Pearson v State of Queensland (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Pearson v State of Queensland (No 3) [2023] FCA 203

File number(s): QUD 714 of 2016
Judgment of: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 10 March 2023
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application by Administrator of the Settlement Distribution Scheme – application to amend the Scheme so as to narrow the group members who will be entitled to a distribution from the residue of the Settlement Distribution Fund - application for a substantial increase in the estimated fees to be paid to the Administrator – application to extend the time to distribute the residue of the Settlement Distribution Fund – application approved.
Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 67
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Solicitor for the Administrator: Bottoms English Lawyers
Solicitor for the Respondent: Crown Law

ORDERS

QUD 714 of 2016
BETWEEN:

HANS PEARSON

Applicant

AND:

STATE OF QUEENSLAND

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MURPHY J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 MARCH 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Amendments to Amended Settlement Distribution Scheme:

1.Pursuant to s 33V and s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), the Amended Settlement Distribution Scheme (the SDS) approved by Orders made 8 September 2020:

(a)be further amended by the insertion of new clause 58A in the form of the double-underlined amendments to the SDS set out at Annexure "A" to these Orders; and

(b)such amendments have retrospective effect from 17 January 2020.

Administrators' destruction of hard copy records:

2.In respect of hard copy records obtained through the administration by or on behalf of the Administrators, the Administrators are directed as follows:

(a)the Administrators are to make an electronic copy of those hard copy records;

(b)upon conclusion of the administration under the SDS, those electronic records be archived in accordance with the document and information management policies of Grant Thornton Australia Limited; and

(c)the Administrators be required to securely destroy the hard copy records within 12 month of the date of the conclusion of the administration under the SDS.

The Administrators’ estimated fees:

3.In respect of the Administrators’ estimate of professional fees provided to the Court dated 6 January 2020:

(a)the Administrators have increased their fee estimate to $2,930,000 plus GST (increased fee estimate);

(b)the increased fee estimate is approved by the Court.

4.All “Administration Costs” (as defined in the SDS) remain subject to Court approval.

Distribution to Claimant erroneously excluded:

5.In respect of the single Claimant referred to in paragraph 22 of the affidavit of Anthony Raymond Beven made 2 December 2022, who was erroneously determined by the Administrators not to be a “Participating Claimant” (as defined in the SDS) (the Final Claimant):

(a)for the purpose of sending a “Distribution Statement” (as defined in the SDS) to the Final Claimant, the Administrators are authorised to extend the date of “30 October 2020” in clause 39 of the SDS, to a date 14 days from the date of these Orders;

(b)within 14…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pearson v State of Queensland (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 203
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Pearson v State of Queensland (No 3), the Administrators of the Settlement Distribution Scheme sought amendments to the Scheme to restrict final distribution payments to living Claimants residing in Australia. The matter was before the Federal Court, which had previously approved the Settlement Distribution Scheme in 2020. The Administrators argued that the amendment was fair and reasonable in the interests of all group members, despite the detriment it would cause to Registered Representatives of Deceased Claimants and living Claimants residing in Papua New Guinea and other countries. The State of Queensland consented to the application.

The court considered the nature of the settlement, the public interest in class action settlements, and the potential benefits of the proposed amendments. The court found that the proposed amendments were fair and reasonable in the interests of all group members, given the average payment amounts and the additional costs associated with making final distribution payments to overseas Claimants. The court approved the amendment to the Scheme, which restricts final distribution payments to living Claimants residing in Australia, and directed the Administrators to make their final report publicly available.

The court's decision reflects the importance of protecting the interests of all group members in class action settlements, while also acknowledging the need for flexibility in the administration of such settlements. The court's approval of the proposed amendments demonstrates its willingness to consider changes to the Settlement Distribution Scheme that are in the interests of all group members.

Orders

Orders of the court

Amendments to Amended Settlement Distribution Scheme:

1. Pursuant to s 33V and s 33ZF of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), the Amended Settlement Distribution Scheme (the SDS) approved by Orders made 8 September 2020:

(a) be further amended by the insertion of new clause 58A in the form of the double-underlined amendments to the SDS set out at Annexure "A" to these Orders; and

(b) such amendments have retrospective effect from 17 January 2020.

Administrators' destruction of hard copy records:

2. In respect of hard copy records obtained through the administration by or on behalf of the Administrators, the Administrators are directed as follows:

(a) the Administrators are to make an electronic copy of those hard copy records;

(b) upon conclusion of the administration under the SDS, those electronic records be archived in accordance with the document and information management policies of Grant Thornton Australia Limited; and

(c) the Administrators be required to securely destroy the hard copy records within 12 month of the date of the conclusion of the administration under the SDS.

The Administrators’ estimated fees:

3. In respect of the Administrators’ estimate of professional fees provided to the Court dated 6 January 2020:

(a) the Administrators have increased their fee estimate to $2,930,000 plus GST (increased fee estimate);

(b) the increased fee estimate is approved by the Court.

4. All “Administration Costs” (as defined in the SDS) remain subject to Court approval.

Distribution to Claimant erroneously excluded:

5. In respect of the single Claimant referred to in paragraph 22 of the affidavit of Anthony Raymond Beven made 2 December 2022, who was erroneously determined by the Administrators not to be a “Participating Claimant” (as defined in the SDS) (the Final Claimant):

(a) for the purpose of sending a “Distribution Statement” (as defined in the SDS) to the Final Claimant, the Administrators are authorised to extend the date of “30 October 2020” in clause 39 of the SDS, to a date 14 days from the date of these Orders;

(b) within 14 days from the date of these Orders, the Administrators shall send a Distribution Statement in respect of the Final Claimant a Distribution Statement;

(c) the Administrators be authorised to make a “Distribution” (as defined in the SDS) in respect of the Final Claimant in accordance with the terms of the SDS as varied by the Court.

Enlargement of time to make Distribution of residue of Settlement Distribution Fund:

6. For the purposes of distributing the residue of the “Settlement Distribution Fund” (as defined in the SDS), the Administrators are authorised to extend the date being “the day which is three months after Distribution Statements are mailed” in clause 49 of the SDS, to a date three months from the date of these Orders.

7. Subject to any amounts required by the SDS to be withheld, the distribution of the residue of the Settlement Distribution Fund be effected in accordance with new clause 58A of the SDS.

Administrators’ report at the conclusion of the Scheme:

8. The Administrators are to make publicly available on the website www.stolenwages.com.au a copy of the report to the Court required by clause 69 of the SDS.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondent in the proceeding, the State of Queensland, consents to the application. For the reasons I explain it is appropriate to make the orders sought.THE EVIDENCE The Administrators rely on the following evidence:(a)an affidavit of Anthony Beven sworn 2 December 2022 in support of the application to vary the Scheme (First Beven Affidavit); and(b)an affidavit of Anthony Beven sworn 2 December 2022 in support of the application to increase the Administrators’ fees for administering the Scheme (Second Beven Affidavit).The application to amend the scheme to restrict final distribution payments to living Claimants residing in Australia Clause 59 of the Scheme allows the Administrators to refer any issues arising from the Scheme administration to the Court for directions. Under clauses 53 and 54 of the Scheme, the Administrators have a discretion to make Preliminary Distributions to Participating Claimants. Where Preliminary Distributions have been made, clause 55 provides that, before the final distribution of the remainder of the monies in the Settlement Distribution Fund, the Administrators are to be paid their Administration Costs, upon Court approval of those costs. In April 2020 the Administrators decided to make Preliminary Distributions to all Claimants and Registered Representatives by December 2020 to enable them to have access to the bulk of their entitlements under the Scheme as soon as reasonably practicable. Mr Beven states that:(a)the final number of eligible Claimants was 10,907, and the Administrators made preliminary distributions totalling $135,756,303.49 to 11,832 individual Claimants and Registered Representatives by way of 20,275 payments. Some Claimants and Registered Representatives received multiple payments as they had claims from multiple Deceased Claimants;(b)the preliminary distributions were made in 23 tranches. The first 17 tranches included more than 97% of Claimants and Registered Representatives and were made between 30 November 2020 and 22 December 2020. These payments were staggered to reduce the pressure on banks, financial counselling services and community services, and to mitigate the risk of social problems in the communities;(c)a total of $4,254,066.40 was returned to the Administrators as a result of rejected payments from the first 17 tranches, due to incorrect or closed bank account details having been provided to the Administrators, and by Papua New Guinean banks where the name of the PNG Claimant or Registered Representative that was provided was not identical to the name of the bank account. Mr Beven states that Papua New Guineans commonly change their name or the spelling of their name on multiple occasions throughout their life, for cultural reasons;(d)some of the rejected payments took up to six months to be returned to the Administrators. There was then further substantial delays as the Administrators endeavoured to contact Claimants or Registered Representatives to obtain corrected or new bank account details. Then, between 23 December 2020 and 28 September 2021 a total of $4,113,343.40 of Preliminary Distributions were made in 592 payments to 366 individuals whose earlier payments had been rejected;(e)some individuals could not be contacted, and as a result, $221,371.06 of the rejected payments, representing 24 Claimants and Registered Representatives, have been retained by the Administrators as Uncollected Amounts. Further, of the eight cheques issued to individuals without a registered bank account, two of the cheques, totalling $35,870.67, have not been presented, and those funds have also been retained as Uncollected Amounts. Thus, a total of $257,241.73 has been retained as Uncollected Amounts and will be included in the residue monies for distribution;(f)total interest on the Settlement Distribution Fund amounted to $2,298,464.36;(g)income and withholding tax in the sum of $230,548 was paid to the ATO, and the Administrators also incurred certain supplier costs essential to the administration, including venue hire, printing costs and the cost of the financial counselling service established for Claimants and Registered Representatives under clause 70 of the Scheme; (h)subject to Court approval, a distribution of $2,615.56 will be made to the Final Claimant who was erroneously deemed ineligible in 2020 as the result of a typographical error in the original Claimant Database; (i)following the payment of the Preliminary Distributions (including the reprocessing of rejected payments) and the other payments outlined above, the Administrators will be left with residue monies of $2,542,048.12.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Court’s obligation to protect the interests of group members does not cease with settlement approval and, as the Federal Court Class Actions Practice Note (GPN-CA) recognises, it will often be appropriate for the Court to require reports as to the progress and costs of the administration. This case involved an issue of significant public interest and it was settled for a great deal of money. As was recently noted:…given their genesis and objects, and the public interest often associated with such large and high-profile cases, class action settlements are rightly subject to a degree of scrutiny not generally applied to more traditional forms of litigation. Parliaments, lawyers, academics, litigants, and the public at large are entitled to expect that they will have access to sufficient information about the resolution of class actions to enable them to evaluate whether the system is achieving its purposes. Jagot J, Murphy B and Moss A, Open Justice and Class Actions: Including a Judicial Perspective, The Australian Class Action - A 30-Year Perspective (Ed. Legg M and Metzger J, Federation Press, 2023). In my view it is appropriate that the Administrators’ report regarding the administration of the settlement be made publicly available.CONCLUSION I have made the orders the Administrators seek.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Administrators seek an order to amend the Scheme to provide that final distributions from the residue monies are made only to living Claimants residing in Australia. To that end, they propose the insertion of new clause 58A into the Scheme, to provide as follows: Notwithstanding clause 57, where the residue in the Settlement Distribution Fund (including the aggregate amount of all Uncollected Amounts) is less than $2,750,000, any further Distribution is only to be made to, or in respect of, a participating Claimant who:(a)has been determined by the Administrator, acting pursuant to the Scheme, to be eligible to participate in the Scheme;(b)was alive on 30 November 2020; and(c)according to the Claim Data, resided in Australia,and no distribution is to be made to any other person, including in respect of a Deceased Claimant or a Claimant who has died prior to 30 November 2020.Consideration An amendment to the Scheme to limit final distribution payments just to living Claimants residing in Australia will be to the detriment of Registered Representatives of Deceased Claimants and to the detriment of living Claimants residing in PNG and other countries. But it does not necessarily follow that the proposed amendment is not fair and reasonable in the interests of group members. The real question is whether the favourable treatment proposed to be afforded to living Claimants residing in Australia, and the detriment to the other categories of group members is reasonable in all the circumstances. In my view the proposed amendments are fair and reasonable in the interests of group members. I commence by noting that Preliminary Distributions were made to 11,832 individual Claimants and Registered Representatives by way of 20,275 payments. It is appropriate to infer that the same number of Claimants and Registered Representatives are entitled to receive payments in the final distribution. Unless the Scheme is amended as proposed, the average payment to a Claimant or Registered Representative will be approximately $59.03, ranging from a high of $122.66 for a living male Claimant, and a low of $16.96 for a deceased female Claimant, depending on the category of the Claimant or Registered Representative under the AMS. On average there are 1.93 Registered Representatives per Deceased Claimant, which means that, on average, the final distributions to be made to each Registered Representative will be approximately $30. Where a Deceased Claimant had three or more children (which is very common) the average final distribution payment will be $20 or less. Where there is more than one Registered Representative for a Deceased Claimant the amounts to be distributed will often be lower than the Administrators’ professional fees for processing the payments, and the bank fees charged. And even where the amount is not lower than the Administrators’ professional fees and bank fees the amount to be distributed to Registered Representatives will often be de minimis. Mr Beven estimated that the Scheme will incur $20,000 in additional costs in making final distribution payments to PNG Claimants. Of the 3,257 living Claimants as at 30 November 2020, only 132 reside overseas, the great majority of whom reside in PNG. In an email to my chambers dated 1 March 2023 Mr Beven estimated that (if the final distribution is restricted to living Claimants as at 30 November 2020) living PNG Claimants will receive approximately $174.76 for a male, and $139.81 for a female. On the basis of that estimate, the Scheme will incur costs of approximately $151 per PNG Claimant to make payments of $139.81 and $174.76 to them.