Slattery v Beare, Brambles Aust Ltd & Fletcher No. DCCIV-96-1607

Link copied
Case Copied 85 min read

Lawrence Slattery & Bronwyn Slattery
v  Ralph Beare, Brambles Australia & Another
[2001] SADC 44

Civil
Judge David Smith

Introduction

  1. In this action the plaintiffs claim damages from the defendants for personal injuries, including a permanent brain injury, sustained by the first plaintiff, Lawrence Slattery, on the 29th December 1993.  The injuries were sustained whilst he was working for a sub-contract engineering company, Blueline Engineering Services, which was engaged in maintenance work at the foundry complex of Castalloy Manufacturing Pty Ltd located at 76-92 Mooringe Avenue, North Plympton.  Lawrence Slattery and Ian Hendy, of Blueline Engineering Services, were attempting to raise the height of a furnace when the claw on one of the two hydraulic jacks fragmented.  A piece of metal struck Lawrence Slattery on the head, fracturing his skull and knocking him to the ground.  It is alleged that the range of injuries which he sustained rendered him unemployable.

  2. I introduce the parties and other participants and set out some preliminary findings as to the roles played by each.

Parties and other participants

  1. On the 29th December 1993, the first plaintiff, Lawrence John Slattery (hereinafter referred to as “Slattery”), a Master Plumber, was working as a trades assistant on a casual basis for Farmon Engineering Services Pty Ltd, trading as Blueline Engineering Services (hereinafter referred to as “Blueline”).  On that day, Blueline was engaged to raise the height of the furnace at the Castalloy premises. 

  2. The second plaintiff, Bronwyn Lee Slattery, is and was, at all material times, the wife of the first plaintiff.

  3. The second defendant, Brambles Australia Ltd, trading as Brambles Equipment (hereinafter referred to as “Brambles”), at all material times carried on the business of, inter alia, a transport operator and transporter of heavy machinery and equipment.  So too, on the 29th December 1993, at a different location in Castalloy’s foundry complex, Brambles was engaged in installing a furnace.

  4. The first defendant Ralph Harvey Neil Beare (hereinafter referred to as “Beare”) was, as at the 29th December 1993, a rigger in the employ of Brambles and he was on site at Castalloy’s on that day.  On this occasion, Brambles, by its employee Beare loaned Blueline two jacks and the ancillary claws (hereinafter referred to as “claws”, “toes”, “shoes”, “clip-ons”, “add-ons” or “slippers”) to assist Blueline to raise the level of the furnace.

  5. The third defendant, Bruce T. Fletcher, trading as Fletcher & Son, (hereinafter referred to as “Fletchers”), at all material times operated a foundry at Gepps Cross.  It is alleged that in or about September 1990, it made the shoe which fractured on the occasion of the accident the subject of this claim.  It is further alleged that Fletchers made the shoe which was one of four such shoes for SES Holdings Pty Ltd, sometimes called SES Cranes (hereinafter referred to as “SES”).  SES was liquidated in 1992 and it is alleged that at or about that time Brambles purchased SES’s rigging equipment, including the toe which ultimately fractured on the 29th December.

  6. The named…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Slattery v Beare, Brambles Aust Ltd & Fletcher No. DCCIV-96-... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] SADC 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Lawrence and Bronwyn Slattery, sought damages from the defendants, Ralph Beare, Brambles Australia Ltd, and Bruce Fletcher, trading as Fletcher & Son, for personal injuries sustained by Lawrence Slattery while working. The injury occurred when a claw on one of the hydraulic jacks used to lift a furnace fragmented, striking Lawrence Slattery on the head and causing a permanent brain injury. The plaintiffs' claims included common law negligence, breaches of the Trade Practices Act, and breaches of the Fair Trading Act. The second plaintiff also claimed for the loss or impairment of her husband's consortium. The court found that the defendants, Beare and Brambles, were liable for the plaintiffs' damages under common law negligence and for breaches of the Trade Practices Act. The court held that the claw which caused the injury had structural defects and was inadequately tested by Brambles. Fletchers were found not liable as the claw was deemed fit for its intended purpose despite the defects. The first plaintiff was awarded damages for pain, suffering, loss of income, and other losses, while the second plaintiff was awarded for the loss or impairment of her husband's consortium. The court dismissed the claims against Fletchers. The final orders included judgments for the plaintiffs against Beare and Brambles for the assessed damages and interest, and a dismissal of the claims against Fletchers. The court reserved the matter for costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established