Webb v State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

WEBB v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

[2024] SASC 102

Judgment of the Honourable Justice McIntyre  

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - PROCEDURE AND EVIDENCE - APPLICATIONS

The applicant seeks judicial review of a decision made by a delegate of the Chief Executive of the Department of Correctional Services (‘the CE’) which had the effect of the applicant remaining detained in prison rather than being transferred to a lower security facility. 

A subsequent decision has been made by the CE lowering the applicant’s security rating which had the effect of transferring the applicant to a lower security facility where he remains. 

Held:

1.      Application for judicial review is dismissed on the ground of futility.

Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) ss 7, 23, 25, referred to.
Webb v Department for Correctional Services [2023] SASC 29, considered.

WEBB v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
[2024] SASC 102

Civil

  1. McINTYRE J: The applicant, Mr Richard Webb, issued these proceedings for judicial review of a decision of the respondent, the Department for Correctional Services (‘the Department’), concerning that he remains detained at Mobilong Prison (‘Mobilong’).

  2. The originating application, filed on 11 December 2023, identified a decision made by the delegate of the Chief Executive of the Department for Correctional Services (‘the CE’s delegate’), Mr Ryan Harber on 12 September 2023.  The applicant sought relief in the form of certiorari, mandamus, declaration, and injunction. 

    Background

  3. The applicant is a prisoner within the meaning of the Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) (‘the Act’).[1]  Much of the background history of these proceedings is covered by Kourakis CJ in his previous judgment in this matter,[2] I need not repeat that history in detail.

  4. On 3 March 2023, Kourakis CJ delivered judgment, having held that Mr Webb, or his representative, was entitled to appear personally before the Serious Offenders Committee (‘SOC’) as the SOC was established under s 23(2) of the Act. The SOC assisted the CE’s delegate and chair of the SOC, Mr Harber, in making an assessment under s 23(1) of the Act for the purposes of determining whether or not the applicant should be transferred to another prison.

  5. Following the delivery of Kourakis CJ’s decision, on 20 April 2023, the Minister for Police, Emergency Services and Correctional Services (‘the Minister’) issued a Ministerial Direction to revoke all previous committees that were established under s 23(2) of the Act.[3]  This direction, disbanded the Case Review Panel and the SOC as they were constituted at the time.

    [3]    Exhibit R2 at AKBH-1.

  6. On the same day, the Minister issued a further Ministerial Direction to establish the Case Review Committee (‘CRC’) under s 23(2) of the Act for the purpose of assisting the CE in carrying out assessments pursuant to s 23(1) of the Act.[4]  The Direction indicated that a CRC will be validly formed if it comprises of two…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Webb v State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASC 102
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Webb v State of South Australia involves an application by a prisoner, Mr Richard Webb, seeking judicial review of a decision made by Mr Ryan Harber, the delegate of the Chief Executive of the Department for Correctional Services, regarding the applicant's security rating and potential transfer to another prison. The decision under review was made on 12 September 2023, following a special case review and a recommendation from the Case Review Committee (CRC). The applicant sought relief in the form of certiorari, mandamus, declaration, and injunction, primarily to challenge the validity of the decision made by Mr Harber and its subsequent impact on his security rating and placement.

The primary legal issues the Court was required to decide were whether the decision made by Mr Harber was legally valid, and if so, whether the application for judicial review was futile in light of subsequent events. The Court had to consider the applicant's argument that the decision was flawed because it did not allow him to appear in person before the committee that made the recommendation. The Court also needed to assess the respondent's argument that any relief granted in relation to the 2023 decision would be futile, as it had been superseded by a subsequent special case review and a decision to reduce the applicant's security rating, which resulted in his transfer to a different prison.

The Court concluded that the application was futile because the decision under review had been superseded by subsequent events, specifically the special case review conducted on 21 March 2024, which led to the applicant's transfer to Cadell. The Court found that granting relief in relation to the 2023 decision would have no practical effect and could potentially have unintended consequences, such as increasing the applicant's security rating to a level requiring him to be transferred out of his current institution to a medium security prison. The Court also noted that the applicant's argument for a declaration was inappropriate due to the lack of legal consequences and any reputational interest.

Based on the above, the Court dismissed the application as futile. The Court did not grant any of the reliefs sought by the applicant, as the decision under review had been superseded, and granting relief would have no practical effect. The Court also considered the potential unintended consequences of granting relief, which further supported its decision to dismiss the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The originating application, filed on 11 December 2023, identified a decision made by the delegate of the Chief Executive of the Department for Correctional Services (‘the CE’s delegate’), Mr Ryan Harber on 12 September 2023. The applicant sought relief in the form of certiorari, mandamus, declaration, and injunction. Background The applicant is a prisoner within the meaning of the Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) (‘the Act’).[1] Much of the background history of these proceedings is covered by Kourakis CJ in his previous judgment in this matter,[2] I need not repeat that history in detail.[1] Correctional Services Act 1982 (SA) (‘CS Act’).[2] Webb v Department for Correctional Services [2023] SASC 29 (‘Webb’). On 3 March 2023, Kourakis CJ delivered judgment, having held that Mr Webb, or his representative, was entitled to appear personally before the Serious Offenders Committee (‘SOC’) as the SOC was established under s 23(2) of the Act. The SOC assisted the CE’s delegate and chair of the SOC, Mr Harber, in making an assessment under s 23(1) of the Act for the purposes of determining whether or not the applicant should be transferred to another prison. Following the delivery of Kourakis CJ’s decision, on 20 April 2023, the Minister for Police, Emergency Services and Correctional Services (‘the Minister’) issued a Ministerial Direction to revoke all previous committees that were established under s 23(2) of the Act.[3] This direction, disbanded the Case Review Panel and the SOC as they were constituted at the time. [3] Exhibit R2 at AKBH-1. On the same day, the Minister issued a further Ministerial Direction to establish the Case Review Committee (‘CRC’) under s 23(2) of the Act for the purpose of assisting the CE in carrying out assessments pursuant to s 23(1) of the Act.[4] The Direction indicated that a CRC will be validly formed if it comprises of two or more members that hold a position specified in the Direction.[5] [4] Exhibit R2 at AKBH-2.[5] Ibid.The Statutory Context Section 23 of the Act requires the CE to conduct an initial assessment of a prisoner for the purposes of determining which prison they should be detained. The CE must subsequently, at regular intervals of not more than one year, assess the prisoner and their circumstances to determine whether or not the prisoner should be transferred to another prison. Section 23 of the Act provides:[6][6] CS Act s 23. 23—Initial and periodic assessment of prisoners(1) The CE must, as soon as practicable after the initial admission to a prison of a person who has been sentenced to a term of imprisonment exceeding six months, to life imprisonment or to a sentence of indeterminate duration, and thereafter at regular intervals of not more than one year, assess the prisoner and his or her circumstances and determine whether or not the prisoner should be transferred to some other prison.(2) The Minister may, for the purpose of assisting the CE in carrying out assessments under this section, establish such committees as the Minister thinks fit.(3) In carrying out an assessment under this section, the CE must have regard to—(a) the age, gender, gender identity, sexuality or sexual identity, and the social, medical, psychological and vocational background and history, of the prisoner; and(b) the needs of the prisoner in respect of education or training or medical or psychiatric treatment; and(c) the aptitude or suitability of the prisoner for any particular form of training or work; and(d) the nature of the offence, or offences, in respect of which the prisoner is imprisoned and the length of sentence; and(e) the information contained in any file held by a court in respect of the prisoner; and(f) the behaviour of the prisoner while in prison; and(g) the security of, and availability of accommodation in, any prison under consideration; and(h) the question of maintaining the prisoner's family ties; and(i) where relevant, any proposed plans in respect of the release of the prisoner and his or her social rehabilitation; and(j) such other matters as the CE thinks relevant.(4)The CE must notify the prisoner before commencing an assessment, and must, if the prisoner so requests, grant the prisoner an opportunity to make representations in person to the CE or to a committee established pursuant to subsection (2), including a request that, if practicable, the assessment be made by a person of the same sex or gender identity as the prisoner.(5)The prisoner may make written representations in respect of his or her assessment to the CE or to a committee established pursuant to subsection (2).(6) After the first assessment of a prisoner has been completed, the CE must prepare a programme in relation to the prisoner that contains particulars of any proposals for the education or training or medical or psychiatric treatment of the prisoner, and may, after any subsequent assessment, add to or vary that programme.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Subsequently a special case review was conducted in relation to the applicant.[12] A placement became available at Cadell. Accordingly, the CMC undertook a review of the applicant’s case. The CRC recommended a security rating reduction from 25 points to 24 points. On 21 March 2024, Mr Harber, as the CE’s delegate, determined to endorse a one point reduction in the applicant’s security rating in the light of this recommendation and the applicant’s positive behaviour. That decision resulted in the applicant being transferred to Cadell, where he currently remains. [12] Exhibit R3 at RMH-2, at [35].Conclusion The parties filed and served written submissions prior to the hearing. At the hearing, a number of affidavits were tendered by consent as follows:·Exhibit A1: Affidavit of Mr Richard Webb dated 22 November 2023.·Exhibit R2: Affidavit of Ms Alexis Hedger dated 25 January 2024.·Exhibit R3: Affidavit of Mr Ryan Harber dated 12 April 2024.·Exhibit R4: Letter to Serious Offenders Committee (including Mr Webb’s submissions) dated 28 June 2023.·Exhibit R5: Letter setting out argument and dealing with costs. The respondent submitted that any relief granted by the Court in relation to the 2023 decision would be futile as that decision has been subsequently superseded by the special case review conducted on 21 March 2024. This position was communicated[13] to the applicant prior to the hearing on 15 April 2024. [13] Exhibit R5. The applicant seeks a declaration as his primary relief as, if I grant a declaration, it will impact his future case reviews. The respondent submits that a declaration would be inappropriate due to the lack of any legal consequences, and a lack of any reputational interest for the applicant. In Ainsworth,[14] the High Court found that the report in question had practical consequences for the applicant’s reputational interest, with the Court ultimately holding that a declaration was appropriate in the circumstances. The respondent contends that this is not the case in the matter before me. [14] Ibid. In my view this application is futile in the light of the subsequent decision. It may also have unintended consequences for the applicant. If the decision under review were to be quashed as the applicant contends it should – this would arguably have the effect of increasing the applicant’s security rating to a level requiring him to be transferred out of his current institution to a medium security prison. Futility is a proper basis for me to withhold relief and to dismiss this application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.