Sandra Neindorf v Marta Junkovic No. Scciv-03-1755

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

NEINDORF v JUNKOVIC

[2004] SASC 94

Magistrates Appeal: Civil

  1. BESANKO J This is an appeal from a decision of a Magistrate. The appeal is brought pursuant to s 40 of the Magistrates Court Act 1991. The appeal is brought by the defendant in a civil action who was held liable to pay damages to the plaintiff. I will refer to the appellant as the defendant and the respondent as the plaintiff.

  2. The Magistrate delivered judgment on 23rd November 2003 and he ordered the defendant to pay the sum of $24,464.00 in damages to the plaintiff.  The Magistrate held that the defendant owed a duty of care to the plaintiff and he found that she had breached that duty.  The Magistrate found that the plaintiff had suffered loss and damage as a result of the breach of duty.

    The Magistrate’s Findings of Fact, and Conclusions

  3. The accident which was the subject of the plaintiff’s claim occurred on Saturday, 5th February 2000, and the facts which follow relate to the position at that date.

  4. The plaintiff was born on 11th July 1946 and was 53 years old at the time of the accident.  The defendant was the owner and occupier of premises at 217 Kelly Road, Modbury Heights in the State of South Australia (“the property”).  The defendant lived in a house on the property.  The defendant placed an advertisement in a publication called the “Trading Post”.  The advertisement advised readers that what is commonly called a garage sale would take place on the property on Saturday, 5th and Sunday, 6th February 2000.  The plaintiff went to the property at about 8:40AM on 5th February 2000 to attend the garage sale.  She was walking along a concrete driveway at the front of the property when she stumbled because of unevenness between two slabs of concrete.  In the course of stumbling, she suffered an injury to her right foot.

  5. At the end of the driveway there was a carport attached to the house.  On the day of the accident, there was a table under the carport on the right hand side of the driveway upon which goods were displayed.  The evidence suggests that there were also some goods on the ground.  The goods consisted of bric-à-brac, toys and a lazy boy chair.  The Magistrate found that there were goods on display to the right of the driveway and under or near the carport, and that the plaintiff was looking at those goods at the time of the accident.   The Magistrate found that at the point where the plaintiff stumbled there were two slabs of concrete with an expansion joint in between the two slabs.  The slab on the left‑hand side was higher than that on the right‑hand side.  The plaintiff placed her right foot on the area where the right‑hand slab was lower than the left‑hand slab, and as she did that her foot rolled and she stumbled and the injury occurred.  The plaintiff did not fall…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sandra Neindorf v Marta Junkovic No. Scciv-03-1755 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] SASC 94
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Magistrate was an action for damages brought by the plaintiff, Sandra Neindorf, against the defendant, Marta Junkovic. The plaintiff sought compensation for injuries she sustained after stumbling on uneven concrete slabs at the defendant's property during a garage sale. The defendant, who was the owner and occupier of the property, advertised the garage sale through a publication, inviting members of the public to attend. The plaintiff attended the sale on 5th February 2000 and, while walking along the driveway, she stumbled over uneven concrete slabs, resulting in an injury to her right foot.

The primary legal issue before the Magistrate was whether the defendant owed a duty of care to the plaintiff and if this duty was breached, causing the plaintiff's injury. The Magistrate needed to determine if the unevenness of the concrete slabs constituted a hazard that the defendant should have reasonably foreseen as posing a risk to attendees, particularly given the distractions of the displayed goods. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the unevenness was a known defect that should have been rectified by the defendant prior to the garage sale.

The Magistrate found that the defendant did owe a duty of care to the plaintiff and that this duty was breached. The unevenness between the concrete slabs was identified as a hazard that the defendant should have been aware of, given their long-term occupancy of the property. The court held that the presence of displayed goods to the right of the driveway, which distracted attendees, increased the duty of care owed to them. The Magistrate concluded that it was reasonably foreseeable that the unevenness posed a risk to those attending the garage sale, and the defendant failed to mitigate this risk. Consequently, the Magistrate awarded the plaintiff damages in the sum of $24,464.00.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BESANKO J
The Magistrate delivered judgment on 23rd November 2003 and he ordered the defendant to pay the sum of $24,464.00 in damages to the plaintiff. The Magistrate held that the defendant owed a duty of care to the plaintiff and he found that she had breached that duty. The Magistrate found that the plaintiff had suffered loss and damage as a result of the breach of duty.The Magistrate’s Findings of Fact, and Conclusions The accident which was the subject of the plaintiff’s claim occurred on Saturday, 5th February 2000, and the facts which follow relate to the position at that date. The plaintiff was born on 11th July 1946 and was 53 years old at the time of the accident. The defendant was the owner and occupier of premises at 217 Kelly Road, Modbury Heights in the State of South Australia (“the property”). The defendant lived in a house on the property. The defendant placed an advertisement in a publication called the “Trading Post”. The advertisement advised readers that what is commonly called a garage sale would take place on the property on Saturday, 5th and Sunday, 6th February 2000. The plaintiff went to the property at about 8:40AM on 5th February 2000 to attend the garage sale. She was walking along a concrete driveway at the front of the property when she stumbled because of unevenness between two slabs of concrete. In the course of stumbling, she suffered an injury to her right foot. At the end of the driveway there was a carport attached to the house. On the day of the accident, there was a table under the carport on the right hand side of the driveway upon which goods were displayed. The evidence suggests that there were also some goods on the ground. The goods consisted of bric-à-brac, toys and a lazy boy chair. The Magistrate found that there were goods on display to the right of the driveway and under or near the carport, and that the plaintiff was looking at those goods at the time of the accident. The Magistrate found that at the point where the plaintiff stumbled there were two slabs of concrete with an expansion joint in between the two slabs. The slab on the left‑hand side was higher than that on the right‑hand side. The plaintiff placed her right foot on the area where the right‑hand slab was lower than the left‑hand slab, and as she did that her foot rolled and she stumbled and the injury occurred. The plaintiff did not fall to the ground. The Magistrate found that the unevenness in the driveway would have been known to the defendant who had lived on the property for some years. The Magistrate found that the unevenness was a hazard. The Magistrate found that the defendant should have been aware that those attending the garage sale on the property would not be familiar with the property and its features, and that they would be distracted by the goods placed on the right side of the driveway. The Magistrate found that the duty of care “would be higher” (to use the Magistrate’s words) during the garage sale because of the distraction caused by the presence of the goods to the right of the driveway. The Magistrate said:“In my view it was reasonably foreseeable that the unevenness in the path posed a risk to the attendees at the garage sale.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BESANKO J