FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2021] FCA 634
File number:
VID 1252 of 2019
Judgment of:
MURPHY J
Date of judgment:
11 June 2021
Catchwords:
REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application for court approval of settlement under s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – principles relevant to settlement approval – whether the proposed settlement is fair and reasonable as between the parties – whether the proposed settlement is fair and reasonable as between group members – whether proposed settlement distribution scheme is fair and reasonable – principles relevant to approval of applicants’ legal costs – whether legal costs proposed to be charged by applicants’ solicitors are reasonable – settlement approved
Legislation:
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 33C, 33J, 33V, 33Y, 33ZB, 33ZF, 37M, 37AF, 37AG, 51A, 54A
Social Security (Administration) Act 1999 (Cth) ss 126, 135, 142 192, Parts 4, 4A
Social Security Act 1991 (Cth) ss 1222, 1223, 1229
Civil Law (Wrongs) Act 2002 (ACT) s 35
Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic) ss 72, 74, 75
Cases cited:
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Richards [2013] FCAFC 89
Blairgowrie Trading Ltd v Allco Finance Group Ltd (Recs & Mgrs Apptd) (In Liq) (No 3) [2017] FCA 330; (2017) 343 ALR 476
BMW Australia Ltd v Brewster [2019] HCA 45; (2019) 94 ALJR 51
Caltex Refineries (Qld) Pty Ltd v Stavar [2009] NSWCA 258; (2009) 75 NSWLR 649
Camilleri v The Trust Company (Nominees) Ltd [2015] FCA 1468
Chippendale v Commissioner of Taxation [1996] FCA 80; (1996) 62 FCR 347
Commissioner for State Revenue (Vic) v Royal Insurance Australia Limited [1994] HCA 61; (1994) 182 CLR 51
Commonwealth v SCI Operations Pty Ltd [1998] HCA 20; (1998) 192 CLR 285
Crimmins v Stevedoring Industry Finance Committee [1999] HCA 59; (1999) 200 CLR 1
Darwalla Milling Co Ltd v F Hoffman-La Roche (No 2) [2006] FCA 1388; (2006) 236 ALR 322
David Securities Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [1992] HCA 48; (1992) 175 CLR 353
Griffiths v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [1994] FCA 402; (1994) 123 ALR 111
Harris v Digital Pulse Pty Ltd [2003] NSWCA 10; (2003) 56 NSWLR 298
Kelly v Willmott Forests Ltd (in liquidation) (No 4) [2016] FCA 323; (2016) 335 ALR 439
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] FCA 634
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court had to determine whether the settlement was fair and reasonable, both between the applicants and group members on the one hand, and the Commonwealth on the other, and between the different categories of group members. The Court also needed to consider whether the legal costs proposed to be charged by the applicants’ solicitors were reasonable. After considering the evidence and submissions, the Court concluded that the settlement was fair and reasonable inter partes and that the proposed legal costs were reasonable. The Court approved the settlement and made orders for its implementation, including extending the time for group members to opt out of the proceeding.
The Court also made orders approving the applicants’ legal costs and the costs of the settlement administrator, subject to future review. The Court held that the settlement was a significant achievement that would provide substantial benefits to the group members, who had suffered considerable hardship and distress as a result of the Commonwealth’s unlawful conduct. The settlement represented a just and efficient resolution of the representative proceeding, and the Court was satisfied that the proposed settlement was fair and reasonable both inter partes and inter se. The Court approved the settlement and made orders for its implementation, including orders extending the time for group members to opt out of the proceeding, approving the applicants’ legal costs, and approving the costs of the settlement administrator.
Orders
Orders of the court
Settlement Approval
1. The Respondent provides an undertaking to the Court in the form set out at Annexure A to these orders.
2. Upon the Respondent giving the undertaking in Annexure A to these orders, pursuant to ss 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act), the settlement of the proceeding upon the terms set out in the Deed of Settlement between the Applicants, the Respondent and Gordon Legal exhibited as “AG-1” to the Affidavit of Andrew Grech dated 22 April 2021 (Settlement Deed), together with the Settlement Distribution Scheme Implementation Plan in Annexure B to these orders (Implementation Plan), be approved subject to the following:
(a) the definition of Scheme Claimant, as contained in the Settlement Deed, is amended to mean “a Category 2 Group Member or an Eligible Category 3 Group Member for whom the Respondent has current bank account details or preferred payment destination at the date set out in or determined under the Implementation Plan”; and
(b) the Framework of Settlement Distribution Scheme at Annexure B to the Settlement Deed and the Implementation Plan (together “the Scheme”) are to be read together. To the extent of any inconsistency between the Framework of Settlement Distribution Scheme and the Implementation Plan (as amended in accordance with order 2 above), the Implementation Plan shall prevail over the Framework of Settlement Distribution Scheme.
3. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Act, the Court authorises the Applicants nunc pro tunc to enter into and give effect to the Settlement Deed and the Scheme for and on behalf of the group members.
4. Pursuant to s 33ZB of the Act the persons affected and bound by the settlement of the proceeding are the Applicants, the group members, and the Respondent.
Opt Out for Objecting Group Members
5. Pursuant to ss 33J and 33ZF of the Act, the date by which any group member, who pursuant to Order 17 of the Orders of 23 December 2020 filed a Notice of Objection with the Court on or before 4.00 pm on 5 May 2021 in respect of the proposed settlement of the proceeding (the Objecting Group Members), may opt out of the proceeding be extended to 4.00 pm AEST on 17 September 2021.
6. Pursuant to s 33Y(2) of the Act, the form and content of the notice set out in Annexure D (Further Opt Out Notice) is approved as that by which Objecting Group Members are to be given notice of their extended period to opt out of the proceeding.
7. Pursuant to s 33Y(3) of the Act, the Further Opt Out Notice is to be given to the Objecting Group Members by 6 August 2021 according to the following procedure:
(a) using its best endeavours the Respondent shall use its own resources to identify the names of all of the Objecting Group Members, the MyGov account details of those Objecting Group Members who have a MyGov account linked to Services Australia, and their last known contact details held by the Respondent including as identified on the Objecting Group Members’ Notice of Objection;
(b) where possible the Respondent shall cause the Further Opt Out Notice to be sent to each Objecting Group Member’s MyGov Account Inbox which is linked to Services Australia; and
(c) where an Objecting Group Member does not have a MyGov account Inbox linked to Services Australia the Respondent will use its best endeavours to send the Further Opt Out Notice by mail to the Objecting Group Member’s last known address.
8. The costs incurred by the Respondent of the procedure referred to in Order 7 above shall be borne by the Respondent, and otherwise the costs of each party of and incidental to the procedure set out in Order 7 above shall be costs in the cause. For the avoidance of doubt, reasonable work done in answering enquiries by class members and members of the public in relation to the Further Opt Out Notice and/or the proceeding generally is work incidental to Order 5 above.
9. The Further Opt Out Notice may be amended by the Applicants’ or Respondent’s solicitors before it is published in order to correct any website or email address or telephone number or other non-substantive error.
10. If the solicitors for any party receive, on or before 4.00 pm AEST on 17 September 2021, a notice purporting to be an opt out notice in response to the Further Opt Out Notice completed by any Objecting Group Member, the solicitors shall file the notice in the Victoria District Registry of the Court within three business days, and the notice shall be treated as an opt out notice received by the Court at the time it was received by the solicitors.
11. The Applicants’ solicitors and the Respondent’s solicitors have leave to inspect the Court file and copy any such opt out notices filed.
Declarations
12. The Court hereby makes the declarations in the form of Annexure C to these orders.
Costs of the proceeding to the date of settlement approval
13. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Act, so much of the Deduction Amount payable to Gordon Legal under the Settlement Deed as comprises legal costs pursuant to clause 2.8.4.a of the Settlement Deed in respect of conduct of the proceeding on behalf of the Applicants and group members be approved in the amount of $8,413,795.71.
Gordon Legal’s future costs for performing its functions under the Scheme
14. The reference to the Costs Referee pursuant to Order 11 of the orders made 23 December 2020 be amended to include the following:
(a) as soon as practicable the Costs Referee shall confer with Gordon Legal, and any other person the Costs Referee considers appropriate, and then determine the best method:
(i) to assess the reasonableness and proportionality of Gordon Legal’s costs for performing its functions under the Scheme on an ongoing basis, and for such costs to be considered for approval by the Court and paid at either monthly or two monthly intervals as the Costs Referee determines; and
(ii) to permit the Costs Referee to make an updated and more accurate estimate of Gordon Legal’s future reasonable and proportionate costs for performing its functions under the Scheme, intended to assist the Court to consider approval of a lump sum amount for future costs so that the distribution of settlement monies to the Scheme Claimants can proceed without material delay;
(b) the Costs Referee shall provide short reports to the Court providing her opinion as to the reasonableness and proportionality of the:
(i) costs in the invoices rendered by Gordon Legal for the firm’s ongoing work;
(ii) updated estimate of Gordon Legal’s future costs in a lump sum amount;
and the Court will decide whether to approve such costs on the papers; and
(c) the Costs Referee or Gordon Legal may seek urgent directions from the Court in relation to any issue which arises.
15. Following receipt and consideration of the Costs Referee’s reports as to Gordon Legal’s costs for performing its functions under the Scheme, pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Act:
(a) so much of the Deduction Amount payable to Gordon Legal under the Settlement Deed as comprises Gordon Legal’s costs pursuant to clause 2.8.4.b of the Settlement Deed in respect of conducting its functions under the Scheme, and in respect to the Costs Referee’s reasonable costs in performing her role and functions after the conclusion of the settlement approval hearing, will be approved and fixed by the Court; and
(b) so much of the Deduction Amount payable to Gordon Legal under the Settlement Deed as comprises legal costs pursuant to clause 2.8.4.a of the Settlement Deed in respect to the Contradictor’s reasonable costs in performing her role and functions after the conclusion of the settlement approval hearing, will be approved and fixed by the Court.
16. Within 7 days of the date of completion of Phase 3 of the Scheme (Assessment, Notification, and Distribution of Entitlements) Gordon Legal will file a confidential costs report with the Costs Referee and the Court for the purpose of reporting on the actual costs incurred in respect of it performing its functions under the Scheme.
Other orders
17. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, the parties each have leave to apply to the Court for orders in respect of any issue arising in relation to the administration of the Settlement Deed or the Scheme.
18. All inter partes costs orders in the proceeding and in proceeding VID 648/2020 be vacated.
19. Upon the Court being informed by the Scheme Assurer that all distributions under the Scheme have been completed, the proceeding be dismissed with no further order as to costs.
Confidentiality
20. Pursuant to s 37AF(1)(b) of the Act, on the ground that the order is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, and until further order, the evidence identified in Annexures E and F to these orders not be published or disclosed without the prior leave of the Court to any person or entity other than the Applicants, their respective legal advisers, the Judge with the carriage of the matter from time to time and officers of the Court to whom it is necessary to disclose the evidence.
21. The parties have liberty to apply.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
ANNEXURE A - RESPONDENT’S UNDERTAKING
The respondent undertakes to the Court that the intended operation and interpretation of clauses 2.2.1 and 2.2.2 of the Settlement Deed, when read together, is that:
(a) Group Members are precluded from objecting to or challenging a debt decision that was the subject of the proceeding if the nature of their objection or challenge is of the same nature as the claims made in the proceeding; however,
(b) Group Members are not precluded from enquiring about, objecting to or challenging (including by exercising their statutory rights of review) debt decisions which were the subject of the proceeding if the basis of their enquiry, objection or challenge is different in nature to the claims made in the proceedings.
ANNEXURE B
ANNEXURE C - DECLARATIONS
In respect of asserted overpayment debts raised against the applicants and group members, the Court declares that:
1. A decision that an applicant or group member owed the Commonwealth a debt under s 1223 of the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth), because the person had obtained the benefit of a social security payment to which they were not entitled, was not validly made where all of the following apply:
(a) the rate of the social security payment for the applicant or group member was dependent upon the person’s ordinary income on a fortnightly basis;
(b) the Commonwealth based its decision on an assumption (Assumption) that the person’s ordinary income for a fortnight (relevant fortnight) was greater than the amount of ordinary income that the person had reported to the Commonwealth for the relevant fortnight;
(c) the Commonwealth relied solely on PAYG employment income data from the Australian Taxation Office (ATO data) to make the Assumption and did not have evidence that the person was likely to have earned employment income at a constant fortnightly rate during a period covered by the ATO data, or other evidence to support the Assumption; and
(d) the Assumption was based on an assessment of the person’s employment income for the relevant fortnight derived from averaging the ATO data, for a longer period that included the relevant fortnight, as if the person had earned income at a constant rate during that period.
ANNEXURE D
ANNEXURE E
ANNEXURE F
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In summary, the proposed settlement provides that the Commonwealth will, without admission of liability:(a) consent to the Court making declarations (Declarations) which, in effect, provide that any decision by the Commonwealth:(i) that an applicant or group member owed a debt under s 1223 of the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth) (the SSA) because the person had obtained the benefit of a social security payment to which they were not entitled, where the Commonwealth relied solely on income averaging from ATO data; and (ii) did not have other evidence that the person was likely to have earned employment income at a constant fortnightly rate during the period covered by the ATO income information;was not validly made; (b) not raise, demand or recover from any Category 1 Group Member or Category 2 Group Member (which categories I later explain) any invalid debt as described in the Declarations; and(c) pay $112 million inclusive of legal costs (Settlement Sum), which after deduction of Court-approved legal costs (Distribution Sum), is to be distributed to Category 2 Group Members and Eligible Category 3 Group Members pursuant to a Court-approved Settlement Distribution Scheme (SDS). The proposed settlement is on top of an earlier announced Commonwealth program under which it withdrew approximately $1.763 billion in debts based on income averaging from ATO data and promised to refund approximately $751 million it had received or recovered from social security recipients in relation to such debts (Commonwealth-recovered amounts). The materials indicate that the Commonwealth maintained the Robodebt system in the face of approximately 29 decisions of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) up to 30 May 2017, which rejected income averaging based on ATO data as a basis for asserting a social security debt. Then, on 27 November 2019, in the “test case” of Amato v The Commonwealth of Australia (Federal Court VID611/2019), the Commonwealth consented to declarations to the effect that the debt in that case, raised based on income averaging from ATO data, was invalid. The financial hardship and distress caused to so many people could have been avoided had the Commonwealth paid heed to the AAT decisions, or if it disagreed with them appealed them to a court so the question as to the legality of raising debts based on income averaging from ATO data could be finally decided. The result has been that, on top of the financial hardship, distress and anxiety caused to a great many vulnerable people and the costs to the public purse of a huge Commonwealth program to identify the debts to be withdrawn and to refund the Commonwealth-recovered amounts, the Commonwealth has now agreed to pay a further $112 million; to meet the substantial costs of the settlement distribution scheme to categorise eligible group members and to pay them a share of that settlement; and to meet its own significant legal costs. That has resulted in a huge waste of public money. For the reasons I explain, in my view it is clear that the proposed settlement is fair and reasonable inter partes, that is, between the applicants and group members on the one hand, and the Commonwealth on the other. I was though troubled as to whether the proposed settlement was fair and reasonable inter se, that is, as between the different categories of group members.