored on a USB, are to be retained by the solicitors for the respondents until the date which is 12 months from the date upon which dismissal of this proceeding takes effect in accordance with Order 11 above.

23. The total amount of the Maurice Blackburn applicants’ costs and disbursements verified by Mr Ramsey-Stewart pursuant to and for the purposes of clauses 1.1 and 5 of the Settlement Deed to be paid pursuant to Order 9(b) above and Order 9(b) made this day in each of proceedings NSD 1459 of 2015 and NSD 1472 of 2015 is AUD43,296,810.22 inclusive of GST.

24. The names of those Group Members who have opted out of this proceeding are specified in the Orders made by the Court on 6 May 2019.

THE SCHEDULE HEREINBEFORE REFERRED TO

1. The Group Members are the applicant and all other persons who:

(a) Prior to 3 October 2015, acquired an interest in an affected Skoda diesel vehicle (as defined in paragraph 38 of the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim filed herein on 18 September 2017); and

(b) Still had an interest in that vehicle as at 3 October 2015,

but not including:

(c) The respondents, or any wholly or partly owned subsidiary of either of the respondents;

(d) Any Skoda or Volkswagen authorised dealer;

(e) Any Judge of the Federal Court of Australia; or

(f) Any group member in proceeding NSD 1308 of 2015 (the VW-Skoda BL Proceeding) who has retained Bannister Law as its legal representative in the VW-Skoda BL Proceeding as at 1 August 2017, except for those group members who have also retained Maurice Blackburn as its legal representative in proceeding NSD 1459 of 2015 or NSD 1473 of 2015 as at 1 August 2017.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.