Lay v PTTEP Australasia (Ashmore Cartier) Pty Ltd (Settlement Distribution)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Lay v PTTEP Australasia (Ashmore Cartier) Pty Ltd (Settlement Distribution) [2023] FCA 242  

File number: NSD 1245 of 2016
Judgment of: LEE J
Date of judgment: 3 March 2023  
Date of publication of reasons: 21 March 2023
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application to approve scheme for distribution of settlement proceeds pursuant to s 33V(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCA Act) – whether deductions proposed to be paid to litigation funder and solicitors are just – where referee appointed to inquire into and report upon reasonableness of legal costs – where report of referee adopted by the Court – proposed deductions from settlement sum allowed – orders made to tender settlement administration
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) Pt IVA, Pt VB, ss 33K, 37P(2), 33T, 33V(1), 33V(2), 33ZF

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) Div 28.6

Cases cited:

Bellamy’s Australia Ltd v Basil [2019] FCAFC 147; (2019) 372 ALR 638

Davis v Quintis Ltd (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) [2022] FCA 806

Gill v Ethicon Sàrl (No 11) [2023] FCA 229

Hogan v Australian Crime Commission [2010] HCA 21; (2010) 240 CLR 651

Lifeplan Australia Friendly Society Limited v S&P Global Inc (Formerly McGraw-Hill Financial, Inc) (A Company Incorporated in New York) [2018] FCA 379

Liverpool City Council v McGraw-Hill Financial, Inc (now known as S&P Global Inc) [2018] FCA 1289

Sanda v PTTEP Australasia (Ashmore Cartier) Pty Limited (Settlement Approval) [2023] FCA 143

Smith v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2020] FCA 837

Smith v Commonwealth of Australia [2019] FCA 2193

Australian Law Reform Commission, Integrity, Fairness and Efficiency – An Inquiry into Class Action Proceedings and Third-Party Litigation Funders (Report 134, December 2018)
Class Actions Practice Note (GPN-CA)
Referee and Assessor Practice Note (GPN-REF)
Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 51
Date of hearing: 3 March 2023
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms K C Morgan SC with Ms Z Hillman
Solicitor for the Applicant: Maurice Blackburn
Counsel for the Respondent: The Respondent did not appear
Counsel for Mr Sanda: Dr P K Cashman with Dr Townsend
Counsel for Harbour Fund II, LP: Mr D Sulan SC with Mr J Entwisle
Counsel for Maurice Blackburn: Mr C A Moore SC with Mr R Yezerwki

ORDERS

NSD 1245 of 2016
BETWEEN:

GUSTAV LAY

Applicant

AND:

PTTEP AUSTRALASIA (ASHMORE CARTIER) PTY LTD (ACN 044 210 164)

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

LEE J

DATE OF ORDER:

3 MARCH 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Settlement Scheme

1.Pursuant to s 33V or s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCA Act), the Court approves the settlement scheme dated 3 March 2023 (Scheme).

Deductions from the Settlement Distribution Fund

2.Pursuant to s 54A(3) of the FCA Act, the report of the referee, Ms Kerrie-Ann Rosati dated 13 February 2023, be adopted by the Court save…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lay v PTTEP Australasia (Ashmore Cartier) Pty Ltd (Settlemen... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 242
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lay v PTTEP Australasia (Ashmore Cartier) Pty Ltd (Settlement Distribution), the primary issue was the approval of a scheme for the distribution of settlement proceeds in a representative proceeding. This followed the earlier approval of the settlement itself, as detailed in the Settlement Judgment. The court was required to decide on the justness of deductions proposed to be made from the settlement proceeds, including those for legal costs and fees claimed by the litigation funder and solicitors. This decision came after a referee had been appointed to report on the reasonableness of legal costs, and the report had been adopted by the court.

The court carefully considered the objections raised by Mr Daniel Aristabulus Sanda, who was one of the group members, to the proposed deductions. Specifically, the court examined whether the report of the referee, Ms Kerrie-Ann Rosati, should be adopted, whether the fees claimed by Maurice Blackburn Lawyers Pty Limited (MBL) for certain interlocutory applications were justified, and whether the amounts proposed by the litigation funder, Harbour Fund II, LP (Harbour), were fair. The court adopted the referee’s report with minor exceptions, approved the proposed deductions for legal costs and fees, and made orders to initiate a competitive tender process for the appointment of a scheme administrator. Additionally, the court made orders to maintain confidentiality of certain sensitive information and set a deadline for the referral of a specific question regarding the costs incurred by Harbour.

The court's decision was grounded in the need to ensure the inexpensive and efficient resolution of the proceedings, consistent with the overarching purpose of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The court's orders approved the settlement scheme, approved specific deductions from the settlement distribution fund, and set out procedures for a tender process for the appointment of a scheme administrator. Furthermore, confidentiality orders were imposed to protect sensitive information and were to be lifted upon the expiration of any appeal period. Finally, the court ordered a reference for the tender process and directed that certain materials be submitted to the referee.

Orders

Orders of the court

Settlement Scheme

1. Pursuant to s 33V or s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCA Act), the Court approves the settlement scheme dated 3 March 2023 (Scheme).

Deductions from the Settlement Distribution Fund

2. Pursuant to s 54A(3) of the FCA Act, the report of the referee, Ms Kerrie-Ann Rosati dated 13 February 2023, be adopted by the Court save for paragraph 245 and to the extent the report refers to costs yet to be incurred.

3. Pursuant to s 33V(2) of the FCA Act, a reimbursement payment in an amount of $30,000 be approved from the settlement distribution fund (as defined under the Scheme) to Mr Daniel Aristabulus Sanda in recognition of his role as applicant in the proceeding up until 23 February 2023.

4. Pursuant to s 33V(2) of the FCA Act, the amount of Mr Sanda and Mr Gustav Lay’s costs in the sum of $28,316,727.79 as assessed by Ms Rosati, be approved from the settlement distribution fund.

5. Pursuant to s 33V(2) of the FCA Act, the amount of Harbour Fund II, LP’s:

(a) commission in the sum of $57,750,000; and

(b) expenses in the sum of $88,621.33;

be approved from the settlement distribution fund.

6. Subject to further order, pursuant to s 33V(2) of the FCA Act, the amount of Maurice Blackburn Pty Limited’s costs of, and incidental to, the settlement approval in the sum of $250,000 be approved from the settlement distribution fund.

Reference

7. Pursuant to s 37P(2) and s 54A of the FCA Act and r 28 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (FCR):

(a) the question set out in Schedule A (Relevant Question) be referred to a referee (Referee) for the purposes of the Referee conducting an inquiry into the Relevant Question (Reference) and providing a report in writing of no more than five pages to the Court on the Relevant Question referred to the Referee stating, with reasons, the Referee’s opinion on the Relevant Question (Report);

(b) the Reference commence within 14 days of the making of these Orders or on such other date as ordered by the Referee;

(c) the Referee consider and implement such manner of conducting the Reference as will, without undue formality or delay, enable a just, efficient, timely and cost-effective resolution of the Reference to allow completion of the Report including, if the Referee thinks fit:

(i) the making of enquiries electronically, by telephone or in writing;

(ii) in order to facilitate the Referee implementing the just, efficient, timely and cost-effective resolution of the Reference, the Referee is to make such directions as the Referee considers appropriate as to the conduct of the Reference; and

(iii) without limiting (i) and (ii), to the extent the Referee considers it is necessary or appropriate for the Referee to obtain any submission from any party, the Referee may make any direction the Referee considers appropriate in relation to such submissions including that any submissions be provided wholly in writing and be limited in length and topic.

8. By 4pm on 30 April 2023, the Referee submit the Report to the Court of no more than ten pages, addressed to the District Registrar, in accordance with FCR 28.66.

9. Mr Roland Matters be appointed as the Referee.

10. The applicant deliver to the Referee forthwith a copy of these orders, together with a copy of FCR 28 and a copy of a briefing note and the tax invoices for the fees rendered by Webb Henderson that are the subject of the Relevant Question.

11. The Referee have liberty to seek directions with respect to any matter arising in the Reference.

Confidentiality

12. Pursuant to ss 37AF(1)(b) and 37AG(1)(a) of the FCA Act, in order to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice and until the day that is 49 days after the date on which these orders are entered, the material identified in Schedule B not be published or disclosed.

Reference for Tender

13. On or by 30 March 2023, subject to further order, the applicant provide to the Associate to Justice Lee the names of three proposed referees to conduct an inquiry and report into the appointment of a scheme administrator.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Schedule A

RELEVANT QUESTION

What are the reasonable costs incurred by Harbour Fund II, L.P. in respect of the fees rendered by Webb Henderson pursuant to the definition of “Legal Costs” in the Funding Agreement?

Schedule B

Material Subject to Non-Publication Order Claim

Basis of Claim

Referee’s Report dated 13 February 2023

Annexure B, Paragraph 40

Statement as to the funding available for the conduct of the proceeding.

Paragraph 66, (a)

Annexure B, paragraph 63, second sentence

Annexure B, paragraphs 132 to 134

The material references a document which includes a confidentiality clause that obliges Harbour and the other parties to the document (including the former lead applicant Mr Daniel Sanda, Maurice Blackburn and Dr Peter Cashman) not to disclose the document or its contents (the Confidential Document).

Annexure B, paragraph 126

Annexure B, paragraphs 135 to 136

Annexure C, paragraphs 2.1 (a) to (j)

Annexure C, paragraphs 3.1 to 3.3

Annexure D, final two paragraphs

The information concerns case strategy or litigation risk.

Affidavit of Rebecca Gilsenan affirmed on 10 February 2023

Paragraph 10, third sentence

Paragraph 27

Paragraphs 29 to 39

Paragraphs 41 to 46

Paragraph 47, first sentence

Paragraphs 48 to 55

Paragraph 64 from “because” on the third line to the end of the paragraph

Paragraph 65

Ms Gilsenan’s confidential opinion on the value of the claim, the reasonableness of the settlement sum and/or privileged information about evidence that forms the basis of that opinion.

Paragraph 59, second sentence

Paragraphs 60 and 61

Paragraph 62, third sentence

Ms Gilsenan’s confidential opinion on the risks associated with the ongoing conduct of this proceeding and/or privileged information about evidence that forms the basis of that opinion.

Exhibit RG-5 (Counsel Opinion), page 212 to 224

Counsel’s confidential opinion on the reasonableness of the settlement sum and the risks associated with the ongoing conduct of this proceeding.

Affidavit of Rebecca Gilsenan affirmed on 1 March 2023

Paragraph 48

Paragraph 107, second sentence

Paragraph 136, first, third and fourth sentences

Ms Gilsenan’s confidential opinion on the value of the claim, the reasonableness of the Settlement Sum and/or privileged information about evidence that forms the basis of that opinion.

Paragraph 62, from the fourth word on the fourth line

Ms Gilsenan’s confidential opinion on the risks associated with the ongoing conduct of this proceeding.

Affidavit of Stephen Christopher O’Dowd sworn 28 February 2023

Paragraph 12(b)

Paragraphs 18 to 20

Confidential Exhibit SOD-2

Confidential Document

Applicant’s Submissions on Section 33V(2) Application

Paragraph 98, second sentence

Counsel’s confidential opinion in relation to the risks associated with the ongoing conduct of this proceeding.

Harbour Submissions on Section 33V(2) Application

Paragraph 22(b)

Paragraphs 27(a)

Paragraph 28

Confidential Document

Advice of Dr Peter Cashman dated 29 January 2023

Paragraphs 17.12 to 17.15

This is work undertaken by Maurice Blackburn concerning the value of the group member’s claims.

Advice of Dr Peter Cashman dated 8 February 2023

Paragraphs 6.2 to 6.5

This is work undertaken by Maurice Blackburn concerning the value of the group member’s claims.

Transcript of the hearing before his Honour Justice Burley on 7 September 2022 in proceedings NSD 1245/2016, NSD 715/2022 and NSD 716/2022

Whole document – included in Exhibit RG-8, pages 319 to 366

The transcript is subject to an extant suppression order by reason of its potential to impact upon the settlement of this proceeding

Copy of orders made by Burley J in proceeding NSD716/2022 on 7 September 2022

Whole document – included in Exhibit RG-8, pages 194 to 195

The orders are subject to an extant suppression order by reason of their potential to impact upon the settlement of this proceeding

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In Sanda v PTTEP Australasia (Ashmore Cartier) Pty Ltd (Settlement Approval) [2023] FCA 143 (Settlement Judgment), I approved the settlement of this class action pursuant to s 33V(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCA Act). It is unnecessary for me to rehearse the background to this proceeding, save to note that earlier this year, I made orders to bifurcate the settlement approval process such that following any approval, it would be necessary to determine subsequently the just distribution of funds paid under the settlement pursuant to s 33V(2) of the FCA Act. I have explained at length elsewhere why this approach has fidelity to the text of s 33V: see Gill v Ethicon Sàrl (No 11) [2023] FCA 229; Davis v Quintis Ltd (Subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) [2022] FCA 806. I determined to take this course because on the last occasion, Mr Daniel Aristabulus Sanda (who was at that time the lead applicant) sought to appear by two counsel: one barrister supporting the s 33V application (instructed by Maurice Blackburn Lawyers Pty Limited (MBL), the solicitors who acted for Mr Sanda at the initial trial); and one barrister opposing, among other things, the payment from any approved sum of the amounts claimed by MBL: see Settlement Judgment (at [2]–[7]). To provide Mr Sanda with an opportunity to ventilate those objections, I made several orders at the settlement approval hearing, including an order substituting Mr Gustav Lay as the applicant in the proceeding pursuant to s 33T of the FCA Act. I also made an order granting leave to amend the statement of claim to include Mr Sanda as a group member pursuant to ss 33K and 33ZF of the FCA Act: see Settlement Judgment (at [6], [34]). Today, as anticipated, Mr Sanda appeared by different counsel, Drs Cashman and Townsend, to oppose some orders sought for the distribution of the settlement proceeds. Broadly speaking, at the hearing, counsel for Mr Sanda pressed three issues relating to the payment of sums out of the approved settlement. First, there is controversy as to whether I should adopt the report prepared by the referee appointed to inquire into the reasonableness of the costs incurred by Mr Sanda in the proceeding. Mr Sanda contends he was not afforded procedural fairness by the referee. Secondly, Mr Sanda raised an issue with respect to fees proposed to be charged by MBL in relation to adjectival interlocutory applications filed in the proceeding last year. Thirdly, Mr Sanda submits that the amounts proposed to be deducted from the settlement proceeds by the litigation funder, Harbour Fund II, LP (Harbour), are not just in all the circumstances. I will deal with each issue in turn.B ADOPTION OF THE REFEREE’S REPORT Ms Kerrie-Ann Rosati was appointed as a referee pursuant to orders made by Perram J in November 2022 to provide a report with respect to the reasonableness of Mr Sanda’s costs for work done up to the date of the Report, and Mr Sanda’s costs (including costs of administering the settlement) yet to be incurred. Ms Rosati prepared a report dated 13 February 2023 (Report).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is necessary to deal with three final matters. E.1 Tender of Settlement Administration The draft orders provided to me proposed that MBL be appointed as scheme administrator. I was provided with some material constituting a proposed budget for the settlement distribution, which indicates that the costs of the administration will total approximately $2,240,000. In the wake of a number of recent cases (including Lifeplan Australia Friendly Society Limited v S&P Global Inc (Formerly McGraw-Hill Financial, Inc) (A Company Incorporated in New York) [2018] FCA 379 (at [52]–[54])), hopefully the assumption that persisted among those conducting Pt IVA work that solicitors for applicants are to be appointed scheme administrators, is slowly being dispelled. A competitive tendering process for the administration of a settlement approved by the Court is an important mechanism that is apt to reflect the Court’s protective and supervisory role in controlling the costs payable by group members in Pt IVA proceedings: see Bellamy’s Australia Ltd v Basil [2019] FCAFC 147; (2019) 372 ALR 638 (at 641 [13] per Murphy, Gleeson and Lee JJ); Gill v Ethicon Sàrl (No 11) [2023] FCA 229. In many cases, it may be appropriate that the solicitors acting for an applicant in Pt IVA proceedings be appointed as scheme administrators, but if the Court is to protect the role of group members, it should attempt to facilitate a process whereby costs are minimised. This is merely a reflection of the need of the Court in making any order, consistently with the overarching purpose in Pt VB, to facilitate the inexpensive and efficient resolution of the proceedings. Accordingly, I will make orders to initiate a tender process and for a referee to decide as to which response to the tender would best provide a fair and reasonable distribution of funds pursuant to the settlement scheme. Consistently with this course, I do not propose at present to approve any cost deductions relating to settlement distribution.E.2 Confidentiality Orders The draft orders also included orders proposing to prohibit the disclosure of information relating to, among other things, the funds available for the conduct of the proceeding and case strategy. The confidentiality orders proposed are proportionate, directed to ensuring they are necessary in the administration of justice, and pertain to matters which are truly confidential: see Hogan v Australian Crime Commission [2010] HCA 21; (2010) 240 CLR 651 (at 663–664 [29]–[30] per French CJ, Gummow, Hayne, Heydon and Kiefel JJ). Having said that, the applicant recognises that the suppression orders should only be in place for the time necessary to serve the ends of confidentiality. Accordingly, I will make orders that the suppression orders cease upon the expiration period of any appeal from the two sets of settlement approval orders.E.3 Costs of Settlement Approval Application The only other outstanding matter is the costs incurred by MBL in relation to the settlement approval application.