Mallonland Pty Ltd v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GAGELER CJ,
GORDON, EDELMAN, STEWARD, GLEESON, JAGOT AND BEECH‑JONES JJ

MALLONLAND PTY LTD & ANOR  APPELLANTS

AND

ADVANTA SEEDS PTY LTD  RESPONDENT

Mallonland Pty Ltd v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd

[2024] HCA 25

Date of Hearing: 6 March 2024
Date of Judgment: 7 August 2024

B60/2023

ORDER

Appeal dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Queensland

Representation

W A D Edwards KC with B A Hall and T A Rawlinson for the appellants (instructed by Creevey Horrell Lawyers)

P J Dunning KC with E J Goodwin KC and M Y Barnes for the respondent (instructed by Herbert Smith Freehills)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. This case concerns whether a producer of commercial hybrid grain sorghum seed, sold in bags contaminated with the seed of another plant known as shattercane, is liable in negligence to commercial farmers who planted the seed and were subsequently required to take costly action to eliminate the contaminant. Shattercane is a plant genetically related to grain sorghum, but not itself useable for grain crops. Its seed-head shatters, spreading seed widely and growing vigorously to the detriment of grain sorghum cultivation.

  2. The sole issue in this Court is whether the respondent ("the producer") owed the appellants ("the growers") a duty to take reasonable care in its production process to avoid the risk that the growers would sustain purely economic losses by reason of a hidden defect in the bags of seed (namely, the presence of shattercane seed).

  3. For the following reasons, the producer did not owe the growers the alleged duty of care. Accordingly, the appeal should be dismissed.

    Facts

  4. The growers were farmers who conducted businesses involving the cultivation and sale of grain sorghum, which is a crop farmed for animal feed and biofuel. They commenced a class action in the Supreme Court of Queensland, in which they alleged that they purchased contaminated grain sorghum seed (labelled "MR43 Elite") from a distributor authorised by the producer and consequently suffered pure economic loss in the form of reduced income and increased expenditure.[1] The growers did not allege that the shattercane caused them property damage, or that their economic loss was consequential on property damage.

  5. Each of the growers purchased bags of the contaminated seed for planting in the summer of 2010/2011. Some months after they planted the seed, the growers became aware of the contamination.

  6. The growers had no way of detecting the contamination prior to planting. To prevent the shattercane from disrupting their grain sorghum growing businesses, the growers were required to stop growing sorghum and remediate the affected fields. The growers' consequential losses comprised the costs of roguing the affected fields (that is, removing inferior or defective plants or seedlings; in this case, shattercane plants or seedlings), applying insecticides and herbicides, and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mallonland Pty Ltd v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] HCA 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellants, referred to as "the growers," appealed a decision concerning their claim against the respondent, Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd ("the producer"). The growers, who cultivate and sell grain sorghum, alleged they purchased contaminated seed from an authorised distributor of the producer and suffered pure economic loss as a result. This loss comprised reduced income and increased expenditure, stemming from the need to remediate their fields due to the contamination, which they could not detect before planting. The growers did not allege property damage or economic loss consequential to property damage.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the producer owed the growers a duty of care to take reasonable steps in its production process to prevent them from suffering pure economic loss due to a hidden defect in the seed. Specifically, the court considered whether the producer had assumed responsibility towards the growers to exercise such care, and whether the salient features of the relationship between the producer and the growers established a duty of care to avoid causing pure economic loss.

The court reasoned that the producer did not owe the growers the alleged duty of care. While acknowledging the "salient features" approach to establishing a duty of care in cases of pure economic loss, the court found no assumption of responsibility by the producer towards the growers. The producer's packaging included a prominent disclaimer of liability, stating that it was the purchaser's responsibility to ensure the product was fit for its intended use and that the producer would not be liable for any loss arising from the use of the product, whether due to negligence or otherwise. The court concluded that the growers' case, which relied on the foreseeability of economic loss, was contrary to established principles, and that the producer's disclaimer was effective in negating any such duty.

Consequently, the appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, the producer did not owe the growers the alleged duty of care. Accordingly, the appeal should be dismissed.Facts The growers were farmers who conducted businesses involving the cultivation and sale of grain sorghum, which is a crop farmed for animal feed and biofuel. They commenced a class action in the Supreme Court of Queensland, in which they alleged that they purchased contaminated grain sorghum seed (labelled "MR43 Elite") from a distributor authorised by the producer and consequently suffered pure economic loss in the form of reduced income and increased expenditure.[1] The growers did not allege that the shattercane caused them property damage, or that their economic loss was consequential on property damage.[1]Mallonland Pty Ltd v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd (2021) 7 QR 234 at 247 [9] ("Mallonland"). Each of the growers purchased bags of the contaminated seed for planting in the summer of 2010/2011. Some months after they planted the seed, the growers became aware of the contamination. The growers had no way of detecting the contamination prior to planting. To prevent the shattercane from disrupting their grain sorghum growing businesses, the growers were required to stop growing sorghum and remediate the affected fields. The growers' consequential losses comprised the costs of roguing the affected fields (that is, removing inferior or defective plants or seedlings; in this case, shattercane plants or seedlings), applying insecticides and herbicides, and leaving the affected fields to lie fallow for several seasons or planting less remunerative crops in those fields. The producer was one of two producers of grain sorghum seed for distribution and sale to Australian growers. The producer did not sell the contaminated seed directly to growers. Rather, the producer supplied the seed to distributors in labelled 20kg bags. These supplies were made by sale or on consignment. In turn, the distributors supplied the seed to growers in the labelled bags. At the time that the seed was supplied to the market, and later, when it was planted, the producer did not know that the seed was contaminated with shattercane. The bags bore prominent labels on the front and the back ("the packaging"). The label on the front of the bags that contained the contaminated seed was branded "Pacific Seeds", the former business name of the producer. The front of the bag highlighted the type of seed and the net weight of the bag, and set out the following data:"Minimum Germination: 85%Minimum Purity: 99%Maximum Other Seeds: 0.1%Minimum Inert Matter: 0.5%"Any suggestion that the contaminated seed did not conform to these specifications was rejected by the primary judge. Reflecting the producer's awareness of the possibility of defective or impure seed, the rear of the bag was printed with what the primary judge described as a "disclaimer". The disclaimer comprised the word "WARNING", next to the headings "ATTENTION" and "CONDITIONS OF SALE AND USE", which were prominently displayed in large bold type and in a font much larger than the conditions themselves. The rear of the bag relevantly included:"ATTENTIONCONDITIONS OF SALE AND USEUpon purchasing this product and opening the bag, the purchaser ('you') agrees to be bound by the conditions set out below. Do not open this bag until you have read and agreed with all the terms on this bag. If, before opening the bag, these conditions are not acceptable to you, the product should be returned in its original condition to the place of purchase immediately, together with proof of purchase, for a refund. The product contained in this bag is as described on the bag, within recognised tolerances.CONDITIONSYou agree that:–You acknowledge that, except to the extent of any representations made by [the producer's] labelling of the product in this bag or made in [the producer's] official current ... literature, it remains your responsibility to satisfy yourself that the product in the bag is fit for its intended use;– If the product in this bag does not comply with its description, within recognised tolerances, the liability of [the producer] will be limited, at [the producer's] option, solely to the cost of replacement of the product or the supply of equivalent goods or the payment of the cost of replacing the goods or of acquiring equivalent goods;– [The producer] will not be liable to you or any other person for any injury, loss or damage caused or contributed to by [the producer] (or its servants or agents), directly or indirectly arising out of or related to the use of the product in this bag, whether as a result of their negligence or otherwise; ..."

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GAGELER CJ, GORDON, STEWARD, GLEESON, JAGOT AND BEECH-JONES JJ EDELMAN J (dissent)
Sixthly, any lack of legal coherence does not improve the growers' case. Properly analysed, the growers' case would involve the imposition of a duty of care on the producer to take reasonable care to avoid causing economic loss to the growers primarily because the risk of such loss was reasonably foreseeable, contrary to the principles identified earlier. Conclusion The producer owed no relevant duty of care to the growers. It follows that the producer's notice of contention does not arise for consideration. The appeal should be dismissed with costs. Introduction We should not attempt to breed from a mule.[68] This appeal arises from attempts to propagate from the decision of this Court in Caltex Oil (Australia) Pty Ltd v The Dredge "Willemstad".[69] Prior to the decision in Caltex a duty of care could be owed to a plaintiff if the duty was (i) based upon an (objective) assumption of responsibility, by an express or implied undertaking by the defendant to the plaintiff or a class of persons of which the plaintiff is a member, or (ii) imposed by law. A duty of care that was imposed by law upon a defendant corresponded with a plaintiff's right to person or property. Caltex purported to recognise a new species of duty of care, one which imposed an abstract duty to take care not to expose a person to loss, independently of a right to person or property, in circumstances involving undefined "salient features".[68]Danby, The Mishnah (1933) at 29 (Zeraim, Kilaim 1:6). [69](1976) 136 CLR 529. As the joint reasons of the other members of this Court explain, the "salient features" approach has been strongly criticised.[70] But the respondent producer did not challenge Caltex or its progeny. I therefore agree with the application of the salient features approach by the other members of the Court and with their conclusion that the appeal must be dismissed. These additional reasons further address two matters: (i) the absence of any assumption of responsibility by the respondent producer; and (ii) how the recognition of a duty of care to avoid exposing another to "pure" economic loss in circumstances of "salient features" has given rise to the highly unsatisfactory state of the present law with the effect that until Caltex and its progeny are challenged or rationalised, a duty of care based upon "salient features" must be confined as narrowly as possible.[71] Duty of care arising from an assumption of responsibility[70]Joint reasons at [36].[71]See also the similar suggestion in Brookfield Multiplex Ltd v Owners Corporation Strata Plan 61288 (2014) 254 CLR 185 at 245 [185], regarding the approach to be taken to Bryan v Maloney (1995) 182 CLR 609 and "[a]bsent any application that Bryan v Maloney should be overruled".The nature of a claim based on assumption of responsibility Category confusion is dangerous. When Dutch explorers landed on Wadjemup they mistakenly identified the friendly quokka marsupial as a rodent and described the island as "Rotte-nest". Without a proper classification of the legal rule by which a duty of care arises from an assumption of responsibility, there was, and remains, a danger that legal genetic engineering could transform that genial rule into a species of legal rat.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GAGELER CJ, GORDON, STEWARD, GLEESON, JAGOT AND BEECH-JONES JJ,

Full text does not contain this section.