Yasmin v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Yasmin v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2025] FCA 123

File number(s): VID 328 of 2020
VID 664 of 2020
Judgment of: HORAN J
Date of judgment: 26 February 2025
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application for approval of costs – where settlement deed requires Court to approve applicant’s other solicitor/client costs and other payments deducted from settlement sum – where legal costs incurred in relation to dispute over costs orders – whether costs incurred by interveners form part of applicant’s solicitor/client costs – whether costs are reasonable and proportionate – application for approval granted
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 33V and 33ZF

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth) s 9(1), (1A)

Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT) s 300(1), (2)

Cases cited:

Bellamy’s Australia Ltd v Basil [2019] FCAFC 147; 372 ALR 638

Blairgowrie Trading Ltd v Allco Finance Group Ltd (in Liq) (No 3) [2017] FCA 330; 343 ALR 476

Caason Investments Pty Limited v Cao (No 2) [2018] FCA 527

Courtney v Medtel Pty Ltd (No 5) [2004] FCA 1406; 212 ALR 311

Earglow Pty Ltd v Newcrest Mining Ltd [2016] FCA 1433

Gulf Conveyor Systems Pty Ltd v Gulf Integrated Systems Solutions Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 1245

Kelly v Willmott Forests Ltd (in liq) (No 4) [2016] FCA 323; 335 ALR 439

Lenehan v Powercor Australia Ltd [2020] VSC 82

Lifeplan Australia Friendly Society Ltd v S&P Global Inc (formerly McGraw-Hill Financial Inc) [2018] FCA 379

Melbourne City Investments Pty Ltd v Treasury Wine Estates Ltd (2017) 252 FCR 1

Modtech Engineering Pty Ltd v GPT Management Holdings Ltd [2013] FCA 626

Petersen Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd v Bank of Queensland Ltd (No 3) [2018] FCA 1842; 132 ACSR 258

Redfern v Mineral Engineers Pty Ltd [1987] VR 518

Yasmin v Commonwealth of Australia [2023] FCA 1661

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 83
Date of last submissions: The Interveners filed written submissions on 1 November 2024
Date of hearing: 22 October 2024
Counsel for the Applicant: A Strahan KC with T Jeffrie
Solicitor for the Applicant: Ken Cush & Associates
Counsel for the Respondent: J Kirkwood SC with A Batrouney
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitors
Counsel for the Interveners: A R Di Stefano
Solicitor for the Interveners: Blaxland Mawson & Rose

ORDERS

VID 328 of 2020
VID 664 of 2020
BETWEEN:

ALI YASMIN

Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

IBU AAT KASWATI AND COLIN SINGER

Interveners

ORDER MADE BY:

HORAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

26 FEBRUARY 2025

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

A.On 21 October 2024, the applicant, the respondent and the interveners entered into an agreement (the costs agreement) pursuant to which they agreed that:

(a)the amount of the Applicant’s Party/Party Costs for the purpose of clause 3.1(a)(iv) of the Deed of Settlement dated 4 October 2023 is $4,794,103.38, inclusive of any GST;

(b)the amount of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yasmin v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 123
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Yasmin v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) involved an application for approval of costs by the applicant, Yasmin, in a representative proceeding on behalf of Indonesian children who were allegedly unlawfully detained in Australia. The applicant sought approval for the deduction of certain costs from the settlement sum agreed upon with the Commonwealth. The legal issues before the court were whether the costs incurred by the interveners formed part of the applicant's solicitor/client costs and whether the costs were reasonable and proportionate. The court had to consider the terms of the Deed of Settlement and the Settlement Distribution Scheme, which provided for judicial oversight of the legal costs to be charged to the group members.

The court found that the costs incurred by the interveners were indeed part of the applicant's solicitor/client costs and that these costs were reasonable and proportionate. The court based its decision on expert evidence provided by Ms Rosati, a legal costs consultant, who assessed the costs incurred by the applicant and the interveners. The court also considered the legislative tests and relevant case law to determine whether the costs were fairly and reasonably incurred. The court approved the payment from the settlement sum of the amounts sought by the applicant in respect of the Applicant’s Other Solicitor/Client Costs and the Authorised Deduction for legal costs.

The court granted the application for approval of the costs, ordering the payment of $2,073,369.26 for the Applicant’s Other Solicitor/Client Costs and $333,742.35 for an Authorised Deduction in respect of legal costs. The court concluded that the applicant's solicitors were entitled to be paid these amounts from the settlement fund, subject to the terms of the Deed of Settlement and the Settlement Distribution Scheme. The court emphasized the importance of judicial oversight in ensuring that the costs charged to group members in representative proceedings are fair and reasonable.

Orders

Orders of the court

2. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (the Act), and for the purposes of clause 4.1 of the Deed of Settlement, the following sum is approved to be paid from the funds held in the Settlement Fund by Australian Unity Trustees, or from funds held by the Administrator in a trust account comprising part of the Settlement Fund, to the applicant’s solicitors, Ken Cush & Associates:

(a) $2,073,369.26 for the Applicant’s Other Solicitor/Client Costs (as defined in the Deed of Settlement).

3. Pursuant to s 33V and 33ZF of the Act and for the purposes of clause 56 of the Settlement Distribution Scheme (SDS), the following sum is approved to be paid from the funds held in the Settlement Fund by Australian Unity Trustees, or from funds held by the Administrator in a trust account comprising part of the Settlement Fund, to the applicant’s solicitors, Ken Cush & Associates on account of the costs incurred in the proceeding:

(a) $333,742.35 for an Authorised Deduction (as defined in the SDS) in respect of legal costs.

4. There otherwise be no further order as to costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, I approve the payment from the Settlement Sum of the amounts sought by the applicant in respect of the Applicant’s Other Solicitor/Client Costs and the Authorised Deduction in respect of legal costs and disbursements after settlement approval. BACKGROUNDOverview of the proceeding The proceeding was brought on behalf of Indonesian children who arrived in Australia unaccompanied over a six-year period between 2007 and 2013 after having been apprehended on suspected illegal entry vessels, and who were investigated for alleged people smuggling offences under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Group Members). The applicant alleged that the Group Members were unlawfully detained or imprisoned as adults, before ultimately being removed to Indonesia. In addition to declaratory relief, the applicant sought damages for unlawful detention, negligence and contraventions of s 9(1) or (1A) of the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth). The claims in the proceeding are summarised in more detail in Yasmin (No 1) at [9]–[23].The Deed of Settlement and the SDS Under the Deed of Settlement, the Commonwealth agreed to pay a Settlement Sum comprising $27.5 million by way of compensation and an amount up to $2.5 million for Administration Costs, plus an amount in respect of the Applicant’s Party/Party Costs. Pursuant to the SDS and the Approval Orders, the Settlement Sum is held in an interest-bearing account administered by Australian Unity Trustees Limited (Settlement Fund). Clause 1.1 of the Deed of Settlement relevantly defines the Applicant’s Party/Party Costs to mean “[t]he Applicant’s party/party legal costs and disbursements of the Consolidated Representative Proceeding up to the date that the Approval Orders become final within the meaning of clause 2.1(b) of this Deed, as agreed or taxed, but does not include Administration Costs”. For such purposes, the “Approval Orders” are those made by the Court on 22 December 2023, which became “final” at the end of the 42-day period following the making of those orders, no appeal or application for leave to appeal having been filed. Under cl 3.1(a)(iv) of the Deed of Settlement, the Commonwealth is obliged to pay the Applicant’s Party/Party Costs within 14 days after they are agreed or taxed. Clause 4.1 of the Deed of Settlement provides that the Settlement Sum is to be applied and distributed in the following order:(a)payment of the Applicant’s Other Solicitor/Client Costs, as approved by the Court;(b)payment of Administration Costs from time to time on an ongoing basis in accordance with the SDS, as approved by the Court;(c)payment of any other amount approved by the Court; and(d)payments to the applicant and Group Members in relation to their claims in accordance with the SDS. The Applicant’s Other Solicitor/Client Costs are defined in cl 1.1 of the Deed of Settlement as “[t]hat part of the Applicant’s solicitor/client legal costs and disbursements of the Consolidated Representative Proceeding which exceeds the Applicant’s Party/Party Costs, but does not include Administration Costs”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Such factors will commonly be the subject of expert evidence from an independent costs consultant or a report by a referee appointed by the Court.Evidence on the application In relation to the fair and reasonable costs of the proceeding, the applicants and the interveners relied primarily on the First Rosati Report, the Third Rosati Report and the Fifth Rosati Report, together with the First Mossman Report and the Second Mossman Report dealing with the fees and expenses incurred by Mr Singer and Ms Kaswati. Ms Rosati is a legal costs consultant and the principal of DGT Costs Lawyers. She was engaged by KCA to provide an opinion as to the reasonableness of the applicant’s costs of the proceeding. Ms Rosati was provided with an extensive set of materials in relation to the proceedings, including costs agreements, pre-billing guides, electronic files, affidavits, court documents, judgments and orders, summaries of KCA’s professional costs, and copies of invoices. The approach adopted by Ms Rosati in assessing whether costs were fairly and reasonably incurred is addressed in the First Rosati Report, which considered the professional fees incurred up to 17 April 2023 and disbursements. Ms Rosati stated that she considered what work had been performed, the reasons for performing that work, and how the work had been carried out, including:(a)the resources utilised by the law practice and how they were utilised. Such factors as the work done by partners, solicitors and paralegals, the use of team structures and the use of counsel are relevant;(b)whether there was an appropriate degree of reliance on counsel;(c)whether an appropriate level of expertise was assigned to the tasks required to be carried out;(d)whether work has been performed that does not directly relate to the proceedings or was strictly administrative in nature;(e)whether billing and time recording practices themselves increased costs; and(f)whether there was any duplication of work. Ms Rosati explained the methodology that she had applied in order to provide an opinion as to a reasonable amount for costs as follows, stating that she had:(a) considered the terms of the costs agreement and the costs information provided by KCA to the Applicant (and other representatives in the AHRC complaint);(b) considered the hourly rates charged by KCA and counsel;(c) reviewed and considered the files of KCA maintained for this Proceeding;(d) considered the KCA time records and itemisation of disbursements and invoices provided by KCA;(e) considered the costs information provided by [Mr Singer and Ms Kaswati] (summarised by Ms Mossman);(f) applied the legislative tests in the [LP Act] detailed above to consider whether the costs and disbursements were reasonable in amount, or reasonably incurred having regard to the circumstances in which the work was undertaken, including whether the work was undertaken efficiently and appropriately, whether the work was undertaken by a person at the appropriate level of seniority, whether the task and charge were appropriate having regard to the nature of the work, the time taken, and the ratio of work and interrelation of work undertaken by the solicitors and counsel retained;(g) when applying these considerations, have had regard to judgments in other matters relating to the approval of legal costs in representative proceedings, including that in Modtech Engineering Pty Limited v GPT Management Holdings Limited (No.2) [2013] FCA 1163 and Wills v Woolworths Group Limited [2022] FCA 1545; and(h) formed an opinion as to the fair and reasonable amount for costs and disbursements.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, I approve the payment from the Settlement Sum, pursuant to cl 4.1(c) of the Deed of Settlement and cl 36 of the SDS, of an Authorised Deduction of $333,742.35 in respect of the legal costs and disbursements of the proceeding that were incurred after settlement approval in relation to the costs disputes.CONCLUSION For the reasons set out above, I will make orders pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the FCA Act in the terms sought by the applicant, approving the payment from the Settlement Sum of $2,073,369.26 for the Applicant’s Other Solicitor/Client Costs and $333,742.35 for an Authorised Deduction in respect of legal costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The issues for determination are confined to the approval of the Applicant’s Other Solicitor/Client Costs to be deducted from the Settlement Sum, and the approval of a further amount to be deducted from the Settlement Sum in respect of the legal costs and disbursements incurred by the the applicant and interveners in resolving questions about the costs of the proceeding.CONSIDERATIONApplicable principles The Court has a supervisory role in relation to legal costs that are proposed to be charged to group members by way of deduction from a settlement: see Melbourne City Investments Pty Ltd v Treasury Wine Estates Ltd (2017) 252 FCR 1 at [90] (Jagot, Yates and Murphy JJ); Kelly v Willmott Forests Ltd (in liq) (No 4) [2016] FCA 323; 335 ALR 439 at [11] (Murphy J); Modtech Engineering Pty Ltd v GPT Management Holdings Ltd [2013] FCA 626 at [26]–[37] (Gordon J); Lenehan v Powercor Australia Ltd [2020] VSC 82 at [7]–[22] (Nichols J). Such oversight is an important aspect of protecting the interests of group members. As Murphy J explained in Petersen Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd v Bank of Queensland Ltd (No 3) [2018] FCA 1842; 132 ACSR 258 at [88]:In class actions the requirement for judicial supervision of legal costs proposed to be charged is obvious because: (a) the applicant’s solicitor is in a more dominant position vis-a-vis a class member than in a solicitor-client relationship in individual litigation; (b) class members are commonly not told about the mounting costs as they are incurred and they suffer a significant information asymmetry in that regard; (c) it is not necessary for class members to retain the applicant’s solicitor and commonly they do not, yet they are usually made liable for a pro rata share of the costs; (d) even where class members retain the applicant’s solicitor they do not provide instructions as to the running of the class action and have no control over the quantum of costs, yet they are usually made liable for a pro rata share of the costs; (e) class members are unlikely to pay much attention to legal costs because they are usually only payable upon success and from the successful outcome; (f) it is usually not until after settlement is achieved that class members are told the total costs claimed, but they are not told (and it is commonly very difficult to accurately estimate) what their pro rata share of the costs will be; and (g) the Court has a protective role in relation to class members’ interests. These considerations are particularly relevant in the present case, where many of the Group Members do not speak English and reside in overseas locations, mostly in remote areas of Indonesia. The requirement for judicial oversight of legal costs was recognised in cl 4.1 of the Deed of Settlement, which expressly contemplated that amounts to be deducted by way of legal costs, including in particular the Applicant’s Other Solicitor/Client Costs, are subject to approval by the Court. This condition was an important consideration when making the Approval Orders: see Yasmin (No 1) at [57], [86]–[90]. At that time, I stated (at [86]):The Deed of Settlement provides for the Commonwealth to pay the applicant’s party/party costs, as agreed or assessed. The applicant’s other solicitor/client costs in excess of the party/party costs are to be deducted from the Compensation Sum, subject to the approval of the Court. In this way, the Deed of Settlement accommodates the need for judicial supervision of the solicitor-client costs to be charged by the applicant’s solicitors and borne by the Group Members: see, e.g., Petersen Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd v Bank of Queensland Limited (No 3) [2018] FCA 1842 at [87]-[89] (Murphy J); Kelly at [11] (Murphy J).