Fordham v Commonwealth Bank of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fordham v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2023] FCA 1106  

File number(s): VID 387 of 2020
Judgment of: O'BRYAN J
Date of judgment: 15 September 2023
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – application for approval of settlement of representative proceeding – s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – principles relevant to settlement approval – whether proposed settlement fair and reasonable – whether proposed settlement distribution scheme just – whether certain deductions from settlement sum should be allowed – where proceeding conducted on a “no win, no fee” basis and without litigation funding – whether deduction for legal costs and disbursements, including “success fee” for applicant’s solicitors, should be allowed – whether actual and proposed costs of administration of settlement distribution scheme should be allowed – whether costs incurred by applicant’s solicitors for adverse costs insurance should be allowed – whether reimbursement payment to applicant and sample group members should be allowed – whether non-publication orders should be made – settlement approved – limited non-publication orders made
Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth), ss 12CB, 12DA(1), 12DM

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 961B, 961G, 961J

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), Pt IVA, ss 33V, 37AF, 54A

Life Insurance Act 1995 (Cth), Pt 9

National Credit Code, s 143(1)(b)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), r 28.67

Cases cited:

Caason Investments Pty Limited v Cao (No 2) [2018] FCA 527

Clark v National Australia Bank Limited (No 2) [2020] FCA 652

Darwalla Milling Co Pty Limited v F Hoffman-La Roche Ltd (No 2) [2006] FCA 1388; 236 ALR 322

Dillon v RBS Group (Australia) Pty Limited (No 2) [2018] FCA 395

Eckardt v Sims Ltd [2022] FCA 1609

Haselhurst v Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd t/as Toyota Australia; Whisson v Subaru (Aust) Pty Ltd; Kularathne v Honda Australia Pty Ltd; Brewster v BMW Australia Ltd; Bond v Nissan Motor Co (Australia) Pty Ltd; Coates v Mazda Australia Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 1076

Kemp v Westpac Banking Corporation (No 4) [2023] FCA 830

Matthews v Ausnet Electricity Services Pty Ltd [2014] VSC 663

Modtech Engineering Pty Ltd v GPT Management Holdings Limited [2013] FCA 626

Reilly v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited (No 2) [2020] FCA 1502

Reilly v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited (No 5) [2023] FCA 896

Williamson v Sydney Olympic Park Authority [2022] NSWSC 1618

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Number of paragraphs: 110
Date of hearing: 4 August 2023
Date of last submissions: 25 August 2023
Counsel for the Applicant: Dr O Bigos KC with Ms G Coleman
Solicitor for the Applicant: Slater and Gordon
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr P Kulevski
Solicitor for the Respondents: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

VID 387 of 2020
BETWEEN:

KRISTY FORDHAM

Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA

First Respondent

THE COLONIAL MUTUAL LIFE ASSURANCE SOCIETY LIMITED

Second Respondent

AIA AUSTRALIA LIMITED

Third Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

O'BRYAN J

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fordham v Commonwealth Bank of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1106
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Fordham v Commonwealth Bank of Australia, the applicant, Ms Fordham, sought approval for the settlement of a representative proceeding against the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA) and its insurers. The proceeding concerned allegations of overcharging of fees for consumer credit insurance. The Federal Court was required to decide whether the proposed settlement was fair and reasonable, if the distribution scheme was just, and if certain deductions from the settlement sum should be allowed. The court considered the nature of the proceeding, conducted on a "no win, no fee" basis and without litigation funding, and the necessity of certain deductions for legal costs, administration costs, and adverse costs insurance. The court also considered whether reimbursement payments to the applicant and sample group members should be allowed and if non-publication orders should be made to prevent prejudice to the administration of justice.

The court found that the settlement was fair and reasonable in the interests of group members, the distribution of the settlement fund was just, and the proposed deductions for litigation and administration costs were appropriate. The court allowed certain non-publication orders to prevent CBA from gaining an unfair forensic advantage if the settlement was appealed and the proceeding continued to trial. The court commended the parties for resolving the proceeding by agreement and approved the settlement on the terms set out in the Settlement Deed and the Settlement Distribution Scheme. The court also made orders regarding the registration of late registrants, the applicant's costs and expenses, confidentiality, and the dismissal of the proceeding.

The final orders included approval of the settlement, authorisation for the applicant to enter into the Settlement Deed, registration of late registrants, approval of distributions for legal costs, administration costs, and reimbursement payments, confidentiality orders, and dismissal of the proceeding with specific provisions for enforcement, application, and costs. The Scheme Administrator was granted liberty to apply in relation to any matter arising in relation to the Settlement Distribution Scheme.

Orders

Orders of the court

Approval of Settlement

1. Pursuant to s 33V of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (Act), settlement of the proceeding be approved on the terms set out in:

(a) the Settlement Deed executed by the Applicant, the Respondents and Slater and Gordon dated 18 October 2022, a copy of which is exhibited as “BH-02” to the affidavit of Benedict Tobin Hardwick affirmed 16 November 2022; and

(b) the Settlement Distribution Scheme (and the annexures thereto), exhibited as “BH-10” to the affidavit of Benedict Tobin Hardwick affirmed 26 July 2023.

2. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, the Court authorises the Applicant, nunc pro tunc for and on behalf of Bound Group Members (being those persons who meet the definition of “Group Member” in the Further Amended Statement of Claim and who did not file an opt out notice in accordance with the orders made on 13 November 2020, as varied on 16 February 2021), to enter into and give effect to the Settlement Deed.

3. Pursuant to ss 33ZB and 33ZF of the Act, the persons affected and bound by the settlement of the proceedings in paragraphs 1 and 2 and the dismissal order in paragraph 11 are the Applicant, the Respondents and all Bound Group Members.

4. Pursuant to s 33ZF of the Act, Slater and Gordon be appointed Scheme Administrator of the Settlement Distribution Scheme, with assistance from Deloitte Financial Advisory Pty Ltd, to act in accordance with the rules of the Settlement Distribution Scheme.

Late Registrants

5. Despite paragraph 5 of the orders made on 9 December 2022 (as varied by paragraph 1 of orders made on 21 February 2023 and paragraph 1 of orders made on 18 May 2023) and clause 5.1 of the Settlement Distribution Scheme, the Group Members identified by the unique IDs CBA66649334, CBA32445789, CBA93146197, CBA05243861, CBA04407507, CBA47465148, CBA52475614, CBA50783380, CBA06178934, CBA49618434, CBA10913661, CBA27970025, CBA90488676, CBA02686790, CBA42867342, CBA24205701/CBA84398418, CBA17559299, CBA76296448, CBA70421374, CBA65446960 and CBA54040305 be registered by the Scheme Administrator and be treated as Registered Group Members for the purposes of the Settlement Distribution Scheme.

Applicant’s Costs and Expenses

6. Pursuant to s 54A of the Act and r 28.67 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (FCR), the referee report of Catherine Mary Dealehr dated 13 July 2023 (whose appointment to conduct an inquiry and make a report to the Court was made pursuant to paragraph 11 of the orders of 9 December 2022) be adopted, save that:

(a) the estimated disbursements of $267,443.40 in respect of the period from 22 June 2023 to the date of the approval hearing is to be reduced by the amount of $50,277.30 that had been allowed for “out-of-scope tasks performed by Deloitte” to assist Slater and Gordon in relation to the approval hearing; and

(b) the estimated settlement administration costs of Deloitte Financial Advisory Pty Ltd of $2,496,935 be increased by the amount of $249,694 on account of GST.

7. Pursuant to ss 33ZF and 33V of the Act, the following distributions from monies paid under the settlement be approved:

(a) the amount of $4,197,001.09 for the Applicant’s legal costs and disbursements to 21 June 2023, on a solicitor and own client basis, incurred in connection with the proceeding including subsequent to the date of the Settlement Deed;

(b) the amount of $701,746.72 for the Applicant’s estimated legal costs and disbursements from 22 June 2023 to 4 August 2023, on a solicitor and own client basis, incurred in connection with the proceeding including subsequent to the date of the Settlement Deed;

(c) the amount of $3,253,615.00 for the estimated legal costs and disbursements from 5 August 2023 incurred in connection with the administration of the Settlement Distribution Scheme;

(d) the amount of $275,000 for the premium charged by Harbour Underwriting Limited with respect to an adverse costs insurance policy dated 22 December 2021;

(e) the amount of $20,000 for the Applicant’s reasonable claim for compensation for the time and/or expenses incurred in the interests of prosecuting the proceeding on behalf of Group Members as a whole; and

(f) the amounts of $3,000 for each of Debra Davies, David Wynn, Emily Woolley, Mark Lockwood and Sue-Anne Taylor, as a reasonable claim for compensation for the time and/or expenses incurred in connection with their role as sample group members in the proceeding.

8. Prior to the distribution of the Residual Distribution Sum (as defined in the Settlement Distribution Scheme), as contemplated by cl 8.9 of the Settlement Distribution Scheme, the Scheme Administrator is to send to chambers a confidential affidavit deposing as to costs incurred by the Applicant and/or the Scheme Administrator since 16 August 2023, so that the Court may make a further order as to the amount of any approved administration costs and the Applicant’s legal costs over this period. Liberty to apply for this purpose is reserved.

Confidentiality

9. Pursuant to s 37AF of the Act, to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the following paragraphs and annexures are confidential and are not to be published until further order:

(a) section A of the confidential affidavit of Benedict Tobin Hardwick affirmed on 26 July 2023 which discusses the confidential opinion of counsel and the reasons for settlement;

(b) annexure BH-16 of the confidential affidavit of Benedict Tobin Hardwick affirmed on 26 July 2023, being the confidential opinion of counsel;

(c) annexure BH-18 of the confidential affidavit of Benedict Tobin Hardwick affirmed on 26 July 2023, being a notice of objection received from a group member containing personal information; and

(d) annexures KM-04 of the confidential affidavit of Kirsten Marie Morrison affirmed on 16 August 2023, being a document describing the software, systems and processes to be designed by Deloitte Financial Advisory Pty Ltd to administer group member registration and the Settlement Distribution Scheme.

10. Pursuant to s 37AF of the Act, to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the following are confidential until the end of the appeal period for this proceeding or further order:

(a) confidential annexure BH-08 to the affidavit of Benedict Tobin Hardwick affirmed on 16 November 2022, being the Confidential Loss Assessment Formula;

(b) section B of the confidential affidavit of Benedict Tobin Hardwick affirmed on 26 July 2023, being an estimate of the costs of proceeding to judgment; and

(c) annexure BH-17 to the confidential affidavit of Benedict Tobin Hardwick affirmed on 26 July 2023, being a table containing estimated distributions of settlement funds prepared by Deloitte Financial Advisory Pty Ltd.

Final Orders

11. Pursuant to ss 22, 23 or 33ZF of the Act or r 1.32 of the FCR and/or the Court's implied jurisdiction, and with effect from the date on which the final distribution of the Settlement Sum (including the Residual Distribution Sum) occurs under the Settlement Distribution Scheme, the proceeding against the Respondents is dismissed on the basis that:

(a) the dismissal is a defence and absolute bar to any claim or proceeding by the Applicant or any Bound Group Member against the Respondents in respect of, or relating to, the subject matter of the proceeding, without prejudice to:

(i) the right of any party to the Settlement Deed to make an application to enforce the Settlement Deed in a new proceeding;

(ii) the right of any Registered Group Member (as defined in the Settlement Distribution Scheme) to make application to the Court in accordance with the terms of the Settlement Distribution Scheme; or

(iii) the right of the Scheme Administrator of the Settlement Distribution Scheme to refer any issues relating to the Settlement Distribution Scheme to the Court for direction or determination in accordance with the terms of the Settlement Distribution Scheme; and

(b) there be no order as to costs as between the Applicant and the Respondents and all previous costs orders in the proceeding between them are vacated.

12. The Scheme Administrator has liberty to apply in relation to any matter arising in relation to the Settlement Distribution Scheme.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The second non-publication order will only continue until the end of the appeal period for this proceeding. I am satisfied that these categories of information may provide CBA with an unfair forensic advantage in the event that the orders made approving the settlement of this proceeding were successfully appealed and the proceeding was to continue to trial. The information concerning the “Loss Assessment Formula” reveals, to some extent, Slater and Gordon’s assessment of the prospects of different categories of claim. The information regarding Slater and Gordon’s estimate of the applicant’s likely costs in proceeding to judgment also reveals, to some extent, Slater and Gordon’s litigation strategy in the proceeding. Accordingly, I am satisfied that a non-publication order in respect of these two limited categories of information until the end of the appeal period for this proceeding is necessary to prevent prejudice to the proper administration of justice.Conclusion For the reasons set out above, I consider that the settlement is fair and reasonable in the interests of group members, the distribution of the settlement fund as between group members is just, and the allowance proposed to be made out of the settlement fund for litigation and administration costs is appropriate. I commend the parties on resolving this proceeding by agreement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is relevant to note that the release and discharge of the CBA and Insurers from the claims made in the proceeding and all liability in relation to the claims does not apply to any insurance claim that a group member has for the payment of benefits under the terms of the consumer credit insurance policies: see the definition of “Claims” in cl 1.Notification and registration On 24 November 2022, following the execution of the Settlement Deed, I made orders requiring the respondents to provide Slater and Gordon with the following information for each potential group member (being customers identified by CBA for the purpose of the opt out procedure in this proceeding who purchased one of the policies during the relevant period, paid a premium for that policy, and did not receive a refund in full for any premiums paid):(a)their customer identification number, name, last-known address, email address and mobile phone number;(b)if available, details of any current transactional bank account held by the potential group member with CBA (to facilitate payment of their entitlement, if any, under the Settlement Distribution Scheme);(c)the relevant policy or policies they took out;(d)for each policy taken out, the policy number, the sales channel, the amount of premiums, refunds, remediation and claims paid under the policy, the date on which a premium was first paid, whether the policy was continuing and, if not, the date on which it was terminated; and(e)any other information reasonably required to assist the applicant in administering and distributing the Settlement Distribution Scheme. On 9 December 2022, I made orders providing for potential group members to be notified of the proposed settlement of the proceeding (on the terms set out in the Settlement Deed), and the requirement to register in order to be eligible to receive compensation through the settlement. More than 760,000 people were sent those notifications. Approximately 78,000 potential group members registered for the purposes of the settlement. The applicant filed comprehensive evidence concerning the work involved in the notification and registration processes, including responding to enquiries from a large number of potential group members and verifying information. It is unnecessary to set out that evidence more generally, but the work was extensive.Settlement Distribution Scheme The Settlement Distribution Scheme is to be administered and applied by the Scheme Administrator with the assistance of the Administrator Staff and Deloitte Financial Advisory Pty Ltd (Deloitte). The Scheme Administrator will, subject to and in accordance with the Settlement Distribution Scheme, hold the settlement fund on trust for the applicant, registered group members and parties to whom distribution is to be made under the Scheme. The Scheme contains provisions with respect to the registration process for group members and the process for verifying information in relation to each group member. The Scheme provides that, prior to distribution from the settlement fund to registered group members, the following payments are to be made in the following order of priority: (a)an amount to Slater and Gordon for the applicant’s legal costs and estimated administration costs, which includes costs payable by the Scheme Administrator to Deloitte for services to administer the Settlement Distribution Scheme;(b)an amount to Slater and Gordon for the premium charged by an insurer, Harbour Underwriting Limited, with respect to an adverse costs insurance policy;(c)an amount to the applicant for her reimbursement payments; and(d)an amount to each sample group member for the sample group member’s reimbursement payment.