Field v Commissioner for Railways for New South Wales

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read
99 CLR 285

COMMISSIONER FOR RAILWAYS FOR

RESPONDENT.

NEW SOUTH WALES DEFENDANT,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Evidence-Action for negligence-Personal injuries-Negotiations for settlement-

Examination of plaintiff by medical practitioner retained by defendant-Admis- sion going to cause of action made by plaintiff to medical practitioner in course of examination-Admissibility of evidence from medical practitioner concerning admission-Whether privileged-Communication in course of " without preju- dice" negotiations--Nature and extent of protection afforded. Practice-Charge to jury-Invitation to consider inherent probability of plaintiff

falling otherwise than alleged if story true-Question of fact depending upon conditions arising out of ordinary experience obtained by observation-Question for jury-No ground for new trial-Allegation that plaintiff's story recent fabri- cation-Direction that as defendant challenged story as recent fabrication plaintiff thereby enabled to lead evidence of statements made to other persons as to how accident occurred-Claim that insufficient foundation for direction existed Plaintiff given no adequate opportunity of meeting suggestion-Challenge to correctness of judge's view as to what occurred at trial-Necessity of basing objection squarely on such a ground-Accuracy of direction in circumstances.

In an action for damages brought against the Commissioner for Railways F. alleged that whilst lawfully alighting from a train run by the commissioner he was thrown on to the station and permanent way and suffered serious injury. Solicitors for the commissioner opened negotiations for settlement of the action on a compromise basis in a letter marked without prejudice" and sought a medical examination of F. by a medical specialist appointed by the department. After further negotiations by correspondence headed " without prejudice " an appointment was made for F. to attend the rooms of a medical specialist for examination. At such examination F., in giving a history of his injury to the specialist, stated that he stepped out of a slowly

99 CLR 286

moving train as it had overrun the platform at which he desired to alight and he thereby sustained injury. At the trial the plaintiff was asked in cross. examination without objection whether he had given this version of the happen. ing to the specialist, to which he answered in the negative. The commissioner called the specialist who, having stated that he had obtained a history from the plaintiff, was then asked to narrate that history. Objection was taken to this evidence by F's. counsel upon the ground that the interview with the specialist was privileged as being 'without prejudice" The trial judge overruled the objection and the specialist gave the version of the occurrence set out above. Upon appeal,

Held, by Dixon C.J., Webb, Kitto and Taylor JJ., McTiernan J. dissenting, that the evidence was admissible in that it was not reasonably incidental to the settlement negotiations that such an admission should be protected.

The scope of the protection from disclosure conferred on admissions made in the course of negotiations to settle litigation discussed, and Thomas v. Austen (1823) 1 L.J. (O.S.) K.B. 99; Kurtz v. Spence (1888) 58 L.T. 438, at p. 441; Paddock v. Forrester (1842) 3 Man. &G.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Field v Commissioner for Railways for New South Wales and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1957] HCA 92
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales concerning an action for damages for personal injuries. The appellant, Percy Walter Field, alleged he was injured while alighting from a train operated by the respondent, the Commissioner for Railways for New South Wales. The core dispute revolved around the admissibility of an admission made by the appellant to a medical practitioner appointed by the respondent during settlement negotiations, and alleged misdirections by the trial judge to the jury.

The legal issues before the High Court were threefold: first, whether an admission made by the appellant to the respondent's medical practitioner during an examination, conducted as part of "without prejudice" settlement negotiations, was protected by privilege and therefore inadmissible; second, whether the trial judge's direction to the jury, inviting them to consider the inherent probability of the appellant falling in a particular direction based on ordinary experience, constituted a misdirection; and third, whether the trial judge's direction regarding the admissibility of evidence of prior consistent statements, in response to an allegation of recent fabrication, was legally sound and adequately supported by the evidence presented.

A majority of the High Court (Dixon C.J., Webb, Kitto, and Taylor JJ.) held that the admission made by the appellant to the medical practitioner was admissible. They reasoned that while communications in "without prejudice" negotiations are generally protected to facilitate settlement, this protection does not extend to objective facts or admissions that are not reasonably incidental to the settlement process itself. The Court found that the purpose of the medical examination was primarily to assess the appellant's injuries for settlement purposes and potentially for evidence if negotiations failed, but it was not reasonably incidental to the negotiations for the appellant to disclose the specific manner in which the accident occurred. Therefore, the admission was not covered by the privilege. The Court also found no grounds for a new trial regarding the judge's directions to the jury, considering them to be matters of fact based on common experience and a correct application of legal principles concerning recent fabrication. McTiernan J. dissented on the admissibility of the medical evidence, finding that the examination was an integral part of the settlement negotiations and thus the admission should have been privileged.

The appeal was dismissed with costs, affirming the decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established