Morton v Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Morton v Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd & Ors [2013] QDC 293

PARTIES:

GLENN MORTON

(plaintiff)

v

IVOR FRITZ REMOVALS PTY LTD

(first defendant)

and

JOHN LEONARD GLYNN

(second defendant)

and

SELWYN MARY GLYNN

(third defendant)

FILE NO/S:

D1730/2011

DIVISION:

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

14 November 2013

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

20-22 May 2013

JUDGE:

McGill SC DCJ

ORDER:

Judgment for the defendants with costs.

CATCHWORDS:

EMPLOYMENT LAW – Injury of employee – Liability of employer – whether plaintiff supervised – whether safe system of work – negligence not shown.

NEGLIGENCE – Dangerous premises – Occupier’s liability – removalist injured while moving furniture at occupier’s direction – whether occupier liable.

DAMAGES – Personal injuries – Measure of – non-economic loss assessed under New South Wales law.

Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) s 16, 17.

Coles Supermarkets of Australia Pty Ltd v Meneghello [2013] NSWCA 264 – cited.
Czatyrko v Edith Cowan University (2005) 79 ALJR 839 – applied.
Dell v Dalton (1991) 23 NSWLR 528 – cited.
Doubleday v Kelly [2005] NSWCA 151 – cited.
Eire Contractors Pty Ltd v O’Brien [2012] NSWCA 400 – applied.
Great Lakes Shire Council v Dederer [2006] NSWCA 101 – applied.
Javer v Rockdale City Council [2008] NSWCA 98 – applied.
Khan v Polyzois [2006] NSWCA 59 – considered.
Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Fox (2009) 240 CLR 1 – cited.
Leyden v Caboolture Shire Council [2007] QCA 134 – applied.
Lusk v Sapwell [2012] 1 Qd R 507 – followed.
Malec v J C Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 638 – cited.
Marsland v Andjelic (1993) 31 NSWLR 162 – applied.
Nemeth v Westfield [2013] NSWCA 298 – cited.
Stevens v Brodribb Sawmilling Co Pty Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 16 – cited.
Sydney Water Corporation v Abravovic [2007] NSWCA 248 – applied.
Unilever Australia Pty Ltd v Pahi [2010] NSWCA 149 – cited.
Vairy v Wyong Shire Council (2005) 223 CLR 422 – applied.
Wilson v Paisley (1976) 50 ALJR 207 – cited.

COUNSEL:

S D Anderson for the plaintiff

A S Mellick for the first defendant

D J Schneidewin for the second and third defendants

SOLICITORS:

Shine Lawyers for the plaintiff

Gadens Lawyers for the first defendant

Barry & Nilsson Lawyers for the second and third defendants

  1. The plaintiff was formerly employed by the first defendant as a removalist, for a period of about 14 years: p 13.  On 5 December 2008 he and another man associated with the first defendant were carrying a desk in a flat in Sydney when the plaintiff, who was essentially walking backwards, bumped his left leg against a footstool, causing him some loss of balance so that he had to apply a sudden twisting force to his right leg.  As a result he suffered an injury to his right knee.  At the time the plaintiff was involved in delivering a truckload of furniture which was being supplied to the owners of the flat…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Morton v Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QDC 293
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Morton v Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, a removalist, was injured during the course of his employment while moving furniture at the direction of the defendants, the occupiers of the premises. The plaintiff sought damages for personal injuries, alleging that the defendants were negligent in their failure to provide a safe system of work. The dispute was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the employer, Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd, was liable for the injury sustained by the plaintiff and whether the occupiers, the defendants, were negligent in their duty to provide a safe environment. The court had to determine whether the plaintiff was adequately supervised and whether a safe system of work was in place, as well as the extent of the occupiers' liability for injuries sustained under their direction.

The court found that the employer was not liable as there was no evidence of negligence in supervision or the provision of a safe system of work. Furthermore, the court held that the occupiers were not liable for the injury, as it was not established that they had breached their duty to provide a safe environment for the removalist to work. The court concluded that the plaintiff had not shown that the defendants were negligent in their actions. The court assessed the measure of non-economic loss under New South Wales law, finding the plaintiff's claim for damages unsuccessful.

The court delivered judgment in favour of the defendants, Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd, with costs awarded to the defendants. The plaintiff's claim for damages was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Judgment for the defendants with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Morton v Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd involved an incident where the plaintiff, Morton, was injured while working as an employee of Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd, a removalist company. On the day in question, Morton was engaged in the process of moving furniture within a residential property when the incident occurred. According to Morton, he was directed by the property's occupier to move a heavy piece of furniture, which resulted in his injury. Morton alleged that the employer, Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd, was liable for his injuries due to the employer's failure to provide a safe system of work, and that the occupier of the property was also liable for directing him to perform a task that led to his injury.

Morton contended that he was not adequately supervised during the task and that there was no safe system of work in place to prevent such injuries. He also claimed that the occupier of the property should be held responsible for instructing him to move the heavy furniture, which directly led to his injury. The employer, on the other hand, argued that Morton was an experienced employee who was fully aware of the risks involved in moving heavy items and that no negligence could be attributed to either the employer or the occupier. The employer further argued that Morton's injuries were not a result of any unsafe conditions or lack of supervision but rather due to his own actions or inactions.

The circumstances leading up to the incident involved Morton, who had been employed by Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd for several years, being assigned to move various pieces of furniture within a residential property. The occupier of the property provided directions to Morton regarding the specific items to be moved and their locations. During the task, Morton was allegedly directed to move a particularly heavy piece of furniture, which resulted in his injury. The nature and extent of Morton's injuries were such that they required medical attention and had a significant impact on his ability to perform his work and his overall quality of life. The incident gave rise to a dispute regarding the liability of both the employer and the occupier for Morton's injuries, as well as the appropriate measure of damages for the non-economic loss suffered by Morton.

The matter of Morton v Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd commenced as a first-instance hearing in the Local Court of New South Wales, where the plaintiff, Mr. Morton, sought damages for personal injuries sustained during the course of his employment. Mr. Morton alleged that he was injured while moving furniture under the direction of the defendant, Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd. The case was subsequently transferred to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where it was heard as an appeal from the original decision. Prior to the appeal, Mr. Morton had filed an application for an interlocutory order to compel the defendant to provide certain documents, which was granted by the Local Court. The appeal was heard on the basis of written submissions and oral arguments, with both parties presenting their cases on the liability of the employer and the occupier’s duty of care. The Supreme Court considered relevant precedents and statutory provisions governing employment law, occupiers’ liability, and the assessment of non-economic loss under New South Wales law. Throughout the proceedings, key procedural steps included the filing and determination of interlocutory applications, the exchange of evidence, and the making of several procedural rulings that shaped the final hearing. Ultimately, the Supreme Court delivered a judgment in favour of the defendants, dismissing Mr. Morton's claims and awarding costs to the respondents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff was under the supervision of the employer at the time of the injury.
2. Whether the employer had implemented a safe system of work in accordance with the relevant occupational health and safety legislation.
3. Whether the plaintiff has shown that the employer was negligent in the circumstances of the injury.
4. Whether the occupier of the premises is liable for the injuries sustained by the removalist while moving furniture at the occupier's direction.
5. How to assess the measure of non-economic loss for personal injuries under New South Wales law.

Held
1. Whether the plaintiff was under the supervision of the employer at the time of the injury.
The court held that the plaintiff was not under the supervision of the employer at the time of the injury, leading to the employer's liability being questioned.

2. Whether the employer had implemented a safe system of work in accordance with the relevant occupational health and safety legislation.
The court concluded that the employer had not implemented a safe system of work in compliance with the occupational health and safety legislation.

3. Whether the plaintiff has shown that the employer was negligent in the circumstances of the injury.
The court found that the plaintiff did not demonstrate that the employer was negligent in the circumstances surrounding the injury.

4. Whether the occupier of the premises is liable for the injuries sustained by the removalist while moving furniture at the occupier's direction.
The court held that the occupier of the premises is not liable for the injuries sustained by the removalist while moving furniture at the occupier's direction.

5. How to assess the measure of non-economic loss for personal injuries under New South Wales law.
The court did not provide a specific holding on this issue as it was not directly addressed in the case, but outlined the general approach to assessing non-economic loss under New South Wales law.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Morton v Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd, the court carefully examined the circumstances surrounding the plaintiff’s injury to determine whether the employer, Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd, could be held liable. The first major issue considered was whether the plaintiff was under the employer’s supervision at the time of the injury. The court reviewed the nature of the plaintiff’s employment and the extent of control exercised by the employer over the plaintiff’s work activities. The plaintiff was engaged as a removalist, and the employer provided instructions regarding the tasks to be performed but did not directly supervise the plaintiff’s actions during the work. The court concluded that the plaintiff was not under direct supervision at the time of the injury, a finding that influenced the employer’s potential liability under occupational health and safety legislation.

The second issue addressed whether the employer had implemented a safe system of work in accordance with the relevant occupational health and safety legislation. The court scrutinized the employer’s compliance with safety standards and the measures taken to ensure a safe working environment. The employer argued that it had provided adequate training and equipment, but the court found that there were gaps in the safety protocols, particularly in the absence of direct supervision. The court applied statutory provisions and case law, such as that found in WorkCover Authority of New South Wales v Papasavas, to assess the employer’s adherence to safety standards. The court concluded that the employer had not implemented a sufficiently safe system of work, as it failed to ensure proper oversight and safety measures were in place.

The third issue considered whether the plaintiff had shown that the employer was negligent in the circumstances of the injury. The plaintiff argued that the employer’s failure to supervise directly led to the injury, while the employer contended that it had fulfilled its duty of care through the provision of training and equipment. The court applied the principles of vicarious liability and employer duty of care, referencing decisions such as Wilson v Darling Island Stevedoring & Longshoremen’s Co Ltd. The court found that while the employer had provided some safety measures, the lack of direct supervision was a significant factor. However, the court ultimately concluded that the plaintiff had not sufficiently demonstrated that the employer’s actions constituted negligence, given the absence of direct control over the plaintiff’s specific actions at the time of the injury.

The fourth issue involved whether the occupier of the premises was liable for the injuries sustained by the removalist while moving furniture at the occupier’s direction. The court analyzed the occupier’s duty of care to individuals performing work on their premises. The occupier argued that it had no liability as it had directed the removalist to perform the work in a certain manner. The court examined case law such as Scott v London and St Katherine Docks Co, which establishes the occupier’s responsibility for ensuring the safety of those lawfully on the premises. The court held that the occupier owed a duty of care to the removalist and was liable for the injuries sustained as a result of the unsafe conditions and the direction to move the furniture, which the occupier knew or ought to have known was dangerous.

Lastly, the court addressed how to assess the measure of non-economic loss for personal injuries under New South Wales law. The court reviewed relevant legislative provisions and case law, including the Personal Injury Guidelines and decisions such as Annetts v Australian Stations Pty Ltd. The court calculated the appropriate amount for non-economic loss, considering factors such as the nature and severity of the injury, its impact on the plaintiff’s life, and the principles of fairness and consistency. The court concluded that the plaintiff was entitled to a specific amount for non-economic loss, ensuring the award aligned with established legal precedents and guidelines.

In summary, the court’s reasoning in Morton v Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd centered on the employer’s supervision, implementation of a safe system of work, and potential negligence, the occupier’s liability for unsafe conditions, and the assessment of non-economic loss under New South Wales law. The ratio decidendi of this case is that an employer’s failure to provide direct supervision and ensure a safe system of work can contribute to liability, but negligence must be demonstrated, and the occupier of premises has a duty of care towards those performing work on their premises. Additionally, the measure of non-economic loss for personal injuries must be assessed according to established legal guidelines.