The Owners - Strata Plan 872321 v 3A Composites GmbH (No 9)

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

The Owners – Strata Plan 872321 v 3A Composites GmbH (No 9) [2025] FCA 1108

File number(s): NSD 215 of 2019
Judgment of: ANDERSON J
Date of judgment: 10 September 2025
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application for extension of time to opt out of representative proceedings under s 33J and/or 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – where applicant may be or has a bona fide claim to be a group member – where applicant sought to opt out of representative proceedings to pursue a cross-claim in the Supreme Court of New South Wales – where full extent of the claim against the applicant in the Supreme Court of New South Wales was not clear until after the date for opt out – where initial trial in representative proceedings has been heard with judgment now reserved – extension of time granted.
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Building Products (Safety) Act 2017 (NSW)

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)

Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW)

Strata Schemes Development Act 2015 (NSW)

Cases cited:

Davaria Pty Ltd v 7-Eleven Stores Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 1234

Dyczynski v Gibson (2020) 280 FCR 583; [2020] FCAFC 120

Fuller v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd [2025] VSC 160

Matheson Property Group Pty Ltd (Trustee) v Virgin Australia Holding Ltd (2022) 165 ACSR 550; [2022] FCA 1243

Muswellbrook Shire Council v The Royal Bank of ScotlandNV [2016] FCA 819

Prygodicz v Commonwealth (No 2) (2021) 173 ALD 277; [2021] FCA 634

Strata Plan 88695 v Metlege [2025] NSWSC 535

Wright Rubber Products Pty Ltd v Bayer AG [2010] FCAFC 85

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Number of paragraphs: 111
Date of hearing: 26 August 2025
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr T Bagley
Solicitor for the Applicant: Williams Roberts Lawyers
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr B Dziubinski
Solicitor for the First Respondent: King & Wood Mallesons
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr S Adair with Mr M Kingsland
Solicitor for the Respondents: Wotton Kearney
Counsel for Tiptell Pty Ltd Mr F Hicks SC with Mr A Girgis
Solicitor for Tiptell Pty Ltd Hamilton Locke

ORDERS

NSD 215 of 2019
BETWEEN:

THE OWNERS - STRATA PLAN NO 87231

Applicant

AND:

3A COMPOSITES GMBH

First Respondent

HALIFAX VOGEL GROUP PTY LIMITED

Second Respondent

IN THE INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION

BETWEEN

TIPTELL PTY LTD

Interested Party

AND

THE OWNERS - STRATA PLAN NO 87231

Applicant

3A COMPOSITES GMBH

First Respondent

HALIFAX VOGEL GROUP PTY LIMITED

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

ANDERSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 SEPTEMBER 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to s 33J(3) and/or s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), the time for Tiptell Pty Ltd (Tiptell) to opt out of this representative proceeding is extended to 14 days from the date of these orders.

2.Tiptell will pay the Applicant’s and the Respondents’ costs of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Owners - Strata Plan 872321 v 3A Composites GmbH (No 9) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 1108
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the applicant sought an extension of time to opt out of the representative proceeding under sections 33J and 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The dispute arose from claims related to the alleged defective cladding on certain buildings, specifically relating to the compliance of the cladding with the acceptable quality guarantee under the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). The parties involved in the case are The Owners – Strata Plan 872321 as the applicant, 3A Composites GmbH as the first respondent, HVG as the second respondent, and Tiptell Pty Ltd as the third respondent.

The central legal issues before the court were whether Tiptell had a bona fide claim to be a group member and, if so, whether the court should grant an extension of time for Tiptell to opt out of the representative proceeding. This decision was crucial as it would determine whether Tiptell could pursue its cross-claim in the Supreme Court of New South Wales rather than participating in the ongoing representative proceeding.

The court examined the evidence presented and concluded that there was a sufficient basis to find that Tiptell may be a group member within the meaning of the relevant statute. The court noted that determining the final status of Tiptell as a group member was not necessary for the interlocutory application and that it was sufficient for Tiptell to establish a prima facie case that it may be a group member or has a bona fide claim to be one. Given that the full extent of the claim against Tiptell in the Supreme Court of New South Wales was not clear until after the date for opting out, and considering the complex issues involved, the court granted the extension of time.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the fact that determining Tiptell's status as a group member involved complex factual and legal issues that were not easily resolved on an interlocutory application. By granting the extension, the court allowed Tiptell the opportunity to pursue its cross-claim in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The final orders included an extension of time for Tiptell to opt out of the representative proceeding and a directive that Tiptell would pay the costs of the application.

In summary, the court granted the extension of time for Tiptell to opt out of the representative proceeding, allowing it to pursue its cross-claim in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. This decision was based on the court's finding that Tiptell had a prima facie claim to be a group member and that the complex issues surrounding its status did not need to be finally determined at that stage of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 33J(3) and/or s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), the time for Tiptell Pty Ltd (Tiptell) to opt out of this representative proceeding is extended to 14 days from the date of these orders.

2. Tiptell will pay the Applicant’s and the Respondents’ costs of this application, to be assessed by a Registrar of the Court on a lump sum basis, if not agreed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

HVG opposes Tiptell’s application. BACKGROUND Prior to 2012, Lichaa Metlege, Mona Metlege, and Joseph Metlege (collectively, the Metleges), and Tiptell, were the registered proprietors of 8 Bourke Street, Mascot, in New South Wales. The Metleges and Tiptell, engaged Casumo to construct a 232 lot strata scheme comprising three multi storey residential and commercial buildings, known as Building A, Building B, and Building C (collectively, the Buildings). The strata plan for the Buildings was registered on 12 December 2013, as SP88695. Upon or shortly after registration of the strata plan:(a)the common property in the Buildings vested in the Plaintiff pursuant to what is now s 28 of the Strata Schemes Development Act 2015 (NSW); (b)the land was subsequently subdivided into further strata plans of subdivision numbered: SP90091 on 24 July 2024, SP90993 on 1 August 2014, SP90457 on 14 October 2014, and SP90458 on 16 October 2014; (c)the Metledges were the registered proprietors of 33 lots in the Buildings; and (d)Tiptell was the registered proprietor of 33 lots in the Buildings. Subsequently, between about 19 August 2014 and 5 November 2014 the Metledges transferred 33 lots in the Buildings to Tiptell. Tiptell subsequently disposed of the lots. The last lot was disposed of by Tiptell on about 22 August 2016. On 14 February 2019, the Applicant commenced these representative proceedings pursuant to Pt IVA of the FCA Act. On 1 July 2020, the Plaintiff filed a Summons and Technology and Construction List Statement (the First List Statement) and commenced the NSWSC Proceedings. It was alleged that Tiptell and others were liable for loss and damage attributable to, amongst other things, the existence and cost of replacing cladding. Annexure A to the First List Statement particularised the alleged cladding related defects and non-complying works in the “Common Property” in two words in paragraph 1(q): “defective cladding”. Pursuant to orders made by Wigney J on 31 August 2020 and 30 October 2020, the Applicant published notification of the proceeding and group member rights both online and in various newspapers, in 2020 and 2021. By order of 30 October 2020, the date by which any group member could file an opt out notice was 30 weeks from the “Distribution Date” of 17 November 2020. The final notice to group members identified 11 June 2021 as the last date to opt out. I heard the initial trial of this proceeding between 26 August 2024 and 3 October 2024. The initial trial heard the claims of the applicant, including, relevantly, their causes of action for damages in respect of the alleged failure of Alucobond PE and Alucobond Plus to comply with the guarantee under s 54 of the ACL. Judgment on the initial trial is presently reserved. EVIDENCE The Applicant and 3A filed no evidence in respect of Tiptell’s application.Tiptell’s evidence Tiptell relies on the affidavits of Venothan Panicker, Tiptell’s solicitor, affirmed 19 June 2025 (Panicker) and Exhibit VSP-1, 8 July 2025 (Panicker 2), and 13 August 2025 (Panicker 3).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant and 3A filed no evidence in respect of Tiptell’s application.Tiptell’s evidence Tiptell relies on the affidavits of Venothan Panicker, Tiptell’s solicitor, affirmed 19 June 2025 (Panicker) and Exhibit VSP-1, 8 July 2025 (Panicker 2), and 13 August 2025 (Panicker 3). From the commencement of the NSWSC Proceedings in 2020 to around May 2023, the proceedings were repeatedly adjourned by consent to enable negotiations for settlement to take place. There was also delay occasioned by reason of the COVID-19 restrictions which were in place at that time. Mr Panicker, on behalf of Tiptell, deposes that in the three years of negotiations, to the best of his knowledge and belief, no claim was made for the complete replacement of the Alucobond ACP’s used in the construction of the Buildings: Panicker [14] On or about 1 July 2020 and 5 February 2021, the Plaintiff served reports from Credwell Consulting Pty Ltd in relation to the “defective cladding” claim dated 25 May 2020 (the May 2020 Credwell Report) and 4 February 2021 (the February 2021 Credwell Report) respectively. These reports did not identify the cladding as Alucobond ACPs: Panicker [15]; Panicker 2 [20]-[21]. The May 2020 Credwell Report records, amongst other things, that samples taken from select locations on Building B and Building C have a polyethylene content of less than 30% and therefore are not considered a banned product in accordance with s 9(1) of the Building Products (Safety) Act 2017 (NSW): Panicker, Exhibit VSP-1, p 26. The February 2021 Credwell Report records, amongst other things, a visual inspection on select parts of the Buildings identifying where aluminium composite panels had been used: Panicker, Exhibit VSP-1, page 120. Neither the May 2020 Credwell Report, nor the February 2021 Credwell Report expressly identified the manufacturer, brand or supplier of the alleged “defective cladding”. Nor did those reports expressly state that all cladding on each of the Buildings was combustible or required remediation or replacement. On 6 December 2023, the Plaintiff served a report prepared by AE&D Fire Pty Ltd (AED) dated 6 February 2019 in relation to Building A (the AED February 2019 Report), which identified the relevant cladding as being “Alucobond PE” and “Alucobond Plus”. This was the first occasion on which the Plaintiff served any material in the NSWSC Proceedings identifying the cladding as being supplied and/or manufactured by HVG or 3A: Panicker [31]; Exhibit VSP-1, p 261; Panicker 2 [22]. Mr Panicker deposes that the conclusions in the AED February 2019 Report were based on an earlier report prepared by AED dated 31 October 2018, which was not served on Tiptell until about 8 August 2024: Panicker [32] There were then extensions of the time for the Plaintiff to serve its evidence in the NSWSC Proceedings to 29 March 2024 and then 28 June 2024. The Plaintiff failed to comply with those orders: Panicker [22] On 12 August 2024, the Plaintiff sought leave in the NSWSC Proceedings to file a proposed amended Technology and Construction List Statement (the Amended List Statement) and what is known as a “Loulach schedule” (the Loulach Schedule) in lieu of Annexure A to the First List Statement. The Loulach Schedule exceeded 6,000 pages and sought to advance approximately 4,700 items of alleged defects: Panicker [26].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the time for Tiptell to opt out of the representative proceeding should be extended to allow it to pursue a cross-claim in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.
2. Whether Tiptell has a bona fide claim to be a group member within the meaning of the 2FASOC.

Held
1. The court granted an extension of time for Tiptell to opt out of the representative proceeding to allow it to pursue a cross-claim in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.
2. The court found that Tiptell has a bona fide claim to be a group member within the meaning of the 2FASOC, subject to final determination.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Alternatively, Tiptell, HVG and 3A submit that whether Tiptell is in fact a group member is a matter which Tiptell need not demonstrate on a final basis on this interlocutory application. Consideration For the reasons that follow, it is unnecessary for me to determine on a final basis whether Tiptell is in fact a group member within the definition found in paragraph [1] of the 2FASOC. First, determining on a final basis whether Tiptell is a group member is undesirable where there is an overlap between the issues that would need to be resolved to make such a final determination, and some of the issues in the initial proceeding on which the Court is currently reserved. The questions whether (a) Tiptell has suffered loss or damage for which statutory damages or compensation is claimed as pleaded in the 2FASOC, or whether (b) the relevant Alucobond cladding in Tiptell’s case was first supplied to a “consumer” in the Relevant Period, are both bound up in the definition of the group in 2FASOC respectively. Both questions involve complex issues of fact and law which are not readily amenable for final determination on an interlocutory application such as this. Second, it is sufficient on the present application that Tiptell establish on a prima facie basis that it may be a group member or that it has a bona fide claim to be a group member: Wright at [34] (Moore J); Dyczynski at [26(a)], [226] (Murphy and Colvin JJ). I am satisfied that there is a sufficient basis for the Court to conclude on a prima facie basis that Tiptell may be a group member within the meaning of [1] of the 2FASOC, and that Tiptell has a bona fide claim, subject to final determination, that it falls within the class. Under [1] of the 2FASOC, group members are persons who, as at the date of the 2FASOC (in summary):(a)either previously owned a building situated in Australia or have previously had an ownership interest in a part of a building situated in Australia;(b)where the relevant building or part of a building is or was fitted with Alucobond ACPs;(c)have suffered loss or damage for which statutory damages or compensation is claimed, as pleaded in the 2FASOC; and(d)where the Alucobond ACPs were first supplied to a consumer in the period between 14 February 2009 and 14 February 2019. Paragraph 1(c) directs attention to [83] and [89] of the 2FASOC. [83(b)] of the 2FASOC pleads that group members have suffered loss and damage by reason of or otherwise resulting from the Alucobond cladding fitted to relevant buildings not complying with the “Acceptable Quality Guarantee”. Tiptell’s Cross Claim seeks relief against HVG in the form of a compensatory order in respect of the Plaintiff’s claim against Tiptell on the basis that HVG is directly liable to Tiptell for loss and damage allegedly occasioned to Tiptell on the basis of breaches of the acceptable quality guarantee under s 54 of the ACL. Tiptell appears to claim compensation from HVG on the basis that it acquired Alucobond cladding as a consumer and is therefore entitled to the benefit of the acceptable quality guarantee under s 54 of the ACL.