Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
GUMMOW, HEYDON, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ

GEOFFREY LAWRENCE KUHL  APPELLANT

AND

ZURICH FINANCIAL SERVICES AUSTRALIA LTD
& ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd [2011] HCA 11
4 May 2011
P31/2010

ORDER

1.        Appeal allowed.

2.Set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Western Australia made on 24 March 2010 in favour of the first respondent and in their place order that:

(a)       the appeal be allowed;

(b)the orders made by Wisbey DCJ on 22 January 2009 in favour of the first respondent be set aside; and

(c)judgment be entered against the first respondent in the amount of $265,000.

3.The first respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and in the courts below.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Western Australia

Representation

B L Nugawela with M A Tedeschi for the appellant (instructed by Taylor Smart)

J E Maconachie QC with J R Criddle and H M O'Sullivan for the first respondent (instructed by SRB Legal)

J E Maconachie QC for the second respondent (instructed by Jarman McKenna)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. FRENCH CJ AND GUMMOW J. On 19 November 1999 the appellant ("Mr Kuhl") suffered injuries in the course of his employment with Transfield Construction Pty Ltd ("Transfield"). Pursuant to s 93E of the Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 1981 (WA)[1], Mr Kuhl was barred from bringing a claim in negligence against Transfield. In the District Court of Western Australia, Mr Kuhl brought an action in negligence against WOMA (Australia) Pty Ltd ("WOMA") and Hydrosweep Pty Ltd ("Hydrosweep"), amongst other parties. Both companies were deregistered after Mr Kuhl's injury but before he commenced proceedings. Pursuant to s 601AG of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), in the place of WOMA and Hydrosweep stand their respective insurers, the first and second respondents.

    [1]Now the Workers' Compensation and Injury Management Act 1981 (WA).

  2. Mr Kuhl was unsuccessful in his action against both insurers before the District Court (Wisbey DCJ)[2] and on appeal to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Western Australia (Martin CJ and Newnes JA; Wheeler JA dissenting)[3].  For the reasons given below, there was insufficient evidence to be satisfied on the balance of probabilities that there existed the relevant duty, breach or causation for Mr Kuhl to be successful in his action in negligence, and the appeal to this Court should be dismissed.

    [3]Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd (2010) 194 IR 74.

    The facts

  3. Mr Kuhl commenced employment with Transfield in September 1999.  He cleaned reactor grid floors at a plant owned and operated by BHP Billiton in Port Hedland, Western Australia.  The reactors cooked "fines", small pieces of iron ore, which changed the composition of the fines into hot briquetted iron (HBI).  Mr Kuhl had the task…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] HCA 11
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal concerning a negligence claim brought by Mr Kuhl against Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd, the insurer of WOMA, a supplier of vacuum equipment. Mr Kuhl suffered injury while using a high-pressure vacuum hose provided by WOMA. The dispute centred on whether WOMA owed Mr Kuhl a duty of care, whether that duty was breached, and whether any breach caused his injuries. Mr Kuhl had been unsuccessful in his negligence action in both the District Court and the Court of Appeal of Western Australia.

The legal issues before the High Court included whether the evidence supported the existence of a duty of care owed by WOMA to Mr Kuhl, specifically concerning the provision of a safe vacuuming system and the issuance of appropriate safety instructions. The court also had to determine if WOMA breached this duty by failing to install a break box and by not issuing instructions against passing the hose while the power was on. Furthermore, the court considered whether Mr Kuhl's injuries were caused by any such breach, and whether the trial judge erred in inferring that Mr Kuhl had withheld evidence regarding the precise circumstances of his injury, particularly in relation to his perceived reluctance to explain how his arm was drawn into the hose.

The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Court of Appeal and the District Court. The court found that the trial judge's adverse inference regarding Mr Kuhl's reluctance to explain the incident was not soundly based, as Mr Kuhl had provided a direct account of his arm being caught in the hose, and he was not further questioned on this point by any party or the judge. The court concluded that there was sufficient evidence to establish a duty of care, a breach of that duty, and causation. Consequently, judgment was entered in favour of Mr Kuhl against the first respondent for $265,000, with the first respondent ordered to pay Mr Kuhl's costs of the appeal and in the courts below.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Western Australia made on 24 March 2010 in favour of the first respondent and in their place order that:

(a) the appeal be allowed;

(b) the orders made by Wisbey DCJ on 22 January 2009 in favour of the first respondent be set aside; and

(c) judgment be entered against the first respondent in the amount of $265,000.

3. The first respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal and in the courts below.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Kuhl was unsuccessful in his action against both insurers before the District Court (Wisbey DCJ)[2] and on appeal to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Western Australia (Martin CJ and Newnes JA; Wheeler JA dissenting)[3]. For the reasons given below, there was insufficient evidence to be satisfied on the balance of probabilities that there existed the relevant duty, breach or causation for Mr Kuhl to be successful in his action in negligence, and the appeal to this Court should be dismissed. [2]Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd [2009] WADC 4.[3]Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd (2010) 194 IR 74. The facts Mr Kuhl commenced employment with Transfield in September 1999. He cleaned reactor grid floors at a plant owned and operated by BHP Billiton in Port Hedland, Western Australia. The reactors cooked "fines", small pieces of iron ore, which changed the composition of the fines into hot briquetted iron (HBI). Mr Kuhl had the task of entering the reactors, breaking up any solidified waste material with a jackhammer or sledge hammer and then removing the accumulated fines and other waste using a vacuum. Those who undertook these tasks were colloquially known as "reactor rats". The evidence accepted by the trial judge as to the relationship between Transfield, WOMA and Hydrosweep was as follows:(a)By November 1999, Transfield was solely responsible for cleaning out the reactors, including using the vacuum hose. A Transfield employee, known as the "hole watcher", would look through a window into the reactor whilst it was being cleaned to monitor the "reactor rats" and test gas levels. Transfield also had supervisors on site and those supervisors would allocate the work to each employee and conduct meetings to discuss, amongst other things, safety prior to each shift.(b)WOMA provided a vacuum truck, the vacuum hose and other equipment relevant to the vacuuming system. WOMA would set up the equipment and supply two operators for the system; one to operate the truck, the other to check and maintain the line. WOMA would also assist in clearing any obstructions in the vacuum hose when Transfield employees were unable to do so. (c)For a period in November 1999, Hydrosweep supplied a vacuum truck and two operators to WOMA for use at WOMA's direction. The vacuum hose used at the time of the accident was flexible, but awkward to use. It was attached to a stand pipe, or manifold, running up the side of the 128 metre tall building, which was in turn connected by hose to a vacuum truck positioned at ground level. The vertical distance from the truck to the manifold connection for the reactor in which Mr Kuhl was injured was some 32 metres. The horizontal distance from the manifold connection to that reactor's entry point is unclear, but was probably between 20‑30 metres.The accident At about 4.30am on 19 November 1999, whilst Mr Kuhl was vacuuming the relevant reactor, a blockage occurred in the hose. Mr Kuhl left the reactor so as to try to free the blockage. The evidence at trial was that blockages frequently occurred in the hose, sometimes up to 20 times per night. Some blockages were cleared by Transfield employees shaking the hose, hitting the blockage with a shovel or using other similar measures. Blockages that could not be fixed were then dealt with by WOMA employees or people provided for the use of WOMA, sometimes by cutting the hose and then taping it back together, or by reversing the suction. Except when the hose was cut or the suction reversed, the vacuum truck would remain on during the process of attempting to clear the blockage. This was done to assist with the unblocking and to enable one to know whether the hose had successfully been unblocked.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Although the plaintiff's case on duty of care was put more ambitiously, one question is whether the evidence on which the plaintiff relied supported the proposition that WOMA owed him a duty to take care to provide a hose, truck and vacuuming facility that would not subject those who might foreseeably use the hose to an unreasonable risk of injury in relation to uses to which it was reasonably foreseeable that the hose might be put. If so, the plaintiff's case was that that duty was breached in that WOMA failed to issue instructions not to pass the hose while the power was on, and in that WOMA had failed to install a break box 10 or 15 metres from the head of the hose which could be employed to break the vacuum pressure at the hose end by letting air in. The plaintiff contended that each breach caused his injuries. The trial judge's attack on the plaintiff's evidence The trial judge's finding. The trial judge said[46]: "The plaintiff was less than expansive when describing how his arm was drawn into the vacuum hose, and I formed the view that for whatever reason he was reluctant to say precisely what happened. I accept the essentially unchallenged evidence of Mr Kelleher that the suction inlet was directed away from the plaintiff as the hose was passed to him, and I am left to infer that some subsequent action by the plaintiff caused his arm to be drawn in by the suction force.I am satisfied that the plaintiff was acutely aware of the necessity not to allow any part of the body to come into contact with the suction inlet. Not only does the plaintiff accept that, but the associated risks were obvious."[46]Kuhl v Zurich Financial Services Australia Ltd [2009] WADC 4 at [30]-[31]. What was the "less than expansive" evidence of the plaintiff which caused the trial judge to conclude that he was "reluctant"? It was the following evidence in chief: "What happened when the hose was handed back towards you? --- My arm was caught in it, in the end, opening of it, whatever you want to call it.If you could just describe in your own words to the court, how was the hose passed back towards you? --- Passed direct ---What was the physical action? --- Just passed directly back to me. I moved it a bit to the side to grab it as it was the only way to do it and the next thing my arm was gone.Which arm? --- Left, sucked in."The plaintiff was not asked further questions in chief on that subject. He was not asked any questions in cross-examination about it either. The judge asked no questions about it. The significance of the trial judge's finding. The conclusion of the trial judge that the plaintiff was "reluctant to say precisely what happened" is an important one. If that conclusion were soundly arrived at, it would be a significant factor against the plaintiff's success. So, at least, the trial judge, the Court of Appeal majority and the first respondent thought. It would be significant because of the following considerations. Witnesses are supposed to answer questions put by counsel responsively: they are supposed to give a full answer, but no more. It is one thing to say that a witness was not asked the right questions. It is another thing to say that a witness did not answer the questions that were asked. And it is an even more serious thing to say that a witness was "reluctant" to answer. The duty of a witness is to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth so far as the questions asked seek it. The duty of a witness to answer questions responsively involves not only a negative duty (not to volunteer material for which the question does not call), but also a positive duty (to proffer all material within the witness's knowledge for which the question does call). To conclude that a party-witness is reluctant to say what happened is to conclude that the party-witness is deliberately failing to comply with the duty to tell the whole truth. That is a serious conclusion to reach, for the following reasons.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ GUMMOW J (dissent) HEYDON, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, HEYDON, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ

Full text does not contain this section.