Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ
GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ

AON RISK SERVICES AUSTRALIA LIMITED  APPELLANT

AND

AUSTRALIAN NATIONAL UNIVERSITY  RESPONDENT

Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University
[2009] HCA 27
5 August 2009
C1/2009

ORDER

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside orders 2 and 3 of the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory dated 25 August 2008 and, in lieu thereof, order that:

a) The appeal be allowed.

b) The orders of Gray J made on 12 October 2007 be set aside, and in lieu thereof there be an order that the plaintiff’s application for leave to amend the further amended statement of claim be dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory

Representation

J T Gleeson SC with N J Owens for the appellant (instructed by Corrs Chambers Westgarth)

B W Walker SC with J Oakley for the respondent (instructed by Sparke Helmore)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. In November 2006, at the commencement of a four week trial of an action against its insurers and its insurance broker Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd ("Aon"), the Australian National University ("ANU") settled with the insurers and consent orders were made to give effect to the settlements.  ANU then applied for an adjournment of the trial to make substantial amendments to its statement of claim against Aon.  The circumstances are set out in detail in the joint judgment[1].  The adjournment was granted, the application for amendment was heard two weeks later, and for reasons which do not appear from the record, the primary judge did not give judgment until 12 October 2007[2].

    [1]Reasons of Gummow, Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ at [38]-[54].

  2. The reasons for judgment of the primary judge involved the following steps:

    .The decision of this Court in Queensland v J L Holdings[3] ("J L Holdings") stood as authority for the proposition that "justice is the paramount consideration" in determining the application to amend[4].

    .ANU's new case was not totally inconsistent with the case as pleaded originally.  The original pleading was widely expressed and not confined to a claim that Aon had failed to act in accordance with its instructions[5].

    .Although the explanations for delay given by counsel and the solicitor for ANU were not entirely satisfactory, it was important that the allegations raised real triable issues between ANU and Aon[6].

    .On an overall consideration of the matters put by ANU and by Aon, leave should be granted[7].

    His Honour rejected a contention by Aon that ANU was seeking a judgment against it inconsistent with the consent orders made in respect of the insurers[8].  He held that there was no abuse of process[9].  His…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National Univer... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] HCA 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal concerning an application for leave to amend a statement of claim made by the Australian National University (ANU) against Aon Risk Services Australia Limited (Aon) on the third day of a four-week trial. The dispute arose from ANU's claim for indemnity for losses suffered due to fire damage, with Aon having been joined to the proceedings for its alleged failure to arrange renewal of insurance over some of the property.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the trial judge erred in granting ANU leave to amend its statement of claim at such a late stage in the proceedings. This involved considering the principles governing amendments to pleadings, particularly in light of the objectives of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), which include the just resolution of real issues, timely disposal, and affordable cost. The Court also had to determine the relevance of the stage of proceedings, the explanation for delay, the extent of the proposed amendment, and whether the decision in *Queensland v J L Holdings Pty Ltd* should be revisited.

The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Court of Appeal and the trial judge. The Court reasoned that the objectives of the Court Procedures Rules, including the minimisation of delay and expense, were not given sufficient weight by the lower courts. While acknowledging the general principle that amendments should be allowed to decide the real issues, the Court emphasised that this discretion must be exercised in accordance with the overarching objectives of the rules, particularly when the application is made so late in the trial. The Court found that granting the amendment at that stage would cause undue prejudice and delay, outweighing the potential benefit of raising arguable issues.

Consequently, the High Court ordered that ANU's application for leave to amend its further amended statement of claim be dismissed with costs. The appeal was allowed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside orders 2 and 3 of the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory dated 25 August 2008 and, in lieu thereof, order that:

a. The appeal be allowed.

b. The orders of Gray J made on 12 October 2007 be set aside, and in lieu thereof there be an order that the plaintiff’s application for leave to amend the further amended statement of claim be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Gray J granted leave to amend[89]. Influential to his Honour's decision was that ANU sought to raise real triable issues. His Honour placed a lesser importance upon the objectives stated in the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) ("the Court Procedures Rules"), of the minimisation of delay and cost of proceedings. His Honour considered the matter to be governed by the decision in Queensland v J L Holdings Pty Ltd[90]. His Honour's decision was upheld by a majority of the Court of Appeal (Higgins CJ and Penfold J, Lander J dissenting) subject to a further order that ANU pay Aon's costs occasioned by the amendment on an indemnity basis[91].[89]The Australian National University v Chubb Insurance Company of Australia Ltd [2007] ACTSC 82.[90](1997) 189 CLR 146; [1997] HCA 1.[91]AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2008] ACTCA 13.The background to the amendments The proceedings were initially brought against Chubb Insurance Company of Australia Limited ("Chubb"), CGU Insurance Limited ("CGU") and ACE Insurance Limited ("ACE"), the insurers under a policy of insurance for the period 31 December 2002 to 31 December 2003 in the proportions, respectively, of 50 per cent, 20 per cent and 30 per cent of any loss. The property in question was listed in two Schedules – Schedule C and the Property Not Insured Schedule ("the PNI Schedule") – which had been provided to Chubb by Aon in October 2002. The Schedules were alleged to form part of the contract of insurance. At the time the proceedings were brought the insurers had each made some payments to ANU with respect to the property referred to in Schedule C. However, in their defences, filed in April 2005, Chubb and CGU alleged that ANU had declared the value of the property in Schedule C to be much less than its true value and that had they known its true value, they would have taken steps to reduce their risk. They claimed to be entitled to reduce their liability to indemnify ANU pursuant to s 28(3) of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) which provides that, in the event of a misrepresentation being made to the insurer prior to the contract of insurance being entered into, but where the insurer was not entitled to avoid the contract, the insurer's liability is reduced to the amount that would place the insurer in the position the insurer would have been in if the misrepresentation had not been made. ACE claimed to be entitled to an additional premium as a consequence of the misrepresentation. The insurers further disputed that the property listed in the PNI Schedule was the subject of the policy at all. ANU alleged that the balance due to it with respect to the property in the two Schedules was in the order of $75 million. The original claim brought by ANU against Aon was based upon a contract dated 28 June 1999, the term of which was said to have been extended until 30 June 2004. ANU alleged that the agreement required Aon to arrange for the renewal of insurance cover for the period in question for all buildings and their contents which were then the subject of insurance which was due to expire. It was alleged to be an implied term of that agreement that Aon would exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence in arranging for the renewal of the expiring cover.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ (dissent) GUMMOW, HAYNE, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ (dissent)
The above conclusion is able to be reached on the facts of this case without having regard to r 21. But r 21 strengthens the conclusion. It mandates consideration of the effect of the proposed amendment on the just resolution of the real issues in the proceeding "with minimum delay and expense". It informs both the requirements set out and the discretions conferred in rr 501 and 502.Conclusion For the preceding reasons the appeal should be allowed. I agree with the orders proposed in the joint judgment. These proceedings were commenced in December 2004 by the Australian National University ("ANU") against three insurers. It claimed an indemnity for losses it had suffered by reason of the destruction of, and damage to, buildings and their contents at its Mount Stromlo Complex by fire in January 2003. ANU's insurance broker Aon Risk Services Australia Limited ("Aon") was joined to the proceedings in June 2005. The claim against it was limited to its failure to arrange the renewal of insurance over some of the property which the insurers claimed was not the subject of insurance. Two of the insurers also claimed, in their defences filed in April 2005, to be entitled to reduce their liability to indemnify ANU with respect to the property which was insured, because the value of the property had been substantially understated by ANU. On 15 November 2006, which was the third day of a four‑week period which had been allocated for the trial of the action in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory, ANU reached a settlement with the insurers. It may be inferred that the sums secured by way of settlement did not reflect the full replacement value of the property. ANU sought an adjournment of the trial of its claim against Aon and foreshadowed an application for leave to amend that claim to allege a substantially different case. It now sought to allege that, under a different contract for services, Aon had been obliged to ascertain and declare correct values to the insurers and provide certain advices to ANU regarding insurance. Gray J granted leave to amend[89]. Influential to his Honour's decision was that ANU sought to raise real triable issues. His Honour placed a lesser importance upon the objectives stated in the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) ("the Court Procedures Rules"), of the minimisation of delay and cost of proceedings. His Honour considered the matter to be governed by the decision in Queensland v J L Holdings Pty Ltd[90]. His Honour's decision was upheld by a majority of the Court of Appeal (Higgins CJ and Penfold J, Lander J dissenting) subject to a further order that ANU pay Aon's costs occasioned by the amendment on an indemnity basis[91].[89]The Australian National University v Chubb Insurance Company of Australia Ltd [2007] ACTSC 82.[90](1997) 189 CLR 146; [1997] HCA 1.[91]AON Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2008] ACTCA 13.The background to the amendments The proceedings were initially brought against Chubb Insurance Company of Australia Limited ("Chubb"), CGU Insurance Limited ("CGU") and ACE Insurance Limited ("ACE"), the insurers under a policy of insurance for the period 31 December 2002 to 31 December 2003 in the proportions, respectively, of 50 per cent, 20 per cent and 30 per cent of any loss. The property in question was listed in two Schedules – Schedule C and the Property Not Insured Schedule ("the PNI Schedule") – which had been provided to Chubb by Aon in October 2002. The Schedules were alleged to form part of the contract of insurance.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: