Mallonland Pty Ltd v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Mallonland Pty Ltd & Anor v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd [2021]
QSC 74
PARTIES:  MALLONLAND PTY LTD ACN 051 136 291 (AS
TRUSTEE FOR THE ANDREW JENNER FAMILY
TRUST)
(First Plaintiff)
AND
ME & JL NITSCHKE PTY LTD ACN 074 520 228 (AS
TRUSTEE FOR THE NITSCHKE FAMILY TRUST)
(Second Plaintiff)
v
ADVANTA SEEDS PTY LTD ACN 010 933 061
(Defendant)
FILE NO/S:  BS 4103 of 2017
DIVISION:  Trial Division
PROCEEDING:  Trial
ORIGINATING  Supreme Court at Brisbane
COURT: 
DELIVERED ON:  9 April 2021
DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  16, 23-26, 30-31 March 2020; plaintiffs’ written submissions
9 April 2020; defendant’s written submissions 14 April 2020.
JUDGE:  Jackson J
ORDER:  The judgment of the court is that the plaintiffs’ claim is
dismissed.
CATCHWORDS:  TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – PURE ECONOMIC LOSS:
NEGLIGENT ACTS, OMISSIONS OR

MISREPRESENTATIONS – DUTY OF CARE: EXISTENCE – GENERALLY – where the plaintiffs grew grain sorghum as part of their farming businesses – where the

defendant carried on business producing and selling seeds for
commercial planting, including grain sorghum seed – where

the plaintiffs grew grain sorghum in the summer of 2010/2011 from MR43 seed produced by the defendant and acquired from

a distributor – where the MR43 seed was contaminated with seed of another subspecies – where the plaintiffs allege that the

contamination was due to the negligence of the defendant in
producing the MR43 – where the defendant relies on terms it
marked on the bags of contaminated MR43 seed to exclude a

duty of care to the plaintiffs – whether the effect of the terms as a disclaimer negated the existence of a duty of care – whether the terms negated the defendant’s assumption of

responsibility, as a salient feature, in determining whether
there was a duty of care – whether a duty of care would operate
incoherently with the contractual rights and obligations on
which the defendant sold the MR43 – whether the plaintiffs
were able to protect themselves against exposure to the risk of
economic loss caused by the defendant’s failure to take care
and were not vulnerable
TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – PURE ECONOMIC LOSS:
NEGLIGENT ACTS, OMISSIONS OR

MISREPRESENTATIONS – SCOPE OF DUTY AND SUBSEQUENT BREACH – where the defendant did not carry

out comprehensive crop inspection and rogueing to remove off-type plants that would or might produce contaminated seed

– where the defendant failed to conduct a grow out test of the
seed produced for MR43 before it was supplied to growers –
where the defendant undertook two forms of scientific testing
of MR43 seed – where employees of the defendant became

aware that there were off-type plants appearing in crops grown from the contaminated MR43 seed but failed to warn the plaintiffs that any off-type plants needed to be removed before

they dropped seed – whether the defendant failed to take

reasonable precautions to avoid a risk of harm to the plaintiffs through the sale of MR43 seed by producing and selling seed that was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mallonland Pty Ltd v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 74
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mallonland Pty Ltd and others initiated legal proceedings against Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd, a company involved in producing and selling seeds for commercial planting. The plaintiffs, who were farmers, alleged that Advanta Seeds was negligent in producing and selling MR43 seed contaminated with seed from another subspecies, which resulted in significant economic losses. The case primarily revolved around whether Advanta Seeds owed a duty of care to the plaintiffs and if their actions constituted misleading or deceptive conduct under consumer protection laws. Additionally, the court examined whether the plaintiffs' claims were barred by the limitation period.

The central legal issues involved whether Advanta Seeds had a duty of care towards the plaintiffs for economic losses resulting from contaminated seed, whether the disclaimer terms on the seed bags excluded such a duty, and whether Advanta Seeds' conduct constituted misleading or deceptive behaviour. The court also needed to determine if the plaintiffs' claims for economic loss were within the limitation period for such actions.

The court found that Advanta Seeds did not owe a duty of care to the plaintiffs for the economic losses incurred. The terms printed on the seed bags did not effectively exclude such a duty. Furthermore, the court held that Advanta Seeds did not engage in misleading or deceptive conduct as they were not in a direct contractual relationship with the plaintiffs. The court also ruled that the plaintiffs' claims for economic loss accrued when the contaminated seed was planted, which was before the limitation period had expired. However, the court concluded that the plaintiffs could not accurately estimate the total amount of damages for the entire group, leading to the dismissal of the claim.

The court dismissed the plaintiffs' claim, finding no liability on the part of Advanta Seeds for the alleged economic losses.

Orders

Orders of the court

The judgment of the court is that the plaintiffs’ claim is

dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The basis for the aggregate group damages claim is s 103V of the Civil Proceedings Act 2011 (Qld), that provides that: “103V Judgment It is not necessary in this case to decide whether aggregate damages can ever be awarded under the section in a case for damages in a representative proceeding involving operational lost crop profits or additional expenses or the like. Perhaps that can be done in some cases, if the range of variability in the data were limited in ways that enabled broad factual inferences to be drawn. In the present case, consideration of the data for the range of claims of the individual plaintiffs and sample group members leads me to the conclusion that no reasonably accurate assessment of the total amount can be made. Mr Lytras expressed the opinion that the sample size of the data of the plaintiffs and sample group members as to the areas planted with contaminated MR43 and the number of bags of contaminated MR43 purchased were sufficiently high percentages to be representative of the data as to the area planted by 44 growers and seed purchased by 39 growers but recognised that for the purposes of extrapolation to the larger total group of 103 members they represented less than 10 percent. The basis of his reasoning to reach those conclusions was not exposed in evidence. The acceptability of proof of a fact in a legal proceeding is not a matter of expert accounting opinion. Whether the proof is a reasonably accurate assessment of the total amount to which group members are entitled is also not a matter for expert accounting opinion. On this question it must be kept in mind that a judgment given in a representative proceeding binds both the parties and group members who have not opted out,[185] and that where an aggregate assessment is made, the individual entitlements of group members will have to be determined either at the same time or later.[186] The individual entitlement of any group member in this case would turn on the sorts of variable information that was tendered in evidence for the plaintiffs and sample group members. How that would be done over the whole group, if the damages were [185] Civil Proceedings Act 2011 (Qld), s 103X(b). [186] Civil Proceedings Act 2011 (Qld), ss 103V(2), 103V(4) and 103W. calculated by reference to the extrapolated “average” areas planted with contaminated MR43 in the separate States, or the extrapolated “average” numbers of bags of seed across the same area divisions was not explained. How that would represent the entitlements of the group members inter se, if those “entitlements will be calculated in accordance with the general law”[187] was not explained. No attention was given to [187] Schutt Flying Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd v Mobil Oil Australia Ltd (2000) 1 VR 545, 558. these matters in the plaintiffs’ case. The defendant submitted that a number of variables were neither precisely nor reasonably captured by the plaintiffs’ evidence of “average” area or bags purchased losses, including:

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It follows that the terms on the bag were not proved to be terms of the contract of sale of the contaminated MR43 seed by a distributor to any of the plaintiffs or group members.[10] [10] An interesting similar Colorado case is Lutz Farms v Asgrow Seed Company 948 F 2d 638, 643-644. However, there are too many differences in the underlying legal principles of law in that US State to give it much weight. Operation of the terms on the bag as a disclaimer The unusual aspect of this case in relation to the organising principles of the tort of negligence is that the alleged duty of care is one to avoid economic loss owed by a producer or manufacturer of goods to an end user where the producer or manufacturer is not in a direct contractual relationship with the end user. Since the development of the law of negligence signalled by the New York Court of Appeals in 1916 by MacPherson v Buick Motor Co,[11] followed in 1932 by the House of Lords in Donoghue v Stevenson[12] and in 1935, for Australia, by the Privy Council in Grant v Australian Knitting Mills Ltd,[13] liability of a producer or manufacturer of goods to an end user in negligence for physical loss or damage has been a central concern of the law of negligence. [11] 217 NY 382 (1916). MacPherson v Buick Motor Co was referred to in Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562, 577, 598 and 617. [12] [1932] AC 562. [13] (1935) 54 CLR 49. But when it comes to loss or damage constituted by economic loss only, the path to liability in negligence has been more difficult. Again, the New York Court of Appeals was a pathfinder, in 1922 in Glanzer v Shepard,[14] but it was not until 1963 in Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd[15] in England, followed in 1970, for Australia, by the Privy Council in Mutual Life and Citizens Assurance Co Ltd v Evatt,[16] that the development of liability in negligence for economic loss only was accepted at the highest level in this country, before the modern cases in the High Court began. [14] 233 NY 236 (1922). Glanzer v Shepard was referred to in Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465, 487 and 537. [15] [1964] AC 465. [16] [1971] AC 793. Glanzer is important as an early case where a relationship that gave rise to a duty of care in negligence was “equivalent to contract”, which is an analytical tool or approach that has proved significant in later cases.[17] Another early case of that kind was Nocton v Lord Ashburton,[18] as explained later in Hedley Byrne.[19] But none of those initial cases of liability for negligence for economic loss only was a case of the liability of a producer or manufacturer of a thing to an end user, particularly where the relationship between them resulted from one or more contracts of sale of goods between the producer or manufacturer and the end user via intermediate purchasers. [17] Barclay v Penberthy (2012) 246 CLR 258, 320 [171]; Kenny & Good Pty Ltd v MGICA (1992) Ltd (1999) 199 CLR 413, 434 [44], 446 [80]-[81]; Hill v Van Erp (1997) 188 CLR 159, 233; Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Peat Marwick Hungerfords (1997) 188 CLR 241, 299. [18] [1914] AC 932, 972. [19] [1964] AC 465, 529 and 530.