Northern SEQ Distributor-Retailer Authority t/a Unitywater v Monadelphous Engineering Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Northern SEQ Distributor-Retailer Authority t/a Unitywater v Monadelphous Engineering Pty Ltd [2025] QSC 253

PARTIES:

NORTHERN SEQ DISTRIBUTOR-RETAILER AUTHORITY TRADING AS UNITYWATER (ABN 89 791 717 472)
(plaintiff)

v

MONADELPHOUS ENGINEERING PTY LTD (ABN 43 010 305 923)
(first defendant)

ACCIONA AGUA AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 128 531 742)
(second defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS 8948/22

DIVISION:

Trial division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

7 October 2025

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

29 August 2025

JUDGE:

Cooper J

ORDER:

1.   The interlocutory application filed by the first defendant on 4 July 2025 is dismissed.

2.   On the interlocutory application filed by the plaintiff on 19 August 2025, it is ordered that the following amendments made in the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim filed on 26 June 2025 take effect against the first defendant for limitation purposes from the date the proceeding commenced:

a.   paragraphs 190I(b), 190S(b)(iv), and Parts L, M and N; and

b.   to the extent they are relied upon in the claim against the first defendant, paragraphs 282 to 420.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – JOINDER OF CAUSES OF ACTION AND OF PARTIES – MATTERS RELATING TO LIMITATION PERIOD – where the plaintiff amended their claim and statement of claim – where the first defendant applied for an order that certain amendments were to take effect against the first defendant for limitation purposes from the date the amended claim and statement of claim was filed – where the plaintiff applied for an order that the amendments take effect from the date when the proceeding commenced – where r 376(4) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (‘UCPR’) permits a party to make an amendment to include a new cause of action which, whilst current at the date the proceeding was started, had ended – where, if a document is amended in accordance with the requirements of r 376(4), the amendment takes effect on and from the date of the document being amended under r 387(1) of the UCPR – whether the amendments in the amended claim and statement of claim were made in accordance with the requirements r 376(4) of the UCPR – whether, if the amendments in the amended claim and statement of claim were not made in accordance with the requirements of r 376(4), the amendments should take effect from some other time to preserve a possible limitation defence

Allonnor Pty Ltd v Doran [1998] QCA 372, cited
Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; [2009] HCA 27, cited
Brisbane Airport Corporation Pty Ltd v Arup Pty Ltd [2017] QSC 232, cited
Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541; [1996] HCA 25, cited
Draney v Barry [2002] 1 Qd R 145; [1999] QCA 491, cited
Hartnett v Hynes [2009] QSC 225, cited
Menegazzo v Pricewaterhousecoopers (A Firm) [2016] QSC 94, cited
Mokrzecki v Popham [2013] QSC 123,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Northern SEQ Distributor-Retailer Authority t/a Unitywater v... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QSC 253
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Northern SEQ Distributor-Retailer Authority t/a Unitywater, the plaintiff, filed a proceeding against Monadelphous Engineering Pty Ltd (MEPL), the first defendant, following alleged breaches of a contract concerning the upgrade of the Kawana Sewage Treatment Plant. Unitywater subsequently amended its claim and statement of claim to include new causes of action. MEPL sought an order that the amendments should take effect from the date the amended claim and statement of claim was filed for limitation purposes. Unitywater applied for an order that the amendments take effect from the date when the proceeding commenced. The court was required to decide whether the amendments in the amended claim and statement of claim were made in accordance with the requirements of rule 376(4) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) and, if not, whether the amendments should take effect from some other time to preserve a possible limitation defence.

The court held that it was appropriate for the contentious amendments to take effect against MEPL from the time the proceeding commenced. The court was satisfied that a fair trial could occur despite the time Unitywater took to make the contentious amendments. It was also satisfied that MEPL would not be unduly prejudiced if the contentious amendments were to take effect from the commencement of the proceeding. The court further found that this would not inappropriately undermine the rationales for the imposition of limitation periods. Therefore, the amendments in the amended claim and statement of claim were to take effect against MEPL for limitation purposes from the date the proceeding commenced.

The court dismissed MEPL’s application and granted the relief sought on Unitywater’s application. It ordered that the amendments in the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim filed on 26 June 2025 take effect against MEPL for limitation purposes from the date the proceeding commenced. The court also ordered that the parties were to be heard as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The interlocutory application filed by the first defendant on 4 July 2025 is dismissed.

2. On the interlocutory application filed by the plaintiff on 19 August 2025, it is ordered that the following amendments made in the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim filed on 26 June 2025 take effect against the first defendant for limitation purposes from the date the proceeding commenced:

a. paragraphs 190I(b), 190S(b)(iv), and Parts L, M and N; and

b. to the extent they are relied upon in the claim against the first defendant, paragraphs 282 to 420.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, relief should be granted in the form sought by Unitywater. MEPL’s application should be dismissed.Background to the proceeding Unitywater is a retail and distribution authority established under s 8(a) of the South East Queensland Water (Distribution and Retail restructuring) Act 2009 (Qld). On about 11 November 2016, Unitywater entered into a contract (Contract) with MEPL pursuant to which MEPL agreed to design, engineer, supply, manufacture, install, test and commission the upgrade of the Kawana Sewage Treatment Plant (Plant) at Birtinya on the Sunshine Coast. The work which MEPL performed under the Contract included the design and construction of a biological wastewater treatment process. MEPL engaged the second defendant (Acciona) to design the biological wastewater treatment process. The biological wastewater treatment process uses Moving Bed Biofilm Reactor (MBBR) technology to facilitate a biological process that treats sewage through the processes of nitrification and denitrification. The process incorporates plastic biofilm carriers (media) that support the biomass. The media provides increased surface area by which biological breakdown of the sewage constituents can occur. Commissioning of the biological wastewater treatment process commenced in September 2019. After commissioning had commenced, fragments of media installed in the MBBRs were released from the Plant on four occasions during periods of wet weather. Those releases occurred on about 18 January 2020, 20-21 September 2020, 22 March 2021, and 5 April 2021. The Plant operates under an Environmental Authority that was issued by the Department of Environment and Heritage Protection, since renamed the Department of Environment, Tourism, Science and Innovation (Department). The Department issued warnings to MEPL (in March 2020), and to Unitywater (in March 2021), for contravening conditions of the Environmental Authority by reason of the release of fragments of media from the Plant. Further, Unitywater says that from about December 2021, the Plant performed poorly in terms of its ability to achieve its nominated design capacity and to comply with ammonia limits in prescribed effluent quality criteria. On 29 March 2022, Unitywater issued a Notice of Dispute to MEPL under the Contract. The dispute was not resolved under the dispute resolution procedures prescribed by the Contract. Unitywater then commenced this proceeding on 28 July 2022 by filing its original claim and statement of claim.The effect of r 376(4) on a potential limitations defence Rule 376(1) provides:“(1) This rule applies in relation to an application, in a proceeding, for leave to make an amendment mentioned in the rule if a relevant period of limitation, current at the date the proceeding was started, has ended.” Where r 376 applies, the court may give leave to make an amendment to include a new cause of action only in the circumstances described in r 376(4):“(a) the court considers it appropriate; and (b) the new cause of action arises out of the same facts or substantially the same facts as a cause of action for which relief has already been claimed in the proceeding by the party applying for leave to make the amendment.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In summary, I do not consider that MEPL would be unduly prejudiced if the contentious amendments are to take effect from the commencement of the proceeding. Further, I do not consider that this would inappropriately undermine the various rationales for the imposition of limitation periods. To the contrary, I am satisfied that a fair trial can occur despite the time Unitywater has taken to make the contentious amendments. Overall, I consider it appropriate that the contentious amendments take effect against MEPL from the time the proceeding commenced.Conclusion For the reasons set out above, I will grant the relief sought on Unitywater’s application. MEPL’s application will be dismissed. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, Unitywater pleads that MEPL’s breaches arising from the PLST Allegations caused it loss or damage because of the need to design and construct a balance tank to achieve the design treatment capacity of 200,000 EP and ensure compliance with the Environmental Authority and the EP Act.[45][45]2FASOC, paragraphs 277 and 412(a).Consideration As Unitywater accepts, the PLST Allegations plead new material facts; specifically, the design assumption concerning the removal of organic loads by the PLST, the alleged deficiency in that design assumption, the consequences of that design deficiency, and MEPL’s responsibility under the Contract and in negligence for the consequences of that design deficiency. MEPL submits that the PLST Allegations are unconnected to allegations in the earlier pleading about problems with the biomass on the media in the MBBRs. Although the PLST forms part of the overall sewage treatment process, it does not contain the media which is the subject of complaint in the earlier pleading. It is a separate piece of equipment which performs a different part of the treatment process to the MBBRs. Consequently, MEPL submits that new causes of action pleaded by the PLST Allegations depend upon establishing that the MBBRs are receiving a higher level of organic loads than intended, and this higher than intended level of organic loads is the reason the Plant is not achieving the design treatment capacity of 200,000 EP and not complying with the effluent quality criteria for ammonia levels. Proof of that case does not require that Unitywater prove the existence of problems in the design of the MBBRs themselves, or the specification of the media used in the MBBRs, which are the subject of complaint in the earlier pleading. On that basis, MEPL argues that none of the allegations in the earlier pleading, save for the ultimate effect on the performance of the Plant, appear to have anything to do with the new story which Unitywater seeks to tell with the PLST Allegations. In the circumstances of this proceeding, I do not accept MEPL’s submission that the design and operation of the PLST should be characterised as entirely distinct and independent from the design and operation of the MBBRs. Nor do I consider that the breaches the subject of the PLST Allegations should be treated as entirely separate and independent from the breaches pleaded in the earlier pleading. In both cases, the breaches concern an alleged failure to design components of the Plant to achieve the minimum treatment capacity and effluent quality required under the Contract. The PLST is not itself involved in the biological wastewater treatment process. However, by the PLST Allegations, Unitywater pleads that, because of the unreasonable design assumption regarding the performance of the PLST, the influent which passed through to the MBBRs contained a higher level of organic loads than was contemplated in the design. This is alleged to have overloaded the MBBRs leading to a reduction in their treatment capacity and to them being unable to remove sufficient ammonia to comply with the effluent quality criteria prescribed by the PPR and the Environmental Authority.