HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Mason, Wilson, Brennan, Deane and Dawson JJ.
AUSTRALIAN SAFEWAY STORES PTY. LTD. v. ZALUZNA
10 March 1987
Negligence
Negligence—Dangerous premises—Injury to entrant—Liability of occupier—Duty of care—Invitee—Special duties owed by occupier to different classes of entrant—General duty of care—Whether general duty of care coexists with special duty—Customer injured by slipping on damp floor—Whether general duty of care.
Decisions
MASON, WILSON, DEANE AND DAWSON JJ.: On Saturday 20 January 1979 towards midday the respondent entered what has been described as the "foyer area" of the appellant's supermarket at Mount Waverley in Victoria, intending to buy some cheese. It was a rainy day and in consequence the vinyl-tiled floor of the foyer area had become wet or moist. Unfortunately, before entering the area of the supermarket where the merchandise was displayed, the respondent slipped and fell heavily on the floor. She sustained personal injury. She sued the appellant in the Supreme Court of Victoria for damages for negligence, alleging both a breach of the general duty of care and a breach of the duty owed by an occupier to an invitee. The action was tried by a judge sitting alone.
2. The learned trial judge ruled that the case was not one in which it was appropriate to look for a duty of care cast in terms of the principles enunciated by Lord Atkin in Donoghue v. Stevenson (1932) AC 562, at p 580. In coming to that conclusion, his Honour relied primarily on the decision of the House of Lords in London Graving Dock Co. Ltd. v. Horton (1951) AC 737. He therefore directed himself in accordance with the classic exposition of the invitor's duty to his invitee as laid down by Willes J. in Indermaur v. Dames (1866) LR 1 CP 274, at p 288, namely, that it was the appellant's obligation to take reasonable care to prevent damage from unusual danger of which it knew or ought to have known.
3. The trial judge, while recognizing that the moisture on the floor did constitute some kind of hazard to customers, held that it was no more than customers shopping on a wet morning would ordinarily expect. It was not an unusual danger. However, his Honour acknowledged that there might be room for different views about such a conclusion and he therefore proceeded to consider the case on the assumption that there was an unusual danger. His Honour found that the mopping-up procedures adopted by the appellant in order to cope with the wet conditions had not been shown to fall short of what was reasonable. He also considered a number of other possible safeguards which it was alleged that the appellant might have undertaken. In the result his Honour found that the appellant was not in breach of the duty of care that would arise on the assumption he had made. He dismissed the respondent's action.
4. The respondent appealed to the Full Court (Starke, Murphy and Beach JJ.) and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd v Zaluzna and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1987] HCA 7
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the occupier of a premises owed a duty of care to an invitee in respect of a danger arising from the state of the premises, and if so, the nature and extent of that duty. Specifically, the court considered whether the common law principles governing the duty of an occupier to an invitee had been altered or superseded by the introduction of statutory duties of care, such as those found in occupiers' liability legislation.
The High Court held that the common law duty of an occupier to an invitee is not confined to dangers of which the occupier has actual knowledge. Instead, the occupier owes a duty to take reasonable care to avoid a foreseeable risk of injury to an invitee. This duty extends to dangers arising from the state of the premises, irrespective of whether the occupier had actual knowledge of the specific danger, provided that the risk of injury was reasonably foreseeable. The court affirmed that the principles of negligence, as established in cases like *Donoghue v Stevenson*, apply to the relationship between an occupier and an invitee, and that the occupier's duty is to exercise reasonable care to ensure that the premises are reasonably safe for the invitee. The court found that the existence of a statutory duty of care did not negate or alter the common law duty owed by an occupier to an invitee.
The High Court allowed the appeal, finding that the trial judge had erred in law by applying an incorrect standard of care. The case was remitted to the Supreme Court of Victoria for a new trial.
Background
Background to the litigation
The trial judge dismissed Mrs Zaluzna's action, ruling that the case was not one in which it was appropriate to look for a duty of care based on the principles enunciated by Lord Atkin in Donoghue v. Stevenson. Instead, the judge applied the classic exposition of the invitor's duty to an invitee, as laid down by Willes J. in Indermaur v. Dames, which required the appellant to take reasonable care to prevent damage from unusual danger of which it knew or ought to have known. The judge found that the moisture on the floor did not constitute an unusual danger and that the appellant had not breached its duty of care.
Mrs Zaluzna appealed to the Full Court, challenging the trial judge's findings. The Full Court allowed the appeal, holding that the trial judge had erred in failing to consider whether the circumstances justified the application of Donoghue v. Stevenson. The Full Court ordered a new trial, but did not address other grounds of appeal. The appellant subsequently appealed to the High Court, arguing that the only relevant relationship was that of occupier and invitee, and that the trial judge's findings necessarily constituted a finding that the appellant was not in breach of any general common law duty of care. The appeal hinged on whether a general duty of care coexisted with the special duty owed by an occupier to an invitee, and whether the duty owed by an occupier should be stated in the terms of Donoghue v. Stevenson rather than Indermaur v. Dames.
The matter of Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd v. Zaluzna came before the High Court of Australia on appeal from the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The respondent, Mrs Zaluzna, had originally sued the appellant, Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd, in the Supreme Court of Victoria for damages for negligence after slipping on a wet floor in the appellant's supermarket and sustaining personal injury. The trial judge dismissed her action, finding that the appellant had not breached any duty of care owed to Mrs Zaluzna as an invitee. Mrs Zaluzna appealed to the Full Court, which allowed the appeal and ordered a new trial. The appellant then appealed to the High Court. The central issue before the High Court was whether the appellant owed a general duty of care to Mrs Zaluzna in addition to any special duty owed by an occupier to an invitee. The Full Court had found that the trial judge had erred by failing to consider whether a general duty of care arose. The High Court considered whether the Full Court's order for a new trial was warranted and whether there was evidence of a general duty of care in addition to the special duty owed by the appellant. The High Court ultimately found that the Full Court's order for a new trial should be set aside and the appeal to the Full Court remitted to the Full Court to determine the remaining unresolved issues.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the relationship between an occupier and an invitee give rise to a general duty of care in addition to the special duty of care?
2. If so, do the special and general duties of care coexist and impose distinct obligations on the occupier, or is the special duty subsumed within the general duty?
3. Should the law continue to distinguish between the special duty owed to invitees and the general duty of care, or should it adopt a more unified approach based on reasonable foreseeability of risk?
4. Was there sufficient evidence in the case to establish circumstances giving rise to a general duty of care, beyond the special duty owed by the occupier to the invitee?
5. If a general duty of care does arise, what is the appropriate standard and scope of that duty in the circumstances of this case?
Held
1. The relationship between an occupier and an invitee gives rise to a special duty of care in addition to the general duty of care. However, these duties coexist and impose distinct obligations on the occupier.
2. The special and general duties of care can coexist and impose distinct obligations on the occupier. The special duty is not subsumed within the general duty.
3. The law should continue to distinguish between the special duty owed to invitees and the general duty of care, as it provides clarity and certainty in defining the occupier's responsibilities.
4. There was insufficient evidence in the case to establish circumstances giving rise to a general duty of care beyond the special duty owed by the occupier to the invitee.
5. The appropriate standard and scope of the general duty of care in this case is to determine whether the occupier took reasonable care to avoid a foreseeable risk of injury to the invitee. This includes considering the specific circumstances of the case, such as the condition of the premises and the occupier's actions.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court in Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd v. Zaluzna considered whether an occupier owes both a special duty of care and a general duty of care to an invitee. The Court held that while the special duty of care owed by an occupier to an invitee is well-established, the law does not require the occupier to owe a more onerous general duty of care in addition to the special duty. The Court found that the special duty owed by an occupier to an invitee is sufficient to cover the occupier's liability in the circumstances of this case.
The Court examined the legal principles and authorities relating to the special and general duties of care. It found that the special duty owed by an occupier to an invitee is to take reasonable care to prevent damage from unusual dangers of which the occupier knew or ought to have known. The Court noted that this duty has been held to be the ordinary duty of reasonable care under the general law of negligence. While the Court found that a general duty of care may arise in some circumstances, the facts of this case did not establish a general duty of care in addition to the special duty owed to the invitee.
The Court also considered whether the law should continue to distinguish between the special duty and the general duty of care. It found that the special duty serves useful purposes by establishing the occupier's duty of care and providing some limitations on that duty. However, the Court noted that the special duties cannot be regarded as obsolete or superseded.
The Court concluded that the trial judge was correct to consider the special duty owed to the invitee under Indermaur v. Dames and that there were no facts in the case to attract consideration of a general duty of care. Therefore, the Court dismissed the appeal and set aside the order for a new trial.