Money Max Int Pty Ltd v QBE Insurance Group Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Money Max Int Pty Ltd (Trustee) v QBE Insurance Group Limited [2016] FCAFC 148

File number: VID 513 of 2015
Judges: MURPHY, GLEESON AND BEACH JJ
Date of judgment: 26 October 2016
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – representative proceedings under Part IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (“the Act”) – litigation funding of representative proceedings – where order is sought for all group members to pay a litigation funding commission from any settlement or judgment, not just those group members who have signed a litigation funding agreement – whether Court has power to make such an order under ss 33ZF and 23 of the Act – meaning of the expression “appropriate or necessary to ensure that justice is done in the proceeding” in s 33ZF of the Act – whether order is appropriate to ensure that justice is done in the proceeding – the significance of the low level of objection by group members – whether there is a benefit for group members in judicial approval of the rate of the funding commission – whether there is a benefit for group members of a condition that they not be worse off by reason of the order – whether there is a benefit for group members in being informed of the obligation to pay a Court-approved funding commission before deciding whether to opt out – whether the right to opt out operates to safeguard group members’ interests – whether the order will be to the detriment of group members – whether a funding equalisation order is likely or to be preferred to a common fund order – whether a common fund order is consistent with the broad policy aims of the representative proceeding regime in Part IVA.
Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Australian Consumer Law (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Amendment Bill 1991 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Richards [2013] FCAFC 89

Blairgowrie Trading Ltd v Allco Finance Group Ltd (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (in liq) (2015) 325 ALR 539; [2015] FCA 811

Bray v F. Hoffman La Roche Ltd [2003] FCA 1505

Brookfield Multiplex Limited v International Litigation Funding Partners Pte Ltd (2009) 180 FCR 11; [2009] FCAFC 147

Campbells Cash and Carry Pty Ltd v Fostif Pty Ltd (2006) 229 CLR 386; [2006] HCA 41

City of Swan v McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc (2016) 112 ACSR 65; [2016] FCA 343

Cominos v Cominos (1972) 127 CLR 588

Darwalla Milling Co Pty Ltd v F Hoffman-La Roche Ltd (No 2) (2006) 236 ALR 322; [2006] FCA 1388

Dorajay Pty Ltd v Aristocrat Leisure Limited [2009] FCA 19

Dugal v Manulife Financial Corporation 2011 ONSC 1785

Earglow Pty Ltd v Newcrest Mining Ltd (2015) 230 FCR 469

Fairfax Digital Australia and New Zealand Pty Ltd v Ibrahim (2012) 83 NSWLR 52; [2012] NSWCCA 125

Farey v National Australia Bank…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Money Max Int Pty Ltd v QBE Insurance Group Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCAFC 148
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Money Max International Pty Ltd brought a class action against QBE Insurance Group Ltd in the Federal Court. The applicant sought an order approving Funding Terms which provided for a funding commission to be charged to all class members, not just those who had entered into a funding agreement. The Court considered whether it had the power to make such an order and if it was appropriate to ensure that justice was done in the proceeding. The Court held that it did have the power to make the order under section 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976. The Court also held that the order was appropriate to ensure that justice was done in the proceeding, given the low level of objection by group members and the benefits to them of judicial approval of the funding commission rate and a condition that they not be worse off by reason of the order. The Court held that the right to opt out operated to safeguard group members’ interests and that the order would not be to their detriment. The Court held that a common fund order was consistent with the broad policy aims of the representative proceeding regime in Part IVA of the Act.
The Court ordered that within 14 days of the date of the order, the parties each file and serve proposed minutes of orders to give effect to these reasons including any written submissions (limited to one and a half pages each) on the question of costs. Costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 14 days of the date of this order, the parties each file and serve proposed minutes of orders to give effect to these reasons including any written submissions (limited to one and a half pages each) on the question of costs.

2. Costs reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 25 September 2015, at the first case management conference, Senior Counsel for the applicant flagged that the applicant would make an application seeking a common fund order. On 3 December 2015, the applicant filed the interlocutory application now before this Court. On 6 April 2016 the Chief Justice directed pursuant to s 20(1A) of the Act that the application be referred to the Full Court for hearing and determination.The evidence The following material is before the Court:(a)two affidavits of Jacob Varghese, a partner in the firm Maurice Blackburn which acts for the applicant, the first affirmed on 11 March 2016 (with some paragraphs redacted) and the second on 26 May 2016;(b)two affidavits of Andrew Watson, a partner in Maurice Blackburn, the first sworn on 5 April 2016 and the second on 16 May 2016;(c)an affidavit of Anthony O’Brien, a solicitor with Maurice Blackburn affirmed on 4 May 2016;(d)an affidavit of Frederick Rose, the Chairman of the Board of the Funder, sworn on 13 May 2016; (e)an expert report of Dr Ramsey Zein, an independent expert economist, dated 11 March 2016 and filed on behalf of the applicant; and(f)documents produced on a notice to produce and subpoena including:(i)an email from Maurice Blackburn to the applicant with attachments including a Funding Agreement, a Retainer and Costs Agreement between the applicant and Maurice Blackburn, a Privacy Statement and a Conflicts of Interest Statement provided by Maurice Blackburn;(ii)the audited Financial Statements of the Funder as at 31 December 2014;(iii)Financial Statements of the Funder for the year ended 31 December 2015 and for the year commenced 1 January 2016, as at 31 March 2016; and(iv)the minutes of the Funder’s Board Meeting held on 17 November 2015. Mr Varghese gave evidence in support of the application and he was not cross-examined. There is nothing in the materials or submissions which cause us to doubt his evidence in any material way and we accept his evidence. We also accept the evidence of the other deponents, most of which is uncontentious.The Funding Agreement The Funding Agreement entered into by the applicant is in evidence, and the funded class members entered into agreements in the same or similar terms. The key provisions of the Funding Agreement are as follows:(a)clause 4, which provides for the obligations of the “Claimant” (being each funded class member), including:(i)to provide instructions to the “Lawyers” (being Maurice Blackburn or any other firm appointed after consultation with the Funder), subject to a direction that the Lawyers consult with the Funder with regard to any “significant issue”: cl 4.1;(ii)to conduct the proceedings so as to avoid unnecessary cost and delay: cl 4.2(c);(iii)to accept and follow the Lawyers’ reasonable legal advice: cl 4.2(d);(iv)to not communicate with QBE about the “Claims” (that is, the Claimant’s own claims) or their compromise other than through the Lawyers or upon their reasonable advice: cl 4.5(a);(v)to permit the representative party (being the applicant) to give binding instructions to the Lawyers in relation to the “Claims” and the claims of other funded class members including instructions and decisions in relation to settlement: cl 4.8;(vi)to authorise the Lawyers to advise the Funder of any settlement discussions, and consult with the Funder as to the terms of any proposed settlement: cl 4.9; and(vii)in the event of a disagreement between the Claimant and the Funder as to the appropriate terms of settlement, to authorise Senior Counsel to provide an advice as to whether the settlement is fair and reasonable. The parties are bound by that advice: cll 4.10-4.11;(b)clause 5, which provides for the obligations of the Funder, including to:(i)pay all legal costs and disbursements reasonably incurred and payable to the Lawyers: cl 5.1(a);(ii)pay any adverse costs order made in the proceeding against any funded class member: cl 5.1(b); and(iii)furnish security for costs as ordered: cll 5.4–5.5;(c)clauses 8 to 10, which provide for the receipt and application of any “Resolution Sum” (being the amount for which the “Claims” – that is, the Claimant’s own claims and not the claims of other class members – are settled or for which judgment is given), including that:(i)the Claimant irrevocably authorises and directs the Lawyers to receive any Resolution Sum into an account kept for that purpose: cl 8.2;(ii)the Claimant irrevocably authorises and directs the Lawyers to make payments out of the account as referred to in cl 10.1: cl 9.1. Those amounts are:(A)an amount equal to the funded class member’s share of the total monies paid by the Funder pursuant to clause 5 and the equivalent clause in other funding agreements: cl 10.1(a). This renders each Claimant liable for his or her proportionate share of the total legal costs of the action by reference to the proportion his or her own recovery bears to the recovery of all Claimants (excluding any amount recovered in respect of costs);(B)an amount equal to the percentage of the Resolution Sum (being, relevantly, either 32.5% or 35% depending on how many QBE shares the Claimant acquired in the claim period): cl 10.1(b). This renders each Claimant liable for a percentage of the amount recovered in respect of its own claim (not the claims of others);(iii)if a lump sum amount is received by way of settlement of the Claims, then, subject to any Court order, following deduction of all amounts permitted by the Funding Agreement, the monies are to be distributed to funded class members on a pro rata basis by reference to the “Gross Recovery” of all funded class members: cl 9.2. The effect of this provision is that each funded class member has agreed that following deduction of his or her share of legal costs and the funding commission, the balance of the recovery by funded class members is to be distributed pro rata to all funded class members.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In our view the proposed orders have the additional benefit that they will enhance access to justice by encouraging open class representative proceedings. If litigation funders are permitted to charge a commercially realistic but reasonable percentage funding commission to the whole class it is less likely that funders will seek to bring class actions limited to those persons who have signed a funding agreement. The encouragement of open class representative proceedings should reduce the potential for conflicts of interest between funded registered class members and unfunded class members and between the solicitors for the applicant and unfunded non-client class members. Open class proceedings will also act to inhibit competing class actions and avoid the multiplicity of actions which they represent. Competing class actions can cause significant delay, increased costs and wastage of the resources of the parties and the courts. As we have said, this is not a factor in the present case but it may be in other cases.CONCLUSION As we have said, upon receipt of an undertaking by the Funder, the applicant and the solicitors for the applicant to comply with their obligations under the Funding Terms attached as Annexure A, we intend to make the orders set out at [9] above. However, we will give the parties an opportunity to make further submissions on the precise form of the orders and the undertaking, including the Funding Terms.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Zein estimates (again on the basis that approximately 920 class members had entered into funding agreements as at 16 March 2016) that the proportion of relevant shares acquired by:(a)funded class members falls in the range of approximately 25% to 47 %; and(b)conversely, unfunded class members falls in the range of approximately 75% to 53%.That is, he estimates that the ratio of relevant shares acquired by funded class members to relevant shares acquired by unfunded class members (the ratio of funded to unfunded class members’ shares) falls within the range 25:75 and 47:53. By the time the application was heard the number of funded class members had increased to approximately 1,290 persons and the ratio of funded to unfunded class members’ shares was therefore higher than Dr Zein’s estimate. It seems likely that more class members will enter into funding agreements over time, and the proportion of funded class members will increase further as a result. Further, as we later explain, it would be unsurprising if the number of unfunded class members who participate in a settlement or judgment in this proceeding was far lower than the number of unidentified class members who fall within the class description. This could significantly increase the ratio of funded to unfunded class members’ shares.The Funding Terms proposed by the applicant The interlocutory application seeks orders for Court approval of Funding Terms modelled on the terms of the Funding Agreement but which seeks that the terms be applied to the applicant and all class members and provides for a reduced funding commission rate of 30%. The terms include that:(a)the Funder’s obligations to pay the applicant and class members’ lawyers (Lawyers), to pay any adverse costs order made and to furnish any security for costs, extends to all class members, and not just funded class members;(b)any sum for which the applicant and class members’ claims are settled, or for which judgment is given (Resolution Sum), is paid into one common account;(c)subject to any order of the Court, the Lawyers are to pay the Funder from the common account:(i)an amount equal to the total monies paid by the Funder for legal costs in funding the proceeding; and(ii)an amount equal to 30% of the Resolution Sum; and the net balance is to be distributed on a pro rata basis to all class members proportionately in accordance with any distribution scheme approved by the Court;(d)the Lawyers’ professional duties are owed to the applicant and not to the Funder. The applicant, as the representative party, will give binding instructions to the Lawyers and make binding decisions on behalf of the class members up to the point of any court approval of settlement or the delivery of judgment in respect of the common issues in the proceeding;(e)if there is a dispute between the Funder and the applicant as to the appropriate terms of settlement, the Lawyers will brief Senior Counsel to provide an advice which will be final and binding on both the applicant and the Funder; and(f)the Funding Terms can only be terminated by Court order on application by the applicant, the Funder or a class member. Those terms provide for what happens upon termination, but expressly subject to “any contrary order of the Court”.