Thunder Studios Inc (California) v Kazal (No 12)

Link copied
Case Copied 83 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Thunder Studios Inc (California) v Kazal (No 12) [2022] FCA 110    

File number(s): NSD 850 of 2014
Judgment of: RARES J
Date of judgment: 18 February 2022
Catchwords:

 DEFAMATION – whether defamatory imputations conveyed – whether matters complained of identified unnamed corporate applicant – where applicant company was alter ego of individual applicant named in matters complained of – whether corporate applicant with less than 10 employees at time of publication of matter complained of able to commence proceedings in defamation under s 9 of Defamation Act 2005 (NSW)

DAMAGES – where respondents have no filed defence – where respondents can raise matters in mitigation of damages – where reputation particularly important in applicant’s industry – where industry practice is to google potential business associates – where defamatory publication and conduct occurred both in Australia and the United States and laws of each jurisdiction are not the same – whether defamatory publication and conduct in the United States protected by First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States able to be taken into account in assessment of damages – where United States Court found that respondents’ conduct was constitutionally protected free speech

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where respondents did not have a defence – where at trial respondents can raise matters in mitigation of damages

EVIDENCE – whether evidence of foreign judgment admissible under s 91 of Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) – where foreign judgment not used to establish truth of facts in issue – whether foreign judgment relevant or admissible to prove what foreign Court said about factual dispute it resolved and reasoning process to arrive at findings

Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law s 18

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Sch 2

Australian Consumer Law (NSW) s 18

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 91, 136, 140 and 175

Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) ss 9, 25, 26, 29, 30, 34, 35, 36 and 38

Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW) s 28

Independent Commission Against Corruption Act 1988 (NSW) ss 8 and 9

17 United States Code §504(c)(2)

California Civil Code §1708.7

Constitution of the United States First Amendment

Digital Millenium Copyright Act (US)

Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (US)

Cases cited:

ALDI Foods Pty Ltd v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia (2020) 282 FCR 174

Amalgamated Television Services Pty Ltd v Marsden (1998) 43 NSWLR 158

Ballina Shire Council v Ringland (1994) 33 NSWLR 680

Broome v Cassell & Co Ltd [1972] AC 1027

Chau v Australian Broadcasting Corporation (2021) 386 ALR 36

Chau v Australian Broadcasting Corporation (No 3) (2021) 386 ALR 36

Consolidated Trust Company Ltd v Browne (1948) 49 SR (NSW) 86

David Syme & Co v Canavan (1918) 25 CLR 234

Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd v Voller (2021) 392 ALR 540

Favell v Queensland Newspapers Pty Ltd (2005) 221 ALR 186

Google Inc v Duffy (2017) 129 SASR 304

Harbour Radio Pty Ltd v Trad (2012) 247 CLR 31

Houghton v Arms (2006) 225 CLR 553

Howard Smith Ltd v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thunder Studios Inc (California) v Kazal (No 12) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 110
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Thunder Studios Inc, an Australian corporation, filed a defamation claim against the Kazal brothers, Charif and Adam, who published defamatory content about Thunder and its principal, Mr David, on their website and social media. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The central legal issues involved whether the publications were defamatory, whether Thunder could bring a defamation claim under the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW), and whether the Kazals' conduct in the United States, which was protected by the First Amendment, could be considered in the assessment of damages.

The Court found that the publications conveyed defamatory imputations about Thunder and Mr David. The landing page and the Intro article on the Kazal website were held to identify Thunder as the subject of the defamatory content, despite it not being named explicitly. The evidence demonstrated that individuals familiar with Mr David’s business dealings understood the publications to refer to Thunder. Furthermore, the Court ruled that Thunder, having fewer than 10 employees at the time of the defamatory publications, was eligible to bring a defamation claim under s 9 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW).

In assessing damages, the Court noted that the Kazals had not filed a defence and thus could not raise matters in mitigation. The Court considered the importance of reputation in the film industry and the practice of Googling potential business associates. It held that the Kazals' conduct in the United States, which was found to be protected by the First Amendment, could not be taken into account in the assessment of damages. The Court awarded damages to Thunder, reflecting the significant harm caused by the defamatory publications.

The Court ordered that the Kazals be permanently enjoined from making further defamatory publications and directed the parties to draft the form of injunctions and other orders. The proceeding was stood over to allow for the finalisation of orders and submissions on costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On or before 25 February 2022 the parties agree and file the form of orders including injunctions necessary to give effect to the reasons for judgment delivered on 18 February 2022 and in the event of disagreement file such form of orders noting any disagreements in mark up together with written submissions limited to two pages each.

2. The proceeding be stood over to 28 February 2022 for the making of final orders.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

THE PROCEDURAL HISTORY

[6]

PRINCIPLES – DEFAMATORY PUBLICATIONS

[24]

THE MATTERS COMPLAINED OF

[27]

The landing page

[27]

The imputations that the landing page is alleged to convey

[48]

The parties’ submissions on imputations conveyed by the landing page

[51]

Identification – principles

[53]

The respondents’ submissions on identification

[55]

Identification – consideration

[56]

Consideration – were the disputed imputations conveyed?

[63]

Imputation 6(a): Mr David is a corporate criminal, who ran away to California after being convicted of breach of fiduciary duty.

[64]

Imputation 7(a): Thunder is run by a corporate criminal, who ran away to California after being convicted of breach of fiduciary duty.

[64]

Imputation 6(c): Mr David was convicted of breach of fiduciary duty as a result of not fulfilling his partnership obligations to the Kazal family.

[66]

Imputation 7(c): Thunder is run by Mr David, who was convicted of breach of fiduciary duty as a result of not fulfilling his partnership obligations to the Kazal family.

[66]

Imputation 6(d): Mr David is so lacking in integrity that he paid the journalist Linton Besser to publish deliberately invented lies in the Sydney Morning Herald about the Kazal family and their business dealings.

[67]

Imputation 7(d): Thunder is run by Mr David, who is so lacking in integrity that he paid the journalist Linton Besser to publish deliberately invented lies in the Sydney Morning Herald about the Kazal family and their business dealings.

[67]

Imputation 6(e): Anyone doing business with Mr David runs the risk of physical injury if they do not go along with him.

[70]

Imputation 7(e): Anyone doing business with Thunder runs the risk of physical injury.

[70]

Imputation 6(f): Mr David paid the journalist Linton Besser to smear the Kazal family in an attempt to cover up his own criminal theft.

[72]

Imputation 7(f): Thunder is run by a person who paid the journalist Linton Besser to smear the Kazal family in an attempt to cover up his own criminal theft.

[72]

THE SECOND MATTER COMPLAINED OF – THE INTRO ARTICLE

[73]

The imputations that the Intro article is alleged to convey

[79]

The parties’ submissions on whether the Intro article conveyed imputations 9(a)–(j) and 10(a)–(j)

[81]

Imputations 9(a) to (e) and 10(a) to (e)

[83]

Imputation 9(f): Mr David was responsible for the children of Charif Kazal and each of his brothers being bullied at school and at sporting activities, because he paid Linton Besser to publish unwarranted attacks upon members of the Kazal family for having sought justice against him through the courts.

[84]

Imputation 10(f): Thunder is run by a corporate criminal who was responsible for the children of Charif Kazal and each of his brothers being bullied targeted at school and at sporting activities, because he paid Linton Besser to publish unwarranted attacks upon members of the Kazal family for having sought justice against him through the courts.

[84]

Imputation 9(g): Mr David attempted to pervert the course of justice, by threatening Charif Kazal and each of his brothers and their business, because the Kazal family sought justice through the courts.

[86]

Imputation 10(g): Thunder is run by a corporate criminal who attempted to pervert the course of justice, by threatening Charif Kazal and each of his brothers and their business, because the Kazal family sought justice through the courts.

[86]

Imputation 9(i): Mr David paid the reporter Linton Besser to lie about the Kazal family and their business dealings.

[89]

Imputation 10(i): Thunder is run by a corporate criminal who paid the reporter Linton Besser to lie about the Kazal family and their business dealings.

[89]

Imputation 9(j): Mr David paid the journalist Linton Besser to smear the Kazal family, in an attempt to cover up his own corporate fraud and theft.

[91]

Imputation 10(j): Thunder is run by a corporate criminal, Rodric David, who paid the the reporter Linton Besser to smear the Kazal family in an attempt to cover up his own corporate fraud and theft.

[91]

THE TWEETS

[93]

How Charif and Adam used their Twitter accounts

[96]

Issues raised in respect of mitigation

[104]

BACKGROUND

[105]

Mr David

[105]

Thunder

[107]

The previous relationship between Mr David and the Kazals

[109]

Mr David’s detention in the UAE

[118]

The next stage in the Cayman Island proceeding

[124]

The ICAC proceeding

[127]

The decision of Jones J

[134]

Later events

[138]

The Bad company Article

[142]

The aftermath of the Bad company article

[151]

The impact of the publication of the matters complained of on Mr and Mrs David

[156]

The Westside dealing

[175]

The LA Biz and backstage posts

[179]

Commencement of this proceeding

[189]

The Steven Rockefeller encounter

[198]

The quiet before the storm

[199]

The 2016 activity on the Kazal website

[205]

Litigation in the United States

[210]

The events of late October and November 2016

[216]

THE REPUTATION WITNESSES

[253]

Mr Panos’ evidence

[253]

Mr Nami’s evidence

[260]

Mr Hammond’s evidence

[261]

REMEDIES

[273]

The United States District Court jury trial and Court of Appeals decision

[273]

The respondents’ submissions

[277]

The claim under s 18 of the ACL – consideration

[293]

The claim in injurious falsehood – consideration

[298]

Did Mr David and Thunder suffer “special damage”?

[310]

Assessment of damages – principles and consideration

[320]

Aggravated damages

[346]

Injunctions

[365]

CONCLUSION

[366]

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my opinion, unless enjoined, both Charif and Adam are likely to continue making publications of the matters complained of, the Kazal website and the defamatory imputations that I have found, as well as the misleading and deceptive use of the bitlink on their Twitter accounts. Their persistent conduct over the seven years to the trial (except in Adam’s case after the consent interlocutory injunctions and contempt proceeding) makes it plain beyond doubt that each will continue his irrational and vendetta-like behaviour the subject of these reasons, unless enjoined permanently from doing so. CONCLUSION I will direct the parties to draft the form of injunctions and other orders to give effect to these reasons. I will also make directions for the parties to make submissions as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondents argued that the particulars of identification were incapable of enabling a reader of either the first or second matters complained of to identify Thunder as their subject. They contended that this was not a case in which it could be inferred, or should be found, that the matters complained of were published to persons with knowledge of the extrinsic facts. They submitted that the content of the matters complained of was personal to Mr David and concerned events that occurred before Thunder was incorporated or Mr David became involved with it.Identification – consideration I reject the respondents’ argument that the landing page and the Intro article did not identify Thunder in its natural and ordinary meaning. The landing page directed the reader’s attention expressly to the question posed in par 16, “In business with Rodric David, an Australian now living in the USA?”. It made repeated references to Mr David’s alleged activities in business, including that he was “The Corporate Thief”. The natural and ordinary meaning of the landing page included that what it conveyed about Mr David as an individual would also apply to any company in which he had a controlling or managing interest. Thus, the formulation of imputations 7(b) to (f) that “Thunder is run by Mr David”, that substitute “Thunder” for him in the same sense as imputations 6(b) to (f) apply to Mr David personally, are meanings that the landing page would convey, in its natural and ordinary meaning, to a person who knew that Thunder was Mr David’s company or that he controlled it, even though Thunder was not named in that publication: World Hosts 141 CLR at 639–640, 642; see too Simon v Lyder [2020] AC 650 at 661–662 [25]–[27] per Lord Briggs JSC giving the opinion of the Judicial Committee (Lord Wilson, Lord Carnwath, Lady Black, Lady Arden JJSC and himself). As I will elaborate below, I accept the evidence of Mike Hammond, a friend of Mr David, who read the first and second matters complained of. I find that he understood each of them to refer to Thunder because he knew it was Mr David’s company. He said that Thunder’s “reputation really was Rodric’s reputation” (see [271] below). Indeed, Mr Hammond first drew Mr David’s attention to the Kazal website by sending him a text message or email with a link to it. Moreover, Charif’s posts, being the LA Biz post and the backstage post each appeared on the same webpage as the articles that named Mr David as owner of Thunder. I describe Charif’s posts below at [181] and [183]. The headline of the LA Biz article was “CEO Rodric David offering $1 million to indie film projects through Thunder Funder”. Mr David described LA Biz as “the number one business paper in Los Angeles”, with a status as a business newspaper similar to The Australian Financial Review in this country. However, the respondents’ argument does not only fail on this level. It is preposterous, given that Charif posted comments on 30 May 2014 and 8 June 2014 respectively on the Facebook walls of each of the LA Biz and backstage articles that were about Mr David’s project using his company, Thunder, that each began: “If you are currently doing business with Rodric David, or even thinking about it, you need to visit our website: [giving the hyperlink to the Kazal family story website] to learn just how Mr David conducts business”.