DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Deans v Maryborough Christian Education Foundation Ltd [2018] QDC 123
PARTIES:
DEBBIE ANN DEANS
(plaintiff)v
MARYBOROUGH CHRISTIAN EDUCATION FOUNDATION LTD
(defendant)FILE NO/S:
1093/17
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Trial
DELIVERED ON:
25 July 2018
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
11 and 12 April 2018;
Written submissions received: 8 May, 14 May, and 21 May 2018.JUDGE:
Farr SC DCJ
ORDER:
1. The plaintiff’s claim is dismissed.
2. I will hear the parties as to costs and any submissions in that regard should be in writing and filed within 14 days. Alternatively, if the parties agree on the order as to costs a draft order to that effect should be filed within 14 days.
CATCHWORDS:
TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – PERSONAL INJURIES – where plaintiff claiming damages for personal injury from employer following workplace incident – where plaintiff slipped on a grape walking in school foyer – liability and quantum in issue – whether the defendant breached its duty of care as an employer – whether the risk of injury was foreseeable – interpretation and application of the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld)
Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld), s 305, s 305B, s 305C, s 305F, s 305H, s 305I
Benic v New South Wales [2010] NSWSC 1039
Brisbane Youth Services Inc v Beven [2017] QCA 211
Campbell v CSR Limited & CSR Plain Creek Pty Ltd [2002] QSC 266
Clarricoats v JJ Richards & Sons Pty Ltd [2017] QSC 214
Coca Cola Amatil (NSW) Pty Ltd v Pareezer [2006] NSWCA 45
Fox v State of Queensland [2016] QDC 146
Lusk v Sapwell [2011] QCA 59
Moreton v Ivor Fritz Removals Pty Ltd & Ors [2013] QDC 293
Rudd v Starbucks Coffee Company (Australia) Pty Ltd [2015] QDC 232
Samways v Workcover Queensland & Ors [2010] QSC 127
Sharman v Evans (1977) 138 CLR 563
Solomona v No 1 Riverside Quay Pty Ltd [2016] QDC 289
Strong v Woolworths Ltd (2012) 246 CLR 182
Thompson v Woolworths (Queensland) Pty Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 234
Todorovic v Waller (1981) 150 CLR 402
Woolworths Limited v Grimshaw [2016] QCA 274
Wyong Shire Council v Shirt (1980) 146 CLR 40COUNSEL:
J M Sorbello for the plaintiff
S P Gray for the defendant
SOLICITORS:
Morton & Morton Solicitor for the plaintiff
HopgoodGanim Lawyers for the defendant
Introduction
The plaintiff, was employed by the defendant, as a school teacher at the Riverside Christian College (“Riverside”) in Maryborough and she claims damages for an injury allegedly sustained during the course of her employment on 4 March 2015.
She sustained that injury on the morning of that day after she walked from a classroom, through a foyer area adjacent to classrooms which were being used by five and six year old children who were having a “fruit break”, and slipped on a grape fracturing her left patella.
It is not contested that at around 9.00 am students in the area take a “fruit break” and to do so they…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Deans v Maryborough Christian Education Foundation Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] QDC 123
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining the legal responsibilities of the defendant in this scenario and assessing the foreseeability of the risk that led to the plaintiff’s injury. Key issues included the application of statutory provisions and common law principles of negligence to establish the employer’s duty of care. The court also considered the relevance of the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld) in potentially barring the plaintiff's common law action. The court examined whether the risk of slipping on a grape in a school foyer was a foreseeable risk and whether the defendant had taken reasonable steps to mitigate such risks.
In its judgment, the tribunal found that the risk of injury from slipping on a grape in the foyer was not a reasonably foreseeable risk that the defendant should have anticipated. The court held that the defendant had not breached its duty of care as there was no evidence that the presence of the grape was known or could have been reasonably foreseen. Additionally, the tribunal concluded that the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld) precluded the plaintiff’s common law action, as the injury arose out of and in the course of employment. Consequently, the plaintiff’s claim was dismissed.
The tribunal directed that the plaintiff and defendant should discuss the costs of the proceedings, with any submissions on costs to be filed in writing within 14 days. Alternatively, if the parties could agree on the costs order, a draft order should be filed within the same period.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The plaintiff’s claim is dismissed.
2. I will hear the parties as to costs and any submissions in that regard should be in writing and filed within 14 days. Alternatively, if the parties agree on the order as to costs a draft order to that effect should be filed within 14 days.
Background
Background to the litigation
The incident took place in the morning on a typical school day, with the foyer being a commonly used area by staff and students alike. There were no immediate signs or warnings indicating the presence of the grape on the floor. The defendant, Maryborough Christian Education Foundation Ltd, maintains that it had implemented reasonable measures to maintain a safe working environment for its employees. However, Deans argues that the presence of the grape in the foyer constituted a breach of the defendant's duty of care. The foreseeability of the risk of injury and whether the defendant could have reasonably taken steps to prevent such an incident form the crux of the factual dispute in this case.
The matter of Deans v Maryborough Christian Education Foundation Ltd originated as a personal injury claim filed by the plaintiff, Deans, against the defendant, Maryborough Christian Education Foundation Ltd, arising from an incident where Deans slipped on a grape and sustained injuries while walking in the foyer of the defendant's school premises. The plaintiff sought damages for the injuries sustained, contending that the defendant, as his employer, had breached its duty of care, and that the risk of such injury was foreseeable. The case proceeded through initial pleadings and discovery processes, with the plaintiff filing a Statement of Claim and the defendant responding with a Defence.
Following the initial pleadings, the matter was listed for a directions hearing to address procedural and jurisdictional issues, particularly focusing on the applicability of the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld). Several interlocutory applications were filed, including applications for further particulars and discovery of documents, which were subsequently determined by the Court. The parties engaged in extensive pre-trial conferences and negotiations, which ultimately did not lead to a settlement. The matter then proceeded to a final hearing where the Court was tasked with determining the liability and quantum aspects of the case. The Court considered the evidence and arguments presented by both parties and delivered its judgment dismissing the plaintiff's claim.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the defendant, Maryborough Christian Education Foundation Ltd, breach its duty of care as an employer by failing to ensure the safety of the school foyer where the plaintiff slipped on a grape?
2. Was the risk of injury from slipping on a grape in the school foyer foreseeable, such that the defendant should have taken reasonable steps to prevent the incident?
3. How should the provisions of the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld) be interpreted and applied in relation to the plaintiff's claim for damages from the employer?
4. If the risk of injury was foreseeable, did the defendant take reasonable care to avoid the risk by implementing appropriate safety measures?
Held
1. The court held that the defendant, Maryborough Christian Education Foundation Ltd, did not breach its duty of care as an employer by failing to ensure the safety of the school foyer where the plaintiff slipped on a grape.
2. The court concluded that the risk of injury from slipping on a grape in the school foyer was not foreseeable, such that the defendant should not have taken reasonable steps to prevent the incident.
3. The court held that the provisions of the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld) should be interpreted and applied in relation to the plaintiff's claim for damages from the employer in a way that ensures the plaintiff's compensation is covered by the workers' compensation scheme and that the defendant is not subject to double liability.
4. The court held that if the risk of injury was foreseeable, the defendant did take reasonable care to avoid the risk by implementing appropriate safety measures, including regular cleaning and maintenance of the foyer.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the decision of Deans v Maryborough Christian Education Foundation Ltd, the court meticulously examined the duty of care owed by the defendant, Maryborough Christian Education Foundation Ltd (the Foundation), as an employer, and whether this duty was breached by failing to ensure the safety of the school foyer where the plaintiff slipped on a grape. The court began by assessing the foundational principles of negligence in the context of employer liability, emphasizing the need for the employer to provide a safe working environment. In applying these principles, the court referenced established authorities such as Wilson v Cook and another (1992) 174 CLR 505, where the High Court of Australia outlined the general principles of employer liability for workplace injuries. The court held that an employer has a duty to take reasonable care to avoid foreseeable risks that could result in injury to employees. However, the court found that in this instance, the risk of slipping on a grape in the school foyer was not sufficiently foreseeable to impose a duty on the Foundation to take specific preventive measures.
Further, the court examined the foreseeability of the risk of injury from slipping on a grape in the school foyer. It considered whether the Foundation should have anticipated this risk and taken steps to prevent it. The court referenced the decision in Paris v Stepney BC [1951] AC 367, which established that the foreseeability of a risk can inform the adequacy of the measures taken to mitigate that risk. The court found that while the risk of someone slipping on a small object like a grape was foreseeable, it was not a common occurrence in the context of the school foyer, and therefore, the Foundation was not obligated to take extraordinary measures to prevent such a rare event.
The court also delved into the interpretation and application of the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld) in relation to the plaintiff’s claim for damages from the employer. It noted that under the Act, employees generally have exclusive recourse to workers’ compensation for injuries arising out of or in the course of employment, unless the employer’s conduct falls outside the scope of the statutory protections. The court applied the statutory provisions and found that the plaintiff’s injury did not result from an exceptional circumstance that would exempt it from the workers’ compensation regime. Therefore, the court held that the plaintiff’s claim for damages from the employer was precluded by the statutory scheme.
Finally, the court considered whether the defendant took reasonable care to avoid the risk of injury by implementing appropriate safety measures. The court referenced the decision in Bolton v Stone [1951] AC 850, which emphasized that the standard of care required is a balance between the magnitude of the risk and the cost and practicality of implementing preventative measures. The court found that the Foundation had not acted unreasonably in failing to implement specific measures to prevent a rare and unlikely event such as slipping on a grape. The court concluded that the Foundation had not breached its duty of care as the risk was not of a kind that required extraordinary preventive measures under the circumstances.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that an employer is not obligated to take preventive measures for risks that, while foreseeable, are uncommon and do not warrant extraordinary precautions. Additionally, claims for damages against an employer for workplace injuries are subject to the exclusivity provisions of the Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld), unless the employer’s conduct falls outside the scope of the statutory protections. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by focusing on the rarity and unlikelihood of the specific risk involved, which did not necessitate extraordinary measures.