Yasmin v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Yasmin v Commonwealth of Australia [2023] FCA 1661

File number(s): VID 328 of 2020
VID 664 of 2020
Judgment of: HORAN J
Date of judgment: 22 December 2023
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application for approval of settlement by Court pursuant to s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – whether proposed settlement is fair and reasonable as between group members and the respondent – whether proposed settlement distribution scheme is fair and reasonable as between group members – whether lead applicant’s compensation payment claim is reasonable having regard to interests of group members as a whole – settlement approval granted
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 33V

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth)

High Court Rules 2004 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Chats House Investments Pty Ltd (1996) 71 FCR 250

Blairgowrie Trading Ltd v Allco Finance Group Ltd (Receivers & Managers Appointed) (In Liq) (No 3) [2017] FCA 330

Caason Investments Pty Ltd v Cao (No 2) [2018] FCA 527

Camilleri v The Trust Company (Nominees) Limited [2015] FCA 1468

Commonwealth v AJL20 (2021) 273 CLR 43

Darwalla Milling Co Pty Limited v F Hoffman-La Roche Ltd (No 2) (2006) 236 ALR 322; [2006] FCA 1388

Davis v Quintis Ltd (subject to deed of co arrangement) [2022] FCA 806

Hassan v State of Victoria [2023] VSC 478

Kamasaee v Commonwealth of Australia [2017] VSC 537

Kelly v Willmott Forests Ltd (in liquidation) (No 4) [2016] FCA 323

Kuterba v Sirtex Medical Ltd (No 3) [2019] FCA 1374

Petersen Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd v Bank of Queensland Limited (No 3) [2018] FCA 1842

Smith v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2020] FCA 837

Somers v Box Hill Institute [2022] VSC 730

Williams v FAI Home Security Pty Ltd (No 4) (2000) 180 ALR 459; [2000] FCA 1925

Australian Human Rights Commission, “An Age of Uncertainty”, report of the Inquiry into the treatment of individuals suspected of people smuggling offences who say that they are children, July 2012

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 96
Date of hearing: 6 December 2023
Solicitor for the Applicant: Ken Cush & Associates
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr A T Strahan KC, Mr P A Tierney, Mr T K Jeffrie, Ms S C B Brenker, Ms H L Canham and Ms E A Brumby
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitors
Counsel for the Respondent: P Knowles SC and A Batrouney

ORDERS

VID 328 of 2020
VID 664 of 2020
BETWEEN:

ALI YASMIN

Applicant

AND:

THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

HORAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 DECEMBER 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Approval of Settlement

1.Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (the Act) and subject to order 5 below, the Court approves:

(a)the settlement of the consolidated proceedings between the Applicant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yasmin v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1661
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Ali Yasmin has brought a representative proceeding against the Commonwealth of Australia on behalf of a group of Indonesian children who were allegedly detained and imprisoned in Australia as adults for people smuggling offences. The proceeding stems from a six-year period during which these children were brought to Australia by boat and were incorrectly assessed as adults by the Commonwealth. The children were subsequently charged, indicted, prosecuted, convicted, and/or imprisoned for people smuggling offences. The applicant seeks approval of a settlement under section 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth).

The court had to decide whether the proposed settlement was fair and reasonable as between the parties and in the interests of the Group Members as a whole. The court also had to determine whether the compensation payment proposed for the applicant was reasonable in the context of the interests of the Group Members as a whole. The court considered the distribution model contained in the Settlement Distribution Scheme, which it found to be within the bounds of reasonableness in achieving a broadly fair, 'rule of thumb' distribution between the claimants.

The court granted approval of the settlement, finding that it was fair and reasonable as between the parties and in the interests of the Group Members as a whole. The court approved the applicant's compensation payment of $40,000, considering it to be justifiable and in the interests of the Group Members as a whole. The court also extended the Registration Deadline and set out various orders regarding the administration of the settlement and the assessment of costs.

The court granted approval of the settlement of the consolidated proceedings between the Applicant and the Respondent upon the terms set out in the Deed of Settlement and the scheme for the distribution of money paid under the settlement among Group Members. The court also authorised the Applicant to enter into and give effect to the Settlement Documents and the transactions contemplated for and on behalf of the Group Members. The court appointed Mark Geoffrey Barrow as the Administrator of the Settlement Distribution Scheme and set out various orders regarding the administration of the settlement and the assessment of costs. The court dismissed the consolidated proceedings on and from the date of completion of the administration of the Settlement Distribution Scheme. The court also set out orders regarding the assessment of costs, including the appointment of an independent costs consultant to inquire into and report on the reasonableness and recoverability of certain costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Approval of Settlement

1. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (the Act) and subject to order 5 below, the Court approves:

(a) the settlement of the consolidated proceedings between the Applicant and the Respondent upon the terms set out in the Deed of Settlement executed by the Applicant, on his own behalf and on behalf of the Group Members, and the Respondent dated 4 October 2023 (being Exhibit MGB-1 to the affidavit of Mark Geoffrey Barrow affirmed 5 November 2023) (Deed of Settlement); and

(b) the scheme for the distribution of money paid under the settlement among Group Members filed by the Applicant (being Exhibit AJH-5 to the affidavit of Arabella Jorgensen-Hull affirmed 4 October 2023) (Settlement Distribution Scheme),

(together, the Settlement Documents).

2. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, the Court authorises the Applicant nunc pro tunc for and on behalf of the Group Members (as defined in [5] and [6] of the Consolidated Statement of Claim dated 19 February 2021 and who did not file an opt out notice in accordance with the orders made on 15 December 2022) to enter into and give effect to the Settlement Documents and the transactions contemplated for and on behalf of the Group Members.

3. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, Mark Geoffrey Barrow be appointed Administrator of the Settlement Distribution Scheme (Administrator) and is to act in accordance with the rules of the Settlement Distribution Scheme, subject to any direction of the Court.

4. Pursuant to ss 33ZB and 33ZF of the Act, the persons affected and bound by the settlement of the proceedings be the Applicant, the Respondent and the Group Members (as defined in [5] and [6] of the Consolidated Statement of Claim dated 19 February 2021 and who did not file an opt out notice in accordance with the orders made on

15 December 2022).

Registration of Group Members

5. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act:

(a) the Registration Deadline as defined in the Settlement Distribution Scheme be extended to 31 December 2024; and

(b) those persons who have been added to the Register of Group Members by the Registration Deadline be considered Participating Group Members for the purposes of the Settlement Distribution Scheme.

Settlement Distribution Scheme

6. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Act, for the purposes of cl 36 of the Settlement Distribution Scheme, the Applicant's Compensation Amount, as defined in the Settlement Distribution Scheme, be approved for distribution from the Settlement Sum in the sum of $40,000.

7. Despite anything to the contrary in the definition of Settlement Fund in the Settlement Distribution Scheme, the Settlement Sum paid by the Respondent pursuant to cl 3.1 of the Deed of Settlement be paid into an account held and administered by Australian Unity Trustees Limited (ACN 162 061 556 / ABN 55 162 061 556) as trustee as contemplated by the definition of Settlement Trust Account in the Deed of Settlement.

8. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Act, for the purposes of cl 56 of the Settlement Distribution Scheme, the amount of $700,000 is approved to be paid from the Settlement Fund (as defined in the Settlement Distribution Scheme, and as provided for in order 7 above) to the Administrator on account of Administration Costs (as defined in the Settlement Distribution Scheme) to be incurred, or expected to be incurred.

9. The Administrator may apply to the Court for approval of his claims for payment of Administration Costs or Additional Administration Costs (as defined in the Settlement Distribution Scheme) in accordance with the procedure in cll 52 to 55 of the Settlement Distribution Scheme. Any such application must be supported by an affidavit disclosing:

(a) the invoice or invoices for which approval for payment is sought, pursuant to cl 52(a) of the Settlement Distribution Scheme; and

(b) the report of an independent costs consultant, as contemplated by cl 52(b) of the Settlement Distribution Scheme;

(c) whether the claim constitutes Administration Costs or Additional Administration Costs for the purposes of the Settlement Distribution Scheme, as contemplated by cl 52(c) of the Settlement Distribution Scheme.

10. The Administrator has liberty to apply in relation to any matter arising under the Settlement Distribution Scheme.

Dismissal of consolidated proceedings on and from the date of Final Distribution

11. The consolidated proceedings be dismissed, with no order as to costs and with all previous cost orders vacated, on and from the date of completion of the administration of the Settlement Distribution Scheme, being the date on which the Final Distribution of the Settlement Sum occurs under the Settlement Distribution Scheme, following the making of a Final Distribution Application by the Administrator and orders made by the Court approving a Final Distribution (as defined in the Settlement Distribution Scheme).

Assessment of costs

12. Until further order, the Administrator shall not exercise his power under the Settlement Distribution Scheme to make any Authorised Deductions (as defined in the Settlement Distribution Scheme) in relation to a claim for costs or disbursements.

13. By 4.00pm on 25 January 2024, the parties are to confer and where possible, reach agreement on any matters relating to the Applicant's Party/Party Costs (as defined in the Deed of Settlement) to be paid by the Respondent pursuant to the Deed of Settlement.

14. Any amounts claimed as costs that cannot be agreed pursuant to Order 13 (Applicant's Outstanding Claimed Party/Party Costs) are to form part of the reference to the Referee set out in Orders 15 and 16.

15. Pursuant to s 54A of the Act, an independent costs consultant nominated jointly by the parties or determined by the Court (the Referee) is to inquire into and report on the following questions (the Reference):

(a) the reasonableness and recoverability of the Applicant's Outstanding Claimed Party/Party Costs; and/or

(b) the reasonableness and recoverability of the Applicant's Other Solicitor/Client Costs (as defined in the Deed of Settlement) to be deducted from the Settlement Fund (as defined in the Settlement Distribution Scheme) (Applicant's Outstanding Claimed Solicitor/Client Costs).

16. The Reference will commence as soon as reasonably practicable after 25 January 2024, and for the purposes of the Reference:

(a) the Referee is to conduct the Reference in accordance with Div 28.6 of Part 28 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), and subject to the following directions;

(b) the Applicant's solicitors shall as soon as reasonably practicable deliver to the Referee a copy of this order and make available all information and records that the Referee advises are relevant to the Reference (with a copy to the Respondent);

(c) the Referee is to consider and implement the Reference to enable a just, efficient and cost-effective resolution of the Reference, which may include, as the Referee considers it appropriate or necessary:

(i) inquiries by telephone and direct communication with any person who the Referee believes may have relevant information, on notice to the parties; and

(ii) the making of directions to a party, or any interested third party, on notice to the other parties, including but not limited to directions to provide:

A. submissions;

B. evidence, which must be provided orally on oath or affirmation or in writing by way of affidavit; or

C. copies of any documents;

(d) the Referee is not bound to conduct the Reference in accordance with the rules of evidence;

(e) the Referee may submit any question arising during the Reference in relation to the inquiry for the decision of the Court and shall thereafter conduct the Reference with any answer or direction by the Court;

(f) by 1 March 2024, the Referee shall submit the Report (on a confidential basis) to the Court and to the parties. Subject to further order, the Report shall not be published or disclosed to any person or entity other than the Referee, the parties and their legal representatives, and the Court;

(g) if, for any reason the Referee is unable to comply with the order for delivery of the Report to the Court by 1 March 2024, the Referee is to communicate that fact to the chambers of the Honourable Justice Horan as soon as it becomes apparent to the Referee that they will be unable to do so;

(h) subject to further order, the costs of and incidental to the appointment of the Referee and the conduct of the Reference, including the Referee's reasonable costs, shall be paid in the first instance by the Respondent, with the question of where those costs ultimately fall to be reserved for the decision of the Court; and

(i) the Referee and the parties have liberty to seek direction with respect to any matter arising under the Reference upon 24 hours' notice, or such other notice ordered by the Court.

Further Hearing on Costs

17. By 4.00 pm on 15 March 2024, the Applicant file and serve any written submissions and evidence concerning the adoption of the Referee's Report and any proposed deduction of the Applicant's Outstanding Claimed Solicitor/Client Costs from the Settlement Fund.

18. By 4.00 pm on 28 March 2024, the Respondent file and serve any evidence and written submissions concerning the adoption of the Referee's Report and any proposed deduction of the Applicant's Outstanding Claimed Solicitor/Client Costs from the Settlement Fund.

19. By 4.00 pm on 8 April 2024, the Applicant file and serve any written submissions and evidence in reply.

20. The matter be listed for a further hearing at 10.15 am on 19 April 2024 to determine any outstanding issues related to the adoption of the Referee's Report and any proposed deduction of the Applicant's Outstanding Claimed Solicitor/Client Costs from the Settlement Sum.

Confidentiality

21. Pursuant to ss 37AF and 37AG of the Act 1976, to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, annexure SAT-1 to the affidavit of Samuel Alexander Tierney affirmed 6 November 2023 is to remain confidential until further order.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

There are some outstanding issues as to certain amounts to be deducted from the Settlement Sum under the Deed of Settlement and the SDS, including issues relating to the assessment of the applicant’s solicitor/client costs in excess of its party/party costs (the latter having been agreed to be paid by the Commonwealth). Those issues will be addressed in subsequent approval processes pursuant to orders made by the Court.BACKGROUND The representative proceeding The proceeding is brought by the applicant, Ali Yasmin, against the Commonwealth on his own behalf and on behalf of persons who:(a)are persons of Indonesian race, national and ethnic origin; (b)arrived in Australia between 1 January 2007 and 31 December 2013 as unlawful non-citizens in circumstances where they were: (i)apprehended by officers of the respondent on suspected illegal entry vehicles (SIEVs) and brought to Australia; (ii)suspected by the respondent of being involved in an offence under s 232A of the Migration Act;(iii)under 18 years of age; and (iv)unaccompanied by any adult who was able to act as their guardian; (c)were detained by or on behalf of the respondent; (d)were not immigration cleared for the purposes of the Migration Act; (e)did not apply for a visa or to otherwise remain in Australia; (f)were investigated for alleged offences under the Migration Act; (g)remained without a guardian while in Australia; (h)were ultimately removed to Indonesia by the respondent; and (i)are not any of the persons mentioned in s 33E(2) of the FCA Act,(Group Members). The consolidated proceeding is both factually and legally complex. It is sufficient for present purposes to outline the key aspects of the claims advanced by the applicant on behalf of himself and the Group Members, as set out in the Consolidated Statement of Claim filed on 19 February 2021 and the Reply to the Amended Defence filed on 7 September 2022. The applicant’s claims arise from events occurring over a period of approximately six years during which it is alleged that Indonesian children who arrived in Australia by boat between 1 January 2007 and 31 December 2013 were incorrectly assessed by the Commonwealth to be adults, and as a consequence were detained and imprisoned as adults for people smuggling offences contrary to s 232A of the Migration Act. It is alleged that these Indonesian children were transferred into the custody of the Australian Federal Police (AFP) for the purposes of being investigated for such offences, and were subsequently charged, indicted, prosecuted, convicted and/or imprisoned in adult correctional facilities in respect of those offences. The underlying circumstances from which these claims arise were the subject of an investigation and report by the Australian Human Rights Commission in July 2012 titled “An Age of Uncertainty”. The applicant alleges that, at the material times, the Commonwealth did not follow its own policies with respect to the assessment and treatment of unaccompanied minors arriving in Australia from Indonesia as unlawful non-citizens, in part due to the pursuit of an alleged “deterrence agenda” under which the Commonwealth sought to disrupt and deter the people smuggling business.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Subject to the question of the compensation amount payable to the applicant, which is addressed separately below, I consider that the distribution model contained in the SDS is “within the bounds of reasonableness in achieving a broadly fair, ‘rule of thumb’ distribution between the claimants”: see Camilleri at [42] (Moshinsky J).Conclusion In summary, balancing the litigation risks against the “best case” outcome, I consider that the proposed settlement is well within the range of reasonableness. It is fair and reasonable as between the parties, and is in the interests of the Group Members as a whole.Applicant’s compensation payment As referred to in paragraph 42 above, the SDS provides for a compensation payment to the applicant, in an amount approved by the Court, that is to be paid out of the Settlement Sum “in recognition of the risk, time and costs” incurred by the applicant in pursuing the consolidated proceedings on behalf of Group Members. The applicant’s interlocutory application dated 6 November 2023 seeks approval of a compensation amount in the sum of $100,000. A compensation or reimbursement payment of this kind requires consideration of whether such special or preferential treatment is justifiable and in the interests of the Group Members as a whole. The applicant submits that payments to representative applicants who have sacrificed time and incurred expenses in prosecuting an action on behalf of others are recognised as “compensation … for the time and expense attributable to the representative features of the applicant’s involvement as a party in the litigation”: Caason Investments Pty Ltd v Cao (No 2) [2018] FCA 527 at [176] (Murphy J). The applicant accepts that the amount of $100,000 is higher than the average or median payment made to lead applicants in other representative proceedings: see, e.g., Kuterba v Sirtex Medical Ltd (No 3) [2019] FCA 1374 at [23] (Beach J). However, the applicant submits that the amount is appropriate when one has regard to the “unusual” degree of inconvenience and hardship experienced by the applicant in discharging his representative role in the proceedings, so as to warrant a reimbursement payment above that which may be appropriate in an ordinary case. The applicant in this regard relies on evidence of Mr Barrow (see Barrow affidavit at [10]-[13]), who deposes to the fact that the applicant has instructed Ken Cush & Associates for a period of more than nine years, during which he has maintained contact with other Group Members and undertaken “extensive” travel from his home in the remote village of Balauring in the district of Omesuri in the sub-province of Lembata in the province of Nusa Tenggara Timur in Indonesia, including obtaining a passport and travelling to Australia, for purposes associated with these proceedings. The applicant has also had to undergo a medical examination by an Australian psychiatrist and had to recount highly distressing events including, among other things, being strip searched and shackled as a child in an adult prison. The applicant further submits that the proposed compensation amount takes into account that the applicant foregoes any entitlement to compensation in connection with an assault alleged to have been perpetrated against him while detained in a maximum-security adult prison in Western Australia, and in connection with his individual claim for misfeasance in public office.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

These considerations are a useful guide but should not be treated as a “checklist” nor necessarily as mandatory or exhaustive. In approving a settlement of a representative proceeding under s 33V of the FCA Act, the Court is instead tasked with making a broad, evaluative and impressionistic decision: Smith at [12] (Lee J).CONSIDERATIONThe proposed settlement is fair and reasonable In addressing the critical questions concerning whether the proposed settlement is fair and reasonable both as between the parties and in the interest of the Group Members as a whole, I have been greatly assisted by a confidential joint opinion provided by senior counsel and three junior counsel representing the applicant dated 6 November 2023 (Joint Opinion). As set out in paragraphs 25 and 26 above, the proceedings are still at a relatively early stage. While the pleadings have closed, there has not yet been any discovery and the parties have not filed their evidence in support of the claims and defences respectively (with the exception of two affidavits filed on behalf of the applicant and the expert report of Professor McFarlane intended to be relied on at trial). There are numerous factual issues which remain in dispute on the pleadings, giving rise to a number of contested legal issues. Some of the key factual issues that are in dispute are:(a)whether the Commonwealth conducted an age assessment of the applicant (and other Group Members), and the scope of any such assessment;(b)whether the applicant (and other Group Members) made a request to be removed to Indonesia within the meaning of s 198(1) of the Migration Act;(c)whether the Commonwealth knew at the relevant time that Wrist X-Ray Analysis is incapable of reliably determining a person’s age; and(d)the purpose of the applicant’s (and other Group Members’) detention under the Migration Act. Further, each of the causes of action on which the applicant relies will require the determination of a number of legal issues including:(a)whether the Commonwealth was under an obligation to remove the applicant and the Group Members as soon as reasonably practicable following their DIAC entry interviews;(b)how any failure by the Commonwealth to perform a duty to remove the applicant and Group Members as soon as reasonably practicable would affect the authority to detain under ss 189 and 196(1) of the Migration Act (see generally Commonwealth v AJL20 (2021) 273 CLR 43);(c)whether the detention of the applicant and the Group Members at the relevant times was authorised by ss 189, 196(1) and 250 of the Migration Act;(d)whether the Commonwealth owed one or more of the alleged duties of care, including whether or not such alleged duties are coherent or consistent with the statutory scheme under the Migration Act;(e)whether loss of liberty is a form of harm that is capable of being the subject of a claim in negligence;(f)whether the Commonwealth’s conduct in relation to the detention, investigation, charging and prosecution of the applicant and the Group Members involved distinctions based on race, ethnic origin or national origin in contravention of ss 9(1) or 9(1A) of the RDA;(g)whether the prosecution notice against the applicant was unlawful and, if so, whether the AFP officer who signed the prosecution notice against the applicant knew or was recklessly indifferent to the fact that the prosecution notice was unlawful; and(h)whether the claims for unlawful detention, negligence or misfeasance in public office are statute-barred by the operation of applicable statutes of limitation.