Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

Federal Court of Australia

Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia [2020] FCA 1454

File number: VID 1252 of 2019
Judgment of: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 17 September 2020
Date of publication of reasons: 8 October 2020
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to amend statement of claim to add claims for further relief – application made shortly prior to trial – purpose of pleadings – adequacy of pleading of knowledge of unlawfulness – availability of claim for aggravated damages in negligence – leave to amend allowed  
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M

Social Security (Administration) Act 1999 (Cth) s 126

Social Security Act 1991 (Cth) ss 1222A, 1223(1), 1229

Cases cited:

Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175

Barclay Mowlem Construction Ltd v Dampier Port Authority and Another [2006] WASC 281

Crump v Equine Nutrition Systems Pty Ltd [2006] NSWSC 512

Gray v Motor Accident Commission (1998) 196 CLR 1

Hunter Area Health Service v Marchlewski (2000) 51 NSWLR 268

Johnson Tiles Pty Ltd v Esso Australia Ltd [1999] FCA 1645; (2000) ATPR 41-743

Lamb v Cotogno (1987) 164 CLR 1

Thomson v STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd [2012] FCAFC 15

Uren v John Fairfax & Sons Pty Limited [1966] HCA 40; (1966) 117 CLR 118

Wickstead v Browne (1992) 30 NSWLR 1

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 64
Date of hearing: 16 September 2020
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr B Quinn QC, Mr M Guo and Mr A Roe
Solicitor for the Applicants: Gordon Legal
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr M Hodge QC, Mr N Bentley and Ms Z Maud
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

VID 1252 of 2019
BETWEEN:

KATHERINE PRYGODICZ

First Applicant

ELYANE PORTER

Second Applicant

STEVEN FRITZE (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

order made by:

MURPHY J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 SEPTEMBER 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The proceeding is listed for a case management hearing on 21 September 2020 at 9.30 am.

2.By 4.00 pm on 21 September 2020, the Respondent is to provide discovery of those documents identified in Annexure A to these orders.

3.The Applicants have leave to file and serve their second further amended statement of claim dated 14 September 2020 (2FASOC).

4.Costs reserved.

5.Liberty to apply.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

MURPHY J:

  1. In this representative proceeding the applicants, Katherine Prygodicz and others, sought leave to file a proposed Second Further Amended Statement of Claim (2FASOC).  The proceeding alleges unjust enrichment, money had and received, and negligence against the Commonwealth.  The claims are all grounded in the Commonwealth’s use of an automated system, colloquially known as ‘Robodebt’, to identify asserted overpayments of social security benefits made to social security recipients based…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1454
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia, the applicants sought leave to amend their statement of claim to include additional claims for relief. The application was made shortly before the scheduled trial. The applicants sought to include claims for aggravated damages in their negligence action, which was a matter of some debate in Australian law. The applicants also sought declarations regarding the Commonwealth's use of income information, its actions in determining and asserting debts, and its duty of care towards the applicants and group members.

The court was required to determine whether the applicants could amend their statement of claim to include claims for aggravated damages. The court considered the settled test for whether such a claim could be pleaded, and whether the claim had a reasonable prospect of success. The court also considered whether the amendment would be just and efficient, given that the same factual matters would need to be heard and determined at trial. The court concluded that it was appropriate to be cautious before exercising the discretion to refuse the amendment, and that it would be more efficient and just to determine the availability of a claim for aggravated damages at trial.

The court granted leave for the applicants to file and serve their proposed second further amended statement of claim. The court noted that the relief sought extended beyond claims for restitution or cancellation of debts, and included claims where debts were not calculated by reference to income averaging from ATO income data. The court also noted that the applicants sought declarations regarding the Commonwealth's use of income information, its actions in determining and asserting debts, and its duty of care towards the applicants and group members.

The court made several orders, including listing the proceeding for a case management hearing, requiring the respondent to provide discovery of certain documents, and granting leave for the applicants to file and serve their second further amended statement of claim. The court reserved costs and granted liberty to apply.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding is listed for a case management hearing on 21 September 2020 at 9.30 am.

2. By 4.00 pm on 21 September 2020, the Respondent is to provide discovery of those documents identified in Annexure A to these orders.

3. The Applicants have leave to file and serve their second further amended statement of claim dated 14 September 2020 (2FASOC).

4. Costs reserved.

5. Liberty to apply.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The test for whether the claim for aggravated damages can be pleaded are settled; and such a claim is maintainable unless it has no reasonable prospect of success. Some doubts have been expressed as to whether aggravated damages are available under Australian law in a negligence action: see Hunter Area Health Service v Marchlewski (2000) 51 NSWLR 268 at [110] (Mason P with whom Stein and Heydon JJA agreed); Crump v Equine Nutrition Systems Pty Ltd [2006] NSWSC 512 at [308] (Hoeben J). But the issue is a matter for full argument which I did not have the benefit of. Further, notwithstanding that the claim may be difficult or problematic, it is appropriate to be cautious before exercising the discretion to refuse to allow the claim to be pleaded when the Court will be required to hear and determine the same factual matters in relation to the claim for exemplary damages. It will be more efficient and just to determine the availability of a claim for aggravated damages in negligence at trial: see Johnson Tiles Pty Ltd v Esso Australia Ltd [1999] FCA 1645; (2000) ATPR 41-743 at [61] (Merkel J): Wickstead v Browne (1992) 30 NSWLR 1 at 5 (Kirby J) and on appeal to the High Court (1993) 10 Leg.Rep page SL 2.Conclusion For these reasons I granted leave to the applicants to file and serve the proposed 2FASOC.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The relief sought in the proceeding also extends beyond claims for restitution or cancellation of debts which were calculated by using income averaging of ATO data to claims where, in fact, the debts were not calculated by reference to income averaging from ATO income data. The two relevant categories of group members in this regard (as described in paragraph 41A of the 2FASOC) are:(a)Category 3 - being persons whose debt was initially partly or wholly determined using income averaging of ATO data but which was later recalculated by the Commonwealth based on information provided by or on behalf of a class member in a review under s 126 of the Social Security (Administration) Act 1999 (Cth) (the SS Administration Act). In relation to category 3 group members the applicants contend that, while the ultimate debt may have been lawfully raised, it was raised on the basis of information procured by unlawful means; it being ‘tainted’ by the initial calculation and assertion of a debt which would have been unlawful if imposed. The applicants contend that the threat of imposition of an unlawful debt could never constitute a legitimate means of procuring income information from a group member who would not otherwise have been required to provide it; and (b)Category 4 - being persons whose debt was wholly determined by the Commonwealth based upon income information provided by or on behalf of the class member (such as payslips and/or bank statements) in response to an Initial Letter, and not based on ATO income data. Again, the applicants contend that, while the ultimate debt was lawfully raised, it was raised on the basis of information procured by unlawful means because the process of debt raising was ‘tainted’ by the initial calculation based on ATO income averaging sent in the Initial Letter, which threatened the imposition of an unlawful debt to procure the provision of actual income information. The relief sought in the Amended Originating Application includes declarations that the Commonwealth:(a)does not have and has not had any statutory power to use any income information provided by or on behalf of an applicant or group member in response to an Initial Letter to determine or assert an Asserted Overpayment Debt;(b)acted unlawfully in using calculations or other outputs of the automated system to procure or compel the provision by an applicant or group member to the Commonwealth of income information, and/or to generate or send to any applicant or group member an Initial Letter;(c)acted unlawfully in determining and asserting against any applicant or class member any Asserted Overpayment Debt or recalculation of the debt; in requesting or demanding repayment of any Asserted Overpayment Debt or recalculation of it; and in recovering from any applicant or class member any asserted repayment debt or recalculation of it;(d)was unjustly enriched by receipt of each Asserted Overpayment Debt which it recovered and is liable to make restitution to the applicants and group members;(e)the Asserted Overpayment Debts which the Commonwealth recovered are monies had and received by the Commonwealth to the use of the applicants and group members, which the applicants and group members are entitled to have returned; and(f)owed and owes a duty of care to the applicants and group members as alleged in the statement of claim; which duty of care the Commonwealth breached in the manner alleged.