Courtney v Medtel Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Courtney v Medtel Pty Limited [2001] FCA 1365

PROCEDURE – discovery – notice to produce – without prejudice privilege – representative proceedings – where documents sought relate to settlement negotiations between respondent and group members in a representative proceeding – whether privilege extends to communications made between the party claiming the privilege and a third party – where documents are produced with names and addresses of group members obscured – whether applicant is entitled to see the names of the group members in the documents produced

PROCEDURE – representative proceedings – order sought by applicant that respondent not communicate with members of the representative group

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 131(1)

Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 201 CLR 49 followed
O’Rourke v Darbishire [1920] AC 581 followed
Cutts v Head [1984] 1 Ch 290 followed
Field v Commissioner of Railways (NSW) (1957) 99 CLR 285 followed
Harrington v Lowe (1996) 190 CLR 311 followed
Rush & Tompkins Ltd v Greater London Council [1989] AC 1280 considered
Austotel Management Pty Ltd v Jamieson (1995) 57 FCR 411 referred to
Bailey v Beagle Management Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 185 referred to
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Coombes (1999) 92 FCR 240 considered
Ralls v United States (1995) 52 F.3d 223 distinguished
Williams v FAI Home Security Pty Ltd (No 3) [2000] FCA 1438 considered
Courtney v Medtel Pty Limited [2001] FCA 1037 referred to
King v GIO Australia Holdings Ltd [2001] FCA 270 distinguished
Kleiner v First National Bank of Atlanta 751 F.2d 1193 (1985) considered
Resnick v American Dental Association 95 F.R.D. 372 (1982) considered

KEVIN GLYNN COURTNEY in a representative capacity on behalf of all persons in whom St Jude Tempo Pacemakers were surgically implanted in Australia v MEDTEL PTY LIMITED
N 661 OF 2000

STONE J
25 SEPTEMBER 2001
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 661 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

KEVIN GLYNN COURTNEY in a representative capacity on behalf of all persons in whom St Jude Tempo Pacemakers were surgically implanted in Australia
APPLICANT

AND:

MEDTEL PTY LIMITED
FIRST RESPONDENT

ST JUDE MEDICAL, INC, a Minnesota corporation with its principal place of business at One Lillehei Plaza, City of St Paul, Country of Ramsey, State of Minnesota
SECOND RESPONDENT

PACESETTER INC, a Delaware corporation with its principal place of business 15900 Valley View Court, Sylmar, California
THIRD RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

STONE J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 SEPTEMBER 2001

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

the notice of motion filed on 15 June 2001 be dismissed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 661 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

KEVIN GLYNN COURTNEY in a representative capacity on behalf of all persons in whom St Jude Tempo Pacemakers were surgically implanted in Australia
APPLICANT

AND:

MEDTEL PTY LIMITED
FIRST RESPONDENT

ST JUDE MEDICAL, INC, a Minnesota…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Courtney v Medtel Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1365
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Courtney v Medtel Pty Limited is a case that involved the issue of whether certain documents could be produced in court, specifically those that were prepared in connection with negotiations to settle a dispute. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The applicant in the case was seeking to produce certain documents that contained privileged information, but the respondents argued that the documents were protected by "without prejudice" privilege and should not be produced.

The legal issues that the court had to decide were whether "without prejudice" privilege extended to communications between the party claiming the privilege and a third party, whether the privilege applied to the production and inspection of the relevant documents, and whether it applied to those parts of the documents where names of the persons with whom the settlement negotiations were held were mentioned.

The court found that the documents were protected by "without prejudice" privilege and could not be produced in court. The court held that the privilege applied to all negotiations genuinely aimed at settlement, whether oral or in writing, and that it protected the parties to a dispute from the consequences of having concessions or admissions made for the purpose of settling the dispute put in evidence if the negotiations failed. The court also found that the privilege extended to communications made between the party claiming the privilege and a third party, and that it applied to those parts of the documents where names of the persons with whom the settlement negotiations were held were mentioned.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the notice of motion filed by the applicant and ordered that the documents in question could not be produced in court. The court also noted that it would hear the parties on the question of costs. This decision reinforces the importance of protecting the confidentiality of settlement negotiations and the public policy of encouraging litigants to settle their disputes.

Orders

Orders of the court

the notice of motion filed on 15 June 2001 be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant did not dispute that the amount of compensation referred to in each sub-bundle is privileged and did not press to see those amounts. The applicant did press its claim to see the names of persons with whom those communications were held and to tender the documents, with names revealed, in relation to the notice of motion.Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) – s 131The respondents submit that, given the notice to produce is expressed to be for the purpose of evidence, s 131(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (“Act”) entitles them to resist production of the documents. Section 131(1) is as follows:“Evidence is not to be adduced of:(a)a communication that is made between persons in dispute, or between one or more persons in dispute and a third party, in connection with an attempt to negotiate a settlement of the dispute; or(b)a document (whether delivered or not) that has been prepared in connection with an attempt to negotiate a settlement of a dispute.”I have examined the documents in Exhibit 1 and am satisfied that they have been prepared in connection with negotiations between the respondents and certain other persons concerning the settlement of a legal dispute. That being so, the communications that they record clearly fall within s 131(1) and could not be adduced in evidence. In relation to the discovery and inspection of these documents, the respondents concede that the decision of the High Court in Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 201 CLR 49 would preclude reliance on the section. Since the right to discovery and the production of documents does not depend on the admissibility of the documents in evidence (O’Rourke v Darbishire [1920] AC 581) the concession was rightly made. “Without prejudice” privilege The respondents’ alternative claim is independent of the Act and relies on the common law doctrine of “without prejudice” privilege which has not been modified by the Act; Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (above). At common law, privilege attaches to negotiations conducted “without prejudice” for the purpose of negotiating a settlement of a legal dispute. The rule, which governs the admissibility of evidence, is founded upon the public policy of encouraging litigants to settle their disputes; Cutts v Head [1984] 1 Ch 290 at 306 per Oliver LJ. It protects the parties to a dispute from the consequences of having concessions or admissions made for the purpose of settling the dispute put in evidence if the negotiations fail; Field v Commissioner of Railways (NSW) (1957) 99 CLR 285 at 291; Harrington v Lowe (1996) 190 CLR 311 at 323. The rule applies to exclude all negotiations genuinely aimed at settlement whether oral or in writing from being given in evidence; Rush & Tompkins Ltd v Greater London Council [1989] AC 1280 (“Rush & Tompkins”) at 1299. This case raises a number of issues concerning “without prejudice” privilege namely,(a)whether it extends to communications made between the party claiming the privilege and a third party;(b)whether it applies to production and inspection of the relevant documents;(c)whether it applies to those parts of the documents where names of the persons with whom the settlement negotiations were held are mentioned.

Decision

Reasons for decision

STONE J
Finally, if I were to accept the submission that the orders sought by the applicant should be made even in the absence of misleading conduct by the respondents, there would be no reason to distinguish between this case and any other representative proceeding. In the absence of a clear indication to the contrary, I do not accept that the legislature intended the public interest that is served by the efficiency of group proceedings to override the public interest in the settlement of disputes to this extent. In any event if would be quite inappropriate for a single judge at first instance to make such an order.CONCLUSION For the above reasons I am not prepared to make the orders sought by the applicant. The orders of the Court will be that the notice of motion be dismissed. I will hear the parties on the question of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: STONE J

Full text does not contain this section.