Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW v Dederer

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GLEESON CJ,
GUMMOW, KIRBY, CALLINAN AND HEYDON JJ

ROADS AND TRAFFIC AUTHORITY
OF NSW  APPELLANT

AND

PHILIP JAMES DEDERER & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW v Dederer [2007] HCA 42
30 August 2007
S122/2007

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed.

2.The first respondent to pay the appellant's costs.

3.Set aside orders 4, 5, 6 and 7 of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 5 October 2006 and in their place order that:

(a)the appeal to that Court by the Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW ("the RTA") be allowed;

(b)set aside so much of the orders made by Dunford J in the Supreme Court of New South Wales on 18 March 2005 as disposed of the action against the RTA and in their place order that there be judgment for the RTA against the plaintiff; and

(c)Mr Dederer to pay the costs of the RTA at trial and in the Court of Appeal.

4.Application for special leave to cross-appeal dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales

Representation

B W Walker SC with A C Casselden for the appellant (instructed by Henry Davis York Lawyers)

D F Jackson QC with D T Kennedy SC and G R Graham for the first respondent (instructed by Emery Partners)

Submitting appearance for the second respondent

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GLEESON CJ.   The principal question to be decided is whether this Court should overturn findings on negligence and causation made in the Supreme Court of New South Wales by the primary judge (Dunford J)[1] and the Court of Appeal (Ipp and Tobias JJA; Handley JA dissenting)[2] in an action for damages for personal injuries brought by the first respondent.

    [1]Dederer v Roads and Traffic Authority (2005) Aust Torts Reports ¶81-792.

    [2]Great Lakes Shire Council v Dederer (2006) Aust Torts Reports ¶81-860.

  2. The facts and issues are set out in the reasons of Kirby J.  The appellant is a public authority responsible for the construction and management of the Forster-Tuncurry bridge.  The first respondent, then aged 14, dived from the bridge, with catastrophic consequences.  It is not in dispute that the appellant owed the first respondent a duty to take reasonable care for his safety.  That the first respondent's own serious carelessness contributed to his injuries is plain; a large deduction from the damages he was awarded was made on account of his contributory negligence.  Nevertheless, the appellant owed him a duty of care, and there was an issue whether, by its acts or omissions, it failed to take reasonable care for the safety of the first respondent.  There was also an issue whether such failure was a cause of his injuries.  Those issues, essentially factual, were resolved by the primary judge, and the Court of Appeal, adversely to the appellant.  The bridge was not designed to be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW v Dederer and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] HCA 42
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an appeal by the Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW ("RTA") against a decision of the New South Wales Court of Appeal, which had upheld a finding of negligence against the RTA. The dispute arose from injuries sustained by Mr. Dederer, a 14-year-old, who dived from a bridge constructed by the RTA's predecessor into shallow water, striking his head on the estuary bed. Mr. Dederer was aware of the variable depth of the water and the presence of signs prohibiting diving.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether the scope of the RTA's duty of care extended to preventing harm in the circumstances of Mr. Dederer's injury, and whether the RTA had breached that duty. The Court was required to determine if the lower courts had correctly applied the principles of negligence, particularly the assessment of risk, the probability and gravity of harm, and the practicability of precautions, as established in cases like *Wyong Shire Council v Shirt*. The Court also considered the relevance of Mr. Dederer's voluntary conduct, the obviousness of the risk, and the concept of "allurement" in the context of the bridge's use.

The majority of the High Court reasoned that a duty of care does not impose an obligation to prevent all potentially harmful conduct, but rather to exercise reasonable care. They found that the lower courts had erred in their application of legal principles, particularly in characterising the risk and assessing breach. The Court noted that Mr. Dederer was aware of the risks, and that the RTA had erected "no diving" pictograms, which were considered a reasonable response to the identified risk. The Court also found that proposed further precautions, such as pool-type fencing or modifications to the handrail, were either not supported by evidence as reasonable or were unlikely to deter a determined individual. The Court emphasised that the assessment of breach must be prospective and based on the facts as they were known at the time, not with the benefit of hindsight.

The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Court of Appeal and ordering judgment for the RTA against Mr. Dederer. Consequently, Mr. Dederer was ordered to pay the RTA's costs at trial and in the Court of Appeal. The application for special leave to cross-appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. The first respondent to pay the appellant's costs.

3. Set aside orders 4, 5, 6 and 7 of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 5 October 2006 and in their place order that:

(a) the appeal to that Court by the Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW ("the RTA") be allowed;

(b) set aside so much of the orders made by Dunford J in the Supreme Court of New South Wales on 18 March 2005 as disposed of the action against the RTA and in their place order that there be judgment for the RTA against the plaintiff; and

(c) Mr Dederer to pay the costs of the RTA at trial and in the Court of Appeal.

4. Application for special leave to cross-appeal dismissed with costs.

(Gleeson CJ and Kirby J dissenting)

Background

Background to the litigation

The errors of which the appellant rightly complains, regarding both the reasons of the trial judge and those of the New South Wales Court of Appeal, did not turn on factual matters upon which reasonable minds might differ. Rather, they concerned the misapplication of basic and settled matters of legal principle. These principles may be restated shortly. First, the proper resolution of an action in negligence depends on the existence and scope of the relevant duty of care. Secondly, whatever its scope, a duty of care imposes an obligation to exercise reasonable care; it does not impose a duty to prevent potentially harmful conduct. Thirdly, the assessment of breach depends on the correct identification of the relevant risk of injury. Fourthly, breach must be assessed prospectively and not retrospectively. Fifthly, such an assessment of breach must be made in the manner described by Mason J in Wyong Shire Council v Shirt[20].[20](1980) 146 CLR 40 at 47-48.The facts The facts are set out in greater detail in the reasons of Callinan J, but it is convenient to set out the main aspects here. The estuary of the Wallamba River divides the twin towns of Forster and Tuncurry on the mid-north coast of New South Wales; Forster lying on the eastern bank, Tuncurry to the west. The estuary contains navigable channels as well as a large central sandbar of shifting depth and dimensions. The towns of Forster and Tuncurry are linked by a bridge which is 632 m long and which carries a two-lane bitumen roadway and a footpath on its northern side. The facts established at the trial included the following. The footpath was enclosed by a wooden post and rail fence around 1.2 m high and consisting of a flat wooden top railing, two horizontal wooden cross-members, horizontal wires and vertical posts. Depending on tidal conditions, the top of the railing was around 9 m from the surface of the water. There was a pictogram indicating the prohibition "no diving" at each end of the bridge, and signs in words prohibiting fishing from, and climbing on, the bridge. The then current "no diving" pictograms were erected by the second respondent, the Great Lakes Shire Council ("the Council"), in 1995, with funding obtained from the appellant, the Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW ("the RTA"). The bridge was built in 1959 by the Department of Main Roads, the predecessor of the RTA. The RTA became the universal successor of that Department and the Commissioner for Main Roads pursuant to the Transport Administration Act 1988 (NSW), Sched 7 Div 5, and now exercises the powers and functions set out in Pt 6 of that Act. Pursuant to s 7(4) of the Roads Act 1993 (NSW), the Council was the relevant "roads authority" within the meaning of that statute. The extent of the obligations of such a "roads authority" was recently considered by this Court in Leichhardt Municipal Council v Montgomery[21].[21](2007) 81 ALJR 686; 233 ALR 200. The interplay between the statutory functions of the Council and the RTA with respect to the bridge was not fully considered at trial or in the Court of Appeal. It was concluded, however, that the RTA was responsible for the erection and maintenance of the bridge and that the Council was responsible for the day to day management of the bridge including, among other things, the enforcement of the prohibition contained in the various pictograms and signs. Each entity thus answered the common law description of a roads authority, namely, as Dixon J put it, "an authority exercising powers for the construction, maintenance, repair and control of highways"[22]. [22]Buckle v Bayswater Road Board (1936) 57 CLR 259 at 286.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

What, then, of the expense, difficulty and inconvenience of taking alleviating action? The erection of further warning signs would not have been expensive, but Mr Dederer provided no evidence that they would be reasonable. The installation of pool-type fencing and a triangular cap on the handrail would have been more expensive and intrusive. The estimate of the cost of the handrail modification was some $108,072, and it was accepted that the cost of new fencing would be around $150,000 but, again, the reasonableness of such measures is open to doubt. The course of the evidence In order to explain these doubts, it is necessary to return to the way the evidence unfolded at trial. Mr Dederer was never asked whether any of the suggested modifications would have deterred him from diving. Each suggestion arose only after he gave his testimony. Mr Dederer called Mr Robert Fogg as an expert on safety and signage. Mr Fogg's uncontradicted evidence was that a "no diving" pictogram was a reasonable response to the risk. As it happens, Mr Fogg mistakenly believed that such a pictogram had not already been installed, but this misapprehension did not otherwise undermine the force of his evidence about what a reasonable response to the risk would have been. The sign proposed by the trial judge was devised solely by his Honour and there was no evidence that such a sign would have been a reasonable response. The sign adopted by the Court of Appeal, a pictogram indicating "no diving, shallow water", scarcely seems reasonable in light of the trial judge's explicit finding that it would probably have been ignored as well, particularly as the large number of young persons jumping and diving without incident indicated that the water under the bridge was not generally shallow. In any event, Mr Dederer admitted that he knew about the variable depth of the estuary and the moving sandbar. A warning sign would not have told him anything he did not already know. The suggestion that it was negligent not to have installed "pool-type" fencing arose out of the 1992 Austroads Bridge Design Code, which recommended that bridges constructed after 1992 use such vertical balusters. That design code did not apply to bridges constructed before 1992, and the Forster-Tuncurry bridge conformed to the applicable standards at the time of its construction. The matter was put to Mr Fogg, whose evidence was that he would be satisfied with the provision of a sign as an alternative to such "pool-type" fencing, and that such fencing was unlikely to deter a person of Mr Dederer's height who wished to dive from the bridge. The Council's Works Engineer and Asset Manager, Mr Keegan, also gave evidence that such fencing had not prevented people jumping from the nearby Bulahdelah bridge. The suggestion of affixing a triangular cap to the handrail emerged only in the cross-examination of Mr Keegan. It was not otherwise the subject of any evidence. Mr Keegan said that it would be "possible" to affix such a cap to the railing, and that it would be more difficult to balance on such a cap before diving or jumping. Significantly, Mr Dederer's safety expert, Mr Fogg, gave no evidence about this aspect of the case. Even if the cap made balancing more difficult, it might be doubted whether this would have impeded Mr Dederer's dive, especially as the risk and danger of diving were part of its attraction.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GLEESON CJ (dissent) GUMMOW J (dissent) KIRBY J (dissent)
On 31 December 1998, Mr Dederer was rendered partially paraplegic after he dived from the bridge into shallow water and struck his head on the estuary bed. Mr Dederer was then aged 14. He climbed onto the railing of the bridge and although he originally intended to jump into the water he changed his mind and dived head first instead. Mr Dederer and his family were familiar with the area, and he had seen many other young people jump or dive from the bridge. He had done so himself on the previous day without any harm. He admitted that he saw and understood the signs forbidding diving and climbing, and that he knew that the sandbar moved and that the channels were of variable depth.The decision at trial At trial in the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Dunford J sitting without a jury) Mr Dederer succeeded against both the RTA and the Council. His Honour found that Mr Dederer saw, understood, and deliberately disregarded the "no diving" pictograms, and that he knew that the water was of variable depth and that jumping from heights could cause injury. Nonetheless, Dunford J placed great emphasis on the fact that many people jumped or dived from the bridge both before and after the then current signs prohibiting diving were erected in 1995. He said[23]:"I am satisfied that almost from the time of its construction and certainly for many years prior to the plaintiff's accident young, and not so young, persons were regularly using the railing and ledge of the bridge as launching pads for jumping and diving into the water below, particularly, but not limited to, during the summer holidays. The reason why jumping and diving off the bridge was so popular was in part due to the flat topped railing along the outside boundary of the bridge, and the ease of access to that railing by reason of the wooden cross members which provided steps up to the top railing. Even if it was not anticipated prior to the construction of the bridge that it would be used in this way, it soon became apparent after its completion and foreseeable that the culture was likely to continue. Although the jumpers and divers entered the water in or near the main navigation channel, both the RTA and the Council were aware of the moving sands and variable depths underneath the water, and it was therefore reasonably foreseeable, and not far fetched or fanciful, that if the practice continued someone engaging in the activity was liable to suffer serious injury.I say this notwithstanding the fact that no one had in fact been injured in nearly 50 years, because the risks should have been so apparent to the officers of both defendants with knowledge of the estuary bed that it was in effect 'an accident waiting to happen'."[23](2005) Aust Torts Reports ¶81-792 at 67,528-67,529. The Council, but not the RTA, admitted that it was aware of this pattern of behaviour. Nonetheless, his Honour found that the RTA "must have known" of it, and because of the "continuing practice" or "culture" of diving Dunford J found that it was:"not sufficient to ignore the fact that the signs were being disregarded and it is necessary to consider what, if any, further steps should reasonably have been taken by way of further warning signs, modification of the bridge or otherwise, to prevent injury to persons such as the plaintiff; or to put it another way, the content of the duty of care"[24].[24](2005) Aust Torts Reports ¶81-792 at 67,529.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: