Krieger v Colonial First State Investments Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Krieger v Colonial First State Investments Limited [2024] FCA 1402

File number(s): VID 1141 of 2019
Judgment of: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 3 June 2024
Date of publication of reasons: 5 December 2024
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application for Court approval of a proposed settlement under s 33V(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – whether the proposed settlement is fair and reasonable in the interests of group members to be bound to it including as between group members – exercise of the discretion to make a common fund order – relevance of after the event insurance to the assessment of a reasonable litigation funding charges - whether proposed litigation funding charges are reasonable and proportionate – proposed settlement approved.
Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investment Commission Act 2001 (Cth) s 12CB

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 960 to 968, 1528

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 33V

Superannuation (Unclaimed Money and Lost Members) Act1999 (Cth)

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Alford v AMP Superannuation Limited (No 2) [2024] FCA 423

Bellamy's Australia Ltd v Basil [2019] FCAFC 147; 372 ALR 638

Blairgowrie Trading Ltd v Allco Finance Group Ltd (in liq) (No 3) [2017] FCA 330; 343 ALR 476

BMW Australia Ltd v Brewster [2019] HCA 45; 269 CLR 574

Caason Investments Pty Ltd v Cao (No 2) [2018] FCA 527

Caason Investments Pty Ltd v International Litigation Partners No.3 Ltd [2018] FCAFC 176

Camilleri v Trust Company (Nominees) Ltd [2015] FCA 1468

Clark v National Australia Bank Limited (No 2) [2020] FCA 652

Coatman v Colonial First State Investments [2022] FCA 1611

Court v Spotless Group Holdings Limited [2020] FCA 1730

Earglow Pty Ltd v Newcrest Mining Limited [2016] FCA 1433

Elliott-Carde v McDonald’s Australia Ltd [2023] FCAFC 162; 301 FCR 1

Evans v Davantage Group Pty Ltd (No 3) [2021] FCA 70

Farey v National Australia Bank Ltd [2016] FCA 340

Galactic Seven Eleven Litigation Holdings LLC v Davaria [2024] FCAFC 54; 302 FCR 493

Ghee v BT Funds Management Limited [2023] FCA 1553

Hall v Slater and Gordon Ltd [2018] FCA 2071

Jenkings v Northern Territory of Australia (No 4) [2021] FCA 839

Kelly v Willmott Forests Ltd (in liq) (No 4) [2016] FCA 323; 335 ALR 439

Klemweb Nominees Pty Ltd (as trustee for the Klemweb Superannuation Fund) v BHP Group Limited [2019] FCAFC 107; 369 ALR 583

Kuterba v Sirtex Medical Limited (No 3) [2019] FCA 1374

Liverpool City Council v McGraw-Hill Financial, Inc (now known as S&P Global Inc) [2018] FCA 1289

Lopez v Star World Enterprises [1999] FCA 104

Money Max Int Pty Ltd (Trustee) v QBE Insurance Group Ltd [2018] FCA 1030; 358 ALR 382

Money Max Int Pty Ltd v QBE Insurance Group Ltd [2016] FCAFC 148; 245 FCR 191

Perera v GetSwift Limited [2018] FCA 732; 263 FCR 1

Perera v GetSwift Ltd [2018] FCAFC 202

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Krieger v Colonial First State Investments Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 1402
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Krieger v Colonial First State Investments Limited involves a class action proceeding under the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976. The primary dispute concerns the approval of a proposed settlement between the parties, specifically focusing on whether the settlement is fair and reasonable for the group members, including the appropriate allocation of litigation funding charges and the role of after-the-event insurance. The Court was required to determine whether the proposed settlement terms were equitable and whether the litigation funding charges were reasonable and proportionate.

The court assessed the fairness of the proposed settlement by examining the breakdown of costs and benefits to the group members, including legal fees, disbursements, and other expenses. A significant consideration was the distribution of the settlement fund and the categorization of group members into different types based on their eligibility for compensation. The court also evaluated the appropriateness of the litigation funding charges, taking into account the after-the-event insurance policy and its relevance to the overall settlement. The decision involved scrutinizing the detailed breakdown of costs and ensuring that the charges were neither excessive nor disproportionate.

After thorough consideration, the court approved the proposed settlement, finding it to be fair and reasonable for the group members. The Court acknowledged the complexity of the case and the necessity of ensuring that the settlement terms were transparent and equitable. The orders included the approval of the settlement deed, the appointment of Slater and Gordon Limited as Settlement Administrator, and the authorization of the applicants to act on behalf of the group members. The Court also made orders regarding confidentiality to protect sensitive information and the administration of the settlement process.

In conclusion, the Court made orders approving the settlement, appointing the necessary parties to oversee the distribution, and ensuring that the proceedings were concluded appropriately. The Court also issued confidentiality orders to protect certain information from public disclosure, ensuring that the interests of the parties and the integrity of related proceedings were maintained.

Orders

Orders of the court

Confidentiality

1. Until further order, pursuant to ss 37AF and 37AG(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act), on the ground that the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the material listed in Annexure A is confidential and not to be published or made available to any person other than:

(a) the Court;

(b) the Applicants and their legal representatives; and

(c) Augusta Pool 1 UK Limited (Company Number 11867886) (Augusta) and its legal representatives.

2. Pursuant to ss 37AF and 37AG(1)(a) of the Act, on the ground that the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, until 24 September 2024, or if an appeal or application for leave to appeal has been filed in respect of these orders by that date then until further order, the material listed in Annexure B is confidential and not to be published or made available to any person other than:

(a) the Court;

(b) the Applicants and their legal representatives; and

(c) Augusta and its legal representatives.

Approval of Settlement

3. Pursuant to ss 33V of the Act, settlement of the proceeding on the terms set out in the settlement deed executed by the Applicants, Respondents and Slater and Gordon dated 10 July 2023 (Settlement Deed) a copy of which is exhibited as Exhibit KMM-01 to the affidavit of Kirsten Marie Morrison dated 12 December 2023 and the Settlement Distribution Scheme (SDS) a copy of which is at Annexure C (together, the Settlement) be approved.

4. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Act:

(a) Slater and Gordon Limited be appointed as Settlement Administrator (as defined in clause 2 of the SDS);

(b) the Respondents are each appointed as Settlement Distributor (as defined in clause 2 of the SDS); and

(c) Ernst & Young is appointed as Expert Consultant (as defined in clause 2 of the SDS).

5. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, the Applicants are authorised nunc pro tunc for and on behalf of group members as defined in paragraph 2 of the Amended Statement of Claim dated 25 March 2022, and for the avoidance of doubt, excluding any person who opted out in accordance with order 2 of the orders dated 15 February 2022 (Group Members) to enter into and give effect to the Settlement and the transactions contemplated for and on behalf of Group Members.

6. Pursuant to s 33ZB of the Act, the persons affected and bound by the settlement of the proceeding are the parties to the Settlement Deed and Group Members.

7. The Settlement Administrator has liberty to apply in relation to any matter arising under the SDS.

Deductions from the Settlement Fund

8. Pursuant to s 33V of the Act, the following distributions from the Settlement Sum (as defined in the SDS) are approved for the purposes of the SDS (inclusive of GST if applicable):

(a) The Applicants’ legal costs, being professional fees and disbursements on a solicitor and own client basis, including incurred in connection with the proceeding on their own behalf and on behalf of all Group Members in the proceeding payable to:

(i) Slater and Gordon in its capacity as solicitor for the Applicants and as Settlement Administrator in the amount of $4,183,492.89 (being $2,906,463.62 in its capacity as solicitor for the Applicants and $1,277,029.27 in its capacity as Settlement Administrator); and

(ii) Augusta as reimbursement for professional fees and disbursements paid for by Augusta in the amount of $4,560,960.80.

(b) the fees, commission, After the Event insurance and costs related to the provision of security for the Respondent’s costs payable to Augusta to fund the proceeding in the amount of $23,111,979.87;

(c) the Applicants’ reimbursement payment, being the reasonable claim for compensation for the time and expenditure reasonably incurred by the Applicants in the interests of prosecuting the proceeding on their own behalf and on behalf of all Gorup Members, in the amount of $40,000, with $20,000 to be paid to each Applicant.

9. The Settlement Administrator is granted liberty to apply for additional amounts of costs relating to settlement administration.

Late registrants

10. Pursuant to section 33ZF of the Act, the Group Members listed in Annexure D who failed to register by the date in Order 7 of the orders made 20 December 2023 but who have subsequently sought to register in the proceeding are deemed to have registered for the purposes of the Settlement.

11. Pursuant to section 33ZF of the Act, the Settlement Administrator shall make enquiries with the Respondents to confirm whether the Group Members listed in Annexure E, being Group Members who objected to the Settlement on the basis of their categorisation as Notice Type C, were correctly so categorised. If, as a result of those enquiries or any information provided by the Group Members listed in Annexure E, any of those Group Members are found to be Notice Type A or B, those Group Members will be deemed to have registered for the purposes of the Settlement.

Final Orders

12. The Settlement Administrator shall within 30 business days of the conclusion of distribution of the Settlement Sum, as defined in the SDS, apply to the Court for orders dismissing the proceeding with no order as to costs and all costs orders vacated.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ANNEXURE A

AFFIDAVIT OF KIRSTEN MARIE MORRISON DATED 14 MAY 2024

#

AFFIDAVIT

CONFIDENTIAL PART (INCLUSIVE)

1.

Paragraph 67

Entire table

#

BUNDLE EXHIBIT KMM-8

CONFIDENTIAL PART (INCLUSIVE)

2.

Executed Conditional Legal Costs Agreements entered into by the Applicants, pages 69 – 92 of KMM-8.

Partial:

· Addresses of Applicants

3.

Executed Litigation Funding Agreements entered into by the Applicants, pages 93 – 194 of KMM-8.

Partial:

· Addresses, email addresses and telephone numbers of Applicants

· Figures in Table 1 – Budget for Proceedings Work

· Details for Claims Trust Account and Augusta bank account in Schedule 2

4.

Funding variation agreements dated 12 April 2021, 31 August 2022, and 5 October 2022, pages 200 – 223 of KMM-8.

Partial:

· Addresses of the Applicants

· Budget figures

5.

Notices of Objection and emails expressing intention to object to proposed settlement, pages 246 – 298 of KMM-8.

Partial:

· Telephone numbers, email addresses and postal addresses of objectors

#

CONFIDENTIAL EXHIBIT KMM-9

CONFIDENTIAL PART (INCLUSIVE)

6.

Counsel Opinion

All

AFFIDAVIT OF CHRIS MARTIN DATED 29 MAY 2024

#

AFFIDAVIT

CONFIDENTIAL PART (INCLUSIVE)

1.

Paragraphs 16(d) to (e)

Entirety of sub-paragraphs (d) to (e)

#

ANNEXURES

CONFIDENTIAL PART (INCLUSIVE)

2.

Annexure “CM-2” page 29

The information between ‘Please make payments to’ and ‘Thank you’

3.

Annexure “CM-2” page 31

Information in schedule.

4.

Annexure “CM-2” page 32

Row in schedule before ‘CAS – ATE Colonial’.

5.

Annexure “CM-2” page 33

Information following ‘Name and address of bank’ and information following ‘Payment Routing’

6.

Annexure “CM-2” page 34

The information between ‘Please make payments to’ and ‘Thank you’.

7.

Annexure “CM-2” page 37

Information following ‘Name and address of bank’ and information following ‘Payment Routing’.

8.

Annexure “CM-4” page 61

The information between ‘Please make payments to’ and ‘Thank you’.

9.

Annexure “CM-5” page 74

Case names in the Schedule, excluding #402 Colonial (Financial Services Class Action).

ANNEXURE B

AFFIDAVIT OF KIRSTEN MARIE MORRISON DATED 14 MAY 2024

#

AFFIDAVIT

CONFIDENTIAL PART (INCLUSIVE)

1.

Paragraph 28

The four dollar amounts

#

BUNDLE EXHIBIT KMM-8

CONFIDENTIAL PART (INCLUSIVE)

2.

Executed Conditional Legal Costs Agreements entered into by the Applicants, pages 69 – 92 of KMM-8.

Partial:

· Total estimate of legal costs

· Estimate of uplift fee

· Estimate of professional fees incurred on No Win-No Fee basis

3.

Funding variation agreements dated 12 April 2021, 31 August 2022, and 5 October 2022, pages 205 – 223 of KMM-8.

Partial:

· Funding amounts

· Costs related to after the event insurance

4.

Expert costs report of Catherine Mary Dealehr dated 5 April 2024, pages 348 – 475 of KMM-8.

Partial:

· Budget and funding figures on pages 360, 362, 363 and 366 of KMM-8 (being pages 13, 15, 16 and 19 of the report)

· Names of expert witnesses (from whom evidence was not filed) on pages 381, 385 and 387 of KMM-8 (being pages 34, 38 and 40 of the report)

· Descriptions and numbers of experts (from whom evidence was not filed) and comments in relation to them and their work on pages 406 and 407 of KMM-8

· Strategic litigation considerations at [3.23] on page 407 of KMM-8

· Information relating to loss estimates at [3.35] – [3.39] on page 409 of KMM-8

AFFIDAVIT OF CHRIS MARTIN DATED 29 MAY 2024

#

AFFIDAVIT

CONFIDENTIAL PART (INCLUSIVE)

1.

Paragraphs 16(a) to (c) and (f)

Entirety of sub-paragraphs (a) to (c), and (f)

2.

Paragraph 24

The dollar amount in line one.

3.

Paragraph 25

Information about increased estimates of fees in

lines 3 to 6.

4.

Paragraph 36

The dollar amounts of the total policy limits for the ATE Policy in lines 1, 5 and 7.

5.

Paragraph 37

The dollar amount of the total policy limit for the ATE Policy in line 6.

#

ANNEXURES

CONFIDENTIAL PART (INCLUSIVE)

6.

Annexure “CM-1”, page 23

The dollar amount of the policy limit.

7.

Annexure “CM-1”, page 24

The percentages of the subscription.

8.

Annexure “CM-1”, page 25 to 26

The percentages of the subscription.

9.

Annexure “CM-1” page 27

The dollar amount of the policy limit and percentages of the subscription.

10.

Annexure “CM-3” page 42

The dollar amount of the defined term existing policy limit.

11.

Annexure “CM-3” page 53

The dollar amounts of the Upfront Premium, Deferred Premium, Deed of Indemnity Fee in Item 5 and dollar amounts of policy limit in Item 6.

12.

Annexure “CM-3” page 55

The figures in the columns of the schedule ‘Subscription’ and ‘Limit of Indemnity’.

13.

Annexure “CM-5” page 64

The dollar amounts of the minimum and maximum limits of indemnity and percentages of ‘ROL’ in schedule of premiums.

14.

Annexure “CM-5” page 66

The percentages in the last sentence.

ANNEXURE C

ANNEXURE D

1. Antonio Giorgiante

34. Anastasia Stavrou

2. Max Troy O’Shea

35. Anne Webster

3. Sarantis Karamalis

36. Andrew Geisler

4. Mariam Habib

37. Jernej Hribernik

5. Chantelle Bicknell

38. Eng Hua Lee

6. Nella Chiodo-Bordin

39. Christine Coxon

7. Fiona Glenn

40. Michael McGarvey

8. Dorothy Anne Little

41. Sandra Sadie Clausen

9. Samir Raut

42. Louise Edwards

10. Byron Peter Shaw

43. Craig Condon

11. Rachel Condon

44. Robin Dunstan

12. Kim Parnell

45. Adam Musgrave

13. David Neil Kent

46. Marie Heil

14. Jennifer June Simpson

47. Lindsey Hooper

15. Hwa Hong Lim

48. Craig Cosgrove

16. Mark Adrian Hauswirth

49. Jane Cale

17. Reginald James Roe

50. Ana Ivonne Zubieta

18. Peter Mizen

51. Scott Thompson

19. Leanne Thirwell

52. Cindy Sabharwal

20. Michael Hill

53. Martin Gibson

21. Gavin Walls

54. Anthony David Carroll

22. Robert Henry Hellow

55. Terry Hannell

23. Lynne Marie Anderson

56. Kathrine Waugh

24. Patricia Tereza Villiers

57. Sundesh Sharma

25. Timothy Theodore Schenken

58. Lisa Grace on behalf of Alice Ruth Tattersell

26. Karin Sansom on behalf of Winifred L Maier

59. Teressa Reschke on behalf of Bernard Jendrzejak

27. The Estate of the late David Guy

60. The Estate of the late Bruce Reymond Little

28. The Estate of the late John Stecki

61. The Estate of the late Janis Nugent

29. Louisa Castaldo on behalf of Ermanno De Filippis

62. The Estate of the late Leah Wilson

30. The Estate of the late Eric Emmanuel Smith

63. The Estate of the late Betty Ihle

31. Kim Taylor on behalf of Barbara Loraine Taylor

64. Carisa Riley

32. The Estate of the late Adric Coghlan

65. Brittany King

33. The Estate of the late Antony Bowring

66. Kate Alexandra Spencer

ANNEXURE E

1. Michael Azzi

7. Teresa Stevenson

2. Christine Phillips

8. Christopher Paul Hanley

3. Estate of the late Geoffrey W Evans

9. Estate of the Late Max Gail Smith

4. Maxwell Stan-Bishop

10. Marvella Stan-Bishop

5. Estate of the late Douglas William Morton

11. Mark Perrin

6. Adrian Woodhead

12. Ed Mitchem

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is also appropriate that insurance policy amounts and other details pertaining to other cases currently on foot are kept confidential. It may prejudice those proceedings for this information to be released.CONCLUSION For these reasons I made the attached orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In her second affidavit Ms Morrison deposed that, based on the data provided by Colonial, there are 395,645 group members. The limited group member registration process The Court made orders on 15 February 2023 fixing a date for opt out and ordering that any group member who did not opt out before the deadline of 12 June 2023 would remain a group member for all purposes. No group member registration or class closure orders were made before settlement was reached. That is appropriate in a class action concerning group members’ superannuation as it is likely that many superannuation fund members will have a low level of engagement in relation to their superannuation. The 2018 Productivity Commission report titled “Superannuation: Assessing Efficiency and Competitiveness” (December 2018) found at 18: Some members are highly engaged with the super system – actively comparing products or opening SMSFs. But most are not. Many members simply default, and rely on their funds to manage their super for them. Levels of engagement are especially low among the young and members with low balances.…See more generally Alford v AMP Superannuation Ltd (No 2) [2024] FCA 423 at [19]-[31], [83] (Murphy J). Then, upon the proposed settlement being reached, by orders made on 20 December 2023, group members were classified into the following four categories:(a)Type A Group Members - being members identified by the respondents that had a product with a linked adviser as at either or both of 1 July 2013 and 31 December 2018 but who did not pay an Adviser Services Fee (ASF). Payment of an ASF is used as a proxy to indicate that a group member has not suffered loss by payment of Advisor Commissions. Members had an option of entering into an ASF relationship with a financial advisor after Advisor Commissions ceased. Entering an ASF allowed a member to receive financial advisor services. It is therefore probable that a member who entered an ASF after the end dates of automatic advisor fees did so in order to continue receiving financial advice services that were available to them before the fee end dates, and which represented a service benefit associated with the fees they were charged by Colonial. The orders provided that Type A Group Members were required to register in order to provide information as to whether they received ongoing financial advice services in return for fees charged to their superannuation account. Under the proposed SDS, Type A Group Members who registered and confirmed that they did not receive ongoing financial advice services will be entitled to compensation. (b)Type B Group Members - being members who fall into two sub-categories:(i)first, members identified by the respondents who can be inferred from structural features of their accounts did not receive financial advice, being those who:(A)had no linked adviser as at 1 July 2013 or at 31 December 2018; or(B)had a linked adviser as at 1 July 2013 or at 31 December 2018, but did not have an ASF relationship; and(ii)second, members of the First Choice Employer Super product who were not group members in the Coatman class action, a partly overlapping representative proceeding alleging breach of trustee duties in relation to the Employer Super Product: see Coatman v Colonial First State Investments [2022] FCA 1611.The orders provided that Type B Group Members do not need to register. Under the proposed SDS they are automatically entitled to compensation.(c)Type C Group Members - being Retail Members identified by the respondents with a financial adviser linked to their account and an ASF relationship. Such group members are considered to have received ongoing financial advice services under these arrangements and on that basis have not suffered loss. The orders provided that they are not required to register, because under the SDS it is not proposed they will be entitled to compensation. (d)Type D Group Members - being members identified by the respondents who were eligible to be compensated in the Coatman class action and who are therefore expected to have individual loss below the proposed minimum of $20 after apportionment under the Scheme. The orders provided that they are not required to register, because it is not proposed they will be entitled to compensation.