Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia (No 3) [2022] FCA 826

File number: VID 1252 of 2019
Judgment of: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 23 March 2022
Date of publication of reasons 15 July 2022
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – representative proceedings – application for approval to set aside an amount for future settlement administration costs – principles applicable to adopting costs referee’s report – costs referee’s report not adopted – approved estimate of future settlement administration costs reduced from the amount claimed by the applicants – any amount left over from that set aside to be paid to the peak body for community legal centres providing legal advice in relation to social security benefits  
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 33V
Cases cited:

Caason Investments Pty Ltd v Cao (No 2) [2018] FCA 527

Kelly v Willmot Forests Ltd (in liquidation) (No 4) [2016] FCA 323; 335 ALR 439

Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2021] FCA 634; 173 ALD 277

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 89
Date of last submission/s: 21 March 2022
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr B Quinn QC and Mr M Guo
Solicitor for the Applicants: Gordon Legal
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms Z Maud and Ms E Gill
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Contradictor Ms E Levine

ORDERS

VID 1252 of 2019
BETWEEN:

KATHERINE PRYGODICZ

First Applicant

ELYANE PORTER

Second Applicant

STEVEN FRITZE (and others named in the Schedule)

Third Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MURPHY J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 MARCH 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Subject to further order, the amount of $1,277,000 be set aside (the Set Aside Amount) from the Settlement Sum for the purpose of paying the reasonable costs and disbursements incurred by Gordon Legal for performing its functions under the Settlement Distribution Scheme including the Costs Referee’s fees for the period 1 February 2022 to the conclusion of the Scheme (the Remaining Period). The Set Aside Amount is to be paid to Gordon Legal, the solicitors for the Applicant, to be held in that firm’s trust account.

2.The reference to the Costs Referee pursuant to Order 11 of the orders made 23 December 2020 be amended to include the following:

(a)as soon as practicable the Costs Referee shall confer with Gordon Legal, and any other person the Costs Referee considers appropriate, and then determine the best method to assess the reasonableness of the costs and disbursements incurred by Gordon Legal for performing its functions under the Settlement Distribution Scheme for the Remaining Period;

(b)the Costs Referee shall provide three short reports (the Reports) to the Court on a periodic basis throughout the Remaining Period providing her opinion as to the reasonableness and proportionality of the costs and disbursements in the invoices rendered by Gordon Legal for the firm’s work throughout the relevant parts of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 826
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia (No 3), the applicants sought approval for a set aside amount to cover costs likely to be incurred by Gordon Legal in the remaining period of a settlement scheme. The court was required to decide on the appropriate amount to be set aside for these future costs, considering various affidavits and a report from a Costs Referee. The applicants proposed a set aside amount of $2,219,983, while the Costs Referee recommended $628,276. The legal issues involved determining the reasonableness of the proposed set aside amount and deciding whether to adopt the Costs Referee's recommendation. The court considered the complexity of the settlement, the likelihood of queries from group members, and the necessity of setting aside funds for future legal costs. Ultimately, the court was tasked with balancing the need for an accurate estimate of future costs against the practical difficulties of making such an estimate.

The court reviewed the evidence provided, including affidavits from partners of Gordon Legal and the Costs Referee’s report. The applicants' evidence included detailed estimates of future costs and the basis for those estimates, while the Costs Referee questioned the reasonableness of the applicants' figures. The court acknowledged the challenges in estimating future costs due to the unpredictability of the number of queries and their complexity. It highlighted the importance of setting aside a reasonable amount to cover future legal costs without unduly delaying distributions to group members. The court decided against adopting the Costs Referee's recommendation outright, noting inconsistencies in her earlier reports and the need for a more refined method of estimating future costs. Instead, the court ordered ongoing assessment by the Costs Referee and periodic review of Gordon Legal's invoices to ensure that costs remain reasonable and proportionate.

The court ordered that the Costs Referee should confer with Gordon Legal and determine the best methods to assess the reasonableness and proportionality of ongoing costs on a monthly or bi-monthly basis. This approach aimed to provide more accurate estimates of future costs, enabling the court to approve costs in a timely manner. The court also required the Costs Referee to provide short reports on the reasonableness of Gordon Legal’s ongoing costs and an updated estimate of future costs. These reports would assist the court in deciding whether to approve the proposed costs. This decision ensured that the court could proceed with the distribution of settlement funds while maintaining oversight over the reasonableness of future legal costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I now turn to further explain my reasons.THE EVIDENCE The applicants relied on the following evidence in relation to the appropriate amount to set aside to meet the costs likely to be incurred in the Remaining Period, being:(a)an affidavit of Andrew Grech, a partner of Gordon Legal, affirmed on 17 February 2022 (Grech Affidavit) in which he referred to and relied upon his earlier affidavits affirmed on 16 December 2019, 25 November 2020, 12 April 2021, 16 April 2021 and 22 April 2021. The Grech Affidavit sets out Mr Grech’s estimate of the costs that Gordon Legal will incur in the Remaining Period in the performance of its role under the Scheme, and the basis for that estimate; and(b)three affidavits of James Naughton, another partner of Gordon Legal, affirmed on 2 March 2022, 3 March 2022 and 7 March 2022 which respectively expand upon information in the Grech Affidavit relating to the number of calls received by Gordon Legal during the opt-out period; correct some matters and miscalculations in the Grech Affidavit, and contain information about Gordon Legal’s paralegal resources throughout the Remaining Period.The applicants sought approval of $2,219,983 as the Set Aside Amount. The Court also had before it the Final Costs Referee’s Report dated 24 February 2022, by the Costs Referee, Ms Cate Dealehr of the Australian Legal Costing Group. The report sets out her opinion that Mr Grech’s costs estimate is not reasonable, and that $628,276 should be approved as the Set Aside Amount. The Contradictor, Ms Eugenia Levine of counsel, submitted that the Court should adopt the Cost Referee’s estimate.BACKGROUND On 11 June 2021 I made orders to approve the settlement of this class action pursuant to s 33V of the FCA, and to approve the costs incurred by Gordon Legal in conducting the proceeding up to and including approval of the settlement. The settlement is substantial, involving a settlement payment of $112 million inclusive of legal costs, on top of an earlier announced program under which the Commonwealth withdrew approximately $1.763 billion in debts which were based on income averaging from ATO data, and promised to refund approximately $751 million that it had received or recovered from social security recipients in relation to such debts. Under the Scheme approximately 394,000 persons are eligible for compensation and the calculation and payment of the settlement payments to eligible group members is complex. Services Australia is performing the great majority of the settlement administration work under the Scheme; but given the Scheme’s size and complexity, Gordon Legal is nevertheless likely to be required to perform a great deal of work in responding to group members’ enquiries. The amount of settlement administration costs initially sought for approval In the settlement approval application the applicants sought approval of approximately $4.7 million in settlement administration costs that Gordon Legal estimated it would incur in undertaking its role under the Scheme. That costs estimate was based on a prediction that in performing its role the firm would receive approximately 40,000 enquiries from group members, which enquiries could be broken down into 38,000 unexceptional queries and 2,000 difficult queries.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The settlement is substantial, involving a settlement payment of $112 million inclusive of legal costs, on top of an earlier announced program under which the Commonwealth withdrew approximately $1.763 billion in debts which were based on income averaging from ATO data, and promised to refund approximately $751 million that it had received or recovered from social security recipients in relation to such debts. Under the Scheme approximately 394,000 persons are eligible for compensation and the calculation and payment of the settlement payments to eligible group members is complex. Services Australia is performing the great majority of the settlement administration work under the Scheme; but given the Scheme’s size and complexity, Gordon Legal is nevertheless likely to be required to perform a great deal of work in responding to group members’ enquiries. The amount of settlement administration costs initially sought for approval In the settlement approval application the applicants sought approval of approximately $4.7 million in settlement administration costs that Gordon Legal estimated it would incur in undertaking its role under the Scheme. That costs estimate was based on a prediction that in performing its role the firm would receive approximately 40,000 enquiries from group members, which enquiries could be broken down into 38,000 unexceptional queries and 2,000 difficult queries. By orders made on 23 December 2020 I had appointed the Costs Referee to inquire and provide a report regarding, amongst other things, the reasonableness and proportionality of the settlement administration costs proposed to be charged. By a report dated 1 April 2021 (the First Costs Referee’s Report) the Costs Referee opined that Gordon Legal’s estimate was not reasonable, and concluded that if 40,000 group members made enquiries in the ratios estimated by Gordon Legal, the firm’s reasonable costs would be approximately $2.7 million. In a supplementary report dated 26 April 2021 (the Second Costs Referee’s Report), after correcting some mistakes in her earlier report regarding the applicable charge-out rates, the Costs Referee said that if Gordon Legal’s prediction of receiving 40,000 queries was accepted, then approximately $4.2 million was a reasonable estimate of settlement administration costs. The Costs Referee did not though resile from the position that she was unable to say whether the estimated number of enquiries Gordon Legal said it was likely to receive from group members over the course of the Scheme was reasonable. I was not prepared to approve an estimate of future settlement administration costs in such a large amount without some further checking, and was also unwilling to adopt the Second Costs Referee’s Report which had an uncertain foundation and had significantly changed between her two reports. In Prygodicz v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2021] FCA 634; 173 ALD 277 (Prygodicz (No 2)) at [375]-[377] I explained as follows:[375]…I do not presently consider it appropriate to adopt the Cost Referee’s Second Report in relation to Gordon Legal’s future work under the SDS. That is because, at this stage, it is unsafe to assume that Gordon Legal will receive 40,000 enquiries from group members, of which 38,000 queries will be “unexceptional” and 2,000 will be “difficult”. The reality is that it is impossible to know how many group members are likely to raise queries or how long they will take to resolve, but at some point an estimate will have to be made because distributions to group members cannot commence until an amount has been set aside to cover Gordon Legal’s costs associated with its functions under the SDS. [376]There are real difficulties in reaching a reasonably accurate estimate of the likely costs to be incurred, but I am not satisfied that it is reasonable to fix an amount of $4.22 million in advance. Instead, I have ordered that:(a)as soon as practicable the Costs Referee shall confer with Gordon Legal, and any other person the Costs Referee considers appropriate, and then determine the best methods:(i)to assess the reasonableness and proportionality of Gordon Legal’s costs for performing its functions under the Scheme on an ongoing basis, and for such costs to be considered for approval by the Court and paid at either monthly or two monthly intervals as the Costs Referee determines; and(ii)to permit the Costs Referee to make an updated and more accurate estimate of Gordon Legal’s future reasonable and proportionate costs for performing its functions under the Scheme, intended to assist the Court to consider approval of a lump sum amount for future costs so that the distribution of settlement monies to the Scheme Claimants can proceed without material delay.(b)the Costs Referee provide short reports to the Court providing her opinion as to the reasonableness and proportionality of the:(i)costs in the invoices rendered by Gordon Legal for the firm’s ongoing work;(ii)updated estimate of Gordon Legal’s future costs in a lump sum amount;and the Court will decide whether to approve such costs on the papers.[377]An obvious problem with this course is that the Settlement Sum is fixed, and distributions cannot be made to group members until the total amount of future costs are fixed. The applicants expressed concerns as to the difficulties that may arise in taking this course. There is some force in that concern but, as Mr Grech said, it is likely the majority of queries will be from Ineligible Group Members, and the majority of the costs will be incurred when group members are informed as to the category into which they fall. In my view, at some point during the period in which the categorisation process is ongoing, or perhaps after the categorisation process is finished but before distributions begin, the Costs Referee should be in a better position to estimate the further legal work that will be required. For the present, it is appropriate to proceed on the basis that the Court will consider the invoices rendered by Gordon Legal on a monthly or two-monthly basis.