Mallonland Pty Ltd v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Mallonland Pty Ltd & Anor v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd [2023] QCA 24

PARTIES:

MALLONLAND PTY LTD
ACN 051 136 291
(first appellant)
ME & JL NITSCHKE PTY LTD
ACN 074 520 228
(second appellant)
v
ADVANTA SEEDS PTY LTD

ACN 010 933 061
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 5214 of 2021
SC No 4103 of 2017

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2021] QSC 74 (Jackson J)

DELIVERED ON:

28 February 2023

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

19 and 20 October 2021

JUDGES:

Morrison and Bond JJA and Williams J

ORDERS:

1.   Appeal dismissed.

2.   The appellants pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal, to be assessed on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – PURE ECONOMIC LOSS: NEGLIGENT ACTS, OMISSIONS OR REPRESENTATIONS – DUTY OF CARE: EXISTENCE – DISCLAIMERS AND ASSUMPTION OF RESPONSIBILITY – where the appellants brought proceedings under Part 13A of the Civil Proceedings Act 2011 (Qld) on behalf of a group of commercial sorghum farmers – where the respondent manufactured sorghum seed under the brand name “MR43 Elite” – where the respondent supplied MR43 Elite only to distributors, either by sale or consignment – where, between 2010 and 2014, the appellants purchased MR43 Elite from distributors – where MR43 Elite was contaminated with a seed known as shattercane – where the appellants suffered pure economic loss due to planting of contaminated MR43 Elite – where the primary judge found that the seed was sold in bags with a prominent and clear disclaimer of liability printed on it – where the case was run not as one where physical damage was suffered but only that pure economic loss was suffered – where the only element of negligence in issue was the duty of care – where the primary judge found that no duty of care was owed to the appellants – whether the primary judge erred in finding that the disclaimer was on the bags at the time the appellants purchased them – whether the disclaimer was effective as a clear and prominent disclaimer of a duty of care which might be owed by the respondent to the appellants – whether a duty of care was owed to the appellants in the circumstances

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – PURE ECONOMIC LOSS: NEGLIGENT ACTS, OMISSIONS OR MISREPRESENTATIONS, DUTY OF CARE: EXISTENCE – GENERALLY – where the respondent manufactured sorghum seed under the brand name “MR43 Elite” – where the respondent supplied MR43 Elite only to distributors, either by sale or consignment – where the appellants purchased MR43 Elite from distributors – where MR43 Elite was contaminated with a seed known as shattercane – where the appellants suffered pure economic loss due to planting of contaminated MR43 Elite – where the respondent had not assumed responsibility to the end users of MR43 Elite – where the respondent had disclaimed responsibility for loss suffered by the ultimate consumer of MR43 Elite –…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mallonland Pty Ltd v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCA 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mallonland Pty Ltd and others appeal against the decision of the primary judge, who found that no duty of care was owed by Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd to the appellants, who are commercial sorghum farmers. The appellants purchased sorghum seed from distributors who had obtained the seed from Advanta. The seed was contaminated with shattercane, leading the appellants to suffer pure economic loss. The primary judge found that a clear and prominent disclaimer was printed on the bags of seed, negating any assumption of responsibility by Advanta. The court had to determine whether the primary judge was correct in finding that the disclaimer was effective in negating any duty of care owed by Advanta to the appellants.

The court found that the primary judge correctly identified that the disclaimers on the seed bags could negate any assumption of responsibility by Advanta. The appellants did not challenge the propositions that the assumption of responsibility was a salient feature in determining a duty of care, and that an express disclaimer could negate an assumption of responsibility. Instead, the appellants argued that the disclaimer was not clear or prominent enough to negate any assumption of responsibility. The court found that the challenge to the primary judge’s factual finding that the disclaimers were on the bags at the relevant times failed. Therefore, the primary judge was correct in finding that the disclaimers negated any assumption of responsibility by Advanta.

The appeal is dismissed. The appellants are ordered to pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal, to be assessed on the standard basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal dismissed.

2. The appellants pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal, to be assessed on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellants challenge the finding that no duty of care was owed by Advanta. For the reasons which follow the appeal must be dismissed.The pleaded facts A number of facts were pleaded and relevantly admitted, or ultimately not in issue. Those that are relevant to the issues in the appeal are set out below. Sorghum is a crop commercially grown and sold in Queensland and New South Wales for the provision of animal feed, and for the production of biofuels. MR43 is a treated sorghum hybrid variety of seed sold and produced by Advanta and used by the crop farmers for purpose of commercial cultivation and sale of sorghum. MR43 can only be used for cropping purposes. It cannot be fed directly to stock. Advanta:(a)was engaged in the business of the commercial production of seed, including sorghum seed, for sale and distribution to growers;(b)produced or caused to be produced MR43 seed for the purpose of commercial planting and harvesting by growers; and(c)made MR43 seed available to be sold and distributed to growers for planting during the period of the claim. The production of commercial hybrid sorghum seed for commercial sale to farmers was a four-year process from initially increasing the desired hybrid parents to production of sufficient seed for Advanta to supply its distributors in bags. The production of the relevant hybrid became a rolling process whereby the four-year production cycle was initiated and continued over the commercial lifetime of the hybrid. Once established, that process continued on a rolling basis subject to expected demand and inventory levels. The desired hybrid characteristics could not be maintained by simply taking and planting a percentage of the commercial hybrid, as there would be a reversion to other genetic characteristics and a loss of type. The MR43 production process included controls to obviate and preclude, or alternatively, minimise the occurrence of contamination by reason of outcross occurring. The MR43 controls included: (i) commercial seed production; and (ii) commercial grow outs.[2][2]Although Advanta contended, for reasons which do not presently matter, that a grow out was impractical in this case. Commercial seed production involved engaging commercial seed producers in areas considered to be free of wild sorghums and sub-weeds. Growing plants were inspected a minimum of seven times at the Pre-Basic, Basic and Commercial Seed production stages to confirm that undesirable plants were not present. Any undesirable plants, such as wild and weedy sorghums, found inside the isolation zones but outside the production area, were rogued (i.e. manually removed from the ground and destroyed). Any undesirable plants, such as outcrosses, found inside the production area were rogued. A “commercial grow out” is an expression that refers to planting and growing a sample of seed from a production batch to assess whether, inter alia, the batch is contaminated with off-type or weed seed. Grow outs involved an inspection by Advanta during the growing stage, at each stage of production (i.e. Pre-Basic Seed, Basic Seed and Commercial Seed), for undesirable plants, including off-types.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Before this Court the appellants spent considerable effort in attacking the quality of the evidence given on this topic and challenging the findings above. For that reason, it is necessary to examine the evidence with a view to determining if his Honour’s conclusion was open.Advanta’s evidenceCroker Mr Croker was the Managing Director of Advanta, having been appointed Acting Managing Director in September 2009, and Managing Director from April 2010. His statement,[44] which was admitted into evidence said this concerning the bag and label issue:[45][44]Exhibit 21, AB 1012.[45]AB 1065-1066.“285.After the seed is released by QC,[46] it is bagged into labelled bags.[46]AA reference to Quality Control (“QC”).286.A bag containing seed produced by Advanta always had a label printed or stencilled onto the actual bag as well as either a sticker or a bag tag attached to the labelled seed bag.287.In 2010, the seed bags used by Advanta were labelled and also had a bag tag attached to them via a plastic connector. The bag tags were made from untearable plastic material.288.In 2010, Advanta had seed bags produced under a contract with a manufacturer in China or Thailand.289.That manufacturer also printed a label directly onto the bag. Advanta provided the manufacturer with the artwork or get up that was required to be printed on the bag.290.Exhibited to me at DEF.300.000.000.004A is the artwork provided to the manufacturer of Advanta's bags for MR43 Elite in 2010.291.The Conditions of Sale and Use were part of the artwork or get up.292.That artwork was designed by the marketing team at Advanta at the time and the Conditions of Sale and Use were incorporated into the artwork which was provided to the manufacturer.293.Exhibited to me at DEF.400.000.000.0147E, DEF.400.000.000.0147F and DEF.400.000.000.0147G are copies of photographs I took of the current bag used by Advanta for the MR Buster variety of hybrid grain sorghum seed.294.I can recall the size of the bag used and the design and lay out on the bags used in 2010. I can also recall the of the font of the Conditions of Sale and Use that ·were printed on the bag label in 2010.295.There is no discernible difference in size between what I can recall about the label used in 2010 and, in particular, the size of the font used in 2010, and that on the bag in my photo. The bags hold the same volume of seed although the dimensions may differ very slightly.” In summary the relevant parts of that evidence were:(a)a bag containing seed produced by Advanta always had a label printed or stencilled onto the actual bag;(b)in 2010, the seed bags used by Advanta were labelled;(c)in 2010 the bag manufacturer printed the label directly onto the bags;(d)the artwork used in 2010 was that in DEF.300.000.000.004A,[47] in the terms set out in paragraph [37] above;(e)he recalled the size of the bag used and the design and lay out on the bags used in 2010;(f)he recalled the font of the Conditions of Sale and Use that were printed on the bag label in 2010; and(g)the size of the label and the font used in 2010 were no different from that shown in the exhibited photos of the bag currently used by Advanta for a particular type of sorghum seed.[48][47]AB 1179.[48]AB 1180-1182.

Decision

Reasons for decision

That approach by the appellants at trial must also be seen in light of an exchange had between Senior Counsel for the appellants at the trial and the learned primary judge. Senior Counsel objected to that part of Mr Croker’s statement which dealt with the labelling issue, i.e. paragraphs 285 to 300 of Exhibit 21[78]. The basis of the objection was that those matters had not been put to the appellants’ witnesses, and that infringed the rule in Browne v Dunn, to such an extent that the paragraphs should be excluded. The objection failed, but in the course of submissions Senior Counsel for the appellants accepted that: (i) it had always been expressly pleaded that the bags contained such conditions, in paragraph 18 of the defence; (ii) that pleaded issue came as no surprise to the appellants, i.e. they were always on notice as to that issue; and (iii) the appellants’ witnesses had not dealt with the paragraph 18 conditions in those terms. In those circumstances the failure to cross-examine Mr Croker or Mr Anderson, and the indirect challenge to Mr Short, followed by the absence of any submission as to their evidence on this issue, provides no proper basis to attack their evidence in the way now attempted before this Court.[78]AB 1400 line 27 to AB 1403 line 2.Conclusion on the factual challenge In my respectful view, the challenge to the factual finding by the learned trial judge, namely that it was likely that the pleaded conditions were on the bags sold by Advanta at the relevant times, fails.Negating the assumption of responsibility The learned primary judge correctly understood the thrust of Advanta’s case based upon the fact that the conditions were printed on the bags:“[200] The substance of the point of the defendant’s reliance on the terms on the bags, in my view, is that they may negate the defendant’s assumption of responsibility, as a salient feature, in determining whether there is a duty of care to avoid economic loss only in the circumstances of this case.” The learned primary judge accepted authority that the assumption of responsibility was one of the salient features in establishing a duty of care.[79] His Honour also accepted authority that assumption of authority may be negated by an express disclaimer of responsibility.[80][79]Reasons below [201]-[202], referring to Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465, 529; Bryan v Maloney (1995) 182 CLR 609, 625; and Woolcock Street Investments Pty Ltd v CDG Pty Ltd (2004) 216 CLR 515, 532 [26].[80]Reasons below [203], referring to Hedley Byrne at 492, 504 and 533; Esanda Finance Corp Ltd v Peat Marwick Hungerfords (1997) 188 CLR 241, 250-251; ABN AMRO Bank NV v Bathurst Regional Council (2014) 224 FCR 1, 117 [603]; and Smith v Eric S Bush (a firm) [1990] 1 AC 831, 856, 872-873. Neither of those two propositions were challenged by the appellants. Rather, their contention was that, assuming the conditions were printed on the bags, the disclaimer was not clear enough or prominent enough to negate the assumption of responsibility.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.