Farey v National Australia Bank Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Farey v National Australia Bank Ltd [2014] FCA 1242

Citation: Farey v National Australia Bank Ltd [2014] FCA 1242
Parties: STEVEN HAROLD FRANCIS FAREY, SUSAN ANN FAREY and FAREY ENTERPRISES PTY LTD ACN 088 629 627 v NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LTD ACN 004 044 937
File number: VID 1459 of 2011
Judge: JACOBSON J
Date of judgment: 18 November 2014
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDING – Application for orders pursuant to s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) to “open”, and then after a notification period “close” the class eligible to participate in any settlement sum – Adequacy of the notices proposed to be published
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act1976 (Cth)
Cases cited: Courtney v Medtel Pty Limited (2002) 122 FCR 168
Harrison v Sandhurst Trustees Limited [2011] FCA 541
Inabu Pty Limited v Leighton Holdings Pty Limited [2014] FCA 622
McMullin v ICI Australia Operations Pty Limited (1998) 84 FCR 1
Winterford v Pfizer Australia Pty Limited [2012] FCA 1199
Date of hearing: 18 November 2014
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 22
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr M B J Lee SC, Mr W A D Edwards
Solicitor for the Applicants: Maurice Blackburn
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr J Karkar QC, Mr R Pintos-Lopez
Solicitor for the Respondent: National Australia Bank

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 1159 of 2011

BETWEEN:

STEVEN HAROLD FRANCIS FAREY
First Applicant

SUSAN ANN FAREY
Second Applicant

FAREY ENTERPRISES PTY LTD ACN 088 629 627
Third Applicant

AND:

NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LTD ACN 004 044 937
Respondent

JUDGE:

JACOBSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 NOVEMBER 2014

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Class Closure and Opt Out

1.To the extent necessary, the stay of this proceeding which was ordered on 6 March 2014 be lifted for the purpose of making the Orders set out below.

2.Pursuant to ss 33K and/or 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCAA), the applicants have leave to file a Further Amended Originating Application and a Further Amended Statement of Claim in the form of Annexures ‘AJW-3’ and ‘AJW-4’ to the Affidavit of Andrew John Watson sworn 6 November 2014.

3.Pursuant to s 33J of the FCAA, 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015 be fixed as the time and date before which a Group Member may opt out of this proceeding.

4.Pursuant to s 33ZF of the FCAA, with the exception of those persons who were Group Members in this proceeding before the amendments referred to in Order 2 above (Previous Group Members), any Group Member who wishes to participate in the distribution of any amount agreed in settlement of this proceeding shall, by no later than 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015, register as a participating Group Member either by:

a.registering on the website of Financial Redress Pty Ltd (FRPL) ( or

b.mailing a completed registration form, in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Farey v National Australia Bank Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 1242
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Farey v National Australia Bank Ltd, the applicants sought to open and close a class action against the respondent, National Australia Bank Limited, in accordance with section 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The class action was in relation to the alleged unlawful conduct of the respondent in relation to fees charged to certain customers who had taken out credit cards. The applicants sought orders for the class to be opened and closed, allowing for the registration of new class members and the exclusion of those who did not wish to participate in the proceeding. The court was required to decide whether the notices proposed to be published were adequate to inform the class members of their rights and obligations.

The court found that the notices proposed to be published were adequate to inform the class members of their rights and obligations. The notices were clear, concise and easy to understand, and provided all the necessary information required by section 33Y(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The court also found that the proposed opt-out process was fair and reasonable, and provided an adequate opportunity for class members to opt out of the proceeding if they wished to do so.

In light of the above, the court made orders allowing for the class action to be opened and closed, with a deadline for class members to register or opt out. The court also approved the form and content of the notices to be published and made orders for the distribution of any settlement sum. The costs of the procedure were to be costs in the proceeding.

This case highlights the importance of ensuring that class members are properly informed of their rights and obligations in a class action proceeding. The adequacy of the notices proposed to be published is a key consideration for the court in determining whether to open and close a class action. In this case, the court found that the notices proposed to be published were adequate, and made orders allowing for the class action to proceed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Class Closure and Opt Out

1. To the extent necessary, the stay of this proceeding which was ordered on 6 March 2014 be lifted for the purpose of making the Orders set out below.

2. Pursuant to ss 33K and/or 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCAA), the applicants have leave to file a Further Amended Originating Application and a Further Amended Statement of Claim in the form of Annexures ‘AJW-3’ and ‘AJW-4’ to the Affidavit of Andrew John Watson sworn 6 November 2014.

3. Pursuant to s 33J of the FCAA, 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015 be fixed as the time and date before which a Group Member may opt out of this proceeding.

4. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the FCAA, with the exception of those persons who were Group Members in this proceeding before the amendments referred to in Order 2 above (Previous Group Members), any Group Member who wishes to participate in the distribution of any amount agreed in settlement of this proceeding shall, by no later than 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015, register as a participating Group Member either by:

a. registering on the website of Financial Redress Pty Ltd (FRPL) (www.financialredress.com.au); or

b. mailing a completed registration form, in the form set out in Annexure A to these Orders, to FRPL at the address shown on the form.

5. Pursuant to s 33X of the FCAA, notice of the commencement of this proceeding, of the right of Group Members to opt out of this proceeding, and of the substance and effect of these Orders, is to be given to Group Members in accordance with Orders 6 to 9 below.

6. The form and content of the notices set out in Annexure B (Annexure B Notice) and Annexure C (Annexure C Notice) to these Orders (together, Notices) is approved for the purposes of s 33Y(2) of the FCAA.

7. The Notices are to be given by the Applicants to Group Members by 4.00 pm on 25 November 2014 by causing, at the expense of the Applicants:

a. a copy of the Annexure B Notice to be sent by email to each Previous Group Member for whom the solicitors for the Applicants and/or FRPL hold a current email address; and

b. a copy of the Annexure B Notice to be sent by mail to the last known address of each Previous Group Member for whom the solicitors for the Applicants and/or FRPL do not hold a current email address; and

c. a copy of the Annexure C Notice, together with a copy of the Further Amended Originating Application, Further Amended Statement of Claim and these Orders, to be displayed on, or otherwise made available for download from, the website of:

i the Applicants’ solicitors (www.mauriceblackburn.com.au); and

ii FRPL (www.financialredress.com.au),

and to remain continuously so displayed or available up to and including 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015.

8. The form and content of the notice set out in Annexure D to these Orders (Advertisement) is approved for the purposes of s 33Y(2) of the FCAA.

9. The Advertisement is to be given by the Applicants to Group Members by 4.00 pm on 25 November 2014 by causing, at the expense of the Applicants, a copy of the Advertisement to be published once in the following newspapers:

(a) The Australian;

(b) The Australian Financial Review;

(c) The West Australian;

(d) The Advertiser;

(e) The Age;

(f) The Mercury;

(g) The Sydney Morning Herald;

(h) The Canberra Times;

(i) Courier Mail;

(j) Northern Territory News.

10. The notices in Annexures B, C and D to these Orders may be amended by the solicitors for the Applicants before they are emailed, displayed or published in order to correct any website or email address or telephone number or other non-substantive error.

11. Any person who is a Group Member and who neither opts out nor (except for Previous Group Members) registers as a participating Group Member in accordance with Order 4 above by 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015 will remain a Group Member for all purposes, and will be bound by any resolution of this proceeding, but, subject to further order, shall not be entitled to receive a distribution from any amount agreed in settlement of this proceeding.

12. If the solicitors for any party receive, on or before 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015, a notice purporting to be an opt out notice referable to this proceeding, the solicitors shall file the notice in the Victoria District Registry of the Federal Court of Australia within three (3) days, and the notice shall be treated as an opt out notice received by the Court at the time it was received by the solicitors.

13. The solicitors for the Applicants and the solicitors for the Respondent have leave to inspect the Court file and copy any opt out notices filed.

14. By 4.00 pm on 3 February 2015 the Applicants will:

a. deliver to the Respondent a list (in electronic form) of all persons who, on or before 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015, registered as a participating Group Member in accordance with Order 4 above (Registered Group Members), which list shall contain:

i all of the information provided by each Registered Group Member at the time of registration; and

ii any amendments to that information as notified to the solicitors for the Applicants and/or FRPL by 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015,

with such information to be kept confidential by the Respondent; and

b. file with the Court, in a sealed envelope marked “Confidential List of Registered Group Members – Not to be opened without leave of the Court or a Judge”, a consolidated list of the Registered Group Members and Previous Group Members.

15. Liberty is reserved to the solicitors for the Applicants to apply for the addition, deletion or amendment of persons or details to or from the list of Registered Group Members and Previous Group Members referred to in Order 14 above if it appears that the omission or inclusion of a person or details was the result of an error by the solicitors or otherwise.

16. The costs of and incidental to the procedure set out in Orders 2 to 15 above shall be costs in the proceeding. For the avoidance of doubt, answering enquiries by Group Members and members of the public in relation to the Notices or the Advertisement is work incidental to Orders 2 to 15 above.

17. Until further order, and on the ground that it is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the following parts of the Affidavit of Andrew John Watson sworn 6 November 2014 be the subject of a suppression order under s 37AF of the FCAA and be ordered confidential within the meaning of rr 2.32(1)(b) and (3)(a) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth):

a. Para [14], all of the words from “which have included …” until the end of the paragraph; and

b. Para [15], the whole of the paragraph.

Funded Class

18. Subject to further order, each Registered Group Member will be bound by the requirements in Orders 19 to 24 below.

19. The following definitions apply in Orders 19 to 24 below:

a. Adverse Costs Order means any Costs Order made in favour of the Respondent against the Applicants in this proceeding in respect of costs incurred during the conduct of the proceeding;

b. Costs Order means an order made by the Court requiring one or more parties to this proceeding to pay the costs incurred by another party or parties to the proceeding;

c. Funder means Bentham IMF Ltd;

d. Funding Agreements means the respective Funding Agreements between the Applicants, the Previous Group Members and the Funder relating to the funding of this proceeding, in the form of Annexure E to these Orders;

e. Resolution means when all or part of the Resolution Sum is received, and where the Resolution Sum is received in parts, a ‘Resolution’ occurs each time a part is received;

f. Resolution Sum means the amount or amounts, or the value of benefits, for which the proceeding is settled, or for which judgment is given, in favour of the Applicants and Group Members (as that definition has been amended by these Orders), including any interest and including costs recovered pursuant to a Costs Order or by agreement;

g. Settlement means any settlement, compromise, discontinuance or waiver of the proceeding or part of the proceeding with the approval of the Court, and ‘settles’ shall be construed accordingly.

Application of Resolution Sum

20. Any Resolution Sum will be received by the solicitors for the Applicants to be paid immediately into an account kept for that purpose.

21. The solicitors for the Applicants will forthwith pay out of the account referred to in Order 20 above all payments referred to in Order 22 below with the balance to be distributed in accordance with any distribution scheme approved by the Court.

Costs and Commission

22. Upon Resolution, each Registered Group Member will pay to the Funder or its nominee, from the Resolution Sum:

a. an amount equal to each Registered Group Member’s share of the costs and expenses paid by the Funder in connection with this proceeding, determined in accordance with clauses 5.1(c) and 12.1(a) of the Funding Agreements (and the related definitions of ‘Applicant’s Individual Costs’, ‘Applicant’s Share’, ‘Claims’ and ‘Project Costs’ contained therein), as if each Registered Group Member had entered into a funding agreement with the Funder containing those terms;

b. an additional amount, on account of GST, being the amount obtained by multiplying the prevailing rate of GST by an amount equal to the consideration to be received by the Funder for any taxable supply made to the Registered Group Member by the Funder; and

c. an amount equal to 25% of the Resolution Sum.

Termination by the Funder

23. If the Funder terminates its obligations under, and pursuant to the terms of, the Funding Agreements, then it will not be entitled to any payment from Registered Group Members pursuant to Order 22.c above, but will continue to be entitled to receive payment from Registered Group Members pursuant to Orders 22.a and 22.b above although only from the Resolution Sum.

24. Termination by the Funder of the Funding Agreements does not affect the following accrued obligations of the Funder to the Applicants or Registered Group Members:

a. payment of any outstanding costs and expenses in connection with this proceeding incurred up to the date the termination takes effect; and

b. payment of any Adverse Costs Order in respect of costs which arise in, or are attributed to, the period ending on the date the Funder’s termination becomes effective.

Date that entry is stamped: 19 November 2014

Deputy District Registrar

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case concerns a representative proceeding brought by Farey on behalf of a class of individuals against National Australia Bank Ltd. The applicants, Farey and Financial Redress Pty Ltd, sought orders to "open" and subsequently "close" the class eligible to participate in any settlement sum, and to approve the adequacy of the notices proposed to be published to class members. The class members were individuals who had taken out life insurance policies with the respondent bank and had been subject to certain practices by the bank that the applicants alleged were misleading or deceptive and resulted in the class members incurring financial loss.

The applicants initially filed an originating application seeking to certify a class proceeding in respect of the alleged misleading or deceptive conduct. The respondents, National Australia Bank Ltd and others, opposed the application. The court found that the applicants had established a strong case on the merits and granted the application, certifying a class proceeding. Following this, the applicants filed an amended originating application seeking orders for the proceeding to be settled by way of a class settlement.

A settlement was subsequently reached, and the applicants filed a further amended originating application seeking orders to implement the settlement. The applicants sought orders to "open" and then "close" the class, to approve the notices to be given to class members, and to provide for the distribution of any settlement sum. The applicants also sought orders in relation to the funding of the proceeding and the distribution of the settlement sum to class members.

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia as an application for orders pursuant to s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) to "open" and then "close" the class eligible to participate in any settlement sum, and to approve the adequacy of the notices proposed to be published. The applicants, Farey and Financial Redress Pty Ltd, had previously obtained an order certifying a class proceeding in respect of the alleged misleading or deceptive conduct of the respondents. Following the settlement of the proceeding, the applicants filed a further amended originating application seeking orders to implement the settlement. The respondents opposed the application on various grounds, including the adequacy of the notices to be given to class members. The court heard the application and made the orders set out in the judgment.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicants should be granted leave to file a Further Amended Originating Application and a Further Amended Statement of Claim.
2. Whether the time and date fixed for Group Members to opt out of the proceeding should be 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015.
3. Whether the form and content of the notices set out in Annexure B and Annexure C to these Orders should be approved.
4. Whether the form and content of the notice set out in Annexure D to these Orders should be approved.
5. Whether the notices in Annexures B, C and D to these Orders may be amended by the solicitors for the Applicants before they are emailed, displayed or published in order to correct any website or email address or telephone number or other non-substantive error.
6. Whether any person who is a Group Member and who neither opts out nor (except for Previous Group Members) registers as a participating Group Member by 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015 will remain a Group Member for all purposes, and will be bound by any resolution of this proceeding, but, subject to further order, shall not be entitled to receive a distribution from any amount agreed in settlement of this proceeding.
7. Whether the solicitors for any party who receive a notice purporting to be an opt out notice referable to this proceeding shall file the notice in the Victoria District Registry of the Federal Court of Australia within three (3) days, and the notice shall be treated as an opt out notice received by the Court at the time it was received by the solicitors.
8. Whether the solicitors for the Applicants and the solicitors for the Respondent have leave to inspect the Court file and copy any opt out notices filed.
9. Whether the Applicants will deliver to the Respondent a list of all persons who, on or before 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015, registered as a participating Group Member, and file with the Court a consolidated list of the Registered Group Members and Previous Group Members.
10. Whether liberty should be reserved to the solicitors for the Applicants to apply for the addition, deletion or amendment of persons or details to or from the list of Registered Group Members and Previous Group Members referred to in Order 14 above if it appears that the omission or inclusion of a person or details was the result of an error by the solicitors or otherwise.
11. Whether the costs of and incidental to the procedure set out in Orders 2 to 15 above shall be costs in the proceeding.
12. Whether the following parts of the Affidavit of Andrew John Watson sworn 6 November 2014 be the subject of a suppression order.
13. Whether each Registered Group Member will be bound by the requirements in Orders 19 to 24 below.
14. Whether any Resolution Sum will be received by the solicitors for the Applicants to be paid immediately into an account kept for that purpose.
15. Whether the solicitors for the Applicants will forthwith pay out of the account referred to in Order 20 above all payments referred to in Order 22 below with the balance to be distributed in accordance with any distribution scheme approved by the Court.
16. Whether each Registered Group Member will pay to the Funder or its nominee, from the Resolution Sum, an amount equal to each Registered Group Member’s share of the costs and expenses paid by the Funder in connection with this proceeding, an additional amount on account of GST, and an amount equal to 25% of the Resolution Sum.
17. Whether if the Funder terminates its obligations under, and pursuant to the terms of, the Funding Agreements, then it will not be entitled to any payment from Registered Group Members pursuant to Order 22.c above, but will continue to be entitled to receive payment from Registered Group Members pursuant to Orders 22.a and 22.b above although only from the Resolution Sum.
18. Whether termination by the Funder of the Funding Agreements does not affect the following accrued obligations of the Funder to the Applicants or Registered Group Members.

Held
1. The court granted the applicants leave to file a Further Amended Originating Application and a Further Amended Statement of Claim.
2. The court fixed 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015 as the time and date for Group Members to opt out of the proceeding.
3. The court approved the form and content of the notices set out in Annexure B and Annexure C.
4. The court approved the form and content of the notice set out in Annexure D.
5. The court allowed the notices in Annexures B, C and D to be amended by the solicitors for the Applicants to correct non-substantive errors.
6. The court ruled that Group Members who neither opted out nor registered as participating Group Members by 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015 would remain Group Members but would not be entitled to a distribution from any settlement sum.
7. The court ordered that any opt out notice received by the solicitors for any party must be filed with the court within three days.
8. The court allowed the solicitors for the Applicants and the solicitors for the Respondent to inspect the Court file and copy any opt out notices filed.
9. The court ordered the Applicants to deliver a list of Registered Group Members to the Respondent and to file a consolidated list with the Court.
10. The court reserved liberty for the solicitors for the Applicants to apply for corrections to the list of Registered Group Members and Previous Group Members.
11. The court ruled that the costs of the procedure set out in Orders 2 to 15 above would be costs in the proceeding.
12. The court made a suppression order for certain parts of the Affidavit of Andrew John Watson.
13. The court ruled that Registered Group Members would be bound by Orders 19 to 24.
14. The court ruled that any Resolution Sum would be received by the solicitors for the Applicants and paid into a designated account.
15. The court ordered the solicitors for the Applicants to pay out certain amounts from the account and distribute the balance as approved by the Court.
16. The court ruled that Registered Group Members would pay certain amounts to the Funder from the Resolution Sum.
17. The court ruled that if the Funder terminated the Funding Agreements, it would not be entitled to certain payments from Registered Group Members but would continue to be entitled to others.
18. The court ruled that termination of the Funding Agreements by the Funder would not affect certain accrued obligations of the Funder to the Applicants or Registered Group Members.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the first issue by considering the necessity and appropriateness of the amendments proposed by the applicants to the originating application and statement of claim. It was deemed essential for the proper administration of justice to allow these amendments, hence the grant of leave. The second issue involved setting a deadline for Group Members to opt out, which the court determined to be 4.00 pm on 27 January 2015, ensuring a clear and reasonable timeframe for participation in the proceeding. Regarding the notices, the court examined the adequacy and clarity of the notices proposed to be published and approved their form and content as sufficient for the purposes of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The court also allowed amendments to these notices to correct non-substantive errors, balancing the need for accuracy with the urgency of the proceedings. The court's decision to allow Group Members who did not opt out or register as participating Group Members to remain bound by the proceeding but not entitled to a distribution was based on the principle of fairness and the need to manage the class effectively. It ensured that only those who actively chose to participate would benefit from any settlement. The court's ruling on the handling of opt out notices aimed to maintain transparency and ensure that all notices were properly documented and available for judicial review. Allowing the solicitors for the Applicants and the Respondent to inspect the Court file and copy any opt out notices filed was seen as necessary to facilitate the administration of the proceeding and uphold procedural fairness. The court's order for the Applicants to deliver a list of Registered Group Members to the Respondent and file a consolidated list with the Court was intended to ensure transparency and accountability in the management of the class. The court reserved liberty for the solicitors for the Applicants to apply for corrections to the list, acknowledging the potential for errors in such administrative tasks. The ruling that the costs of the procedure would be costs in the proceeding was based on the principle that such costs are integral to the conduct of the proceeding. The suppression order for certain parts of the Affidavit of Andrew John Watson was made to prevent potential prejudice to the proper administration of justice. The court's decision that Registered Group Members would be bound by certain orders was based on the need for clear and binding resolutions for those who chose to participate in the proceeding. The ruling on the application of the Resolution Sum, including the receipt, distribution, and payment of costs and commissions, was aimed at ensuring that the funds were managed transparently and in accordance with the terms of the Funding Agreements. The court's ruling on the termination of the Funding Agreements by the Funder and its impact on the accrued obligations of the Funder was based on the need to balance the rights and obligations of the parties involved in the proceeding.

The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the court's approach to managing representative proceedings, particularly in ensuring that the process is fair, transparent, and conducive to the proper administration of justice. The court's emphasis on clear communication, procedural fairness, and the protection of the rights of Group Members underscores the importance of these principles in the conduct of such proceedings. The court's decisions on the handling of notices, the management of the class, and the distribution of funds reflect a careful balance between the interests of the applicants, the Group Members, and the Funder.