Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd v Victoria

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GLEESON CJ,
GAUDRON, GUMMOW, KIRBY, HAYNE AND CALLINAN JJ

MOBIL OIL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD  PLAINTIFF

AND

THE STATE OF VICTORIA & ANOR  DEFENDANTS

Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd v Victoria [2002] HCA 27

26 June 2002
M141/2000

ORDER

Each of the demurrers to the amended statement of claim is allowed with costs.

Representation:

D F Jackson QC with G R Kennett for the plaintiff (instructed by Blake Dawson Waldron)

D Graham QC, Solicitor-General for the State of Victoria with C M Kenny for the first defendant (instructed by Victorian Government Solicitor)

J B R Beach QC with B F Quinn and L M Nichols for the second defendant (instructed by Slater & Gordon)

Interveners:

D M J Bennett QC, Solicitor-General of the Commonwealth with K L Eastman and G A Hill intervening on behalf of the Attorney-General of the Commonwealth (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

B M Selway QC, Solicitor-General for the State of South Australia with P S Psaltis intervening on behalf of the Attorney-General for the State of South Australia (instructed by Crown Solicitor for the State of South Australia)

M G Sexton SC, Solicitor-General for the State of New South Wales with M J Leeming intervening on behalf of the Attorney-General for the State of New South Wales (instructed by Crown Solicitor for the State of New South Wales)

R M Mitchell intervening on behalf of the Attorney-General for the State of Western Australia (instructed by Crown Solicitor for the State of Western Australia)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GLEESON CJ. Demurrers by each of two defendants to an Amended Statement of Claim were set down for hearing before a Full Court. The plaintiff, Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd ("Mobil"), commenced an action in this Court seeking a declaration that the provisions of Pt 4A of the Supreme Court Act 1986 (Vic), which were inserted by the Courts and Tribunals Legislation(Miscellaneous Amendments) Act 2000 (Vic), are beyond the legislative power of the Parliament of Victoria and are invalid. Two grounds of invalidity were advanced. They were that the provisions:

    (a)exceed the territorial limits on the legislative power of the State arising under the Constitution or otherwise; and

    (b)are inconsistent with the requirements for the exercise of judicial power by the Supreme Court arising under the Constitution.

  2. The essential ground of each demurrer is that Pt 4A is within the legislative power of the Victorian Parliament and is valid. 

  3. Part 4A provides for the commencement and conduct of group proceedings.  Mobil, a company incorporated in Victoria, is the defendant in group proceedings commenced in the Supreme Court of Victoria by Schutt Flying Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd ("Schutt").  The second defendant in the action in this Court was later substituted for Schutt as plaintiff in the group proceedings.  The group proceedings arose out of the manufacture in Victoria, by Mobil, of allegedly contaminated aviation fuel, and the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd v Victoria and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] HCA 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd ("Mobil") sought a declaration from the High Court of Australia that section 13 of the Courts and Tribunals Legislation (Miscellaneous Amendments) Act 2000 (Vic) was invalid. This section inserted Part 4A into the Supreme Court Act 1986 (Vic), which provided for the commencement and conduct of "group proceedings" in the Supreme Court of Victoria. Mobil's challenge arose in the context of a group proceeding commenced by Tasfast Air Freight Pty Ltd (formerly Schutt Flying Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd) against Mobil, alleging breaches of contract and negligence in relation to the manufacture and supply of aviation fuel.

The High Court was required to determine several significant legal issues. Firstly, it had to consider whether the Victorian Parliament possessed the legislative power to enact a law providing for group proceedings that could bind unaware claimants in other Australian States, and whether such a law offended the territorial limitations of State legislative power. Secondly, the Court was tasked with examining whether the operation of these State group proceedings involved an impermissible exercise of the judicial power of the Commonwealth, specifically whether a judgment in such a proceeding constituted a "judgment, decree, order or sentence" within the meaning of section 73 of the Constitution, and if the proceedings were otherwise incompatible with Chapter III of the Constitution.

The Court's reasoning focused on the constitutional division of powers between the Commonwealth and the States. It held that a State's legislative power must be consistent with the legislative powers of other States and the Commonwealth. The Court found that the impugned provisions of the Victorian Act, which purported to regulate proceedings involving parties and circumstances extending beyond Victoria, exceeded the territorial limits of the Victorian Parliament's legislative authority. The Court concluded that the State legislation, in its attempt to bind individuals and claims originating outside Victoria, encroached upon the legislative powers of other States and potentially the Commonwealth, and was therefore invalid.

Consequently, each of the demurrers to Mobil's amended statement of claim was allowed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Each of the demurrers to the amended statement of claim is allowed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

It will not be a sufficient answer to a challenge to the constitutionality of a State law that the purported repository of power is a court which can be assumed to exercise the jurisdiction conferred upon it properly and in accordance with rules laid down by, or under, a statute or in accordance with the rules of the common law or equity. Where a challenge is made, there is no alternative but to measure the impugned law against the Constitution and its express provisions and implications that divide lawmaking power in Australia. In a federal nation, a State's legislative power must necessarily adapt to, and be consistent with, the legislative powers of the other States, as well as of the Commonwealth.The facts and the proceedings Pursuant to the Constitution[82], Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd ("Mobil") has commenced proceedings in this Court. It seeks declaratory relief that s 13 of the Courts and Tribunals Legislation (Miscellaneous Amendments) Act 2000 (Vic) ("the amending Act") is beyond the legislative power of the Parliament of Victoria and therefore invalid. That section inserted Pt 4A into the Supreme Court Act 1986 (Vic) ("the Act"). That Part provides for the commencement and conduct of "group proceedings" in the Supreme Court of Victoria ("the Supreme Court").[82]Constitution, s 76(i). Prior to the commencement of the amending Act, a predecessor to Tasfast Air Freight Pty Ltd ("Tasfast") in the litigation had begun proceedings in the Supreme Court, pursuant to Order 18A of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 1996 (Vic). That Order permitted and regulated "group proceedings". The validity of the Order, within the rule-making power under the Act[83], was challenged by Mobil. It was upheld by the Court of Appeal of Victoria[84]. However, the Court of Appeal was divided on the point[85].[83]s 25.[84]Schutt Flying Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd v Mobil Oil Australia Ltd (2000) 1 VR 545.[85]Ormiston, Phillips and Charles JJA; Winneke P and Brooking JA dissenting. Subsequently, the Parliament of Victoria enacted the amending Act introducing Pt 4A into the Act. It did so in response to an earlier suggestion by the judges of the Supreme Court that Parliament should legislate for group proceedings along the lines of Pt IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)[86]. An application for special leave to appeal to this Court from the Court of Appeal's judgment was initiated. However, before it could be heard, and ostensibly to set at rest the issue of validity upon which the Court of Appeal had differed[87], the amending Act was brought into effect. It provided that the new Part would be deemed to have commenced on 1 January 2000[88]. This was some time prior to the day on which Tasfast's statement of claim was filed in the Supreme Court. That process asserted breaches of contract and negligence by Mobil in connection with aviation fuel manufactured by it and supplied to numerous persons in Victoria, New South Wales, Queensland, the Australian Capital Territory and elsewhere in Australia. It was accepted that, if valid, the Act, as amended, would authorise the continuance of Tasfast's proceedings as "group proceedings" in the Supreme Court within Pt 4A of the Act. To that end, Mobil initiated its action in this Court seeking a declaration of invalidity of the amending Act. It discontinued its application for special leave to appeal concerned with the validity of O 18A. [86]Explained by Brooking JA in Schutt (2000) 1 VR 545 at 549 [9]. See also at 548 [7] per Winneke P.[87]Victoria, Legislative Assembly, Parliamentary Debates (Hansard), 31 October 2000 at 1252.[88]The Act, s 33ZK.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GLEESON CJ GAUDRON, GUMMOW AND HAYNE JJ (dissent) KIRBY J (dissent)
The second ground of challenge to the validity of the legislation also fails.Conclusion Each demurrer should be allowed with costs. Section 13 of the Courts and Tribunals Legislation (Miscellaneous Amendments) Act 2000 (Vic) ("the Courts Legislation Amendment Act") amended the Supreme Court Act 1986 (Vic) by inserting, as Pt 4A of the latter Act, provisions governing "group proceedings" in the Supreme Court of Victoria. Mobil Oil Australia Pty Ltd ("Mobil"), the plaintiff in this Court, alleges that the enactment of s 13 of the Courts Legislation Amendment Act was beyond the legislative power of the Parliament of Victoria and invalid. For the reasons that follow, that contention should be rejected.The proceedings in the Supreme Court and in this Court In January 2000, Schutt Flying Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd ("Schutt") commenced a proceeding in the Supreme Court of Victoria as plaintiff against Mobil as defendant. Mobil is incorporated in Victoria and argument of the matter in this Court proceeded on the basis that the writ in the Supreme Court proceeding had been served on Mobil in Victoria. Schutt's action against Mobil was brought as a group proceeding under O 18A of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 1996 ("the 1996 Victorian Rules"), it being alleged that seven or more persons had claims against Mobil which were claims arising out of the same or similar circumstances and giving rise to a substantial common question of law or fact. Schutt alleged breach of contract and negligence by Mobil in connection with aviation fuel manufactured by it (in Victoria) and supplied to numerous persons at various places in Victoria, New South Wales, Queensland, the Australian Capital Territory and other, unspecified, places in Australia. Schutt commenced the proceeding as representing all of those persons. Mobil challenged the validity of O 18A of the 1996 Victorian Rules. In June 2000, the Court of Appeal of Victoria, by majority (Ormiston, Phillips and Charles JJA, Winneke P and Brooking JA dissenting), held[25] that the Rules were valid. Mobil filed an application for special leave to appeal to this Court from the orders of the Court of Appeal. Its application for special leave was discontinued.[25]Schutt Flying Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd v Mobil Oil Australia Ltd (2000) 1 VR 545. After the application for special leave had been filed, the Courts Legislation Amendment Act was passed. The amendments inserting Pt 4A in the Supreme Court Act were deemed to have commenced on 1 January 2000[26]. It follows that if the relevant provisions of the Courts Legislation Amendment Act are valid, the commencement and further conduct of the proceeding brought in the Supreme Court by Schutt would be regulated by Pt 4A.[26]Courts and Tribunals Legislation (Miscellaneous Amendments) Act 2000 (Vic), s 2(2). In December 2000, an order was made in the Supreme Court that Schutt cease to be the plaintiff in the proceeding in that Court, and that Tasfast Air Freight Pty Ltd ("Tasfast") be substituted as plaintiff. Soon after that order was made, Mobil began the present action in the original jurisdiction of this Court seeking a declaration that s 13 of the Courts Legislation Amendment Act was beyond the legislative power of the Parliament of Victoria and invalid or, alternatively, a declaration that one particular provision of Pt 4A, as introduced by that amending Act (s 33ZK), was beyond power and invalid. The State of Victoria, the first defendant to the proceeding in this Court, and Tasfast, the second defendant, each demurred to Mobil's statement of claim on the ground that the impugned provisions are within the legislative power of the Victorian Parliament. Those demurrers were set down for hearing by a Full Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GLEESON CJ,