FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Pearson v State of Queensland (No 2) [2020] FCA 619
File number:
QUD 714 of 2016
Judge:
MURPHY J
Date of judgment:
17 January 2020
Date of publication of reasons:
8 May 2020
Catchwords:
REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application for court approval of settlement under s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – claim by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander workers in respect of wages earned but not paid between 1939 and 1972 –relevant principles in relation to settlement approval – whether the settlement amount is fair and reasonable – whether proposed deductions including for legal costs and funding commission are fair and reasonable – consideration of objections to the settlement – the operation of the extant common fund order – settlement approved
Legislation:
Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth)
Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth)
Imperial Acts Application Act 1984 (Qld)
Limitation Act 1960 (Qld)
Limitation of Actions Act 1974 (Qld)
Statute of Frauds and Limitations 1867 (Qld)
Succession Act1981 (Qld)
The Aboriginals Preservation and Protection Act of 1939 (Qld)
The Aborigines’ and Torres Strait Islanders’ Affairs Act 1965 (Qld)
The Aborigines’ and Torres Strait Islanders’ Regulations of 1966
The Torres Strait Islanders Act of 1939 (Qld)
The Aboriginals Regulations of 1945 (Qld)
The Islanders Regulations 1946 (Qld)
Colonial Laws Validity Act 1865 (Imp)
Slavery Abolition Act 1833 (Imp)
Cases cited:
Blairgowrie Trading Ltd v Allco Finance Group Ltd (Recs & Mgrs Apptd) (In Liq) (No 3) [2017] FCA 330; (2017) 343 ALR 476
BMW Australia Ltd v Brewster [2019] HCA 45 (2019) 374 ALR 627
Chubb Insurance Co of Australia Ltd v Moore [2013] NSWCA 212; (2013) 302 ALR 101
Commercial Bank of Australia v Amadio [1983] HCA 14; (1983) 151 CLR 447
Cubillo v Commonwealth of Australia [2001] FCA 1213; (2001) 112 FCR 455
Darwalla Milling Co Ltd v F Hoffman-La Roche (No 2) [2006] FCA 1388; (2006) 236 ALR 322
Kelly v Willmott Forests Ltd (in liquidation) (No 4) [2016] FCA 323; (2016) 335 ALR 439
Money Max Int Pty Limited (Trustee) v QBE Insurance Group Limited [2016] FCAFC 148; (2016) 338 ALR 188
Santa Trade Concerns Pty Limited v Robinson (No 2) [2018] FCA 1491
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Pearson v State of Queensland (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] FCA 619
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine if the settlement was fair and reasonable, taking into account the relevant principles for settlement approval, and if the proposed deductions were equitable. Additionally, the court had to review objections to the settlement and assess the impact of the common fund order on the settlement process.
The court approved the settlement, reasoning that the settlement amount was fair and reasonable, and the proposed deductions were justified. The decision was based on a comprehensive notice regime and community outreach program to ensure all class members were informed of the settlement. The court also found that the common fund order did not adversely affect the settlement. The court's orders included provisions for class member registration, confidentiality, and the appointment of administrators for the settlement distribution scheme. The court also approved further amounts for legal costs and disbursements and directed the Queensland Government to provide access to a relevant database for data verification purposes.
The final orders included the approval of the settlement, the discharge of certain undertakings, and the appointment of administrators for the settlement distribution scheme. The court also ordered that all existing costs orders in the proceeding be vacated and directed the Queensland Government to provide access to a relevant database for data verification purposes.
Orders
Orders of the court
OTHER MATTERS:
A. The Court notes that the common fund order, Order 2 of the Orders made on 25 August 2017, continues in effect.
AND THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
Confidentiality
1. Pursuant to ss 37AF and 37AG(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (the Act), and to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, each of:
(a) Exhibits JT1, JT2, the second sentence of paragraph 21 and paragraph 22 of the Second Affidavit of Jerry Tucker filed 19 November 2019;
(b) Exhibit JB1 of the Sixth Affidavit of John Bottoms filed 13 December 2019;
(c) the Applicant’s confidential submissions in response to Mr Msii’s submissions, filed 10 December 2019,
shall be treated as confidential and, subject to further order of the Court:
(i) the relevant exhibits, affidavits and submissions be sealed on the Court file in envelopes marked “Not to be opened except by leave of the Court or a Judge” and are not to be published or made available in the Registry or on the Court’s internet platform;
(ii) not disclosed to any person other than:
1. the Court;
2. the Applicant and his legal representatives;
3. LLS and its legal representatives;
4. upon the giving of a confidentiality undertaking in a form reasonably satisfactory to the Applicant or approved by the Court – group members and their legal representatives.
Group member registration
2. The 168 persons referred to at paragraph 17 of the Sixth Affidavit of Jerry Tucker filed 17 December 2019, being persons from Papua New Guinea who have provided registration forms to Bottoms English Lawyers (BELAW), are deemed to have been registered in accordance with the orders of 4 September 2019.
3. The Applicant’s solicitors are to write to Mr Kebei Salee, referred to at paragraph 14 of the Sixth Affidavit of Jerry Tucker filed 17 December 2019, to advise that registration forms will be accepted by BELAW from Papuans who maintain that they are group members prior to 4.00 pm (in Queensland) on 7 February 2020. Any such persons who provide a registration form prior to 4.00 pm (in Queensland) on 7 February 2020 will be deemed to have registered in accordance with the orders of 4 September 2019.
Settlement approval
4. Pursuant to s 33V of the Act, the settlement of this proceeding be approved on the terms set out in:
(a) the Settlement Deed (Deed) annexed to the First Affidavit of John Bottoms filed 15 November 2019; and
(b) the Settlement Distribution Scheme (Scheme), in the form annexed to these orders as Annexure A.
5. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Act:
(a) on and from the date of this order, the Applicant and Group Members shall be barred from any further proceedings made in, arising out of, or in connection with, whether directly or indirectly the allegations in and the facts, matters and/or circumstances of the proceeding against the Respondent (including its present and former officers, servants, employees, agents, successors or assigns), save that such bar will not prevent the Applicant and Group Members from making any application to the Court in connection with the administration of the Scheme; and
(b) the Applicant is authorised, nunc pro tunc, to enter into the Deed for and on behalf of group members.
Approval of further amounts to be deducted, pursuant to the Scheme
6. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Act:
(a) the legal costs rendered by BELAW to 17 October 2019 and disbursements rendered to 31 October 2019 in the sum of $12,742,357.79; and
(b) the legal costs rendered by BELAW from 17 October 2019 to 12 December 2019 and disbursements rendered from 31 October 2019 to 12 December 2019 in the sum of $841,876.13,
making total legal costs and disbursements to 12 December 2019 of $13,584,233.92, are approved as the “Applicant’s Legal Costs and Disbursements” for the purposes of the Scheme.
7. Subject to any contrary order by the Court, any further amount allowed or certified by Elizabeth Harris as Referee in respect of “Approval Costs” are deemed to be approved as the “Applicant’s Legal Costs and Disbursements” for the purposes of the Scheme.
8. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Act, the amount of $35,000 be paid to the Applicant in recognition of the time and inconvenience in acting as the representative Applicant and prosecuting the proceeding on behalf of Group Members.
Appointment of Administrator
9. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Act, Anthony James Jonsson and Anthony Raymond Beven of Grant Thornton Australia Ltd be appointed as Administrators of the Scheme, to act in accordance with the Scheme and have the powers and immunities contemplated by the Scheme.
Matters consequential upon settlement approval
10. Pursuant to ss 33V and 33ZF of the Act, upon the coming into effect of Orders 4 to 9 above, each of the undertakings given by:
(a) the Applicant;
(b) BELAW; and
(c) Litigation Lending Services Ltd,
to each other, and to the Court, on 12 September 2017 to comply with their obligations under the Funding Terms being Annexure A to the orders of the Court dated 25 August 2017, be discharged.
11. The Referee, Ms Elizabeth Harris, is directed to inquire and report to the Court at 3-monthly intervals as to the reasonableness and proportionality of costs charged or proposed to be charged by the Advisor to the Scheme for work undertaken under the Scheme.
12. Further to Order 10, upon the coming into effect of Orders 4 to 10 above, the undertaking given by Litigation Lending Services Ltd to the Respondent on 13 March 2017 to meet the terms of any order as to costs made against the Applicant in favour of the Respondent, be discharged.
13. All existing costs orders in the proceeding be vacated.
14. Pursuant to s 33ZB of the Act, the persons affected and bound by Orders 4 to 9 above are the Applicant, group members (other than those who have opted out pursuant to Order 1 of the Orders made 12 December 2017 and Order 4 of the Orders made 4 September 2019), and the Respondent.
15. The Applicant shall apply for the proceeding to be dismissed within 7 days after the Court is notified that the administration of the Scheme is complete.
Access to State Database
16. For the purpose of data verification by the Administrator in relation to the Settlement Distribution Scheme, the respondent provide the Administrator with access to the database established by the Queensland Government Department of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Partnerships for the purposes of the Indigenous Wages and Savings Reparations Scheme(s), subject to an appropriate confidentiality regime agreed between the parties, or in the absence of agreement as determined by the Court.
17. Leave to apply.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
On 4 September 2019 I made orders providing that any class member who wished to seek any benefit pursuant to the proposed settlement must register his or her claim with BELAW by 8 November 2019. Any class member who was already a client of that firm in relation to the proceeding or who had already registered their claim with that firm was to be accepted as having registered already. Any class member who neither opted out nor registered for the proceeding would remain a class member for all purposes of the proceeding, but shall not be permitted to seek any benefit under the proposed settlement (the class member registration and class closure orders). The orders included a comprehensive notice regime, requiring that:(a) a notice (Notice of Proposed Settlement) be posted by 18 September 2019 to all persons whose details were contained within the CPH database, de-duplicated to remove the names of persons who had previously registered;(b) the Notice of Proposed Settlement be sent by 11 September 2019 to 68 Aboriginal and Islander communities and towns and, where applicable, to the Councils thereof, in the manner best calculated by BELAW to bring the notice to the attention of class members;(c) information meetings be conducted by BELAW at 22 specified Aboriginal or Islander communities by 18 October 2019, with the object of bringing the Notice of Proposed Settlement to the attention of class members and explaining its content. This community outreach program had a broad geographical spread, including information sessions at six large centres and 16 smaller, remote indigenous communities whose residents were considered unlikely to travel to the larger centres around the areas of Cape York, Torres Strait Islands, North and Central Queensland, South East Queensland and Western and North-Western Queensland;(d) the Notice of Proposed Settlement be posted by 6 September 2019 on the Federal Court of Australia website and made available for inspection at each registry;(e) a short version of the Notice of Proposed Settlement (Settlement Advertisement) be published at least once by 11 September 2019 in each of the following newspapers: Cape York News, Courier Mail, Koori Mail and National Indigenous Times; and(f) a radio advertisement (Settlement Radio Announcement) be broadcast at least once in the months of September and October 2019 on each of six radio stations, being: 4BSN Black Star based in Cairns which reaches 30 remote communities, 4MUR (Murri FM) based in Mackay, BIMA 98.9 based in Brisbane, 4RR FM in Mid-West Queensland, 4KIG (TAIMA) based in Townsville and 4UM based in Cherbourg. I considered that it was appropriate to take a flexible approach to class members’ compliance with the deadline for registration because of the characteristics of the class. Ms Tucker deposed that:(a) BELAW received a total of 210 registration forms between 9 November 2019 and 20 November 2019. On 21 November 2019 I made orders to extend the deadline for class member registration to 21 November 2019, such that those 210 class members were accepted as registered in accordance with the orders of 4 September 2019;(b) there were 1,816 persons who provided their registration information orally to BELAW. On 21 November 2019 and 10 December 2019 I made orders that those persons be deemed to have registered in accordance with the orders of 4 September 2019;(c) there were 1,539 persons who provided registration forms but did not sign them as required. On 21 November 2019 and 10 December 2019 I made orders that persons who provided information by means of an unsigned registration form be deemed to have registered in accordance with the orders of 4 September 2019.