Great Lakes Shire Council v Dederer

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Great Lakes Shire Council v Dederer & Anor; Roads & Traffic Authority of NSW v Dederer & Anor [2006]  NSWCA 101

FILE NUMBER(S):
40257/05
40294/05

HEARING DATE(S):               20/03/06, 21/03/06

DECISION DATE:     05/10/2006

PARTIES:
CA 40257/05
Great Lakes Shire Council (Appellant)
Philip James Dederer (First Respondent)
Roads & Traffic Authority of NSW (Second Respondent)
CA 40294/05
Roads & Traffic Authority of NSW (Appellant)
Philip James Dederer (First Respondent)
Great Lakes Shire Council (Second Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:       Handley JA Ipp JA Tobias JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court - Common Law Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          SC 20122/02

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Dunford J

COUNSEL:
CA 40257/05
M McCulloch SC/S Glascott (Appellant)
D T Kennedy SC/G Graham (First Respondent)
M J Cranitch SC/A C Casselden (Second Respondent)
CA 40294/05
M J Cranitch SC/A C Casselden (Appellant)
D T Kennedy SC/G Graham (First Respondent)
M McCulloch SC/S Glascott (Second Respondent)

SOLICITORS:
CA 40257/05
Phillips Fox (Appellant)
Emery Partners (First Respondent)
Henry Davis York (Second Respondent)
CA 40294/05
Henry Davis York (Appellant)
Emery Partners (First Respondent)
Phillips Fox (Second Respondent)

CATCHWORDS:
NEGLIGENCE - boy rendered paraplegic after diving off bridge - duty of care owed by Council as Road Authority for public road under Roads Act 1993 (NSW) - miscellaneous defences - obviousness of risk - fourteen year old boy - Civil Liability Act 2001 (NSW) s 5F.
NEGLIGENCE - duty of care owed by RTA - consequences of RTA's predecessor designing and building bridge - knowledge of RTA of allurement and dangers constituted by bridge - signs prohibiting diving - signs ineffective for many years - RTA's knowledge that signs not achieving purpose - situation was "accident waiting to happen" - whether different signs should have been installed - whether bridge should have been modified to make diving more difficult - the justifiability of policy decisions in cases of negligence involving statutory authorities - availability of resources and competing priorities - causation - contribution negligence.  D

LEGISLATION CITED:
Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), Pt 1A, ss 5F, 5G(2), 5K, 5L
Main Roads Act 1924 (NSW), s 25
Roads Act 1993 (NSW), ss 4, 7(3), 7(4), s 48(1), 63, 64, 71, 145(3), 249(1)
Transport Administration Act 1988 (NSW) Sch 7 Pt 5 cl 24(e) and (g)

DECISION:
(1)  The appeal by the Council is upheld with costs.  (2)  The orders made by Dunford J against the Council are set aside and substituted by a judgment in favour of the Council with costs.  (3)  Mr Dederer is granted a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act 1951 (NSW) if he is otherwise entitled.  (4)  The appeal by the RTA is partially upheld.  (5)  The orders of Dunford J in regard to the apportionment of damages is set aside and substituted with an apportionment of 50 per cent.  (6)  Otherwise, the appeal by the RTA is dismissed.  (7)  No order is made as regards the costs of the appeal by the RTA.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Great Lakes Shire Council v Dederer and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWCA 101
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Great Lakes Shire Council v Dederer concerned a negligence claim brought by a young man who sustained severe injuries, including paraplegia, after diving off a bridge. The plaintiff sued both the Great Lakes Shire Council, as the responsible road authority, and the Roads and Traffic Authority (RTA), the successor to the body that designed and built the bridge. The dispute centred on whether these authorities owed a duty of care to the plaintiff and whether they breached that duty, leading to his injuries. The matter was heard in the Court of Appeal of New South Wales.

The legal issues before the court included whether the Council, as the road authority, owed a duty of care to the plaintiff regarding the safety of the bridge and its surrounds, particularly given the known propensity for people to dive from it. The court also had to consider the RTA's duty of care arising from its predecessor's design and construction of the bridge, including whether the RTA had sufficient knowledge of the dangers and the ineffectiveness of existing signage prohibiting diving. Furthermore, the court was required to determine the application of the obviousness of the risk defence under section 5F of the Civil Liability Act 2001 (NSW), the issue of causation, and the extent of any contributory negligence by the plaintiff. The justifiability of policy decisions made by statutory authorities in the context of negligence claims, including considerations of resource availability and competing priorities, was also a significant aspect of the appeal.

The Court of Appeal's reasoning involved a detailed examination of the duties owed by statutory authorities and the principles of negligence. The court considered the plaintiff's age and experience, his knowledge of the estuary's tidal conditions and the potential for shallowing water, and his observations of others diving from the bridge. The court also assessed the adequacy of the warning signs and the feasibility of modifying the bridge to deter diving. Ultimately, the court found that while the RTA had some responsibility, the Council's appeal was upheld, and the original judgment against it was set aside. The RTA's appeal was partially upheld, with the apportionment of damages significantly altered.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) The appeal by the Council is upheld with costs. (2) The orders made by Dunford J against the Council are set aside and substituted by a judgment in favour of the Council with costs. (3) Mr Dederer is granted a certificate under the Suitors Fund Act 1951 (NSW) if he is otherwise entitled. (4) The appeal by the RTA is partially upheld. (5) The orders of Dunford J in regard to the apportionment of damages is set aside and substituted with an apportionment of 50 per cent. (6) Otherwise, the appeal by the RTA is dismissed. (7) No order is made as regards the costs of the appeal by the RTA.

Background

Background to the litigation

The pictograph sign that Mr Dederer observed before diving was located on a telegraph pole between pier no 47 and the Forster end of the bridge. It depicted a person diving with a diagonal line through the person. A sign in words, prohibiting fishing from and climbing on the bridge, stood at both entrances to the bridge. The plaintiff’s background and knowledge of the area Mr Dederer was about 182 centimetres tall and “a fairly solid person” at the time of the accident. He was a good sportsman, played rugby league as front row forward and in 1998 was awarded Player of the Year for his school. He participated in several other sports as well. He had previously dived from a 10-metre tower at a swimming pool. Mr Dederer and his family had spent holidays in the area since he was a very small boy. They stayed at a caravan park north of the Tuncurry township over weekends and school holidays. They regularly spent time swimming, water skiing and fishing in the estuary. Mr Dederer became aware that, in the area of the bridge, the estuary was “very much given to tidal action”. Mr Dederer and his family frequently ran their boat onto the sandbar, jumped off the back of the boat and swam in the channel. The depth of the water dropped suddenly at the edge of the sandbar and the water in the channel was “fairly deep”. Mr Dederer’s feet did not touch the bottom in that area. He knew that the tide shifted the sand around and resulted in a scouring of sand, particularly through the channel. He said there would not be a “sudden shift of sand” in the middle of a channel. But at times it was noticeable that “some sort of a shallowing up of the bottom” had occurred. At times when the water was clear one could see yellow patches in the channel. These were long stretches of sand indicating shallower areas. Whether the shallower areas within the channels could be seen depended on the tide and the day and, Mr Dederer said, “a number of factors”. He accepted that the depth of the water in the channels was hard to judge “due to the flow of the water going under the bridge”. Over the years, Mr Dederer frequently observed children and adults jump and dive off the bridge. He assumed from these observations that the water “must be deep”. Mr Dederer had been under the bridge from time to time in a boat. He said that, from that vantage point, “the bridge looked fairly high but the water also looked very deep”. On 30 December 1998, the day before the accident, Mr Dederer went with a friend, Grant Cunial, to Forster. They walked onto the bridge and as they approached it Mr Dederer saw what he described as the “big sign” at the side of the bridge that read “Fishing and Climbing Prohibited”. He had seen that sign and the identical sign at the Tuncurry end of the bridge previously. He advanced some distance along the bridge and jumped into the river twice, first from the ledge at the base of the bridge and the second time from the top of the handrail. Both times his body was totally submerged and his feet did not touch the bottom. This was the first time he had jumped or dived from the bridge. That day he saw other people (who he described as “a group of kids”) jumping and diving from the bridge.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As I have indicated, ultimately the test is an objective one to be determined on the balance of probabilities. In the circumstances referred to, the primary judge held that it was probable that the plaintiff would not have dived as he did and, therefore, would not have sustained his injuries. That was finding which, as Ipp JA observes, was clearly open to the primary judge on the evidence and one which is not vitiated by error which would justify the intervention of this Court.Conclusion I have had the unenviable task of considering the judgments of my brethren, each of which contain powerful arguments in favour and against the RTA’s appeal being upheld. I have attempted to isolate the differences between their Honours and to express my own views as to how those differences should be resolved. At the end of the day, for the reasons I have given, I have resolved them in favour of the RTA’s appeal other than with respect to the apportionment of damages, being dismissed. I therefore agree with the orders proposed by Ipp JA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.