Greentree v Jaguar Land Rover Australia Pty Ltd (Carriage Application)

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Greentree v Jaguar Land Rover Australia Pty Ltd (Carriage Application) [2023] FCA 1209

File numbers: NSD 1010 of 2022
NSD 85 of 2023
Judgment of: LEE J
Date of judgment: 12 October 2023
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – multiplicity of proceedings – where two substantially duplicative open class actions commenced – two funded class actions – common fund orders sought – questions of carriage deferred pending delivery of judgment in Elliott-Carde v McDonald’s Australia Limited [2023] FCAFC 162 – Court should strive to resolve carriage issues with a minimum of cost and a maximum of expedition – contrary to the administration of justice for substantially duplicative, open class proceedings to continue without sound justification – application of multi-factorial approach – consideration of discrete factors – number of factors neutral – experience of solicitors in conducting analogous claims most compelling factor absent issues of cost – one funded class action permanently stayed subject to applicants giving undertaking to match costs regime of the other funded class action
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2, ss 2(1), 54, 236, 271, 272, 272(1)(a), 272(1)(b)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) Pt IVA, Pt VB, ss 33E(2), 33N, 33V, 33V(2), 33X, 33Y, 33Z, 33Z(1)(e), 33Z(1)(f), 33ZA, 33ZG(c)(iv), 33ZJ(3)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) Sch 3, rr 9.12(1), 30.11

Legal Profession Law Application Act 2014 (Vic), s 183(1)

Cases cited:

CJMcG Pty Ltd as Trustee for the CJMcG Superannuation Fund v Boral Limited (No 2) [2021] FCA 350; (2021) 389 ALR 699

Elliott-Carde v McDonald’s Australia Limited [2023] FCAFC 162

J & J Richards Super Pty Ltd v Linchpin Capital Group Limited (Settlement Approval) [2023] FCA 656

Klemweb Nominees Pty Ltd (as trustee for the Klemweb Superannuation Fund) v BHP Group Ltd [2019] FCAFC 107; (2019) 369 ALR 583

McKay Super Solutions Pty Ltd (Trustee) v Bellamy’s Australia Ltd [2017] FCA 947

Money Max Int Pty Ltd v QBE Insurance Group Ltd [2016] FCAFC 148; (2016) 245 FCR 191

Perera v GetSwift Ltd [2018] FCA 732; (2018) 263 FCR 1

R&B Investments Pty Ltd (Trustee) v Blue Sky Alternative Investments Limited (Administrators Appointed) (in liq) (Carriage Application No 2) [2023] FCA 142

Wigmans v AMP Limited [2021] HCA 7; (2021) 270 CLR 623

Williams v Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Limited (Initial Trial) [2022] FCA 344

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Number of paragraphs: 107
Date of hearing: 28 February 2023
Counsel for the applicant in NSD 1010 of 2022: Mr S Free SC with Mr P Meagher and Mr P Strickland
Solicitors for the applicant in NSD 1010 of 2022: Gilbert + Tobin
Counsel for the applicant in NSD 85 of 2023: Mr C Moore SC with Mr J Entwisle
Solicitors for the applicant in NSD 85 of 2023: Maurice Blackburn
Counsel for the respondent in NSD 1010 of 2022: Mr M Darke SC with Mr I Ahmed
Solicitors for the…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Greentree v Jaguar Land Rover Australia Pty Ltd (Carriage Ap... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1209
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Greentree v Jaguar Land Rover Australia Pty Ltd involved two funded class actions brought against Jaguar Land Rover Australia Pty Ltd, concerning alleged defects in diesel particulate filter systems in motor vehicles sold to Australian consumers. The court was required to decide whether to permanently stay one of the proceedings to prevent duplicative and costly litigation. The legal issues included the appropriate approach to resolving multiplicity of proceedings in class actions, the factors to consider in determining whether to stay one of the proceedings, and the implications of the competing funding proposals.

The court applied a multi-factorial approach to determine whether to stay one of the proceedings. It considered factors such as the number of proceedings, the experience of solicitors, the funding models, and the cost implications. The experience of the solicitors in conducting analogous claims was the most compelling factor. However, since one of the proceedings was funded, the court found that the issue of cost was neutral. The court deferred the decision on common fund orders pending the judgment in Elliott-Carde v McDonald’s Australia Limited.

The court decided that it was contrary to the administration of justice for substantially duplicative, open class proceedings to continue without sound justification. Therefore, the court granted the application to stay one of the proceedings permanently, subject to the applicants providing an undertaking to match the costs regime of the other proceeding. If the undertaking was not provided, the court would declass and temporarily stay the proceeding pending mediation and further stays if necessary. The court appreciated the care and thought that went into the funding models in both proceedings and acknowledged the benefits of competitive class actions.

The court made orders to facilitate the course it had outlined. It granted leave to the applicants in the Greentree proceeding to intervene in the Jennings proceeding, required an undertaking to be provided within 28 days, and set out the consequences if the undertaking was not provided or accepted. The court reserved costs and allowed for immediate relisting upon delivery of the proposed undertaking.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to rule 9.12(1) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the applicants in proceeding NSD 1010 of 2022 (Greentree proceeding) be granted leave to intervene in proceeding NSD 85 of 2022 (Jennings proceeding).

2. In the event the applicants in the Greentree proceeding (Greentree applicants), Gilbert + Tobin and Balance Legal Capital II UK Ltd (Balance) provide to the Associate to Justice Lee an undertaking to the Court within 28 days of these Orders that the Greentree applicants, Gilbert + Tobin and Balance will not seek to recover a total amount upon any settlement or judgment representing all legal costs, and other fees and expenses of more than 25 per cent (proposed undertaking) then, upon the receipt and acceptance by the Court of the proposed undertaking as an undertaking to the Court, the Jennings proceeding be permanently stayed.

3. A copy of the proposed undertaking is to be served on the applicants in the Jennings proceeding immediately upon its delivery to the Associate to Justice Lee.

4. In the event the proposed undertaking is not provided in accordance with Order 2 above or is thereafter not accepted by the Court, the Greentree proceeding be declassed pursuant to s 33N of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and then be temporarily stayed pending a mediation of the Jennings proceeding and the Greentree proceeding (with the intention that if the mediation does not result in a s 33V application in the Jennings proceeding, the Greentree proceeding then be the subject of a further stay until after the initial trial and determination of common questions in the Jennings proceeding).

5. Liberty to any party in the Greentree proceeding or Jennings proceeding to relist the proceeding immediately upon delivery of any proposed undertaking to the Associate to Justice Lee.

6. Costs be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I have organised the balance of these reasons under the following headings:B BACKGROUND TO THE PROCEEDINGS C THE RELEVANT LAW D CONSIDERATION OF RELEVANT FACTORSE THE APPROPRIATE REMEDYF THE POSSIBLE WAYS FORWARDG CONCLUSION AND ORDERSB BACKGROUND TO THE PROCEEDINGSB.1 The Greentree Proceeding The Greentree proceeding was commenced on 23 November 2022. It is being conducted by the firm of solicitors, Gilbert + Tobin, and is funded by Balance Legal Capital II UK Ltd, being a fund managed by Balance Legal Capital LLP (collectively, Balance). For reasons that will assume some importance, Gilbert + Tobin successfully conducted almost identical claims the subject of these proceedings on behalf of applicants in a class action against Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Limited (Toyota proceeding) concerning allegedly defective diesel particulate filter (DPF) systems in motor vehicles sold to Australian consumers (see Williams v Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Limited (Initial Trial) [2022] FCA 344). Mr Mackenzie and Ms Spigelman, partners of Gilbert + Tobin, have had carriage of the Toyota proceeding since April 2019. Mr Mackenzie gave evidence in his affidavit sworn 26 February 2023 (Mackenzie Affidavit) that Gilbert + Tobin began investigating matters the subject of the Greentree proceeding in around April 2022. The investigation conducted by Gilbert + Tobin was thorough. It has involved three stages, the first of which comprised of searches and reviews of information relating to DPF systems in diesel vehicles distributed by Jaguar in Australia and issues consumers reported experiencing with the DPF systems. The second stage involved Gilbert + Tobin negotiating the provision of “seed funding” with Balance to enable Mr Smithers (a technical expert engaged by the Greentree applicants) to investigate technical matters, and to enable Gilbert + Tobin counsel to identify a suitable representative applicant (or applicants) and prepare an originating application and statement of claim. In May 2022, Gilbert + Tobin and Balance entered into an agreement pursuant to which Balance agreed to provide the seed feeding to facilitate the investigation. The third stage involved Mr Smithers and solicitors from Gilbert + Tobin between May and October 2022 investigating various technical matters, including, among other things:(1)reviewing public information collated by Gilbert + Tobin for the purpose of designing a detailed plan for inspecting and testing certain models of diesel motor vehicles distributed by Jaguar in Australia;(2)physically inspecting and testing 14 diesel motor vehicles which featured a Jaguar “D8” or “D7U” vehicle platform, which included Mr Smithers and Mr Schenk (an employee of Mr Smithers’ company, 44 Energy Technologies) travelling from the United States to Australia to inspect, inter alia: (a)the physical design, layout, geometry, components and operation of DPF systems in the relevant vehicles; (b)the servicing records of the relevant vehicles; and (c)oil samples from the relevant vehicles;(3)conducting a programme of logging data recorded by on-board computers of 11 diesel motor vehicles distributed by Jaguar in Australia, including calibrating “HEM data loggers” which collected real-time data about the performance of the vehicles while they were being driven, including:(a)the frequency and duration of regeneration experienced by the vehicles;(b)the temperature of the exhaust produced by the vehicles’ engines measured at different locations in the DPF systems; and(c)the speeds at which the vehicles were being driven; and(4)Mr Smithers and Mr Schenk participating in video conferences with counsel and solicitors from Gilbert + Tobin with respect to the results of tests on the operation of DPF Systems.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further, if an undertaking is not provided, it would be inappropriate to grant a permanent stay of the Greentree proceeding as no doubt significant costs have been incurred and there will be a necessity to deal with the individual claim. Accordingly, after a declassing, a temporary stay will be maintained until there is a mediation of both proceedings, which I will order in due course. If the mediation is unsuccessful and there is a necessity to determine common issues, then the Greentree proceeding will be further stayed until after the initial trial. Although if an undertaking is not provided, the adverse consequences of losing the benefit of the experience of Gilbert + Tobin could be somewhat mitigated by counsel previously instructed by Gilbert + Tobin, who have had extensive experience in the Toyota class action, being briefed in the Jennings proceeding, if it was thought appropriate that this course be adopted.G CONCLUSION AND ORDERS It would be remiss of me not to record the Court’s appreciation for the evident care and thought that has gone into the funding models in both proceedings. The competition engendered by competitive class actions places demands upon the Court and might be conducive of some delay. Counterbalanced against this, however, is the reality that the sort of funding proposals the Court has considered in this case are vast improvements on those pursuant to which class actions were conducted at an earlier stage in the development of Pt IVA. Accordingly, I will make orders facilitating the course I have outlined above.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I should stress that I have had the opportunity of reading the affidavit material and the submissions filed by the applicants in both proceedings and, to the extent that I do not refer to any of the material filed, it does not mean that I have not had regard to it. These applications are not to be equated to mini-hearings. Indeed, at some risk of repetition, it is inimical to the overarching purpose in Pt VB to allow applications such as the present to give rise to lengthy judgment and delay the pursuit of the substantive underlying claims. The only reason why the resolution of this dispute has been delayed is because of the necessity to await the Full Court’s decision as to common fund orders.D CONSIDERATION OF RELEVANT FACTORS I now turn to consider each of the factors relevant in the circumstances of this case dealing initially with the two most prominent factors I have identified.D.1 Competing Funding Proposals Two competing funding proposals are in evidence, and it is necessary to descend into the detail of each proposal.D.1.1 The Greentree proposal This funding proposal is reflected in the funding agreement dated 15 November 2022 (Greentree LFA). Also relevant are the retainer and conditional costs agreement between the Greentree applicants and Gilbert + Tobin dated 14 November 2022 (Greentree Retainer) and the coordination agreement between Gilbert + Tobin and Balance dated 15 November 2022 (Greentree Coordination Agreement). In summary, pursuant to those agreements, Balance is to fund Gilbert + Tobin’s legal fees and disbursements, adverse costs awards, the costs of any “after-the-event” (ATE) insurance and the costs of any insurance or deed of indemnity providing for security for costs: Greentree LFA, cl 5.1. As consideration, subject to the Court’s approval, Balance is entitled to recover a commission on the resolution sum of:(1)20 per cent if the proceeding is resolved within 12 months of its commencement (that is, by 23 November 2023); (2)25 per cent from 23 November 2023 until six weeks before the trial; or (3)30 per cent thereafter. In the event of any appeal (or further appeal), Balance is entitled to recover a further five per cent per appeal, including all legal costs and any adverse costs liability: Greentree LFA, cll 5.1, 8.1. ATE insurance costs are also said to be recoverable notwithstanding the fact that several judges of this Court, experienced in class actions, have pointed to the inappropriateness of such an impost to be recovered by a funder which, in substance, is a cost incurred to defray the very risk to be run by the funder in exchange for its funding commission. If a traditional funding fee is sought, it is generally unfair that the cost of this prudential protection for the funder should be visited upon group members. Put bluntly, the exposure to risk is what the funder is being paid for. As I recently said in J & J Richards Super Pty Ltd v Linchpin Capital Group Limited (Settlement Approval) [2023] FCA 656 (at [54]): “[t]here is a limit to how much a funder should be allowed to wet its beak”.