Haswell v Commonwealth of Australia (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Haswell v Commonwealth of Australia (No 3) [2023] FCA 1093

File number: NSD 431 of 2020
Judge: LEE J
Date of judgment: 25 August 2023
Date of publication of reasons: 13 September 2023
Catchwords: 1           REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application for approval of proposed settlement of class action pursuant to s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – proceeding commenced on behalf of group members who owned land in or around seven Royal Australian Air Force bases throughout the Commonwealth – where land contaminated as a result of the Commonwealth’s use of per-fluoroalkyl and poly-fluoroalkyl substances – where counsel’s confidential opinion detailed and carefully rendered – proposed settlement fair and reasonable – proposed settlement approved
Legislation: Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) Pt VAA, ss 33V, 33V(1), 33V(2)
Cases cited:

Davaria Pty Ltd v 7-Eleven Stores Pty Ltd [2020] FCAFC 183; (2020) 281 FCR 501

Smith v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2020] FCA 837

Watson & Co Superannuation Pty Ltd v Dixon Advisory and Superannuation Services Ltd (No 3) [2023] FCA 988

Wreck Bay Aboriginal Community Council v Commonwealth of Australia [2023] FCA 660

Wreck Bay Aboriginal Community Council v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2023] FCA 811

Principles of the Law of Aggregate Litigation (American Law Institute, 2010)
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 38
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr WAD Edwards KC with Mr RJ May
Solicitor for the Applicants: Shine Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr E Muston SC with Ms CO Gleeson
Solicitor for the Respondent: King & Wood Mallesons
Counsel for LCM Funding Pty Ltd (Intervener): Mr I Pike SC with Mr E Olivier

ORDERS

NSD 431 of 2020
BETWEEN:

REANNAN LAURA HASWELL

First Applicant

BEAUX DANIEL TILLEY

Second Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

JUDGE:

LEE J

DATE OF ORDER:

28 AUGUST 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Settlement approval

1.Pursuant to s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCA Act), the settlement of this proceeding be approved on the terms set out in:

(a)the heads of agreement entered into between the applicants, the respondent, Shine Lawyers, and LCM Operations Pty Ltd dated 14 May 2023 (HoA); and

(b)the Settlement Distribution Scheme (SDS) in Annexure A.

2.Pursuant to s 33ZB of the FCA Act, the persons affected and bound by the settlement of this proceeding are the applicants, the respondent, and the group members, other than:

(a)those persons who opted-out in accordance with s 33J of the FCA Act; and

(b)the City of Salisbury, other than in respect of any claim for diminution of the value of its land located in whole or in part within the Relevant Area as marked on Annexure 5A to Schedule 5 to the Statement of Claim filed 15 April 2020.

3.Any group member who previously registered to participate in the proceeding with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Haswell v Commonwealth of Australia (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1093
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Haswell and others brought a class action against the Commonwealth of Australia on behalf of group members who owned land in or around seven Royal Australian Air Force bases throughout the Commonwealth. The land was contaminated as a result of the Commonwealth’s use of per-fluoroalkyl and poly-fluoroalkyl substances. The Federal Court was asked to approve the proposed settlement of the class action under section 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The central legal issue was whether the settlement was fair and reasonable for the group members. The court had to consider the confidential opinion of counsel, the terms of the settlement, and whether the settlement adequately protected the interests of the group members.

The court examined the confidential opinion and the settlement documents in detail. The opinion concluded that the settlement was fair and reasonable, taking into account the risks, costs, and benefits of proceeding with litigation versus settling. The settlement provided a certain quantum of compensation now, rather than the uncertainty of a potentially prolonged legal battle. The court found that the settlement terms were consistent with other similar class actions and thus approved the settlement. The court also approved the ancillary orders, including the appointment of administrators and independent counsel, deductions from the settlement sum, and consequential orders for dismissal and costs.

The court approved the settlement of the proceeding and made several consequential orders. These included dismissing the proceeding with no order as to costs once the administration was complete, vacating previous costs orders, and releasing security. The court also granted leave to one group member to apply to opt-out of the proceeding and ordered that certain confidential material remain confidential for up to 10 years. The court further provided for group members to inspect the confidential opinion under strict conditions to prevent disclosure.

Orders

Orders of the court

Settlement approval

1. Pursuant to s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCA Act), the settlement of this proceeding be approved on the terms set out in:

(a) the heads of agreement entered into between the applicants, the respondent, Shine Lawyers, and LCM Operations Pty Ltd dated 14 May 2023 (HoA); and

(b) the Settlement Distribution Scheme (SDS) in Annexure A.

2. Pursuant to s 33ZB of the FCA Act, the persons affected and bound by the settlement of this proceeding are the applicants, the respondent, and the group members, other than:

(a) those persons who opted-out in accordance with s 33J of the FCA Act; and

(b) the City of Salisbury, other than in respect of any claim for diminution of the value of its land located in whole or in part within the Relevant Area as marked on Annexure 5A to Schedule 5 to the Statement of Claim filed 15 April 2020.

3. Any group member who previously registered to participate in the proceeding with Shine Lawyers or otherwise signed a funding agreement with LCM Operations Pty Ltd will be deemed to have registered in accordance with the Orders dated 6 June 2023, and will be permitted to seek a benefit under the settlement of this proceeding and is a “Claimant” for the purposes of the SDS.

Late registrations

4. Pursuant to s 33V and/or 33ZF of the FCA Act, any group member who has completed the registration form annexed to the Orders dated 6 June 2023 and provided it to Shine Lawyers by 21 August 2023 is permitted to seek a benefit under the settlement of this proceeding and is a “Claimant” for the purposes of the SDS.

Appointment of administrator and independent counsel

5. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the FCA Act, Craig Allsopp and Caitlin Wilson (of Shine Lawyers) be appointed as Administrators of the SDS to act in accordance with the SDS subject to any direction of the Court, and to have the powers and immunities conferred by the SDS on the Administrators.

6. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the FCA Act, James Mack be appointed as Independent Counsel of the SDS to act in accordance with the SDS subject to any direction of the Court, and to have the powers and immunities conferred by the SDS on the Independent Counsel.

Deductions from the settlement sum for the purposes of the SDS

7. Pursuant to s 33V(2) of the FCA Act, the Court approves the following just deductions from the settlement sum only:

(a) the “Applicants’ Legal Costs and Disbursements” in the amount $16,590,984.34;

(b) the “Reimbursement Payments” in the amount of:

(i) $50,000 to the applicants;

(ii) $35,000 to Colin Butland;

(iii) $9,000 to Christopher Carter;

(iv) $9,000 to Kevin Gavin and Ian Gavin;

(v) $9,000 to Timothy Francis Moore and Linda Janelle Condor;

(vi) $9,000 to Norman John Land;

(vii) $9,000 to Joanna Elizabeth Pickford;

(viii) $9,000 to Bradley Sutton;

(ix) $9,000 to Kevin Stewart Cole, Marlene Gail Cole and Cameron Jason Cole;

(x) $9,000 to Peter Fotopoulos and Chrisoula Fotopoulos;

(xi) $9,000 to GNB Nominees Pty Ltd ATF The GNB Family Trust;

(xii) $9,000 to Roger Paul Hurkens and Clare Lorraine Hurkens;

(c) the “Approval Costs” in the amount of $795,537.88;

(d) the “Administration Costs” in an amount of no more than $900,000;

(e) the “Funding Costs” in the amount of $33,175,000.00.

Consequential orders

8. The Court notes that the proceeding is to be dismissed with no order as to costs but such order for dismissal is not to be made until the Administrator provides to the Associate to Justice Lee a minute of order (containing a draft order dismissing the proceeding) together with written confirmation that the administration is complete.

9. All previous costs orders be vacated.

10. The security provided pursuant to the Orders dated 23 July 2020, 13 December 2021, 6 February 2023 and 17 April 2023 be released.

11. The applicants and the respondent have liberty to apply on three days’ notice to relist the matter for the purpose of seeking orders consequential to or in connexion with the settlement of this proceeding.

Leave to apply to opt-out

12. Leave be granted to Mr Mark Masetto (group member) to file by 1 September 2023 an interlocutory application to opt-out of these proceedings.

Confidentiality

13. Pursuant to ss 37AF and 37AG of the FCA Act, to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the Confidential Opinion of Mr W A D Edwards KC and Mr R J May dated 18 August 2023 (Exhibited to the Affidavit of Mr Allsopp dated 20 August 2023) (Confidential Opinion) remain confidential for a period of 10 years from the date of these Orders.

14. Pursuant to ss 37AF and 37AG(1)(a) of the FCA Act, to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice:

(a) the material in “Part A” of the Schedule of Confidential Material annexed to these Orders and marked “Annexure B” remain confidential for a period of 10 years from the date of these Orders;

(b) the material in “Part B” of Annexure B remain confidential:

(i) until the appeal period has expired without appeal or application for leave to appeal being filed in the Court from orders approving the settlement of the proceeding (Approval Orders); or

(ii) until all appeals in respect of the Approval Orders have been determined in such a manner that the Approval Orders have been upheld, and/or orders consistent with the Approval Orders have been made; or

(iii) if any appeals in respect of the Approval Order have been determined in a manner other than described in (ii), until further order of the Court.

Inspection of confidential opinion

15. Until such time as the proceeding has been dismissed in accordance with Order 8 above, group members bound by Order 2 above may, upon request, inspect the Confidential Opinion, provided the group member inspecting the Confidential Opinion agrees:

(a) not disclose the contents of the Confidential Opinion to any person other than the lawyer engaged by the group member;

(b) not make or disseminate copies (by any means) of the Confidential Opinion;

(c) to sign and be bound by the Confidentiality Undertaking (a template of which is contained in Annexure C of these Orders);

(d) inspect the Confidential Opinion in the presence of a Shine Lawyers solicitor or a nominated agent of Shine Lawyers;

(e) provide their Registration ID associated with their registration to the class action and a valid form of identification to a Shine Lawyers solicitor or nominated agent of Shine Lawyers on the date of inspection of the Confidential Opinion;

(f) sign the Confidentiality Undertaking in the presence of a Shine Lawyers solicitor or nominated agent of Shine Lawyers on the date of inspection of the Confidential Opinion;

(g) allow a copy of the signed Confidentiality Undertaking to be made by a Shine Lawyers solicitor or nominated agent of Shine Lawyers.

16. For the purposes of Order 15 above:

(a) a list of Shine Lawyers’ offices is at Annexure D of these Orders (with the addresses of the Darwin, Townsville, Adelaide, Perth, Parramatta and Sydney offices highlighted in yellow), and group members may inspect the Confidential Opinion at any of those offices, upon the giving of at least seven days written notice in advance;

(b) Shine Lawyers will appoint a town agent in each of Wagga Wagga and Wodonga (or Albury), so as to enable inspection of the Confidential Opinion by group members, upon the giving of at least 14 days written notice in advance so that Shine Lawyers can arrange for transmission of the Confidential Opinion to those town agents to facilitate inspection.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves a class action on behalf of group members who own land in or around seven Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF) bases throughout the Commonwealth. The land has been contaminated as a result of the Commonwealth's use of per-fluoroalkyl and poly-fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS). The class action was brought by the applicants against the Commonwealth of Australia as the respondent. The applicants sought to have a proposed settlement of the proceeding approved. The settlement was intended to resolve claims arising from the contamination of the land by PFAS. Counsel's confidential opinion detailed and carefully rendered the proposed settlement, which was considered to be fair and reasonable. The applicants and the respondent had reached an agreement on the terms of the settlement, which was set out in the heads of agreement and the Settlement Distribution Scheme.

The case was brought as a representative proceeding under section 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The proceeding was initially filed on behalf of the group members who own land in or around the seven RAAF bases. The matter came before the court for the approval of the proposed settlement. This was the third time the court had been asked to approve the settlement, with the previous applications being heard and determined in Haswell v Commonwealth of Australia (No 1) [2021] FCA 1440 and Haswell v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2023] FCA 404. The court had to consider the fairness and reasonableness of the proposed settlement, taking into account the confidential opinion of counsel and the interests of the group members.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I do not propose in this judgment to explain why I have previously taken the view that the making of a settlement CFO is licit as a matter of power. My views about this matter are set out in Davaria Pty Ltd v 7-Eleven Stores Pty Ltd [2020] FCAFC 183; (2020) 281 FCR 501 (at 514–515 [57]–[59] per Lee J, with whom Middleton and Moshinsky JJ agreed). There is a certainty as to precise quantum that exists in the making of a settlement CFO now that would not be present if a funding equalisation order was made. To take such an approach in this proceeding has the virtue of consistency with the way in which the other, similar class actions have been resolved. Accordingly, I am satisfied it is just for such a payment to be made out of the settlement fund.D CONCLUSION AND ORDERS For the above reasons, I propose to approve the settlement and make the ancillary orders discussed during the course of the day with counsel for the applicants and LCM. I congratulate the parties on reaching this settlement. Group members may feel that their fondest hopes may not have been realised, but hopefully there is some comfort that their worst fears also may not have been realised, being the prospect of prolonged litigation which may have meant they took nothing home at the end of the day. All I can do is indicate to them that, having analysed the confidential opinion very carefully, I consider the settlement is fair and reasonable, in view of my duties to ensure the interests of group members are adequately protected.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the application for approval of a proposed settlement of a class action on behalf of group members who owned land in or around seven Royal Australian Air Force bases throughout the Commonwealth. The land was contaminated as a result of the Commonwealth's use of per-fluoroalkyl and poly-fluoroalkyl substances. The court noted that counsel's confidential opinion, which was detailed and carefully rendered, played a significant role in determining whether the proposed settlement was fair and reasonable. The court referred to its previous views on the legitimacy of making a settlement funding equalisation order, as expressed in Davaria Pty Ltd v 7-Eleven Stores Pty Ltd [2020] FCAFC 183; (2020) 281 FCR 501. The court found that there was a certainty as to the precise quantum in making a settlement funding equalisation order, which would not be present if a funding equalisation order was made. This approach was consistent with the way in which other similar class actions had been resolved. The court was satisfied that it was just for such a payment to be made out of the settlement fund.

After analysing the confidential opinion carefully, the court concluded that the settlement was fair and reasonable, considering its duty to protect the interests of group members adequately. The court proposed to approve the settlement and make the ancillary orders discussed during the course of the day with counsel for the applicants and LCM. The ratio decidendi of this case is that, in determining the fairness and reasonableness of a proposed settlement in a class action, the court will consider the confidential opinion of counsel, the certainty of the quantum in making a settlement funding equalisation order, and the consistency with the resolution of other similar class actions.