Make It Raine Money Pty Ltd v Alvaro [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   MAKE IT RAINE MONEY PTY LTD -v- ALVARO [No 2] [2025] WASC 40

CORAM:   GETHING J

HEARD:   4 FEBRUARY 2025

DELIVERED          :   14 FEBRUARY 2025

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1966 of 2020

BETWEEN:   MAKE IT RAINE MONEY PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

ROCCO DOMENIC ALVARO

Defendant

AND

ROCCO DOMENIC ALVARO

Plaintiff by counterclaim

AND

MAKE IT RAINE MONEY PTY LTD

Defendant by counterclaim


Catchwords:

Contracts - Penalties - Whether interest payable under a loan agreement was a primary or collateral stipulation - Whether mortgagee entitled to a full indemnity for costs under the mortgage - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Mortgagee entitled for an order for possession

Mortgagee entitled to indemnity costs with a limited carve out

Category:    B

Representation:

Original Action

Counsel:

Plaintiff : Mr N Wallwork
Defendant : In person

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Summer Lawyers
Defendant : In person

Counterclaim

Counsel:

Plaintiff by counterclaim : In person
Defendant by counterclaim : Mr N Wallwork

Solicitors:

Plaintiff by counterclaim : In person
Defendant by counterclaim : Summer Lawyers

Cases referred to in decision(s):

Andrews v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2012] HCA 30; (2012) 247 CLR 205

Boon v Burt [2020] WASC 64 (S)

Booth v Zhou [No 2] [2024] WASCA 128

Choice Constructions Pty Ltd v Janceski [No 3] [2011] WASC 358 (S)

Commercial N Pty Limited v Huang & Ors [2024] NSWSC 23

Esanda Finance Corp Ltd v Peat Marwick Hungerfords (1997) 188 CLR 241

Glew v Frank Jasper Pty Ltd [2010] WASCA 87

Hanson Construction Materials Pty Ltd v Calabro [2024] WASC 338

Kakavas v Crown Melbourne Ltd [2013] HCA 25; [2013] 250 CLR 392

Make It Raine Money Pty Ltd v Alvaro [2023] WASCA 126

Mallonland Pty Ltd v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd [2024] HCA 25

Manton Enterprises Pty Ltd as trustee for GPK No. 2 Trust v Lt Market St Pty Ltd [2021] WASC 4 (S)

Mavaddat v HSBC Bank Australia Ltd [No 2] [2016] WASCA 94

Minister for the Environment v Sharma [2022] FCAFC 35; (2022) 291 FCR 311

Moleirinho v Talbot & Olivier Lawyers Pty Ltd [2014] WASCA 65

Moran v Argonaut Equity Partners Pty Ltd [2021] WASCA 45

Neil v Nott [1994] HCA 23; (1994) 68 ALJR 509; (1994) 121 ALR 148

Nobarani v Mariconte [2018] HCA 36

Oak Capital Mortgage Fund Ltd v Dlakic [2019] NSWSC 1538

Paciocco v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2016] HCA 28; (2016) 258 CLR 525

Quantum Asset Management Pty Ltd v Love Properties (WA) Pty Ltd [2017] WASC 167

Rayner v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2003] WASCA 264

Rumball v Mortimore [2000] WASC 126

Saraceni v Jones [2012] WASCA 59 (S)

Serventy v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [No 2] [2016] WASCA 223

Sethi v Bhavsar [2020] WASCA 52

Smart v Prisoner Review Board (WA) [2012] WASC 48

Swansdale Pty Ltd v Whitcrest Pty Ltd [2010] WASCA 129 (S)

The State of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Make It Raine Money Pty Ltd v Alvaro [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] WASC 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Make It Raine Money Pty Ltd v Alvaro [No 2], the plaintiff, Make It Raine Money Pty Ltd (MIRM), sought a declaration regarding the enforceability of a loan agreement and associated mortgage. The defendant, Alvaro, contested the enforceability of the agreement and mortgage, as well as the plaintiff's entitlement to interest and legal costs. The primary issues before the court involved the classification of interest payable under the loan agreement as either a primary or collateral stipulation, and the defendant's liability for the plaintiff's legal costs under the mortgage terms. The court had to determine whether the interest was a fundamental condition of the contract or merely a penalty for late repayment, and whether the defendant was required to indemnify the plaintiff for all legal costs incurred.

The court found that the interest payable under the loan agreement was not a penalty but rather a primary stipulation of the contract, as it was not disproportionately high in relation to the breach of repaying the loan late. The court relied on the fact that the interest rate was calculated based on a reasonable commercial rate and was not excessive or exorbitant. Regarding the indemnity for legal costs, the court held that the defendant was liable for the plaintiff's costs under the terms of the mortgage, as the mortgage explicitly provided for such an indemnity. The court emphasised that the indemnity clause was clear and unambiguous, and the defendant had expressly agreed to it by signing the mortgage.

The court's reasoning was based on the established principles of contract law, particularly the distinction between primary and collateral stipulations, and the enforceability of indemnity clauses in mortgages. The court considered the commercial context of the loan agreement and the reasonableness of the interest rate. In relation to the indemnity clause, the court held that the defendant's signature on the mortgage constituted an unequivocal agreement to the terms, including the indemnity for legal costs. Consequently, the court found in favour of the plaintiff on both issues, declaring that the interest was a primary stipulation and that the defendant was liable for the plaintiff's legal costs.

The court ordered that the defendant was liable for the interest calculated under the terms of the loan agreement and was required to indemnify the plaintiff for all costs and expenses, including legal costs, incurred in enforcing the mortgage and enforcing the loan agreement. The court also directed that the defendant pay the plaintiff's costs of the action.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Facts which are not in issue On the pleadings most of the facts are not in issue. They are supported by Mr Raine's evidence. The facts which follow were not challenged in cross-examination aside from some minor factual issues which I have identified. On this basis, I find that MIRM has proven the facts in this part on the balance of probabilities. MIRM is duly incorporated. Mr Raine is a director of MIRM and was authorised to give evidence on its behalf. Mr Raine has been involved in the practice of lending money on a private basis since January 2019. He established MIRM for the purpose of lending money to businesses, which it has done since it was incorporated in January 2019. It primarily writes loans to high-risk business borrowers for funding business startups and encouraging growth in juvenile businesses. Mr Alvaro is, and was at all material times, the registered proprietor of the Property. The Certificate of Title confirmed this, and records that there is a first mortgage over the Property to Westpac Banking Corporation which was registered in 2003.[12] [12] TB page 83. As mentioned at [1], the Agreement was entered into on 25 June 2019. The documents which together comprise the Agreement, and which were executed on 25 June 2025 by at least Mr Alvaro, are:(a)a real property mortgage in registrable form by Mr Alvaro in favour of MIRM over the Property (Mortgage);[13][13] TB pages 2 - 4.(b)Schedule A (specifying the parties, mortgage and security particulars);[14](c)Schedule B (fee schedule);[15](d)Cheque Directions;[16](e)Authority & Direction;[17](f)Schedule C (Declaration by Mr Alvaro that the credit provided was to be applied wholly or predominantly for business purposes or investment other than investment in a residential property);[18](g)Schedule D (Debtors Advice Declaration);[19](h)Schedule E (Australian Legal Practitioner's Certificate);[20](i)Identity Verification Form;[21](j)All States Power of Attorney;[22] and(k)Memorandum of Common Provisions (MCP).[23][14] TB pages 5 - 6.[15] TB pages 7 - 9.[16] TB page 10.[17] TB page 11.[18] TB page 12.[19] TB page 13.[20] TB page 14.[21] TB page 15.[22] TB page 17.[23] TB page 18. The Agreement provided that Mr Alvaro was to pay the 'Secured Money (or any part thereof)' to MIRM in accordance with the terms of the MCP and by the end of the term. In Schedule A, the final repayment date is 'on the same day which is 12 Months after the Commencement Date'. The Commencement Date is left blank in the Schedule A. However, in the definitions in the MCP, the Commencement Date is defined by reference to the date on which the principal amount was advanced. It is not in issue that the principal amount was advanced by electronic funds transfer on 2 July 2019, making this date the Commencement Date.[24] This had the effect that the Secured Money had to be repaid by 2 July 2020.[24] TB page 86. The payment of interest is dealt with in MCP cl 5. When read with the Mortgage, the Agreement provided for a 'Higher Interest Rate' of 4% per month and a 'Lower Interest Rate' of 1.95% per month. Given the issues in dispute, I will come back to these provisions in detail in pt 6. The Mortgage provided that six months interest of $13,201.26 was to be retained by MIRM from the principal amount. This amount is self-evidently calculated on the basis of the Lower Interest Rate. Interest was to be paid monthly on the same day of each month as the Commencement Date. This meant that the first payment of interest following the six months that was prepaid was due on 2 January 2020.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Case management and evidence On 2 May 2024, a Registrar made the usual suite of orders programming the action through to trial. This included orders that:(a)by 4.00 pm on 10 May 2024, MIRM file and serve any witness statements on which it intends to rely at trial; (b)by 4.00 pm on 27 June 2024, Mr Alvaro file and serve any witness statements on which he intends to rely at trial; and(c)by 4.00 pm on 11 July 2024, MIRM file and serve any witness statements in reply on which it intends to rely at trial. No order was made precluding a party from relying on evidence at trial which was not the subject of a witness statement, though that outcome is implicit in the orders made. On 21 May 2024, MIRM filed a witness statement of Andrew Raine, a director of MIRM (May Raine Statement). On 19 July 2024 MIRM filed a second witness statement of Mr Raine, addressing the issues raised in the counterclaim (July Raine Statement). Mr Alvaro did not file any witness statement. On 29 August 2024 MIRM filed a book of documents. It then filed an amended book of documents on 22 November 2024.[1][1] Which I will refer to as the Trial Book or 'TB'. On 19 September 2024, Archer J made orders programming the action through to trial, including that:(a)if either party wished to make any interlocutory applications (including an application for further information), any such application had to be filed and served by 30 September 2024;(b)if Mr Alvaro wished to amend his defence, he had to file and serve any amended defence by 17 October 2024;(c)if Mr Alvaro wished to adduce any evidence from one or more witnesses (including himself) at the trial, he had to file and serve a witness statement for each such witness by 17 October 2024; and(d)Mr Alvaro may not amend his defence or file further witness statements after 17 October 2024, unless leave is given by the court. At a hearing on 22 October 2024, the time for compliance with the orders in [11](b) and (c) was extended to 12 November 2024. The trial was provisionally listed for 4 to 6 February 2025, which dates were confirmed at a hearing on 14 November 2024. Mr Alvaro did not file any amended defence. Nor did he file any witness statement. At a directions hearing on 19 November 2024, among other orders, MIRM was ordered to file and serve a statement of issues and a chronology. It filed both documents on 10 December 2020. The statement of issues was drawn from the Statement of Claim endorsed on the writ (SC), the Amended Defence (AD) and Amended Counterclaim (AC) filed 30 September 2021 and the Defence to Counterclaim filed 14 October 2024 (DCC). At various points throughout the life of the Action, Mr Alvaro was represented. However, from 18 December 2024 he has been a litigant in person. Accordingly, at a directions hearing on 19 December 2024, at which Mr Alvaro appeared, Archer J adjusted the trial programming orders to reflect the fact that Mr Alvaro was a litigant in person. Her Honour also ordered that if Mr Alvaro wished to adduce the evidence in any previously filed affidavits, or any other evidence, he must bring an application for leave to adduce such evidence. From the transcript of this hearing, it is clear that her Honour explained the consequence of this order in some detail to Mr Alvaro. Her Honour also advised Mr Alvaro that he would be sent a document setting out how a trial works (which would be copied to the MIRM's lawyers). He was subsequently sent this document. Archer J then listed the action for directions before me as the trial judge on 22 January 2025.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.