Alford v AMP Superannuation Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Alford v AMP Superannuation Limited (No 2) [2024] FCA 423

File number(s): VID 572 of 2019
Judgment of: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 5 April 2024
Date of publication of reasons: 24 April 2024
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application seeking orders for opt out, group member registration regime and class closure – registration and class closure orders opposed by applicants – real caution is appropriate before making a class closure order over the applicant’s objection - where registration and class closure is not necessary to facilitate settlement – likely low level of group member registration – substantial cost of proposed registration regime –registration regime unlikely to be necessary for the great majority of group members to be paid a share of any settlement or judgment – the relationship of respondents to group members is that of trustee and beneficiary - application dismissed
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 33J, 33X, 33Y and 33ZF

Superannuation (Unclaimed Money and Lost Members) Act 1999 (Cth)

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth)

Supreme Court Act 1986 (Vic) s 33ZG

Cases cited:

Anderson-Vaughan v AAI Limited (No 2) [2024] VSC 65

Bradgate (Trustee) v Ashley Services Group Ltd [2017] FCA 1591

Coatman v Colonial First State Investments Limited [2022] FCA 1611

Fox v Westpac Banking Corporation; O’Brien v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited; Nathan v Macquarie Leasing Pty Ltd [2023] VSC 414

JWisbey & Associates Pty Ltd v UBS AG [2024] FCA 147

Kuterba v Sirtex Medical Limited [2018] FCA 1467

Matthews v SPI Electricity Pty Ltd (No 13) [2013] VSC 17; 39 VR 255

Melbourne City Investments Pty Ltd vTreasury Wine Estates Ltd (No 2) [2017] FCAFC 98; 252 FCR 1

Pallas v Lendlease [2024] NSWCA 83

P Dawson Nominees Pty Ltd v Brookfield Multiplex Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 176

Parkin v Boral (Class Closure) [2022] FCAFC 47; 291 FCR 116

Thomas v Powercor Australia Ltd (No 1) [2010] VSC 489

Winterford v Pfizer Australia Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 1199

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 101
Date of hearing: 5 April 2024
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr A Hochroth
Solicitor for the Applicants: Maurice Blackburn and Slater & Gordon
Counsel for the First and Second Respondents: Ms S Mirzabegian and Ms J Buncle
Counsel for the Third, Fourth, Fifth and Sixth Respondents: Ms S Tame
Solicitor for the Respondents: King & Wood Mallesons

ORDERS

VID 572 of 2019
BETWEEN:

DALE ROBERT ALFORD

First Applicant

SEBASTIAN SMITH

Second Applicant

ANNE COOPER (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Applicant

AND:

AMP SUPERANNUATION LIMITED (ACN 008 414 104)

First Respondent

N.M. SUPERANNUATION PTY LTD (ACN 008 428 322)

Second Respondent

AMP LIFE LIMITED (ACN 079 300 379) (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MURPHY J

DATE OF ORDER:

5 APRIL 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The interlocutory application by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alford v AMP Superannuation Limited (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 423
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The interlocutory application in the case of Alford v AMP Superannuation Limited (No 2) was brought before the court, with the applicants seeking orders for an opt-out mechanism, a group member registration regime, and class closure. The respondents opposed these applications. The central issue before the court was whether the proposed registration and class closure orders were appropriate, considering the objections from the applicants, the necessity of these orders for settlement, the anticipated low level of group member registration, and the substantial costs associated with the proposed registration regime.

The court held that real caution was necessary before making a class closure order against the applicants' objections. Given that the registration and class closure were not essential for facilitating a settlement and considering the likely low level of group member registration, the court deemed the proposed registration regime unlikely to be necessary for the majority of group members to receive a share of any settlement or judgment. Furthermore, the relationship between the respondents and group members was that of trustee and beneficiary, which influenced the court's decision.

Ultimately, the court dismissed the application for registration and class closure orders, but considered the application for an opt-out mechanism to have more merit. It was deemed appropriate to dismiss that aspect of the application as well, suggesting that it would be more efficient for opt-out to occur after the pending mediation. The court ordered that the first and second respondents pay the applicants' costs of and incidental to the application.

The court's final orders were to dismiss the interlocutory application by the first and second respondents and to mandate that the first and second respondents pay the applicants' costs of and incidental to the application. This decision underscores the need for careful consideration of the implications of registration and class closure orders in class action proceedings, particularly in light of the likely engagement levels of group members and the overall costs involved.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The interlocutory application by the First and Second Respondents is dismissed.

2. The First and Second Respondents pay the Applicants’ costs of and incidental to the application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The application for orders in relation to opt out has more merit, but I considered it appropriate to dismiss that aspect of the application too. It is likely to be cheaper and more efficient if opt out is ordered to occur after the pending mediation. THE FACTS The respondents rely upon the affidavit of Natalie Tatasciore, a partner of King & Wood Mallesons (KWM), one of the partners with the conduct of the proceeding for the respondents, sworn 2 April 2024. Ms Tatasciore is an experienced lawyer, having been admitted in 2003 and a partner of KWM since July 2018. She is experienced in complex litigation, including in the conduct of class actions and of mediations in such proceedings. The applicants rely upon the following evidence:(a)an affidavit of Rebecca Gilsenan, a partner of Maurice Blackburn which (together with Slater & Gordon) represents the applicants in the proceeding, affirmed 28 March 2024. Ms Gilsenan is an experienced lawyer, with lengthy experience in class action litigation, having practised principally in class action litigation since 1999, and having been a partner in the firm’s Class Actions division since 2005 and the National Head of the Class Actions division of the firm since November 2023; and(a)an affidavit of Emma Pelka-Caven, a solicitor in the employ of Slater & Gordon which (together with Maurice Blackburn) represents the applicants in the proceeding, affirmed 28 March 2024. She is an experienced lawyer, with experience in class action litigation, having been admitted in 2005, a Practice Group leader in the Class Actions department of Slater & Gordon since November 2018 and the Head of that department since July 2022. None of the deponents were cross-examined. The number of group members Based upon an expert’s report, Ms Pelka-Caven estimated that there are approximately 2 million to 2.2 million persons who were members of the Impugned Products over the relevant periods. However, she said that limitations in that estimate mean that there might be substantially more group members than that. The respondents referred to the applicants’ estimate but did not confirm its accuracy or provide an alternative estimate. For the purposes of the application I accept that there are approximately two million group members.Presently registered group members Ms Tatasciore stated, based upon an earlier affidavit of Ms Gilsenan, that there are at least 13,691 potential group members who have provided their details to the solicitors for the applicants, comprising:(a)3,382 persons who have retained Maurice Blackburn. According to the applicants, all of those persons have provided their contact details and all but approximately 500 of them have provided information as to the superannuation product of which they were a member during the Relevant Periods; and(b)10,309 persons who have registered with Slater & Gordon. According to the applicants, those persons have only provided their contact details and no other information. I accept that evidence.The adequacy of the respondents’ records

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I am not persuaded that it is appropriate to require the applicants to spend substantial money now on providing an opt out notice to group members when there is a chance that the case will resolve at mediation. If the proceeding does settle at mediation there will be a substantial saving by combining the opt out notice with the notice of proposed settlement. And if it does not settle at mediation there will be ample time to send an opt out notice to group members well prior to trial. For example, the opt out notice could be sent out in, say, December 2025, with group members being required to opt out by a deadline of mid-February 2025.CONCLUSION Accordingly I made orders to dismiss the application and order the first and second respondents to pay the applicants’ costs of and incidental to the application. The other respondents did not seek a costs order.OTHER MATTERS I listed a case management hearing for 9 May 2024 for the purposes of:(a)deciding whether it is appropriate to direct that Maurice Blackburn and Slater & Gordon provide to the respondents, for the purposes of mediation, the information provided to them by the 13,691 group members that have registered with them. My present view, subject to hearing further from the parties, is that it is appropriate to do so on a confidential basis for the purposes of mediation, and subject to an undertaking that the respondents will not contact those group members for the purposes of the proceeding. It may also be appropriate to direct Maurice Blackburn and Slater & Gordon to make attempts to gather further information from those group members for provision to the respondents for the purposes of mediation; and(b)deciding whether it is appropriate to direct the respondents to provide Maurice Blackburn and Slater & Gordon with information relevant to the group member losses for the purposes of the mediation. This issue has been a matter of contention between the parties for a long time, and it may be appropriate to refer the issue to a referee or for the Court to appoint an expert to prepare a report for the purposes of mediation only.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Tatasciore stated that the respondents are not opposed to structuring the registration process so as to allow group members who have not registered by the proposed 6 September 2024 deadline a further opportunity to do so after any settlement is reached, although she said that would be “subject to the terms of any settlement agreement” which carried with it some uncertainty. I accept that evidence.The likely low level of registration Ms Pelka-Caven stated that a feature of the superannuation industry is that superannuation fund members have relatively low engagement in relation to their superannuation. She relied on several documents in support of that statement:(a)an internal memorandum of the respondents dated October 2009 to the directors of ASL titled “Use of General Purpose Reserves – Employee Brochure”, which suggested that the expected response rate to communications to members was 1-2%;(b)an internal memorandum of the respondents dated September 2012 to the directors of ASL titled “Personalised Member Benefit Reporting Initiative – Status Update”, which discussed the results of that ASL initiative which included the distribution of 900,000 personalised documents to the members of Flexible Lifetime Super and AMP Flexible Super (both Impugned Products). A listed goal of the initiative was to improve the engagement of members with their superannuation. As at the date of the memorandum 4.51% of the 514,859 members who had been mailed a report were considered to be “engaged” under the KPIs set for the initiative; and(c)the 2018 Productivity Commission report titled “Superannuation: Assessing Efficiency and Competitiveness” (December 2018 p18) which found: Some members are highly engaged with the super system – actively comparing products or opening SMSFs. But most are not. Many members simply default, and rely on their funds to manage their super for them. Levels of engagement are especially low among the young and members with low balances.…Low member engagement is not necessarily a problem. For many members, it is rational. Engaging takes time and effort, and trustees are charged with acting on members’ behalf and in their best interests. Indeed, low engagement is to be expected in a compulsory and complex system that covers the bulk of the population. In some cases, disengagement can also be a consequence of cognitive constraints and behavioural biases such as myopia, loss aversion, and a tendency to procrastinate.(Emphasis added.) Nothing in Ms Tatasciore’s evidence or the respondents’ submissions contradicted Ms Pelka-Caven’s evidence about the likely low level of engagement of superannuation fund members in relation to their superannuation. I accept that evidence. Ms Pelka-Caven also gave evidence in relation to the opt out rates in three superannuation class actions brought by Slater & Gordon, being:(a)Tracy Ghee v BT Funds Management Limited & Anor (VID 962 of 2019) (BT Funds Class Action), a class action on behalf of members in two superannuation funds of which the first respondent, BT Funds Management Limited, was the trustee. She stated that in this case the opt out notice was sent to a total of 78,739 group members by a variety of distribution methods including email and post. Only 86 group members opted out, which represented only 0.11% of the class; (b)Keith Kayler-Thomson & Ors v Colonial First State Investments Limited & Ors (VID 1313 of 2018), a class action on behalf of members in the respondents’ superannuation funds. In this case the opt out notice was sent to a total of 731,246 group members by email, post, and SMS. Only 657 group members opted out, which represented 0.09% of the class; and(c)Marcel Eugene Krieger & Anor v Colonial First State Investments Limited (VID 1141 of 2019) (Colonial First State Fees Class Action), a class action on behalf of members in the respondent’s superannuation fund. In this case the opt out notice was sent to a total of 395,454 group members by email and post. Only 815 group members opted out, which represented 0.21% of the class.