Apotex Pty Ltd v Les Laboratoires Servier (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Apotex Pty Ltd v Les Laboratoires Servier (No 5) [2011] FCA 1282

Citation: Apotex Pty Ltd v Les Laboratoires Servier (No 5) [2011] FCA 1282
Parties:

APOTEX PTY LTD (ACN 096 916 148) v LES LABORATOIRES SERVIER AND ANOR;

LES LABORATOIRES SERVIER AND ANOR v APOTEX PTY LTD (ACN 096 916 148) AND OTHERS

File number: NSD 657 of 2008
Judge: FLICK J
Date of judgment: 10 November 2011
Catchwords: EVIDENCE – without prejudice settlement negotiations – claim for privilege – whether the “substance” of the communication already disclosed – whether non-disclosure “likely to mislead” the Court
Legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 122, 131
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 50
Cases cited: Adlam v Noack [1999] FCA 1606, cited
Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd v Dennis Family Homes Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 276, 193 FCR 479, referred to
Bhagat v Global Custodians Ltd [2002] NSWCA 160, cited
Bloss Holdings Pty Ltd v Brackley Industries Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 756, cited
Brown v Commissioner of Taxation [2001] FCA 596, 187 ALR 714, considered
Brown v Commissioner of Taxation [2002] FCA 318, 119 FCR 269, considered
Field v Commissioner for Railways for New South Wales (1957) 99 CLR 285, cited
Hoefler v Tomlinson (1995) 60 FCR 452, considered
In the Marriage of Bradford (1995) 120 FLR 75, cited
Korean Airlines Co Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (No 3) [2008] FCA 701, 247 ALR 781, considered
Leasing Centre (Aust) Pty Ltd v Rollpress Proplate Group Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 877, cited
Mulkearns v Chandos Developments Pty Ltd (No 4) [2005] NSWSC 511, referred to
Owners of Strata Plan 64622 v Australand Corporation Pty Ltd [2009] NSWSC 614, considered
Pitts v Adney [1961] NSWR 535, considered
Poulet Frais Pty Ltd v Silver Fox Company Pty Ltd [2005] FCAFC 131, 220 ALR 211, cited
Rodgers v Rodgers (1964) 114 CLR 608, cited
Silver Fox Company Pty Ltd v Lenard’s Pty Ltd (No 3) [2004] FCA 1570, 214 ALR 621, cited
Simply Irresistible Pty Ltd v Couper [2010] VSC 505, cited
Tim Barr Pty Ltd v Narui Gold Coast Pty Ltd [2008] NSWSC 1070, referred to
Date of hearing: 8 November 2011
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 52
Counsel for the Applicant/Cross-Respondents: Mr D K Catterns QC
Solicitor for the Applicant/Cross-Respondents: Freehills
Counsel for the Respondents/Cross-Claimants: Ms C L Cochrane
Solicitor for the Respondents/Cross-Claimants: Allens Arthur Robinson

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NSW DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 657 of 2008

BETWEEN:

APOTEX PTY LTD (ACN 096 916 148)
Applicant

AND:

LES LABORATOIRES SERVIER AND ANOTHER (ACCORDING TO THE SCHEDULE)
First Respondent

BETWEEN:

LES LABORATOIRES SERVIER AND ANOTHER (ACCORDING TO THE SCHEDULE)
First Cross-Claimant

AND:

APOTEX PTY LTD (ACN 096 916 148) AND OTHERS (ACCORDING TO THE SCHEDULE)
First Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

FLICK J

DATE…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Apotex Pty Ltd v Les Laboratoires Servier (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 1282
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Apotex Pty Ltd brought an interlocutory application in the Federal Court of Australia to challenge the assertion of privilege over six letters exchanged between the parties as part of settlement negotiations. The primary issue was whether the letters were privileged under section 131 of the Evidence Act, which excludes evidence of settlement negotiations, and whether the non-disclosure of one particular letter was likely to mislead the Court. The court considered whether the substance of the communications had been disclosed and whether the non-disclosure was likely to mislead the Court.

The Federal Court concluded that the six letters were part of an attempt to negotiate a settlement of the dispute, and thus fell within section 131(1) of the Evidence Act. The court rejected Apotex's submission that the letters did not form part of a settlement negotiation. Furthermore, the court found that the letter dated 23 September 2011 did not fall within either section 131(2)(b) or (g) of the Evidence Act, as the substance of the evidence had not been disclosed with the consent of all parties, and the non-disclosure was not likely to mislead the Court.

As a result, the Court made orders prohibiting Apotex from adducing evidence of the specified letters at the interlocutory hearing and reserved the costs of the Interlocutory Application. The court also recognised the importance of preserving the confidentiality of previous transcripts and the identities of the proposed additional Cross-Respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. At the interlocutory hearing to be heard by Bennett J on 11 November 2011, the Applicant may not adduce evidence of the:

(a) letter from Allens Arthur Robinson to Freehills dated 5 August 2011;

(b) letter from Freehills to Allens Arthur Robinson dated 25 August 2011;

(c) letter from Allens Arthur Robinson to Freehills dated 23 September 2011;

(d) two letters from Freehills to Allens Arthur Robinson dated 3 October 2011; and

(e) letter from Allens Arthur Robinson to Freehills dated 4 October 2011.

2. Costs of the Interlocutory Application as filed on 4 November 2011 are reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 131 of the Evidence Act provides in relevant part as follows: Exclusion of evidence of settlement negotiations (1)Evidence is not to be adduced of: (a) a communication that is made between persons in dispute, or between one or more persons in dispute and a third party, in connection with an attempt to negotiate a settlement of the dispute; or (b) a document (whether delivered or not) that has been prepared in connection with an attempt to negotiate a settlement of a dispute. (2)Subsection (1) does not apply if: …(b) the substance of the evidence has been disclosed with the express or implied consent of all the persons in dispute; or …(g) evidence that has been adduced in the proceeding, or an inference from evidence that has been adduced in the proceeding, is likely to mislead the court unless evidence of the communication or document is adduced to contradict or to qualify that evidence; or … The course of “without prejudice” negotiations, it may be noted at the outset, may be relevant in explaining what may otherwise be sought to be characterised as “delay”: Hoefler v Tomlinson (1995) 60 FCR 452 at 453 to 454. Spender J there relevantly observed :The rationale of the rule excluding evidence of settlement negotiations is the public policy of encouraging out-of-court settlements and the principle promoting the individual's right to enter into such negotiations openly and without interference. I acknowledge that the common law admits of a possible exception where delay is an issue, as in proceedings involving want of prosecution or laches. In such proceedings it is clear enough that the fact of without prejudice communication between the parties may be a relevant matter. It may explain delay, for instance. Another reason for the exception may be that in such cases the communication is not genuinely intended to be an attempt at settlement and therefore does not come within the general rule. Or it may be that the reason for its disclosure, namely to assess whether there has been unreasonable delay, does not offend the policy behind the general rule.Sackville and Kiefel JJ agreed. THE SIX LETTERS The six letters for which privilege is now claimed cannot be considered completely in isolation. They must be considered in a wider context. Relevantly, the events date back to at least 23 March 2011 when Apotex informed the Servier Parties that the proposed additional Cross-Respondents had roles in the manufacture and supply of the products the subject of the proceeding. The Servier Parties formed the view that the proposed additional Cross-Respondents were “proper parties to the proceeding”. They so advised Apotex by way of an “open” letter dated 4 May 2011. That letter stated that the Servier Parties would be willing not to join the proposed additional Cross-Respondents if certain admissions and undertakings were given. The letter identified those admissions and undertakings as follows:2.Admissions soughtOur clients would require admissions from each of your clients that finished perindopril product and API manufactured or supplied after 1 October 2008 is for all material purposes the same as the finished perindopril product manufactured and supplied by Apotex Inc and Apotex Pharmachem Inc prior to 1 October 2008. In order for this to work, it would also be necessary to finalise the issues relating to admissions and discovery, so that it is unambiguous as to what finished products and API are referred to in the admissions. These issues had been previously discussed but not concluded. The time is apposite to finalise these issues, in any event, given that the parties are now moving to the second tranche of discovery, the scope of which will be impacted by the form of any admissions. Our clients propose admissions from the Apotex parties in the following terms:(i) the API Sample is for all material purposes the same as the API in the finished perindopril products (whether manufactured or supplied before or after 1 October 2008); and(ii) the UK Experiment 3 XRPD Data is for all material purposes representative of the API in the finished perindopril products (whether manufactured or supplied before or after 1 October 2008)(where API, API Sample and UK Experiment 3 XRPD Data have the same meaning as set out in our Notice to Admit Facts dated 9 November 2009).3.Further Undertakings soughtIn addition to the admissions required above, our clients would require undertakings from [the proposed additional Cross-Respondents] that they will comply with a decision of the Court against Apotex Inc or Apotex Pharmachem Inc in the Alpha Crystalline Patent Proceeding as if it were made in relation to [the proposed additional Cross-Respondents]. Our clients would also require undertakings from [the proposed additional Cross-Respondents] that if any document required to be discovered by Apotex, Apotex Inc and/or Apotex Pharmachem Inc in this proceeding is not in possession, power or control of Apotex, Apotex Inc or Apotex Pharmachem Inc, but is in the possession, power or control of [the proposed additional Cross-Respondents], then [the proposed additional Cross-Respondents], as the case may be, will provide access to that document to Apotex, Apotex Inc and/or Apotex Pharmachem Inc, so as to enable Apotex, Apotex Inc and/or Apotex Pharmachem Inc to discover and produce it in these proceedings. Further correspondence was exchanged, including correspondence in response to the 4 May 2011 letter. On 10 June 2011 Freehills wrote that “our clients will not provide the admissions sought under heading 2 of your letter”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 131(2)(g) does not apply. The non-disclosure of the 23 September 2011 letter does not satisfy either of the “two requirements” set forth in that provision.CONCLUSIONS It is concluded that each of the six letters the subject of present dispute form part of an “attempt to negotiate a settlement of the dispute” within the meaning of and for the purposes of s 131(1) of the Evidence Act. The submission advanced on behalf of Apotex to the contrary is thus rejected. Notwithstanding the expression of a tentative view at the outset of the hearing on 8 November 2011 that the letter dated 23 September 2011 may fall within s 131(2)(b), it has ultimately been concluded that the letter does not fall within either s 131(2)(b) or (g) of the Evidence Act. . It is understood that Bennett J has made orders pursuant to s 50 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) in respect to preserving the confidentiality (in particular) of previous transcripts in this proceeding and thereby the identities of the proposed additional Cross-Respondents. Although any individual Judge has an independent discretion to be exercised as to whether any like order should be made, the preferable course in the present case was to make orders of the kind previously made by Bennett J. That order was made on 9 November 2011. Her Honour would unquestionably be free to vary or revoke that order in such manner as she sees fit. ORDERSThe Orders of the Court are: 1.At the interlocutory hearing to be heard by Bennett J on 11 November 2011, the Applicant may not adduce evidence of the:(a)letter from Allens Arthur Robinson to Freehills dated 5 August 2011;(b)letter from Freehills to Allens Arthur Robinson dated 25 August 2011;(c)letter from Allens Arthur Robinson to Freehills dated 23 September 2011;(d)two letters from Freehills to Allens Arthur Robinson dated 3 October 2011; and(e)letter from Allens Arthur Robinson to Freehills dated 4 October 2011.2.Costs of the Interlocutory Application as filed on 4 November 2011 are reserved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.