Smith v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Smith v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2020] FCA 837

File number:

NSD 1908 of 2016
NSD 1155 of 2017
NSD 1388 of 2018

Judge: LEE J
Date of judgment: 5 June 2020
Catchwords:

REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – applications for approval of settlements of three class actions pursuant to s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – where three class actions commenced against the Commonwealth – where each class action advanced claims in nuisance, negligence and for contraventions of Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (Cth) – where claims alleged damage in relation to land and business value diminution caused by use of firefighting foam containing per- and poly-fluoroalkyl substances at Royal Australian Air Force bases – where large number of submissions made by group members opposed to approval of the settlements – where several group members made oral submissions during hearing of applications for settlement approval – consideration of views of and feelings expressed by objectors – where proposed settlement sums as a percentage of the best possible quantum recoverable “excellent” – proposed deductions from settlement sum to be paid to litigation funder – consideration of principles concerning proposed deductions for litigation funding costs – where proposed percentage of deductions from settlement sum to be paid to litigation funder substantially lower that percentage funder entitled to under funding agreements – proposed percentage deduction just – proposed deductions from settlement sum for legal costs – where two class actions commenced by one firm of solicitors and third class action brought by separate firm – where three class actions case managed together – where one class action could have been brought as a matter of law and practicality – where legal costs would have been reduced if proceedings brought as one class action – consideration of special circumstances of these class actions – where expense sharing order proposed to distribute costs incurred in one class action across two class actions commenced by same solicitors – consideration of relevant principles – where referee appointed to inquire into and report upon reasonableness of legal costs in all proceedings – where reports of referee in each proceeding adopted by the Court in full – proposed deductions allowed – proposed deductions from settlement sum for representative applicants – consideration of relevant principles – where applicants in one class action sought payments to be made to members of a class action “steering committee” – where proposed quantum of payments excessive – where representative applicant in one class action subject to harassment by reason of having acted in that capacity – payment to an applicant allowed in an amount that exceeds recompense for time spent acting in representative capacity – settlements approved

HIGH COURT AND FEDERAL COURT – where non-confidential opinions and submissions filed on settlement approval applications contained sufficiently detailed information – consideration of fundamental principle of open justice – applications for approval considered without regard to confidential opinions

Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 837
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved three class actions brought against the Commonwealth by individuals who alleged damage to their property and businesses due to the use of firefighting foam containing per- and poly-fluoroalkyl substances at Royal Australian Air Force bases. The applicants sought approval for the settlements of these class actions under section 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The primary issues the court had to decide were whether the settlements were fair and reasonable and whether the proposed deductions from the settlement sums were justified.

The court first considered the objections raised by some group members, noting that while there was significant opposition, the majority of the group members were content with the settlements. The court also examined the proposed deductions from the settlement sums, including those for litigation funding costs, legal costs, and payments to representative applicants. The court found that the proposed deductions for litigation funding costs were justified as they were lower than what the funder was entitled to under the funding agreements. The court also approved the expense sharing order to distribute legal costs across two class actions commenced by the same solicitors. The court allowed a payment to one representative applicant who had faced harassment, but reduced the amount to exceed only the recompense for time spent in the representative capacity.

The court approved the settlements, noting that the net recovery for group members was fair and reasonable. The settlements would release and quell the claims of group members, except for any future claims for personal injury. The court also noted that the settlements would be binding on group members who registered late, subject to certain conditions. The court appointed Administrators and Independent Counsel to oversee the settlements and directed that the proceedings be dismissed with no order as to costs once the administration was complete. The court vacated all previous costs orders and extended the time for any appeal.

The settlements were approved on the terms set out in the Settlement Deed and the Settlement Distribution Scheme, with amendments to the group member definition. The court allowed specific deductions from the settlement sums for legal costs, funding costs, and other expenses. The court also addressed consequential matters, including the dismissal of the proceedings and the extension of the time for any appeal. The final orders were to be entered in accordance with Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

Settlement approval

1. Pursuant to s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCAA), the settlement of this proceeding be approved on the terms set out in:

(a) the Settlement Deed dated 5 June 2020 in the form being pages 74 to 99 of the affidavit of Joshua Aylward affirmed 5 June 2020 (Deed), on the basis that the Deed only binds Group Members as set out in these orders and otherwise takes effect between the parties to the Deed; and

(b) the Settlement Distribution Scheme in the form being pages 841 to 862 of the exhibit to the affidavit of Joshua Ian Aylward affirmed 29 May 2020 (SDS) as amended per Annexure A below.

2. Pursuant to s 33ZB of the FCAA, the persons affected and bound by the settlement of these proceedings are the Applicants, the Respondent and Group Members.

Late registrations

3. Pursuant to s 33V and/or 33ZF of the FCAA, any group member who has completed and returned the registration form annexed to the orders dated 6 April 2020 to the Applicants’ solicitors or funder between 8 May and 3 June 2020 is eligible to benefit from the settlement of this proceeding, and is a “Claimant” for the purposes of the SDS.

Change in group member definition

4. Pursuant to s 33K of the FCAA, criterion (a) of the group member definition in the Second Further Amended Originating Application and Further Amended Statement of Claim is amended so as to provide:

“(a) as at 23 November 2016 were: (i) the registered owners of a fee simple interest in a lot (within the meaning of the Land Titles Act 2000 (NT)), located in whole or in apart within the area delineated by the solid purple line on the map which is Annexure A to the Statement of Claim; or (ii) Arnold and Gai Whitehouse of 7 Rapide Street, Katherine; or”

Appointment of Administrator and Independent Counsel

5. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the FCAA, Janice Mary Saddler and Joshua Ian Aylward (of Shine Lawyers) be appointed as Administrators of the SDS to act in accordance with the SDS subject to any direction of the Court, and to have the powers and immunities conferred by the SDS on the Administrator.

6. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the FCAA, James Mack be appointed as Independent Counsel of the SDS to act in accordance with the SDS subject to any direction of the Court, and to have the powers and immunities conferred by the SDS on the Independent Counsel.

Deductions from settlement sum for the purposes of the SDS

7. The report dated 3 June 2020 of Roland Matters, appointed as Referee pursuant to the Court’s Orders dated 6 April 2020, is adopted in full.

8. Pursuant to s 33V(2) of the FCAA, the Court approves the following just deductions from the settlement sum only:

(a) the “Applicants’ Legal Costs and Disbursements” in the amount of $12,408,000;

(b) the “Reimbursement Payment” in the amount of:

(i) $20,000 in respect of the First Applicant;

(ii) $20,000 in respect of the Second Applicant;

(c) the “Approval Costs” in the amount of $250,000;

(d) the “Funding Costs” in the amount of $23,125,000; and

(e) the “Funding Expenses” in the amount of $113,245.

Consequential matters

9. The Court notes that the proceeding is to be dismissed with no order as to costs but such an order for dismissal is not to be made until the Administrators provide to the Associate to Justice Lee a minute of order (containing a draft order dismissing the proceeding) together with written confirmation that the administration is complete.

10. All previous costs orders are vacated.

11. Pursuant to r 1.39 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) or otherwise, the time for any application for leave to appeal or the institution of any appeal from these orders be extended to the later of the time permitted under rr 35.13 and/or 36.03 or 14 days from the date of publication of reasons for judgment.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ANNEXURE A

AMENDMENTS TO THE SDS

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no reason, in my view, why an order should not be made under s 33K to allow them to participate as group members in circumstances where the Housing Commission of the Northern Territory, I am told, opted out of the proceeding.J CONCLUSION One of the matters that is evident is that although there were strong feelings held by some persons who opposed settlement, there is a lack of any appetite by those persons to seek leave to opt out late and continue to maintain their claim against the Commonwealth. In making this comment, I do not make any implicit criticism of persons who opposed the settlement and yet are unenthusiastic about maintaining their claim. The prospect of making an application to opt out and to pursue the claim is, to say the least, a daunting one. It would presumably be necessary to gather together a cohort of such persons and arrange to somehow deal with the prospect of adverse costs. Even Mr Roseworne, who is adamantly opposed to the Williamtown settlement, agreed that one thing he did not wish to do was to opt out and continue his own case. In these circumstances, one must balance the fact that a number of people are unhappy, with the fact that a large number of people are content with the settlement. The figures in this regard speak for themselves. Although there is a very large number of objections compared to other class action settlements, taken as a whole, the level of opposition is heavily outweighed by those who wish the settlement to go ahead. I have given close consideration to the views of those that have opposed these settlements. Much of that opposition was based on what was, with great respect, a somewhat misguided notion that I could somehow compel the Commonwealth to offer a greater amount in some sort of counterfactual settlement. But this is not the real counterfactual. The relevant counterfactual is between the settlements as proposed, and the spectre of continuing with the case and proceeding to an initial trial. In my view, the settlements are fair and reasonable and in the interests of group members in all three proceedings and, accordingly, I propose to approve them. K ORDERS There has been significant discussion during the course of the hearing as to the proposed orders. I have now been provided with proposed minutes of order which reflect the orders that the applicants propose that I make. During the course of these reasons I have raised a number of issues which require those proposed orders to be varied and, given the lateness of the hour, it seems to me that the appropriate course is for the parties to provide to my Associate copies of revised orders so that those orders can be made in Chambers early next week. Having said that, there are a couple of issues to which I should make reference. The first is the terms of consequential orders which are referred to as being sought pursuant to ss 22, 23, 33V or 33ZF of the Act or FCR 1.32 and/or the Court’s implied jurisdiction, that the proceeding is dismissed with no order as to costs and with all previous costs orders vacated with effect from the date in which the final payment is made pursuant to the settlement scheme, and that this order of dismissal will operate “as a defence and absolute bar to any claim or proceeding by the Applicant or Group Member with respect to this proceeding”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The real issue on these applications is not the gross settlement sums but rather the net recovery, being the quantum of the settlement to be distributed to group members. This is reflected in a large number of the objections and, in the next section of these reasons, I will deal with the appropriateness of some of these deductions when I come to considering specific aspects of the proposed settlements.F CONSIDERATION OF ASPECTS OF THE SETTLEMENTSF.1 Release and quelling of claims I have written before about the important responsibility of representative applicants to ensure that deeds entered into in resolution of the claims of group members in class actions appropriately reflect the limited nature of the authority which applicants have in relation to group member claims. The claims of group members exist separately from and prior to the class action. The applicant has authority to deal with the “claim” of a group member as that term is used in s 33C of the Act. It has no authority (and no business) to deal with claims that extend beyond the class action. There has been a recognition of this important matter by those acting on behalf of the representative applicants in these cases. The most important illustration of this was the fact that the claims of the group members extended beyond those common issues which were proposed to be agitated at the initial trial. In this sense, these class actions were somewhat unusual. Each group member had a claim in tort for damages. Despite this, the only damages particularised, related primarily to the diminution in the value of property or business conducted by the group members. There was no pleading of any claim made by the group members of any personal injury. All parties proceeded to conduct the class actions and proceed to settlement on the basis that any claim a group member may have for damages for present or latent personal injury (if any such claims do, in fact, exist) would not be the subject of the class actions and would not be quelled by any settlement of these class actions. Given the potential for an argument to be raised that each group member may have a singular claim for damages in tort, this was a matter in respect of which I sought clarity, and it was expressly agreed that the settlements, if approved, would not prevent any claim for damages for personal injury arising out of the same circumstances being made in the future, if a group member was advised to bring such a claim. This was an important component of the way the claims were advanced in these class actions and which I raised period to mediation, and has informed my approach to the approval of the settlement that emerged. Initially, orders were sought pursuant to s 33ZF to give authority for the applicants nunc pro tunc to enter into deeds with the Commonwealth to resolve the claims of group members and binding the group members to the terms of those deeds and service of those deed. In final submissions, such a course has not been persisted in, and different orders are sought which will be addressed below. In my view, this was a sensible course for the parties to take and if the settlements are approved, all the claims of both the applicants and the group members (other than that any aspect of the claims which relate to personal injury) will be resolved, once and for all, by operation of ss 33V and 33ZB of the Act. F.2 Legal costs