Waller Projects Pty Ltd v F.W. Estate Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Waller Projects Pty Ltd v F.W. Estate Pty Ltd [2025] QSC 16

PARTIES:

WALLER PROJECTS PTY LTD
ACN 160 554 165

(plaintiff)

v
F.W. ESTATE PTY LTD
ACN 600 909 920

(first defendant)

BREMHA PTY LTD
ACN 133 642 458

(second defendant)

DG JIMBOOMBA DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
ACN 609 512 183

(third defendant)

DOWLING YEPPOON PTY LTD
ACN 152 346 926

(fourth defendant)

CRAIG ANTHONY JOHN DOWLING

(sixth defendant)

NICOLA TRACEY DOWLING

(seventh defendant)

DOWLING YEPPOON PTY LTD
ACN 152 346 926

(first plaintiff by counterclaim)

CRAIG ANTHONY JOHN DOWLING

(second plaintiff by counterclaim)

NICOLA TRACEY DOWLING

(third plaintiff by counterclaim)

DOWLING DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
ACN 151 353 258

(fourth plaintiff by counterclaim)

WALLER PROJECTS PTY LTD
ACN 160 554 165

(first defendant by counterclaim)

CCH STRADBROKE PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR THE CCH STRADBROKE TRUST
ACN 160 851 972

(second defendant by counterclaim)

JOHN WATSON QUINN

(third defendant by counterclaim)

RORY ANN QUINN

(fourth defendant by counterclaim)

CLARE ELIZABETH GRENENGER QUINN

(fifth defendant by counterclaim)

RHYS JAMES GRENENGER QUINN

(sixth defendant by counterclaim)

GABRIELLE JOHANNA QUINN

(seventh defendant by counterclaim)

LACHLAN BARCLAY QUINN

(eighth defendant by counterclaim)

Q FABRICS PTY LTD
ACN 150 002 752

(ninth defendant by counterclaim)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 6105 of 2019

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

28 January 2025

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

16-19 and 22-26 July 2024; 12 November 2024

JUDGE:

Kelly J

ORDER:

The answers to the separate questions are as follows:

1.   The answer to Question 1 is “No”.

2.   The answer to Question 2 is “Not necessary to answer”.

3.   The answer to Question 3 (a) is “No”.

4.   The answer to Question 3(b) is “No”.

5.   The answer to Question 3(c) is “No”.

6.   The answer to Question 4 is “No”.

7.   The answer to Question 5 is “Not necessary to answer”.

I will hear the parties as to further orders and costs.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – FORMATION OF CONTRACTUAL RELATIONS – where there is contested evidence as to the formation of an oral agreement – where the witnesses’ recollections of the conversation allegedly giving rise to the agreement substantially varied – whether an oral agreement was formed between the parties

EQUITY – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – FIDUCIARY OBLIGATIONS – GENERALLY – where, if an oral agreement was not reached, there is a dispute as to whether Waller and Dowling Yeppoon, by Mr Quinn and Mr Dowling respectively, held a mutual confidence that, where a potential project or opportunity became known to either party that the party considered suitable to acquire and to develop jointly, that party could refer the opportunity to the other party, and any activities carried out by the parties in respect of such a project or opportunity would be carried out for their joint advantage only – whether the alleged mutual confidences give rise to the fiduciary obligations

EQUITY – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – FRAUDULENT AND INNOCENT MISREPRESENTATION – GENERALLY…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Waller Projects Pty Ltd v F.W. Estate Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] QSC 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Waller Projects Pty Ltd v F.W. Estate Pty Ltd involved a complex dispute concerning the formation of an oral agreement and the existence of fiduciary obligations between Waller Projects and F.W. Estate. The case focused on whether an oral agreement was formed between the parties, whether fiduciary obligations existed between them, and whether there were any misrepresentations or non-disclosures that would entitle the plaintiffs to rescind the alleged agreement. Additionally, the case examined whether the plaintiffs' delay and inaction rendered it unjust to grant them relief or compensation.

The court was required to decide several legal issues, including the formation of the oral agreement, the existence of fiduciary obligations, and the implications of any misrepresentations or non-disclosures. The court needed to assess the credibility of the key witnesses, Mr. Quinn and Mr. Dowling, given their substantially varied recollections of the alleged agreement. The court also had to consider whether the parties held a mutual confidence that would give rise to fiduciary obligations and whether any non-disclosures or misrepresentations provided grounds for rescission. Finally, the court needed to determine if the plaintiffs' delay and inaction constituted a defence of laches, which would prevent them from receiving equitable relief.

The court concluded that no oral agreement was formed between the parties, and therefore, no fiduciary obligations existed. The court found that the evidence did not support the existence of a mutual confidence or a fiduciary relationship between Waller and Dowling Yeppoon. Additionally, the court determined that the non-disclosures and misrepresentations, even if found to be true, did not provide grounds for rescission. The court also found that the plaintiffs' delay and inaction, combined with their knowledge of the defendants' efforts, rendered it unjust to grant them relief or compensation.

The court ordered that no oral agreement was formed between the parties and that no fiduciary obligations existed. The court also found that the plaintiffs were not entitled to rescind the alleged agreement due to non-disclosures or misrepresentations. Finally, the court held that the plaintiffs' delay and inaction constituted a defence of laches, preventing them from receiving equitable relief or compensation. The court will hear the parties regarding further orders and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

The answers to the separate questions are as follows:

1. The answer to Question 1 is “No”.

2. The answer to Question 2 is “Not necessary to answer”.

3. The answer to Question 3 (a) is “No”.

4. The answer to Question 3(b) is “No”.

5. The answer to Question 3(c) is “No”.

6. The answer to Question 4 is “No”.

7. The answer to Question 5 is “Not necessary to answer”.

I will hear the parties as to further orders and costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The parties agreed a list of issues in respect of each of the separate questions. Several parties and proposed parties did not participate in the trial but gave undertakings to abide and be bound by the determination of the trial.[20] In these reasons, where I refer to the defendants, I am referring to the defendants who actively participated in the trial, being the first to fourth, sixth and seventh defendants. [20]The first to ninth defendants by counterclaim, the first and fourth plaintiffs by counterclaim, C&N Management Pty Ltd, Wesley Street Pty Ltd and Centra Harts Road Pty Ltd.The witnesses and credit considerations Evidence in chief was given by the witnesses adopting their respective witness statements. Waller called as witnesses Mr Quinn and Mrs Quinn. Mr Quinn was cross examined over days one to seven of the trial. The defendants called Mr Dowling, Mrs Dowling, Mrs Mabel Wynne (“Mrs Wynne”), Mr John Littler (“Mr Littler”) and Mr Brian Gassman (“Mr Gassman”). Mr Dowling was cross examined over days seven to nine of the trial. The credit of Mr and Mrs Quinn and Mr and Mrs Dowling fell to be assessed in determining whether the General Agreement was made. By the end of the trial, Waller’s written submissions focused principally upon the Relationship case, whilst noting that the General Agreement case was “not abandoned”. According to those submissions, credit was not “central” to the Relationship case because of the existence of what was described as “a robust documentary record that speaks for itself”. In that context, it may be observed that Waller did not allege that the parties had executed a formal document which, on its face, recognised or purported to establish a fiduciary relationship as between Waller and Dowling Yeppoon in respect of the acquisition and development of the Jimboomba Property. The “robust documentary record” relied upon by Waller was a record essentially comprised of emails, handwritten file notes, correspondence and the drafting and execution of deeds and contracts, the latter in connection with other projects. That documentary record was interspersed with disputed conversations. To the extent that, by submitting that credit was not “central” to the Relationship case, Waller was suggesting that the Court could decide the issues raised by the Relationship case without careful regard to the credit of Mr Quinn and Mr Dowling, I reject that submission. The Relationship case required attention to the actual circumstances of the alleged relationship, which included many informal documents and some significant disputed conversations. Waller bore the burden of proof in respect of establishing the relationship. An important issue was whether the circumstances were such that Waller, acting through Mr Quinn, was entitled to expect that Dowling Yeppoon, acting through Mr Dowling, would act in relation to the Jimboomba Property in Waller’s interests in and for the purposes of the relationship. In the context of any relationship which existed, Waller sought to demonstrate that Mr Quinn was relevantly vulnerable and placed faith and confidence in Mr Dowling. Mr Quinn gave evidence in chief about the “features of the relationship as I observed and remember them”. He said that he was conscious that he could not self-deal with “an opportunity that had been brought for consideration by Craig to me, or vice versa”. He gave evidence in chief about the “nature of the relationship between me and Craig”. The defences to the Relationship case which alleged non-disclosures, representations and reliance involved credit considerations. There was also the defence of laches which required consideration of all relevant circumstances including determining the period of delay and the proper characterisation of conduct during the interval. Mr Quinn gave evidence about his subjective reasons for his conduct during the period of delay and his understanding of what was occurring during that time. It was not possible to resolve the issues raised by the Relationship case, including the defences, without having regard to the credit of Mr Quinn and Mr Dowling in particular.