Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Adelaide Concrete Cutting & Drilling Pty Ltd v Marino (No 2) [2024] NSWSC 499 Hearing dates: 8-11 August, 23-25 October 2023 Date of orders: 03 May 2024 Decision date: 03 May 2024 Jurisdiction: Equity Before: Meek J Decision: Findings in favour of plaintiffs against first defendant on contractual claim. Findings against the plaintiffs’ claims against second defendant. Parties to bring in short minutes of order.
Catchwords: COMMERCIAL — Investment arrangements — D1, a licensed real estate agent, and D2, a solicitor trading as Oracle Law, secured office premises in Queensland and worked from separate parts of the premises — D1 assisted D2 to set up office, referred conveyancing matters to Oracle Law, was given title “business development manager” and used an Oracle Law email address — D1 met P1’s director and stated he was a lawyer — D1 assisted P1 with loan arrangements regarding two associates of P1 — D1 and D2 subsequently left office premises and parted ways — D1 sought from D2 and was permitted to retain use of Oracle Law email address — P1’s director introduced P2 to D1 — D1 presented investment proposals to plaintiffs — P1 paid $10,000 and P2 paid $200,000 to D1 to be invested by him via a trading platform under asset management agreements (“AMAs”) and funds were not repaid — Plaintiffs claim that D1 represented to them that he was a lawyer, that the investments were risk-free or virtually risk-free, would give 100% return after 90 days, and were government controlled (“representations”) — Plaintiffs seek to recover against D1 based on contract, guarantee, breach of fiduciary duties or misrepresentation, pursuant to s 1041I(1) of the Corporations Act2001 (Cth) (“Corporations Act”) and s 236 of the Australian Consumer Law (“ACL”) and for negligence — Plaintiffs allege that D1 was an employee or officeholder of Oracle Law and seek to recover against D2 under the compensatory limb of the Court’s inherent supervisory jurisdiction, and by negligence, with alternative claims based on vicarious liability and breaches of the ACL — D2 cross-claims against D1 for contribution or indemnity
EVIDENCE — Privilege against self-incrimination — There is a distinction between the prohibition against drawing an adverse inference from a claim of privilege and adverse inferences that may arise from the absence of evidence which a party or witness could be expected to give (Jones v Dunkel) — It is not permissible to draw an adverse inference from a witness’ exercise of his or her privilege against self-incrimination
CONTRACT — Construction — Issues regarding aspects of AMAs that bear upon repayment — Whether trade period had commenced — “official start date” an undefined term but no real dispute that the 90-day period had commenced — Whether “return” refers to the initial investment or also the profit on the initial investment — Properly construed, “return” only refers to the profit component, accordingly, there was an unqualified obligation under the AMAs to pay…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Adelaide Concrete Cutting & Drilling Pty Ltd v Marino (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NSWSC 499
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the real estate agent owed fiduciary duties to the plaintiffs, whether the plaintiffs were entitled to rescind the asset management agreements, and if the solicitor could be held liable under the compensatory limb of the Court’s inherent supervisory jurisdiction. The court also had to consider the impact of the plaintiffs' failure to properly frame and list the issues, and the inadequacies in the Court Book, on the progression and costs of the case.
The court found that the real estate agent was not a fiduciary of the plaintiffs as the alleged duties were proscriptive in nature and not prescriptive. The court also held that the plaintiffs had affirmed the asset management agreements and, therefore, could not rescind them. The claims against the solicitor under the supervisory jurisdiction were dismissed as the plaintiffs failed to establish gross negligence or a "culpable quality" of negligence. The court noted that the presentation of the case, including the Court Book, was not conducive to a just, quick, and cheap resolution of the issues and directed the parties to address the proportionality provisions of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) in relation to costs.
The court ruled in favour of the plaintiffs against the real estate agent on the contractual and misleading or deceptive conduct claims, but declined to make findings on other claims due to the success of the contractual claim and the plaintiffs' failure to address essential aspects of those claims. The claims against the solicitor were dismissed. The court highlighted the importance of proper framing of issues and adherence to procedural directions to facilitate the efficient resolution of disputes.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court as a result of claims filed by the plaintiffs against D1 and D2. The plaintiffs filed claims for breach of contract, guarantee, fiduciary duties, misrepresentation, negligence, and under the Corporations Act and the Australian Consumer Law. They also sought to hold D2 liable under the Court's inherent supervisory jurisdiction, negligence, vicarious liability, and breaches of the ACL. D2 cross-claimed against D1 for contribution or indemnity. The court considered the claims and cross-claim in light of the evidence presented and submissions made by the parties. The court heard evidence from the parties and made findings on the various claims and cross-claim.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did D1 have an obligation under the AMAs to repay the initial invested capital after 90 days?
2. Did D1 owe fiduciary duties to the plaintiffs as an asset manager?
3. Did D1's misrepresentations contribute to the plaintiffs entering into the AMAs?
4. Did D1 breach the financial services provisions of the Corporations Act?
5. Did D1 engage in misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law?
6. Did D1 owe a duty of care to the plaintiffs?
7. Did D2 owe a duty of care to the plaintiffs?
8. Was there a partnership between D1 and D2?
9. Was D1 an employee of D2?
10. Did the plaintiffs fail to adequately list and frame the issues in their pleadings?
Held
1. D1 had an obligation under the AMAs to repay the initial invested capital after 90 days.
2. D1 did not owe fiduciary duties to the plaintiffs as an asset manager.
3. D1's misrepresentations contributed to the plaintiffs entering into the AMAs.
4. The court declined to make any findings on the claim that D1 breached the financial services provisions of the Corporations Act.
5. The court found that D1 engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct under the ACL.
6. D1 owed a duty of care to the plaintiffs.
7. D2 did not owe a duty of care to the plaintiffs.
8. There was no partnership between D1 and D2.
9. D1 was not an employee of D2.
10. The plaintiffs failed to adequately list and frame the issues in their pleadings.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced by addressing the contractual obligations under the AMAs, clarifying that "return" in the agreements referred to profit on the initial investment, not the initial capital. The plaintiffs were thus entitled to recover the initial capital from D1. The court noted that since the contractual claim was successful, there was no need to address the fiduciary duty claims, as the fiduciary duties in question were proscriptive and not prescriptive in nature.
On the issue of misrepresentation, the court held that D1's misrepresentations played a role in the plaintiffs entering into the agreements, but since there was no evidence of rescission prior to the filing of the claims, the court did not deem it necessary to declare rescission.
The court examined the financial services provisions of the Corporations Act but declined to make any findings due to the lack of submissions on the matter. Regarding misleading or deceptive conduct under the ACL, the court found that D1's conduct did breach these provisions, and the plaintiffs were entitled to relief, although damages remained unchanged.
In terms of negligence, the court found that D1 owed a duty of care to the plaintiffs, but D2, the solicitor, did not, as the plaintiffs were not established as D2's clients. The court also dismissed the claim against D2 under the Court's inherent supervisory jurisdiction, as the plaintiffs failed to demonstrate that D2's negligence met the threshold of "culpable quality."
The court examined the indicia of partnership and concluded that there was no partnership between D1 and D2. It also held that D1 was not an employee of D2, and any tortious acts committed by D1 occurred outside the scope of any employment relationship.
Lastly, the court addressed the inadequacies in the pleadings and the Court Book, noting that the failure to adequately list and frame the issues, along with the non-compliant Court Book, complicated the proceedings and did not facilitate a just, quick, and cheap disposition of the issues at hand.