EOX17 v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

EOX17 v Commonwealth of Australia [2018] FCA 1656

File number: NSD 1601 of 2017
Judge: PERRY J
Date of judgment: 2 November 2018
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where applicant’s application for disability support pension under s 94 of the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth) refused by the respondent on the ground that her psychiatric impairment was not “permanent” – where applicant seeks damages pursuant to s 23 of the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (Cth) and for breach of duty of care – where application to summarily dismiss proceeding – whether the application has no reasonable prospects of success and/or the Court lacks jurisdiction – where alleged duties inconsistent with mandatory criteria for grant of pension – where no common law duty of care arises with respect to exercise of powers under the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth) – where no intention to confer private right of action for damages under the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (Cth)

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE –where application determined under r 17.04 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 on the applicant failing to appear – where complex history of case management in light of applicant’s distress at hearings - where requests to adjourn the matter and/or appear by telephone refused

Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)

Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (Cth)

Social Security Act 1991 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011  

Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Cassimatis [2013] FCA 641; (2013) 220 FCR 256

Australian Solar Mesh Sales Pty Ltd v Anderson [2000] FCA 864; (2000) 101 FCR 1

Byrne v Australian Airlines Ltd (1995) 185 CLR 410

C v Commonwealth of Australia [2015] FCAFC 113; (2015) 234 FCR 81

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Frangieh (No 3) [2017] NSWSC 252; (2017) 321 FLR 1

Kowalski v MMAL Staff Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd [2009] FCAFC 117; (2009) 178 FCR 401

LNC Industries Limited v BMW (Australia) Limited (1983) 151 CLR 575

O’Connor v S. P. Bray Ltd (1937) 56 CLR 464

Pickering v Centrelink [2008] FCA 561

Riva NSW Pty Limited v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2017] FCA 188

Scott v Officer Pedler, Department of Social Security [2004] FCAFC 67; (2004) 80 ALD 283

Scott v Secretary, Department of Social Security [2000] FCA 1241; (2000) 65 ALD 79

Shamir v Commonwealth of Australia (Australian Taxation Office) [2015] FCA 1463

Spencerv the Commonwealth [2010] HCA 28; (2010) 241 CLR 118

Sullivan v Moody [2001] HCA 59; (2001) 207 CLR 562

Wang v Secretary, Department of Employment & Workplace Relations [2006] FCA 898

White IndustriesAust Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2007] FCA 511; (2007) 160 FCR 298

Date of hearing: 7 February 2018 and 24 October 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 49
Counsel for the Applicant:
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read EOX17 v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1656
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of EOX17 v Commonwealth of Australia involves the applicant, who sought damages from the Commonwealth for the refusal of her application for a disability support pension. The application was dismissed by the Federal Court, and the Commonwealth subsequently applied to summarily dismiss the applicant's proceeding as having no reasonable prospects of success and for the Court to lack jurisdiction. The applicant's claims included negligence, breach of statutory duty, and defective administration, as well as damages pursuant to the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (Cth).

The court was required to decide whether the applicant's claims had reasonable prospects of success and whether the Court had jurisdiction to hear them. The Commonwealth argued that there was no cause of action for breach of statutory duty and that the Court lacked jurisdiction, relying on the decision in Pickering. However, the court noted that other authorities suggested the Court may still have jurisdiction. Nevertheless, the application was dismissed on the basis that it had no reasonable prospects of success.

The court found that the alleged duties were inconsistent with the mandatory criteria for the grant of the pension, and that no common law duty of care arose with respect to the exercise of powers under the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth). Additionally, the court held that there was no intention to confer a private right of action for damages under the Public Governance, Performance and Accountability Act 2013 (Cth). The applicant was given every opportunity to appear and make submissions, and appropriate arrangements were made to enable her to appear while minimizing distress. However, she failed to appear at the hearing, and the application was dismissed with costs.

The court dismissed the originating application filed by the applicant on 15 September 2017 under subsection 31A(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The applicant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs as agreed or assessed. The dismissal was based on the finding that the application had no reasonable prospects of success and that the Court lacked jurisdiction to hear the case. The court exercised its discretion with caution, considering the substance of the proceeding rather than just its form.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The originating application filed by the applicant on 15 September 2017 is dismissed under subsection 31A(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth).

2. The applicant is to pay the respondent’s costs as agreed or assessed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Given these matters, I consider that the applicant was given every opportunity to appear and make submissions, that she was aware that she had not been granted leave to appear by telephone, and that she was aware that orders may be made in her absence if she did not appear, I also consider that appropriate arrangements were put in place to enable her to appear while also minimising the distress which attending the hearing may cause and ensuring her safety. As such, when the applicant did not appear at the hearing, I considered that it was appropriate in all of the circumstances to make the orders for the summary dismissal application to be determined in the applicant’s absence pursuant to FCR rule 17.04(b) and on the papers.3. EVIDENCE The Commonwealth relies in support of its application upon the affidavits of Carolyne Michelle Jeeves affirmed on 21 December 2017 and Katherine Nicole Hooper affirmed on 19 December 2017. I also had regard to the material filed by the applicant in addition to the pleadings and particulars already referred to, namely:(1)the applicant’s affidavits affirmed on 15 September 2017 and 21 November 2017;(2)a letter and attached “Final Report” from the medical records services at the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital confirming her attendance at the hospital from 19 to 20 December 2017 and emergency on 26 November 2017;(3)a “ED Discharge Referral” dated 14 October 2018 from the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital; and (4)the transcript of the hearing before the Tribunal on 6 December 2017, which was annexed to the applicant’s amended statement of claim.4. THE SOCIAL SECURITY ACT As earlier explained, the applicant’s claim for the pension was rejected by the Department on the basis that she did not satisfy the eligibility criteria set out in s 94 of the Social Security Act. That section as at the time that the applicant applied for the pension and in its current form relevantly provides:(1) A person is qualified for disability support pension if:(a) the person has a physical, intellectual or psychiatric impairment; and(b) the person’s impairment is of 20 points or more under the Impairment Tables… By subs 23(1) of the Social Security Act, “Impairment Tables” means the tables determined by an instrument made under subs 26(1) of the Social Security Act. Section 26 in turn provides:(1) The Minister may, by legislative instrument, determine tables relating to the assessment of work related impairment for disability support pension.(2) An instrument under subsection (1) may contain such ancillary or incidental provisions relating to those tables as the Minister considers appropriate.Rules for applying Impairment Tables(3) The Minister may, in an instrument under subsection (1), determine rules that are to be complied with in applying the tables referred to in subsection (1) and the provisions referred to in subsection (2).(4) An instrument under subsection (1) may contain such ancillary or incidental provisions relating to those rules as the Minister considers appropriate.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Commonwealth initially submitted in writing that, there being no cause of action for breach of statutory duty, it followed that there was no federal claim. As a result, the Commonwealth submitted that the Court lacked jurisdiction because there was no “matter … arising under any laws made by the Parliament …” for the purposes of subs 39B(1A)(c) of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). In support of that submission, the Commonwealth relied upon the decision in Pickering at [25] (McKerracher J). However, at the hearing on 24 October 2018, Counsel for the Commonwealth very properly drew the Court’s attention to two authorities said to indicate by analogy that the Court may nonetheless have jurisdiction: LNC Industries Limited v BMW (Australia) Limited (1983) 151 CLR 575 and Australian Solar Mesh Sales Pty Ltd v Anderson [2000] FCA 864; (2000) 101 FCR 1. Neither of these decisions are mentioned in Pickering and do not appear to have been drawn to the Court’s attention in that case. In the circumstances, however, it is unnecessary for me to endeavour to resolve these authorities as the application must be summarily dismissed in any event on the basis that it has no reasonable prospects of success. 7. CONCLUSION For these reasons, the application is dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As a consequence, the Tribunal determined that the applicant had a total impairment rating of nil points and therefore did not satisfy subs 94(1)(b) of the Social Security Act (Tribunal reasons at [16]). The Tribunal therefore affirmed the decision not to grant her the pension.6. CONSIDERATION6.1 Relevant principles Section 31A of the FCA Act provides for the Court to summarily dismiss a proceeding in the following terms: (2) The Court may give judgment for one party against another in relation to the whole or any part of a proceeding if:(a) the first party is defending the proceeding or that part of the proceeding; and(b) the Court is satisfied that the other party has no reasonable prospect of successfully prosecuting the proceeding or that part of the proceeding.(3) For the purposes of this section, a defence or a proceeding or part of a proceeding need not be:(a) hopeless; or(b) bound to fail;for it to have no reasonable prospect of success. The principles governing the application of s 31A are well established. First, the respondent as the moving party bears the onus of persuading the Court that the application has no reasonable prospects of succeeding: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Cassimatis [2013] FCA 641; (2013) 220 FCR 256 (Cassimatis) at [45] (Reeves J). Secondly, an order may be made under subs 31A(2) even if it is not possible to characterise the proceeding as bound to fail or hopeless: see e.g. C v Commonwealth of Australia [2015] FCAFC 113; (2015) 234 FCR 81 at [58] (the Court); and Riva NSW Pty Limited v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2017] FCA 188. Thirdly, the assessment required by s 31A of whether a proceeding has no reasonable prospects of success necessitates the making of value judgments in the absence of a full and complete factual matrix and argument, with the result that the provision vests a discretion in the Court: Kowalski v MMAL Staff Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd [2009] FCAFC 117; (2009) 178 FCR 401 (Kowalski) at [28] (the Court). Finally, despite the threshold for summary dismissal having been lowered, the discretion must still be exercised with caution (Spencerv the Commonwealth [2010] HCA 28; (2010) 241 CLR 118 (Spencer) at [24] (French CJ and Gummow J) and [60] (Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ)). Consistently with this, the discretion is concerned “with the bringing and defending of proceedings, not just with pleadings; with substance, not just with form”: White IndustriesAust Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2007] FCA 511; (2007) 160 FCR 298 at [50] (Lindgren J) (approved in Kowalski at [30] (the Court); see also Spencer at [23] (French CJ and Gummow J)).6.2 The alleged claims in negligence, and for breach of statutory duty and defective administration First, the applicant alleges that the Department owed her a duty of care which was breached by the Department ignoring medical evidence that her condition was fully diagnosed, treated and stabilised, and in denying her the pension despite the criteria having been met and a New South Wales Supreme Court finding that she had a disability. Secondly, the applicant alleges “a gross defective administration by the Respondent, in, ignoring medical advice, and support letters of those addressing all criteria of the DSP payment, and denying the Applicant her DSP payment.” Thirdly, the applicant seeks damages pursuant to s 23 of the Public Governance Act. The applicant contends in this regard that the Department knew or ought to have known that their actions would cause her much distress, damage and loss. The applicant also says that she has been denied a basic standard of living and has suffered economic loss in the form of unpaid pension payments, as well as emotional and psychological distress. These claims were elaborated upon in the applicant’s particulars of claim and damage.